Pepper Brooks is busy navigating her final quarter at NWU. She's excited but sad to know her friends will be leaving soon. She's also left wondering where she stands with her maybe boyfriend Alex upon his return from the police academy in Seattle. Then there's student Sam Delaney who keeps going on about the poor water quality on campus. When Pepper stumbles across fellow student Katie lying dead in the campus creek, Pepper vows to stay out of the police investigation. She trusts them to figure this out without her, after all, there was nothing literary about Katie's death, was there? As more female students turn up dead, Pepper begins to see a connection. Is she crazy? She's terrified Liv could be next and is determined to keep that from happening, even if it means breaking her promise to Alex.
I didn't like this one as much as the first book in the series. First, I don't enjoy Hemmingway and other early-mid- 20th-century American writers. I never read any of the stories mentioned in this book. Second, I didn't like the high body count in this one. I ESPECIALLY can't stand violence against women and this story is tailor made for me to not like. I thought I knew whodunit because it can't be an obvious suspect or a recurring character and one person stood out to me as super creepy and weird. I was certain it was that person until a clue late in the story popped up pointing me in a different direction. I wasn't 100% certain which one was the killer. The dramatic finale requires a LOT of suspension of disbelief. It was so crazy! I also found the literary connection to the deaths to be quite a stretch. It was rather odd and absurd. The romance subplot was OK but not my favorite. I could take it or leave it at this point.
Pepper is young but she's learned from her missteps in the previous book. She's trying hard to change her reputation and grow into someone her future colleagues can respect. I'm not sure why she assumes she's going to automatically get a teaching job at NWU or that the same people she takes classes from will be her colleagues but Pepper goes through life wearing rose-colored glasses. At that age, I too thought I had the world at my feet and I was destined to fulfill my dreams. Pepper isn't experienced enough at life yet to become jaded and disillusioned but this is why I like her. She's sweet, friendly and charming. Alex is kind of Mr. Big Shot. He's a rookie cop after completing the police academy in a matter of months and assigned to the Pine Crest PD already, as automatically as Pepper will be given a professorship at NWU I guess. Nepotism. Alex has a softer side than his dad though. Detective Valdez is tough and super serious. Alex has a softer side. He misses his mom who was killed in the line of duty and feels connected to her through reading her favorite classic novels. AWWW!! When he's being son Alex and reader Alex, he's sweet and charming but when he's cop Alex, he tries too hard to emulate his dad and becomes kind of a jerk at times. Of course he claims he cares about Pepper and wants her to be safe. Liv is a better friend. She knows what Pepper wants to do it wrong but to make sure Pepper is safe, she plays Watson to Pepper's Sherlock. Liv is a lot smarter than Pepper and makes better judgement calls but she goes along for the ride and actually enjoys it. I appreciate that she's a female in a man's world and can keep up with the guys. They respect her and appreciate her. I hope that continues. Hammy, the Boston Terrier, is the cutest little love bug. She can sense people's emotions and is always there to help. I just want to steal her!
Naked Newt is growing on me. He's a nice guy, albeit socially awkward. I'd wonder if he was on the autism spectrum because he's definitely off. I think he likes Pepper and Liv and wants to be friends with them but doesn't really know how. If they let him, I think they could be friends. Plus, that could snag them free coffee! Alex's partner, Frank, is a fun character. He's lively and charming but maybe a little too meddling at times. I don't like Liv's boyfriend, Carson. She says she likes him because he makes her laugh but it's clear she's more serious and intelligent than he is. I don't expect this romance to last past graduation. He can't keep up with her. Plus, now he's in a relationship, he's eager to push Alex and Pepper together. Carson and Alex seem like opposites and yet enjoy each other's company. I wouldn't trust them to hang out together. Alex might be a bad influence on Carson and make Carson into a serious, overprotective jerk. At least Alex does have the right to ask Pepper not to investigate because he's a cop. Pepper's sister Maggie is such a lovely big sister. I adore how much of a theater geek she is and didn't need her to explain the comet reference.
The victim was "Crazy Katie" who we met in the previous book. My heart sank because she was obviously somewhat unstable and probably put her trust in the wrong man. Her bragging and made-up stories may have angered someone to kill her. What if it was a professor? Pepper keeps hearing stories that point in that direction. Katie didn't deserve to die.
Reuben Cross, Pepper's new classmate, is one weird guy. He's REALLY into Hemmingway and seems as into Pepper as he is Hemmingway. He has a funny way of showing appreciation and gives me the creeps. I don't trust him, especially around women. Sam Delaney is another weirdo. Are all the men on campus creeps? Sam keeps going on and on about the water supply but never actually explains what he means and what his evidence is. He wants the administration to pay attention to the issue but what exactly IS the issue? He has a tendency towards violence and may have been at the scene of the crime just before the murder. Should Pepper trust him? NO WAY! Professor Garrison is a charismatic theater professor all the girls seem to adore. Some girls adore him more than they should and that's just wrong of him. It's unprofessional AND he's married. He's a total sleaze and I kept hoping he would be the one to get killed. Pepper suspects he might be the murderer. That's too obvious. I don't think he's that smart. He's not smart enough to hide his affairs. However, it could be Mrs. Garrison. If this were the Shakespeare themed book we could pull in the quote about a woman scorned. Why resort to murdering her husband's student lovers though? That sounds counterproductive because these GIRLS aren't old enough to realize they've been taken advantage of. They deserve sympathy, not murder.
The bartender, Isaac, seems like he's either a nice guy or a creep. He intervenes with the mean girls but he also gives Pepper special treatment. He's 10 years older and a bar owner so he shouldn't be showing favoritism towards a student and patron of his establishment. I don't think he deserves the witch hunt the town council is mounting for no reason other than he's a stranger.
There are a lot of mean girls on campus. Ginger, an education major who works in the library, is the opposite of Pepper. She's quick to make sly innuendo and offers false sincerity. Pepper doesn't trust the scientists (YES! Don't trust anyone who doesn't read novels!) They are true mean girls, making snide remarks about a fellow student drinking alone. Heidi Schultz is the Queen Bee, a cheerleader and mean girl to her core. She's rude and totally misguided on what makes a real man. I don't like her any more than Pepper does but she doesn't deserve her fate. Her boyfriend, Nick, seems a little scary. Although he refused to fight a rival baseball player on the field, he seems to have a barely contained temper. If I were Alex, I would have nipped that in the bud right away by bringing him in to the station.
I like Mindy so much! She is like me- sitting at a table, reading a big book, drinking alone and minding her own business. She's my new favorite character. That's why what happened came as a huge shock and upset. I also really like Victoria from the coffee cart. She's shy and quiet and rarely speaks. She may know more about the first murder than she is willing to say. Pepper is kind and compassionate towards the girl but has an ulterior motive I can't quite like. Pepper also pushes Victoria into doing something she isn't comfortable doing. The poor girl is terrified. At least Det. Valdez isn't his usual stern self with her.
I do love all the bookish references and the next story revolved around AHHHH cue angel music AHHHH JANE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I need to read that one so even though I disliked this one, I'm going to keep going. Plus any story about dear Jane's characters will be lighter than Hemmingway.