I normally don't review books I don't like, but this one had so many errors I felt like I should mention them. (If you're the author, I'm sorry if this seems harsh. I'm just stating facts, not trying to tear you down.) I know that this book is a kid's book, but as a kid, these errors would've annoyed me because I knew a lot about animals. I feel like the author didn't know much about animals and didn't take the time to do the research to get things right. Yes, it's fantasy, but adding a dose of realism, especially when the book is dealing with environmental issues, would really have helped my ability to enjoy the book. Here are some of the errors.
I myself live on a ranch in Montana, so I know a bit about animals, the climate, and hunting.
1. Arctic wolves are not forest animals. Their white coats help them blend into snow and tundra, but would stick out in a forest. Forests are where you're more likely to find black wolves, not white ones. (This may be mentioned in the book, but only in passing.)
2. The main character's pack doesn't hunt, so they eat fish and she supplements them with chicken and pumpkin stew. (Why killing a bunch of chickens is preferable to one deer is beyond me.) Firstly, she can't grow pumpkins in the spring. Those are fall crops. Secondly, a couple dozen chickens aren't going to feed a pack of six wolves. Wolves as big as hers should be eating seven pounds of meat a day.
3. Wolves are too small for a twelve year old to ride. These are canines, not horses.
4. You candle eggs after you've incubated them a couple days and then you can tell if they're developing. You can't tell if an egg is fertile, even if you crack it open. After the rooster dies, the eggs will be fertile for a couple weeks. (I'm also wondering how this girl was hatching the chicks since broody hens don't lay eggs.)
5. The main character rescues a black and white bunny at the start of the book. This coloration only happens in domestic breeds, but the story acts like it's a wild rabbit. If it's a domestic rabbit, she abandoned it in the wilderness.
6. The story acts like wolves only eat other canines if they're starving. Actually, wolves kill other canines to protect their territory, so they'll kill them even if they're well-fed.
7. The girl rescued a baby owl and fed it worms. Baby owls should be fed real meat, like mice and other small rodents. She also gave it water. Baby birds should never be given water. They get all they need from the food they eat.
8. The main character sees a trap and springs it. Firstly, trappers hide traps because wolves won't step in them willingly. Secondly, the purpose of a leg hold trap isn't to maim the animal, it's to hold it so the trapper can get it.
9. The wolf bounty makes little sense. The first thing to do in a situation like this is legalize wolf hunting, then the farmers and ranchers will defend their livestock. During the winter, wolf pelts are very valuable, so there's no need for a bounty. (Coyote pelts go for over fifty bucks, and wolf pelts are much higher.) Granted, pelts are worth little in the spring and summer.
10. If an injured wolf can stand, it will run from fire. Animals are a lot tougher than they get credit for.
The environmental agenda in this book is quite annoying. Why can't farmers and ranchers defend their their livestock from a pack of wolves who is moving in on the rancher's territory? The author depicts the wild as some utopia with humans being the only problem, and never shows what wolf overpopulation does to the other animals. Why not show how a pack of wolves will decimate the deer population, kill all the baby moose and elk, and eat everything before dying horribly of disease and starvation? I'd have liked to see the book address how to deal with wolf overpopulation, which is a real problem, especially if they're near human habitation.
I don't have anything against animal fantasy, but I do have a problem with it when it paints an unrealistic view of wild animals in a way that leaves humans as the only problem they face.
For good things about the book, it does have decent pacing, a sense of wonder, and the main character is clever, and the few illustrations I saw are cute.