All opinions stated in this review are my own and are based on an advanced copy that I requested.
This book has both on-screen sex and cursing, including f-bombs. If those things will cause you to leave a bad review, you might want to skip this one. There should be a trigger warning for this book. I understand that the warning would be a major spoiler, but it is important to warn readers with certain sensitivities. ***MAJOR BUT IMPORTANT SPOILERS TO END OF PARAGRAPH*** This book has a scene that graphically describes a date rape which could be highly triggering for some readers. Although I know that this is a spoiler, I was very surprised that this was not warned for in the blurb as it is graphic and detailed and most definitely rape. If you're triggered by described sexual assault, PLEASE be aware of your own self-care when reading this book. I wish that I had been warned that it was graphically described because I would have skipped this book.
Without getting into spoilery specifics, a lot of dramatic/traumatic things happen in this book. Although it isn't a dark, depressing book, this is also not a light-hearted romance novel. If you're looking for light and fluffy romance, this is not that book.
Some of this story is told via flashbacks and alternating time lines. While that can sometimes be really confusing, Ms. Talley does a really great job of labeling every chapter clearly so you know what timeline you're reading. Even if two consecutive chapters were set in the “present day” setting, they are labeled clearly so there is no question about what year you're reading. I don't typically care for books loaded with flashbacks, but that style actually worked really well in this story. To be honest, if the book had been told with all of the “2003” parts first and the “big reveal” had happened earlier in the book, this would have been a DNF for me, but by that time I was so invested in Summer and David that I finished the book despite my annoyance at how that was handled. (trying to be vague to avoid spoilers)
I loved Summer and David and they were the only thing that kept me reading this book. Summer was an amazing character who was strong, solid, and an amazing mother. I had nothing but a truck load of respect for her from the start but especially to the finish. She could so easily have been bitter and full of hate, but she took her pain and made herself so much stronger than any of the bad things that happened to her. Her capacity for love and forgiveness was amazing and something this world needs more of. She didn't blindly forgive and she wasn't naive, she just didn't let hate control her. Rhett I struggled with. (SPOILERS TO END OF PARAGRAPH) I'm still not at all sold on his commitment to Summer despite their alleged happily ever after. I wanted him to chase her, to do something show her that he was sorry and that he not only loved her but was worthy of her love, but instead he insulted her and treated her horribly and then made her chase him. It was really disappointing that once again Summer had to be the one to put herself out there while Rhett got to just be his rich, spoiled, shiny self.
To my shock, Hunt was a really intriguing character and even with all his flaws, I liked him far more than I liked Rhett. I suspected, but wasn't sure of, what his “sins” from the past were, but I was really surprised and impressed by how he eventually dealt with them. I liked the way that he protected David, and that even when he didn't know how to be a father because he'd never learned how to be one, he had tried his best. I also really liked that he learned from David – even if it was something he should have learned about decades before, he still figured it out and tried to make amends for his sin. He was flawed and incredibly imperfect, but by the end of the book he really was more redeemed than I ever dreamed he would be. His redemption was far more believable than Rhett's, to be honest. That says a lot about Ms. Talley's writing because this is one character I didn't expect to be redeemable.
This is a three star read for me because Ms. Talley has tremendous writing skills and I look forward to reading more from her, but this book just wasn't for me.