What do you think?
Rate this book
The Island in the Mind
Through the lives of three individuals, the island of the mind plunges the reader into a world of court intrigue, and religious upheavals, bloodshed and sexual politics, empire, voyages, exotic discoveries and the new art form of the time - opera.
576 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 1996
4 people are currently reading
61 people want to read
About the author
Rodney Hall
63 books21 followersBorn in Solihull, Warwickshire, England, Hall came to Australia as a child after World War II and studied at the University of Queensland. Between 1967 and 1978 he was the Poetry Editor of The Australian. After a period living in Shanghai in the 1980s, Hall returned to Australia, and took up residence in Victoria.
Hall has twice won the Australian Literature Society Gold Medal, and has received seven nominations for the prestigious Miles Franklin Award, for which he has twice won ("Just Relations" in 1982 and "The Grisly Wife" in 1994).
Hall has twice won the Australian Literature Society Gold Medal, and has received seven nominations for the prestigious Miles Franklin Award, for which he has twice won ("Just Relations" in 1982 and "The Grisly Wife" in 1994).
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews
May 24, 2019
Australia is a land of dreaming. The Aboriginal inhabitants of this country have had their dreaming songs for thousands of years, and although the European inhabitants have done much to wipe out Aboriginal culture since they arrived a little over 200 years ago, the dreaming has carried into the new arrivals - for such a "young" country in the European sense, there have been many attempts at myth-making, epic poetry and grand imaginative prose, art and music, all trying and failing to get to grips with this ancient landscape.
The Island in the Mind is one of the more unusual attempts to create a "backstory" to the European story of Australia, and Hall, in this set of three more-or-less interlocking stories has used his skill as a poet to sweep the reader away to the 17th century and into a world of princely courts, pirates and emperors, as the East and Terra Incognita begin to infest the European imagination.
The novel's three stories are all written as reflections on European attitudes to conquest, empire, and natives. The first section of the book, which revolves around the staging of an opera in a fictional kingdom to impress the young Louis XIV on a state visit, investigates heredity, the naked use of power, and the ability of the arts to expand human thought and horizons. Scarron, the King's composer and eminence grise of this section of the book, is low-born but the Kings favourite: a genius, but hated by all except the King. The opera is the first introduction to the reader of the idea of an island in the mind; with the story of the opera being reminiscent of King Lear. It's clear that Scarron longs for the island in the mind to be real, and compromises his own safety to try and find out all he can about Terra Incognita. The first section ends with Louis XIV arriving and taking over the kingdom by a coup de main. So some of the themes of the book are set in this first section: the European lust to discover new things, exploitation of people, the battle between money and honour (honour wins, just in this first section, but that changes further into the book), and the brutal truth of naked power.
The second section, focused around a young Venetian girl and an Aboriginal, who gets sold to the King of Spain only to be kidnapped by the Sultan, takes us further into the island in the mind, literally. Yuramiru actually gets into Isabella's mind, and takes her across Australia in her dreams - through the desert country, the scrub country, the mountain country and down to the sea. She becomes connected to him and he to her. When they realise that the Sultan is going to kill Yuramiru to display his bones as a curio, he leaps off the ship to drown, after giving Isabella two of his teeth and getting her to promise to have them buried in his homeland. This section of the book delves into concepts of freedom and slavery, and the ability of some people to treat others as less than human.
The final section of The Island in the Mind follows the Godolphin boys - Richard snr, his son Richard jnr and their nephew/cousin Denzil as they travel through Asia to track down the legendary pirate Captain Shilling, to try to co-opt him to engage in privateering for their own cause. As they are dragged further and further east in their search, they not only become besotted with the tropics, but realise that all is not as it seems when it comes to Captain Shilling. In fact it is Shilling who has been hunting the Godolphins, and he finally gets his way when Richard snr is drugged and taken aboard his ship. It turns out that Shilling is more philosopher than pirate, and in a reaction to a world where the greed for money has taken over, he has chosen the path of honour, and searches out Terra Incognita under the pretence of discovery but, as the reader discovers at the end of the book, actually to return Yuramiru's teeth, after meeting Isabella in the Emperor's harem. This section of the book shows us the reality of the European takeover of other countries, how greed and dishonesty are the rule when there are no moral or legal checks to behaviour. Shilling is a fascinating character, and in some respects a proxy for Australia itself - at first the descriptions of who he is and what he looks like vary widely, and when Richard Godolphin finally meets him he is an enigma - not at all a brutal privateer, but not above violence, a seeker, and a man who holds life cheaply. The final view Godolphin has of him is him waving as his ship is wrecked on the coast of Terra Incognita.
Until the end of the book Australia itself is not mentioned or described (the word Australia is not used at all throughout the book), and yet the idea of the land runs like a thread through the novel, drawing the narrative tighter and tighter until the final moment in the surf at the edge of the World. The longing of the Europeans for a pristine land to begin again or to see what Eden was like fights against the reality that Hall shows us of a land so unlike Europe, infinitely older and more reserved from human knowledge, containing a people with a society completely alien to European notions of property, rank or behaviour.
The Island in the Mind is a hard book book to describe - my 8 year old son asked me what I was reading when I was about half-way through and I realised that in many ways this is a book that defies description - Hall has interwoven huge questions about what it means to explore, discover and conquer into a narrative that glistens like a jewel - some of the descriptive prose sparkles like a raindrop in the sun. It is the prose that keeps dragging you through the book, even when you have no idea where Hall is taking you or how this book will end. It is a book that makes you think even as you enjoy turning the pages. He has truly made the island in the mind resonate, and you will be thinking about this book long after you put it down.
Highly recommended.
Check out my other reviews at http://aviewoverthebell.blogspot.com.au/
The Island in the Mind is one of the more unusual attempts to create a "backstory" to the European story of Australia, and Hall, in this set of three more-or-less interlocking stories has used his skill as a poet to sweep the reader away to the 17th century and into a world of princely courts, pirates and emperors, as the East and Terra Incognita begin to infest the European imagination.
The novel's three stories are all written as reflections on European attitudes to conquest, empire, and natives. The first section of the book, which revolves around the staging of an opera in a fictional kingdom to impress the young Louis XIV on a state visit, investigates heredity, the naked use of power, and the ability of the arts to expand human thought and horizons. Scarron, the King's composer and eminence grise of this section of the book, is low-born but the Kings favourite: a genius, but hated by all except the King. The opera is the first introduction to the reader of the idea of an island in the mind; with the story of the opera being reminiscent of King Lear. It's clear that Scarron longs for the island in the mind to be real, and compromises his own safety to try and find out all he can about Terra Incognita. The first section ends with Louis XIV arriving and taking over the kingdom by a coup de main. So some of the themes of the book are set in this first section: the European lust to discover new things, exploitation of people, the battle between money and honour (honour wins, just in this first section, but that changes further into the book), and the brutal truth of naked power.
The second section, focused around a young Venetian girl and an Aboriginal, who gets sold to the King of Spain only to be kidnapped by the Sultan, takes us further into the island in the mind, literally. Yuramiru actually gets into Isabella's mind, and takes her across Australia in her dreams - through the desert country, the scrub country, the mountain country and down to the sea. She becomes connected to him and he to her. When they realise that the Sultan is going to kill Yuramiru to display his bones as a curio, he leaps off the ship to drown, after giving Isabella two of his teeth and getting her to promise to have them buried in his homeland. This section of the book delves into concepts of freedom and slavery, and the ability of some people to treat others as less than human.
The final section of The Island in the Mind follows the Godolphin boys - Richard snr, his son Richard jnr and their nephew/cousin Denzil as they travel through Asia to track down the legendary pirate Captain Shilling, to try to co-opt him to engage in privateering for their own cause. As they are dragged further and further east in their search, they not only become besotted with the tropics, but realise that all is not as it seems when it comes to Captain Shilling. In fact it is Shilling who has been hunting the Godolphins, and he finally gets his way when Richard snr is drugged and taken aboard his ship. It turns out that Shilling is more philosopher than pirate, and in a reaction to a world where the greed for money has taken over, he has chosen the path of honour, and searches out Terra Incognita under the pretence of discovery but, as the reader discovers at the end of the book, actually to return Yuramiru's teeth, after meeting Isabella in the Emperor's harem. This section of the book shows us the reality of the European takeover of other countries, how greed and dishonesty are the rule when there are no moral or legal checks to behaviour. Shilling is a fascinating character, and in some respects a proxy for Australia itself - at first the descriptions of who he is and what he looks like vary widely, and when Richard Godolphin finally meets him he is an enigma - not at all a brutal privateer, but not above violence, a seeker, and a man who holds life cheaply. The final view Godolphin has of him is him waving as his ship is wrecked on the coast of Terra Incognita.
Until the end of the book Australia itself is not mentioned or described (the word Australia is not used at all throughout the book), and yet the idea of the land runs like a thread through the novel, drawing the narrative tighter and tighter until the final moment in the surf at the edge of the World. The longing of the Europeans for a pristine land to begin again or to see what Eden was like fights against the reality that Hall shows us of a land so unlike Europe, infinitely older and more reserved from human knowledge, containing a people with a society completely alien to European notions of property, rank or behaviour.
The Island in the Mind is a hard book book to describe - my 8 year old son asked me what I was reading when I was about half-way through and I realised that in many ways this is a book that defies description - Hall has interwoven huge questions about what it means to explore, discover and conquer into a narrative that glistens like a jewel - some of the descriptive prose sparkles like a raindrop in the sun. It is the prose that keeps dragging you through the book, even when you have no idea where Hall is taking you or how this book will end. It is a book that makes you think even as you enjoy turning the pages. He has truly made the island in the mind resonate, and you will be thinking about this book long after you put it down.
Highly recommended.
Check out my other reviews at http://aviewoverthebell.blogspot.com.au/
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 5, 2010
Was tempted to make this a 4-star, but can't remember it well enough. I do remember, though that my main thought at the time was "Why aren't more Australian writers this ambitious?" I recall impressive depth, scope, and intellectual rigour. It was a long time ago, though.One for a re-read, I think.
March 4, 2022
Of all Hall's novels I've read I've found this the most enjoyable. The story is excellent, dream-like and a pleasure to read. I found myself three quarters through it in a few days and then slowed my pace so I could savour Hall's excellent writing.
Three books, all linked and woven together beautifully in the final book, it's an epic tale of exploration, court politics in the 18th century, love, avarice, betrayal, lust, promise, treachery, romance and disappointment written in vivid prose.
The first book details the court happenings of an unnamed small monarchical nation state in Europe in the 1700s. A composer, the king's favourite, is working on an opera about the as yet undiscovered great southern land, Terra Incognita (Australia, though the name is never mentioned) in celebration of the state visit of the newly crowned King Louis 15th of France. As the composer, Scarron, researches and composes his epic tale he finds himself accused of treachery and sedition after liaising with the Portuguese, in an attempt to find evidence of the mystery content's mapped location. The book concludes with the king of France arriving and, well, I won't say any more!
The second book involves an unusual relationship between an enslaved young Aboriginal man and the daughter of a Venetian trader. For me this second book was a highlight of The Island In The Mind, its originality is outstanding.
The last book is an explorer's tale, three relations setting off on a voyage to the East Indies to track down several well known pirates operating in the area. Their mission to to enlist these pirates to help them secure trading routes for a new business venture. They find themselves waylaid, mocked and led astray by these pirates who have heard these three men are trying to track them down. Here the story has some major twists and delightful, intriguing turns before being brought together in an etherial crescendo of a finish that left me deeply moved and thinking about the book for long afterwards.
Hall's got to be one of the finest novelists Australia has produced. He's won the Miles Franklin twice, and for good reason.
The book creates a mythology behind the "discovery" of Australia, long before the continent itself is found by Europeans. It's such a great concept for a book and only Hall could pull it off. I absolutely loved every page of it.
Three books, all linked and woven together beautifully in the final book, it's an epic tale of exploration, court politics in the 18th century, love, avarice, betrayal, lust, promise, treachery, romance and disappointment written in vivid prose.
The first book details the court happenings of an unnamed small monarchical nation state in Europe in the 1700s. A composer, the king's favourite, is working on an opera about the as yet undiscovered great southern land, Terra Incognita (Australia, though the name is never mentioned) in celebration of the state visit of the newly crowned King Louis 15th of France. As the composer, Scarron, researches and composes his epic tale he finds himself accused of treachery and sedition after liaising with the Portuguese, in an attempt to find evidence of the mystery content's mapped location. The book concludes with the king of France arriving and, well, I won't say any more!
The second book involves an unusual relationship between an enslaved young Aboriginal man and the daughter of a Venetian trader. For me this second book was a highlight of The Island In The Mind, its originality is outstanding.
The last book is an explorer's tale, three relations setting off on a voyage to the East Indies to track down several well known pirates operating in the area. Their mission to to enlist these pirates to help them secure trading routes for a new business venture. They find themselves waylaid, mocked and led astray by these pirates who have heard these three men are trying to track them down. Here the story has some major twists and delightful, intriguing turns before being brought together in an etherial crescendo of a finish that left me deeply moved and thinking about the book for long afterwards.
Hall's got to be one of the finest novelists Australia has produced. He's won the Miles Franklin twice, and for good reason.
The book creates a mythology behind the "discovery" of Australia, long before the continent itself is found by Europeans. It's such a great concept for a book and only Hall could pull it off. I absolutely loved every page of it.
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews