Pepper Brooks has lived in Pine Crest her whole life. Her late father was an English professor and Pepper grew up surrounded by the classics. She's now a student at Northern Washington University and it's come time to declare a major. It comes as no surprise to her roommate that she chooses to major in English. Pepper is especially close to Dr. "Fergie" Ferguson, who has arranged for Dr. Campbell, from Oxford University, to give a guest lecture on Shakespeare. Fergie asks Pepper to get Dr. Campbell and show him to the auditorium but when Pepper arrives in Fergie's office, she discovers Dr. Campbell dead! In a panic, Pepper calls 911 which proves to be a mistake because the police suspect Fergie is the murderer! Pepper knows her friend would never do such a thing and something about the crime scene really bothers her. Off to the library to research Shakespeare's plays, Pepper figured out the vital clue. Unfortunately, she runs into her crush, Alex Valdez, whose father happens to be the lead detective investigating the murder! Alex and his father warn Pepper to stay out of police business and Alex even thinks his father knows best but Pepper knows her college community and is certain the police have it wrong. Can she figure out who the murderer is before her beloved Fergie gets hauled off to jail?
I really enjoyed this cozy mystery. I laughed a lot and could relate to Pepper, being an English major (and book sniffer and library research nerd) myself. The mystery kept me guessing. I thought I knew who and why pretty early on but I got distracted by the timing of the investigation and the characters' alibis. I was beginning to think there was an unusual plot twist I didn't see. It turns out I was right all along. That's OK because I enjoyed the story anyway. I think if I hadn't been an English major, I'm not sure I would have enjoyed this one as much. It features a younger heroine and requires a little more suspension of disbelief than some other cozies. I really liked the Shakespeare references. I took a few Shakespeare classes in my day and visited Stratford-Upon-Avon and saw A Midsummer Night's Dream at the RSC. I caught only a very few typos/grammatical errors, mostly my pet peeve "alright" instead of "all right." Pepper is an English major! She should know how to spell and know grammar so take the time to get it right, please!
Pepper is young but that makes her immaturity and stupidity NORMAL! Her frontal lobe hasn't developed yet, she's still figuring out who she is and what she wants to do with her life. She's also navigating the social waters of college friendships and dating knowing she's going to be sticking around and everyone else can't wait to leave. Pepper is a sweetheart even if she's a nit naïve. She's a great friend, adoring dog mama to a Boston Terrier named Hamburger (her 3-year-old niece named Hamburger), loving sister and aunt. Pepper is still mourning her father who died more than a year earlier. He was her whole world and gave her an understanding and appreciation of literature. He made her who she is today and she wants to follow in his footsteps. She's latched on to the eccentric professor she calls Fergie as a surrogate for her mother who doesn't seem to miss Dr. Brooks in the same way his daughter does.
Dr. Sharon Ferguson, aka Fergie, is the most eccentric English professor I've ever met. A woman in a field of old white men, she makes her mark on her students with her passion and compassion. Pepper shares many cups of tea with Fergie discussing Pepper's dad, life and literature. Fergie reminds me a bit of Professor Trelawny in Harry Potter. She always wears flowing clothes and seems to be a bit distracted. Maybe she's the absent-minded professor type. She can relate to Pepper's loss having lost her own husband years ago and she was also a close colleague of Pepper's dad so she feels the loss too. I don't think she has it in her to murder anyone but the police seem to have evidence she did it and she does like to drink tea. Perhaps she prepared some exotic brew that put the victim to sleep while she murdered him. It sounds too far-fetched. I like her a lot and hope she's not the murderer. I never had ANY English professors like her but I wish I did. (They really were mostly all old White dudes teaching old, dead White dudes!)
My favorite character is, of course, Hamburger. She's there with a doggie smile, stump wag and licks to cheer everyone up. She doesn't do anything extraordinary, she's just a sweet, loving pup. I LOLs a LOT at how she got her name. That's the way to do it! My then-almost-5-year-old niece nicknamed her little brother before he was born. The name stuck and he still uses it 8 years later. I don't think naming a DOG Hamburger is the greatest idea but she can always change it later. That might be wise LOL! I also liked Liz, Pepper's business major roomie and BFF. Liz is fun, funny and sharp enough to pull Pepper's head out of the clouds. She's a devoted friend and always has Pepper's back even if she doesn't understand Pepper's motives.
Alex Valdez is not my favorite character. He's young, like Pepper, and kind of arrogant. He thinks he's a big shot because his father is the lead detective on the case, his mother was a cop and he's going to the Academy soon. I understand why he would trust his dad to do the right thing. I would too but he's kind of rude about it at times. As Alex and Pepper get to know each other better, he grew on me. He's kind of... Darcyish, a comparison that isn't lost on Pepper. Maggie, Pepper's big sister, is as kind as Pepper. She's loving and also misses her dad even though she's closer to their mom. Maggie is a great mother and I'm sure her arguing with a toddler skills will come in handy once she's a lawyer. Her husband Josh is super nice and a devoted dad.
Pepper's chief suspect is Professor Evensworth, the man she calls Evilsworth. He LOATHES Shakespeare and Shakespeare scholars, including Dr. Campbell and doesn't mind telling everyone so. I don't mind Steinbeck that much but I don't see how any literature professor can badmouth another, let alone push the students away from an iconic writer. I did have an arrogant tenured professor who proclaimed he could teach whatever he wanted because he had tenure. I can see Evilsworth saying that. He's snippy and rude to everyone, especially Fergie and seems to hate Pepper. What about his TA, Destiny? I think she's hiding something and she seems to be the only one who loves Evensworth. Could she have murdered Dr. Campbell out of misplaced loyalty?
Another suspect is Nathan Newton aka Naked Newt, a creepy man who now owns the local coffee shop. His conversation tends to veer towards the macabre and he reminds Pepper of a snake. He certainly comes across as weird and creepy but I'm not sure he's violent. Plus why and how would he be in the English department when he's not a student? Josh's colleague in the IT department, Danny, is a good suspect for murderer. He has a record and history of violence. He has a motive, means and opportunity. However, the way Dr. Campbell was killed makes me think it wasn't Danny, unless Danny was clever enough to kill Dr. Campbell away from anything connected to himself or the IT department.
Pepper's heart goes out to Dr. Campbell's stepdaughter, Stephanie. Stephanie is a botanist and more into plants than literature but she helped her stepfather with his lectures a lot. She seems cold and strange to me. Who prefers plants to books?! She is quick to refer to Dr. Campbell as her stepfather so I'm guessing she wasn't close to him. Still, to lose your mother and then your stepfather in a matter of months has got to be tough. I wanted more female friendship and bonding between these two fatherless girls. Katie Landin, a classmate of Pepper's, insinuates she saw something that led to the murder but can she be trusted? I'm going to say no. This girl likes attention and goes about getting it in weird ways. She seems stuck in a fantasy world of her own making. I feel sorry for her that she feels the need to act that way and it results in everyone thinking she's crazy.
I enjoyed this so much I went right away to read the second book!