I have to say, this struck me as rather a strange book, but once I got into its groove, I actually enjoyed it very much. It almost reads like a superhero comic book without the pictures. I expect Smoke Bellew is essentially an idealised version of the author, Jack London, himself, and represents how London would like to be if he had superhuman strength and courage. It lacks the emotional depth and honesty to be a proper book for adults, but is certainly not a book for children.
One of the main attractions of the book is how much it teaches you, indirectly, about the Klondike gold rush, which has always fascinated me. The only other writer I am aware of who tackles it to any degree is the poet, Robert Service. Living in Australia, I have long been fascinated by the similarities and differences between Australia and Canada. The Yukon and the Australian Outback have much in common. They are both hostile, extreme environments, with little water or cultivable land and sparse populations. The main difference, of course, is that the Yukon is very cold, while the Australian Outback is very hot. Australia has also had its gold rushes. Australia also has its own snow country, but it is nowhere near as extensive, or as cold, as Canada's.
Smoke Bellew is something of a Paul Bunyan. Whereas Bunyan is competing against modern technology, Bellew is showing that a 'newbie' (or 'cheechako') can match it with an old timer. There seems to be nothing Bellew cannot achieve if he applies himself wholeheartedly to the task in hand.
Much of the description of the various ice, snow and water conditions went over my head, but I understood enough to get the general gist most of the time. London is certainly inventive, and manages to dream up a good number of diverse challenges for Bellew to tackle.
London appears to have a real problem describing male/female relationships. This was especially so in 'The Sea Wolf', and 'Smoke Bellew' is no exception. Yes, there is a love interest in the book, but the relationship is strictly platonic. The reader is left to imagine that the two may have eventually become closer, but London certainly isn't going to tell you about it!
All in all, though the book has a very old fashioned feel to it, it is a great fun read, and the unusual nature of the subject matter adds further appeal. For people who love historical books set in the snow, like me, it is definitely worth reading.