An indispensable guide to koans, teaching the reader about the importance of lineage, the practice of “just sitting,” and koan practice as paths to awakening.
“This marvelous book opens the treasure house of Zen and yet, happily, does not dispel its mystery . James Ford, an excellent storyteller and longtime Zen practitioner, presents a detailed and beautiful description of the craft of zazen, including “just sitting” and various forms of breath meditation—but focuses primarily on koan introspection.
The power of koans, these 'public cases' from China, has never ceased to enrich my own experience of Zen. They are a medium of exploration of the history, culture, and view of Zen, but most importantly are a medium of awakening.
James Ford is fundamentally a koan person, and for this, the book is particularly rich, opening the practice of koans in a splendid way. I am grateful for his long experience as a teacher and practitioner of this rare and powerful practice. Since the word koan has found its way into popular English usage, I am grateful too for the more nuanced and fertile view of koans that Ford presents. His definition of the word is “a koan points to something of deep importance, and invites us to stand in that place.”
He has also has created a wonderful translation of the Heart Sutra, Zen’s central scripture—and carefully opens up the heart of the Heart Sutra through scholarship and practice. Rich in textual sources and woven throughout with the perspectives of contemporary teachers, Introduction to Zen Koans sheds new light on ancient teachings. Through it, the reader will discover the importance of lineage, the traceless traces of the Zen ancestors, and the places of “just sitting” and koan practice as paths to awakening, as the great doorways into Zen.” —from the foreword by Joan Halifax
Always a delight to read a new book by Roshi James Ford. He brings a unique perspective to Zen studies, a scholarly approach that combines the best of both ancient Buddhist texts plus a wide range of contemporary Buddhist scholars and teachers. In addition, he has a penchant for clarifying Buddhist traditions and practices to help make sure that Buddhism continues to thrive in the US, in ways that can help individuals but also maintain the rigor of traditional Buddhism practice.
This book is a bit of a misnomer in that it is really about more than koans. The book has 27 chapters and it really isn't until chapter 10 that he delves into koans. Early chapters focus on the life of Buddha and explaining the basics of Zen Buddhist practice, such as breathing, posture, and the history of Buddhism. Much of this information will be old hat to Buddhist practitioners but even when reviewing this material, Roshi Ford's long-time practice and scholarly bent make it so that these sections reward careful attention so that beginners and long-time practitioners would get something out of it.
Starting around chapter 10, Roshi Ford digs into koan studies. I have read a fair amount of books about koan study. This one covers some of the initial history of koans and the place of koans within the general practice life. He reviews some basic koans, including the Mu koan, though unlike other books on koans, he doesn't dig into particular koans into much depth, focusing more on the general nature of koan practice.
Throughout the book, Roshi Ford weaves his own experiences in the dharma, though he does this in a more modest way than other Zen books (other authors seem to concentrate on their own personal experience as a lens to help others understand practice). For him, I feel like his own personal practice and experience are less important than the wide scope and tradition of Zen history. Important to share his own experiences, but more important to weave into the narrative the teachings of others.
This is a quick read, written in clearly defined chapters of about 4 to 20 pages each. Thank you for your teaching Roshi Ford. Highly recommended!
I enjoyed this text tremendously and would recommend it over some other introductory texts I've encountered like, for instance, The Heart of the Buddha's Teaching by Thich Nhat Hanh. Ford writes with remarkable clarity, even on difficult subjects, and I appreciate that he takes a broad view informed by a number of spiritual perspectives and religious traditions outside of Western Zen Buddhism alone.
It is impossible to say with any certainty how much of my positive reaction here is a reflection on the quality of Ford's writing, and how much of it is a reflection on the conditions in which I read it. Not least of these conditions is my own evolving Zen practice, which has included engagement with koans with my teacher for a little over a year. That is, if my practice can be called a practice at all, given that I still do not meet Ford's 30-minutes-per-day bare minimum zazen threshold that I also noted in my 2022 review of his If You're Lucky Your Heart Will Break. He's probably right, and this may explain the (snail's) pace of my progress through the koan curriculum. I will admit—I think I turned to this book more than a little bit because I was looking for help, or at least looking for a kind of help that I've struggled to ask my teacher for. Of course, Ford's book both helped and didn't help. We can only expect so much from a book. I was reassured by the couple odd places that Ford acknowledges that practitioners get little guidance on how exactly to approach koans in the dokusan room and things can be a bit unclear (it has indeed felt that way, and yes, yes, there's some ego going on there that I was looking for reassurances at all, but a little can go a long way, I think). Not for nothing, I also got to enjoy a well-written, very educational book that touched on all manner of interesting, new-to-me historical context. But in the end, as far as my koan practice is concerned, I suspect there is no substitute for living life with as much awareness and intention as we can muster, including, to my chagrin, on the cushion. It's fortunate that I have a lifetime to keep practicing, reading, and seeing what else might be alive in the dokusan room!