4.5 stars for this Psychological thriller. I was roped in just from reading the first few pages.
Main characters are The Connolley family; David, husband, father and professor, Caroline, wife and mother, their two children, Robbie and Holly and another possible? Daughter named Zoe. Zoe is supposedly? the result of a previous affair David had with his “passionate, one true love,” Linda, while in school and in between an off/on relationship with his current wife, Caroline.
David and Linda had parted ways; David never knew there was a pregnancy/child, until a young woman shows up to his teaching class and then comes to his office at the university telling him she’s his daughter. Her delivery of the message and lacking proof and odd speak and body language (he describes her as shy, waif-like) leave a lot to be desired/believed, so at first she is not taken seriously. Get ready as once the word gets out, this turns not only David’s world upside down, but also the rest of their family and friends, and his position at the University ends up at stake, Caroline’s position at her employer starts to show stress cracks and also her relationship with David suffers so much more so. Holly starts to withdraw, and Robbie becomes aggressive at school.
David has many ongoing flashbacks of his relationship with the departed Linda. At times, he confuses Zoe with Linda. He’s really in a la la land state of mind as he relives in his mind his and Linda’s young love. It’s the connection he had with Linda of this “true, passionate love” that makes it easy for Zoe to be fully accepted by him. I wanted to smack him in the head for so easily falling into her trap without fully confirming questionable details from her. He really was a weak, confused man, however, without his weakness, this story would not get on. We wonder why he got back together with Caroline a 2nd time and then married her - supposedly because it was “safe.”
Caroline, David’s wife, thinks from the get go, that something is way off with all this and she is not happy with the surprise announcement, Zoe’s presence and the upheaval it brings into their lives. But Caroline is no angel either, and everyone has lies they are telling, past secrets they are hiding.
David brings Zoe into their house and into their family and little by little, Zoe neatly and firmly entrenches herself into their lives. As for the Connolley kids, Robbie has some sort of attraction for Zoe and Holly has a big dislike and distrust for Zoe and detests her for showing up and being in their home.
David was so easily manipulated by Zoe. He seems overly infatuated that she is “his daughter.” Caroline, however, is the one who starts checking even further into Zoe’s background and her distrust continues to grow with proof. Her relationship with her husband continues to shatter. David and Caroline continue to see and experience behavioral issues in their children and between themselves since this hot mess of Zoe began. There also are DNA tests to prove/disprove David is Zoe’s father, but with different results. How can this be? Keep on reading...
We are teased psychologically and constantly throughout the story. There are many twists and turns as you try to figure things out, but nonetheless, each page reveals more and more and before you know it, you are coming on to the end of the book. And the surprises just keep on coming. You just have to read it. This was a really good story about an off base, manipulative young woman and the sheer destruction she caused, not just for this particular family, but her adoptive parents, her stepfather, and anyone else who crossed her path.