What do you think?
Rate this book
Bitter Root Mysteries #2
Bitter Truth
Bitter Truth (Book 2 of Bitter Root Mysteries)
In the isolated ranching community of Lost Trails, Montana, Lacy Stillman, a rich elderly rancher has died of a heart attack in her own bed. What could be more normal than that? As Zak Waller, dispatcher with the local Sheriff’s Office, joins the town in mourning the loss of the community matriarch, some disquieting information makes Zak wonder if Lacy’s death was not what it seemed.
Meanwhile, Zak's friend Tiff Masterson is overwhelmed by her mother’s escalating mental breakdown and her aunt’s stubborn denial of the problem. Tiff’s load becomes even heavier when family friend and local lawyer Justin Pittman looks to her for help with his own serious health issues.
When an unexpected connection is discovered between the Mastersons and the Pittmans, an old crime is uncovered with far reaching ramifications that will change everything.
In the isolated ranching community of Lost Trails, Montana, Lacy Stillman, a rich elderly rancher has died of a heart attack in her own bed. What could be more normal than that? As Zak Waller, dispatcher with the local Sheriff’s Office, joins the town in mourning the loss of the community matriarch, some disquieting information makes Zak wonder if Lacy’s death was not what it seemed.
Meanwhile, Zak's friend Tiff Masterson is overwhelmed by her mother’s escalating mental breakdown and her aunt’s stubborn denial of the problem. Tiff’s load becomes even heavier when family friend and local lawyer Justin Pittman looks to her for help with his own serious health issues.
When an unexpected connection is discovered between the Mastersons and the Pittmans, an old crime is uncovered with far reaching ramifications that will change everything.
338 pages, Kindle Edition
First published February 15, 2018
645 people are currently reading
320 people want to read
About the author
C.J. Carmichael
107 books831 followersUSA Today bestselling author C. J. Carmichael has written over 50 novels, including two mystery series, as well as romance and women’s fiction. Three of her novels have been nominated for the Romance Writers of America RITA Award, including A Bramble House Christmas. A film version of A Bramble House Christmas premiered as a Hallmark Mystery movie in 2017.
Married, with two grown daughters and some adorable grandchildren, C. J. and her husband and their Welsh Springer Jazz divide their time between their home in Calgary, Alberta and the family cottage on Flathead Lake, Montana. C.J. enjoys giving workshops to aspiring authors--her talk on writing a Christmas story is a favorite.
Visit C.J.'s website at http://CJCarmichael.com
For information on C. J.’s new releases and giveaways please sign up for her newsletter.
https://cjcarmichael.com/contact/#sub...
Married, with two grown daughters and some adorable grandchildren, C. J. and her husband and their Welsh Springer Jazz divide their time between their home in Calgary, Alberta and the family cottage on Flathead Lake, Montana. C.J. enjoys giving workshops to aspiring authors--her talk on writing a Christmas story is a favorite.
Visit C.J.'s website at http://CJCarmichael.com
For information on C. J.’s new releases and giveaways please sign up for her newsletter.
https://cjcarmichael.com/contact/#sub...
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 90 reviews
April 22, 2018
Bitter Truth by C.J. Carmichael is the second book in the Bitter Root Mysteries series. Each book in the series is centered around a new mystery so they could be understood if reading as a standalone however there is character development carried over from the first book.
In this installment of the series the citizens of Lost Trails, Montana are all mourning the loss of ninety one year old Lacy Stillman when she is found in her home presumably having suffered a heart attack. As details come about and the debate over Lacy’s wealth begins Zak Waller begins to question whether the death really was natural causes or not seeing that Lacy had just had her check up and a clean bill of health.
While things heat up with Lacy’s death Tiff Masterson is going through a lot with her mother and aunt. Having returned to Lost Trails recently she begins to question her mother’s mental health but her aunt will hear nothing of the sort. It’s assumed Tiff’s father and brother passing years before are the cause but Tiff finds herself in for a huge surprise when old family secrets become uncovered.
Again I found myself amazed at what C.J. Carmichael can accomplish with a story in such a short time. These books aren’t incredibly long but so much gets packed into each story and never once do I feel like the details are forgotten or the mystery is too rushed. Everything in the book is woven together wonderfully to keep a reader guessing through each turn of the page and the characters have more depth to them than some 500+ page reads. After finishing this installment I’ll definitely be interested in the next book in this series for sure.
I received a copy from the publisher via NetGalley.
For more reviews please visit https://carriesbookreviews.com/
In this installment of the series the citizens of Lost Trails, Montana are all mourning the loss of ninety one year old Lacy Stillman when she is found in her home presumably having suffered a heart attack. As details come about and the debate over Lacy’s wealth begins Zak Waller begins to question whether the death really was natural causes or not seeing that Lacy had just had her check up and a clean bill of health.
While things heat up with Lacy’s death Tiff Masterson is going through a lot with her mother and aunt. Having returned to Lost Trails recently she begins to question her mother’s mental health but her aunt will hear nothing of the sort. It’s assumed Tiff’s father and brother passing years before are the cause but Tiff finds herself in for a huge surprise when old family secrets become uncovered.
Again I found myself amazed at what C.J. Carmichael can accomplish with a story in such a short time. These books aren’t incredibly long but so much gets packed into each story and never once do I feel like the details are forgotten or the mystery is too rushed. Everything in the book is woven together wonderfully to keep a reader guessing through each turn of the page and the characters have more depth to them than some 500+ page reads. After finishing this installment I’ll definitely be interested in the next book in this series for sure.
I received a copy from the publisher via NetGalley.
For more reviews please visit https://carriesbookreviews.com/
February 20, 2018
Small town secrets come to the forefront in this fascinating second book of the Bitter Root mysteries.
Lacy Stillman, a 91-year-old rancher woman has been found dead in her bed by one of her sons. Evidently she died of a heart attack even though a doctor's visit the day before pronounced her as very healthy. She has been the town's leading citizen and the whole town is in mourning.
Zak Waller, the police dispatcher who should be a deputy, has some information that may shed a different light on Lucy's death.
(Book Blurb) Zak's friend Tiff Masterson is overwhelmed by her mother’s escalating mental breakdown and her aunt’s stubborn denial of the problem. Tiff assumes the root of the problem is the death of her brother and father sixteen years ago. But the real atrocity goes back much further than that. When the truth is revealed in a shocking twist, Tiff’s world is turned completely upside down. The ramifications affect many of the most prominent citizens and provide the missing clue to Lacy Stillman’s murder.
Bitter Truth is the second of a 3-book series. Although this is easily read as a stand alone, I would highly recommend reading them in order.
The characters are fascinating. I love how a small community can come together ... to either hide secrets or reveal them. The family dynamics are guaranteed to keep the reader turning pages. There's a wealth of town residents that bear watching. It's fairly fast-paced and every page is a twist, a turn, a surprise.
There's no cliff hanger, but a hint of what is to come next. This is definitely an enjoyable mystery.
Many thanks to the author / Tule Publishing / Netgalley for the digital copy. Opinions expressed here are unbiased and entirely my own.
Lacy Stillman, a 91-year-old rancher woman has been found dead in her bed by one of her sons. Evidently she died of a heart attack even though a doctor's visit the day before pronounced her as very healthy. She has been the town's leading citizen and the whole town is in mourning.
Zak Waller, the police dispatcher who should be a deputy, has some information that may shed a different light on Lucy's death.
(Book Blurb) Zak's friend Tiff Masterson is overwhelmed by her mother’s escalating mental breakdown and her aunt’s stubborn denial of the problem. Tiff assumes the root of the problem is the death of her brother and father sixteen years ago. But the real atrocity goes back much further than that. When the truth is revealed in a shocking twist, Tiff’s world is turned completely upside down. The ramifications affect many of the most prominent citizens and provide the missing clue to Lacy Stillman’s murder.
Bitter Truth is the second of a 3-book series. Although this is easily read as a stand alone, I would highly recommend reading them in order.
The characters are fascinating. I love how a small community can come together ... to either hide secrets or reveal them. The family dynamics are guaranteed to keep the reader turning pages. There's a wealth of town residents that bear watching. It's fairly fast-paced and every page is a twist, a turn, a surprise.
There's no cliff hanger, but a hint of what is to come next. This is definitely an enjoyable mystery.
Many thanks to the author / Tule Publishing / Netgalley for the digital copy. Opinions expressed here are unbiased and entirely my own.
February 15, 2018
LET ME FIGURE OUT WHAT I DID NOT LIKE ABOUT C.J. Carmichael's "Bitter Truth". Hummm...? Well not anything to mention here. NOW WHAT DID I LIKE ABOUT THIS MYSTERY? It was a stand-alone which was good since I had not read Bitter Root#1. The characters were amazing and interesting even the murder victim Lacy who died at the beginning of the book. There was family drama times three to keep the pages turning. Budding romances that were just that; not yet blooming but being pollinated. Past events never really going away but getting the dusty attic box opened to the light. Has the cat, the dog, adorable preschool girls and hay rides. Great holiday novel that takes place from Thanksgiving through the end of the year in a small community. Had a wealth of town folks to keep track of but as the mystery progressed everyone had their place and key roll to play. Did not end on a cliff hanger but did leave some crumbs to follow into the next book. "A copy of this book was provided by Tule Publishing via Netgalley with no requirements for a review. Comments here are my honest opinion." This is a great narrative not to miss.
January 25, 2019
After meeting the main characters and the Bitter Root community along with a twisting murder mystery, I was primed and ready to keep going with the series and enjoy further developments in the lives, loves, secrets, and yes, another murder in small town Montana.
Bitter Truth is book two of the Bitter Root series. A reader could pick it up out of order, but it reads best after the first book because of the ongoing personal and romantic story lines introduced in Bitter Roots.
The story begins with the death of Lacy Stillman, a large ranch owner in the community. The Stillmans are shook by Lacy's surprising will and how it complicates matters. Their lawyer, Justin Pittman, is undergoing his own crisis after his wife deserted him and his newly adopted daughter right when he learns his cancer is back. Tiff is still feeling unsettled about coming home and where things stand with her new love interest when her aunt starts acting strange and her mother's mental health deteriorates. Meanwhile, Zach is not convinced Lacy's death was an accident. Little things don't add up and the sheriff isn't planning to pursue them so he is forced to play amateur detective once again while also trying to figure out what happened to cause Nadine to back away when he thought they were finally getting a chance.
So, the author has written a full plot with three different narrators and their separate storylines that cross paths and occasionally come together. Because of this, like the first book, it can take a while for the plot to move forward at times. I was ready for the strong character driven gentle pacing and enjoy how it is a bit of everything as a result- fiction, romance, and suspense.
This is the story of a town because of all the storylines and characters and I enjoy that. It is also the story of the three people around the same age dealing with personal issues, family, and love. Tiff has to figure out where she belongs and if she is ready to try out a relationship again after the last disaster. Zach needs to work through letting his past dictate his future which means not hiding behind the dispatcher desk and maybe try for a deputy job that suits him better and also work harder at what he has with Nadine. Justin's story breaks my heart a little. He just wanted a family of his own and a child. His wife loves someone else and wants to jetset around the world with the guy so came back to marry then leave him, but at least he has a child. He fought cancer alone the first time to protect his dad from worry, but now it came back and worse so he has to tell his dad and his daughter while worrying what will happen if a stem cell donor can't be found. He's also found a nice woman and her daughter who he enjoys being around, but he's still married and has no guarantees beyond a year left.
Now, the mystery turns out to be not so straight forward because it turns out there are three mysteries. Tiff is confused by what is going on with her aunt and what she is hiding while Zach is working at a death that he feels was a murder, but has no actual proof yet. And, then a woman goes missing. The twists and suspense were great when they built to the surprise ending. Well, I worked out the big shockers based on a few curious points earlier in the book, but I still had a great time seeing that I was right and how that all fell out.
So, this second book in the series was fabulous if a bit slow to get rolling at first. Those who want a cozy mystery paired with a romantic suspense should definitely check out this series.
Bitter Truth is book two of the Bitter Root series. A reader could pick it up out of order, but it reads best after the first book because of the ongoing personal and romantic story lines introduced in Bitter Roots.
The story begins with the death of Lacy Stillman, a large ranch owner in the community. The Stillmans are shook by Lacy's surprising will and how it complicates matters. Their lawyer, Justin Pittman, is undergoing his own crisis after his wife deserted him and his newly adopted daughter right when he learns his cancer is back. Tiff is still feeling unsettled about coming home and where things stand with her new love interest when her aunt starts acting strange and her mother's mental health deteriorates. Meanwhile, Zach is not convinced Lacy's death was an accident. Little things don't add up and the sheriff isn't planning to pursue them so he is forced to play amateur detective once again while also trying to figure out what happened to cause Nadine to back away when he thought they were finally getting a chance.
So, the author has written a full plot with three different narrators and their separate storylines that cross paths and occasionally come together. Because of this, like the first book, it can take a while for the plot to move forward at times. I was ready for the strong character driven gentle pacing and enjoy how it is a bit of everything as a result- fiction, romance, and suspense.
This is the story of a town because of all the storylines and characters and I enjoy that. It is also the story of the three people around the same age dealing with personal issues, family, and love. Tiff has to figure out where she belongs and if she is ready to try out a relationship again after the last disaster. Zach needs to work through letting his past dictate his future which means not hiding behind the dispatcher desk and maybe try for a deputy job that suits him better and also work harder at what he has with Nadine. Justin's story breaks my heart a little. He just wanted a family of his own and a child. His wife loves someone else and wants to jetset around the world with the guy so came back to marry then leave him, but at least he has a child. He fought cancer alone the first time to protect his dad from worry, but now it came back and worse so he has to tell his dad and his daughter while worrying what will happen if a stem cell donor can't be found. He's also found a nice woman and her daughter who he enjoys being around, but he's still married and has no guarantees beyond a year left.
Now, the mystery turns out to be not so straight forward because it turns out there are three mysteries. Tiff is confused by what is going on with her aunt and what she is hiding while Zach is working at a death that he feels was a murder, but has no actual proof yet. And, then a woman goes missing. The twists and suspense were great when they built to the surprise ending. Well, I worked out the big shockers based on a few curious points earlier in the book, but I still had a great time seeing that I was right and how that all fell out.
So, this second book in the series was fabulous if a bit slow to get rolling at first. Those who want a cozy mystery paired with a romantic suspense should definitely check out this series.
April 21, 2023
I'm really enjoying this series.
It could be a stand alone, but I don't recommend it.
In this one, there are some twists and turns. Zak the dispatcher is great.
The romance is miniscule, but safe. No OW/OM, no cheating, and it's kisses only.
No cursing.
I plan to read them all
It could be a stand alone, but I don't recommend it.
In this one, there are some twists and turns. Zak the dispatcher is great.
The romance is miniscule, but safe. No OW/OM, no cheating, and it's kisses only.
No cursing.
I plan to read them all
June 26, 2025
A good fast fun read. A strong 4-4.5 stars. Just bought book 2.
February 16, 2018
Bitter Truth by CJ Carmichael
Book Two of the Bitter Root series MYSTERY
Murder in a small town is always personal.
In the isolated ranching community of Lost Trails, Montana, Lacy Stillman, a rich elderly rancher has died of a heart attack in her own bed. What could be more normal than that? As Zak Waller, dispatcher with the local Sheriff’s Office, joins the town in mourning the loss of the community matriarch, some disquieting information makes Zak wonder if Lacy’s death was not what it seemed.
Meanwhile, Zak’s friend Tiff Masterson is overwhelmed by her mother’s escalating mental breakdown and her aunt’s stubborn denial of the problem. Tiff assumes the root of the problem is the death of her brother and father sixteen-years-ago. But the real atrocity goes back much further than that.
When the truth is revealed in a shocking twist, Tiff’s world is turned completely upside down. The ramifications affect many of the most prominent citizens and provide the missing clue to Lacy Stillman’s murder.
this is Zak Waller and Tiff Masterson’s story.
Tiff knowing her aunt was visiting friends in Hamilton and her mother rarely answered the phone Tiff dash to the kitchen. the phone for the third time. want me to get that? Tiff asked.
I wanted to let your mom know Lacy Stillman died in her sleep last night Sybil said.
Zak was at the coffee machine when the call came in on the Lost Trail, Montana, emergency line, three days before Thanksgiving.
As dispatcher, he was used to being treated like low man on the totem pole by Sheriff Ford and Deputy Butterfield.
And Zak Waller wasn’t your typical dispatcher.
Zak abandoned his mug and leapt over a box of evidence from their last big case to grab the phone. “You’ve reached 911, what’s your emergency?” He grabbed his notepad and pen, ready for whatever was to come.
Was Lacy Stillman’s death not what it seemed? read this book to find out.
I highly recommend reading.
Bitter Truth by CJ Carmichael is a wonderful well written 5 star book.
"I voluntarily reviewed an Advance Reader Copy of this book."
I am looking forward to reading Bitter End Bitter Root mysteries series Book 3 by CJ Carmichael.
CJ's Books with Tule:
Promise Me, Cowboy
Carrigans of the Circle C
The 75th Copper Mountain Rodeo
Good Together
Carrigans of the Circle C
Close to Her Heart
Carrigans of the Circle C
Snowbound in Montana
Carrigans of the Circle C
A Cowgirl’s Christmas
Carrigans of the Circle C
Writing the Bestseller: Romantic and Commercial Fiction
Non-Fiction
Writing the Bestseller II: Romantic and Commercial Fiction
Non-Fiction
A Bramble House Christmas
Carrigans of the Circle C
A Book Girl’s Guide to Marietta
Melt My Heart, Cowboy
Love at the Chocolate Shop
Bitter Roots (Bitter Root Mysteries Book 1
Bitter Truth (Bitter Root Mysteries Book 2
Bitter End Bitter Root mysteries Book 3
Book Two of the Bitter Root series MYSTERY
Murder in a small town is always personal.
In the isolated ranching community of Lost Trails, Montana, Lacy Stillman, a rich elderly rancher has died of a heart attack in her own bed. What could be more normal than that? As Zak Waller, dispatcher with the local Sheriff’s Office, joins the town in mourning the loss of the community matriarch, some disquieting information makes Zak wonder if Lacy’s death was not what it seemed.
Meanwhile, Zak’s friend Tiff Masterson is overwhelmed by her mother’s escalating mental breakdown and her aunt’s stubborn denial of the problem. Tiff assumes the root of the problem is the death of her brother and father sixteen-years-ago. But the real atrocity goes back much further than that.
When the truth is revealed in a shocking twist, Tiff’s world is turned completely upside down. The ramifications affect many of the most prominent citizens and provide the missing clue to Lacy Stillman’s murder.
this is Zak Waller and Tiff Masterson’s story.
Tiff knowing her aunt was visiting friends in Hamilton and her mother rarely answered the phone Tiff dash to the kitchen. the phone for the third time. want me to get that? Tiff asked.
I wanted to let your mom know Lacy Stillman died in her sleep last night Sybil said.
Zak was at the coffee machine when the call came in on the Lost Trail, Montana, emergency line, three days before Thanksgiving.
As dispatcher, he was used to being treated like low man on the totem pole by Sheriff Ford and Deputy Butterfield.
And Zak Waller wasn’t your typical dispatcher.
Zak abandoned his mug and leapt over a box of evidence from their last big case to grab the phone. “You’ve reached 911, what’s your emergency?” He grabbed his notepad and pen, ready for whatever was to come.
Was Lacy Stillman’s death not what it seemed? read this book to find out.
I highly recommend reading.
Bitter Truth by CJ Carmichael is a wonderful well written 5 star book.
"I voluntarily reviewed an Advance Reader Copy of this book."
I am looking forward to reading Bitter End Bitter Root mysteries series Book 3 by CJ Carmichael.
CJ's Books with Tule:
Promise Me, Cowboy
Carrigans of the Circle C
The 75th Copper Mountain Rodeo
Good Together
Carrigans of the Circle C
Close to Her Heart
Carrigans of the Circle C
Snowbound in Montana
Carrigans of the Circle C
A Cowgirl’s Christmas
Carrigans of the Circle C
Writing the Bestseller: Romantic and Commercial Fiction
Non-Fiction
Writing the Bestseller II: Romantic and Commercial Fiction
Non-Fiction
A Bramble House Christmas
Carrigans of the Circle C
A Book Girl’s Guide to Marietta
Melt My Heart, Cowboy
Love at the Chocolate Shop
Bitter Roots (Bitter Root Mysteries Book 1
Bitter Truth (Bitter Root Mysteries Book 2
Bitter End Bitter Root mysteries Book 3
February 18, 2018
There are a lot of secrets in the town of Lost Trails, Montana. But when Lacy Stillman is discovered dead in her bed, Zak Waller, dispatcher for the local Sheriff’s Office, doesn’t believe Lacy died from natural causes like everyone is being told. He sets out to discover the truth and finds a lot more than he expected.
Zak’s friend Tiff Masterson has returned to Lost Trails after a breakup with her boyfriend. She is back living at home and helping her aunt take care of her mother. But it seems someone is trying to force Tiff to leave town again. A family secret is also revealed which surprises everyone in town.
I was fully engaged in this story as soon as I started reading it. There were a lot of twists and turns that took me by surprise. Even though this book can be read as a stand-alone, I would recommend reading Bitter Roots first. It will give you more of a background on all of the characters. If you enjoy a good mystery, I would recommend this book.
Zak’s friend Tiff Masterson has returned to Lost Trails after a breakup with her boyfriend. She is back living at home and helping her aunt take care of her mother. But it seems someone is trying to force Tiff to leave town again. A family secret is also revealed which surprises everyone in town.
I was fully engaged in this story as soon as I started reading it. There were a lot of twists and turns that took me by surprise. Even though this book can be read as a stand-alone, I would recommend reading Bitter Roots first. It will give you more of a background on all of the characters. If you enjoy a good mystery, I would recommend this book.
September 11, 2018
Lacy an elderly rancher has died in her bed starting a huge family feud. The dispatcher,Zak, thinks there may be more to it. Zak’s friend Tiff is overwhelmed by her mother’s mental problems and her aunt’s denial of it. Tiff thinks it is because of her father and brother’s death but the real problem started years before. There is a good twist at the end that solves the problem and answers the questions.
February 15, 2018
I voluntarily read a advanced reader's copy of this book.
Bitter Truth by C.J. Carmichael, book two of the Bitter Roots Mysteries series. I really enjoyed this story. It had me thinking of what was happening the whole time I was reading it. Really pulled me in with the great characters from the previous book and the storyline. I can't wait to see what is up next in this series.
Bitter Truth by C.J. Carmichael, book two of the Bitter Roots Mysteries series. I really enjoyed this story. It had me thinking of what was happening the whole time I was reading it. Really pulled me in with the great characters from the previous book and the storyline. I can't wait to see what is up next in this series.
January 5, 2021
This one had a puzzling mystery. There was more development of our main characters, Zak Waller, Tiff Masterson, Justin and Geneva. But I could use more development of them. Nadine is sort of just there, why does Zak like her, other than she's attractive? I don't know if I can get more in the series from the library. We will see.
August 11, 2025
An awesome read full of secrets and lies that the bitter truth will come out in the end. Not what you expect in a little town of Lost Trails, Montana, when they find the town matriarch, Lacy Stillman dead in her bed from a presumed heart attack. Zach, the town dispatcher for the local sheriff office wonders if there is more to the death of Lacy.
Tiff, has returned home to help with the care of her mother with her aunt but soon family secrets to come out , as someone is forcing Tiff to leave town.
A great cast of characters that I was fully engaged with. Lots of family drama. Plus , I'm rooting for a few budding romances that are developing. This is the second book in the series, that can be read as a stand alone, but I highly recommend that you read the first book too.
Tiff, has returned home to help with the care of her mother with her aunt but soon family secrets to come out , as someone is forcing Tiff to leave town.
A great cast of characters that I was fully engaged with. Lots of family drama. Plus , I'm rooting for a few budding romances that are developing. This is the second book in the series, that can be read as a stand alone, but I highly recommend that you read the first book too.
February 18, 2018
An exciting mystery
This is book 2 in the Bitter Root Mystery series and it is an excellent, exciting, twisted read. I read this book in one day because I couldn't out it down. Tiff and her childhood friend Zak know that there are some deep secrets in Lost Trails, Montana. When a rich, elderly rancher does suddenly of an apparent heart attack after having been given a clean bill of health, Zak begins to suspect foul play. As the police dispatcher he has access to a lot of records and he knows a lot of people. He begins a subtle investigation and he consults his best friend Tiff. At the same time Tiff is struggling to find her way back home on the Christmas Tree Farm and struggling with her mother's obvious deteriorating mental health. Tiff believes her mom still can't come to terms with her brother's death and then the sudden tragic death of her father as well. Her mother has been relying on her sister for so many years and Tiff doesn't understand why suddenly her usually living aunt seems desperate for Tiff to leave and go back to Seattle. Suddenly things change for the worse and old secrets come forward to threaten the lives of Tiff and her mother. Will Zak be able to save them and will be be able to find out what happened to the old rancher lady? This book is full of exceptional plot twists and turns that keeps the reader enthralled to the last page. I love C.J. Carmichael 's books and I can't wait to read the next book in this series.
This is book 2 in the Bitter Root Mystery series and it is an excellent, exciting, twisted read. I read this book in one day because I couldn't out it down. Tiff and her childhood friend Zak know that there are some deep secrets in Lost Trails, Montana. When a rich, elderly rancher does suddenly of an apparent heart attack after having been given a clean bill of health, Zak begins to suspect foul play. As the police dispatcher he has access to a lot of records and he knows a lot of people. He begins a subtle investigation and he consults his best friend Tiff. At the same time Tiff is struggling to find her way back home on the Christmas Tree Farm and struggling with her mother's obvious deteriorating mental health. Tiff believes her mom still can't come to terms with her brother's death and then the sudden tragic death of her father as well. Her mother has been relying on her sister for so many years and Tiff doesn't understand why suddenly her usually living aunt seems desperate for Tiff to leave and go back to Seattle. Suddenly things change for the worse and old secrets come forward to threaten the lives of Tiff and her mother. Will Zak be able to save them and will be be able to find out what happened to the old rancher lady? This book is full of exceptional plot twists and turns that keeps the reader enthralled to the last page. I love C.J. Carmichael 's books and I can't wait to read the next book in this series.
February 21, 2018
I was intrigued and held in suspense while reading Biter Truth by CJ Carmichael, the second book in her Bitter Roots Mysteries series. Zak Waller, the dispatcher for the Sheriff’s Office of Lost Trail, Montana as he mourns the death of Lacy Stillman, a wealthy and elderly rancher. Zak hears some disturbing information which makes him question if Lacy’s death by heart attack was really as it seemed. At the same time, Zak’s friend Tiff Masterson becomes very concerned about her mother’s health as it spirals downward along. Complicating this is her aunt’s continual denial that a problem even exists and blames Tiff’s return home to be troubling to her mother. When Justin Pittman’s cancer returns he worries about his father and daughter. After a donor match drive takes place, he unexpectedly and unknowingly adds on to Tiff’s burden. When an old crime is uncovered with far reaching complications exposes an unexpected connection between the Mastersons and the Pittmans ends up affecting everything. I love how CJ Carmichael kept me on my toes, guessing and wondering what would happen next throughout this story.
I really, really enjoyed reading this moving story. Ms. Carmichael is an outstanding storyteller, keeping me interested in this story so that I had trouble putting it down. I highly recommend this outstanding book to other readers and look forward to the next book in the series.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book.
I really, really enjoyed reading this moving story. Ms. Carmichael is an outstanding storyteller, keeping me interested in this story so that I had trouble putting it down. I highly recommend this outstanding book to other readers and look forward to the next book in the series.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book.
October 21, 2023
3.5⭐️
While I do acknowledge that this book is better written and structured than the first one, I can't help but wish it didn't throw so many twists and turns at us.
Sure, small towns are rarely as simple as they seem, and people harbor family secrets. But goodness, this book takes complexity to a whole new level. The amount of intrigue and hidden secrets is astonishing.
So much unfolds in this story. I know Doctor Pittman seems to have evaded justice, but I can't help but think his respite won't last. I'm not buying his version of Aunt Marsha being a master manipulator and him being at her mercy’s end.
Then there's the whole tangled web of love affairs involving Lacy, Jack, and the school principal. It’s a lot to take in, just like Justin’s current situation. I genuinely hope he manages to overcome it.
I’m genuinely excited about the next book. I can’t wait to see Zak, maybe as a deputy at the very least. I know many people encourage him to aim for sheriff, but I'm not sure how realistic that is. He might face resistance from the old-timers in the police department. Well, except for Nadine, as it's clear Deputy Black has a soft spot for him. I’m eager to see where their relationship goes in the next book and whether they’ll decide to take the plunge and move in together. Maybe then I’ll finally enjoy a bit of romance in this book, as I’m definitely not a Tiff and Kenny shipper.
While I do acknowledge that this book is better written and structured than the first one, I can't help but wish it didn't throw so many twists and turns at us.
Sure, small towns are rarely as simple as they seem, and people harbor family secrets. But goodness, this book takes complexity to a whole new level. The amount of intrigue and hidden secrets is astonishing.
So much unfolds in this story. I know Doctor Pittman seems to have evaded justice, but I can't help but think his respite won't last. I'm not buying his version of Aunt Marsha being a master manipulator and him being at her mercy’s end.
Then there's the whole tangled web of love affairs involving Lacy, Jack, and the school principal. It’s a lot to take in, just like Justin’s current situation. I genuinely hope he manages to overcome it.
I’m genuinely excited about the next book. I can’t wait to see Zak, maybe as a deputy at the very least. I know many people encourage him to aim for sheriff, but I'm not sure how realistic that is. He might face resistance from the old-timers in the police department. Well, except for Nadine, as it's clear Deputy Black has a soft spot for him. I’m eager to see where their relationship goes in the next book and whether they’ll decide to take the plunge and move in together. Maybe then I’ll finally enjoy a bit of romance in this book, as I’m definitely not a Tiff and Kenny shipper.
March 1, 2018
“Bitter Truth” by CJ Carmichael is book two of the Bitter Root Mystery Series. After completing this mystery novel I would say it is not necessary to read “Bitter Roots” first. This is a complete and wonderful story and works well as a stand alone book. Although now I can't wait to go back and read “Bitter Roots”. I have seen the name “CJ Carmichael” time after time and wondered what the fuss was all about. Now I know. I am so glad that I veered away from my normal reading and chose this book. I am not normally a big Mystery fan. I usually find them too intense and can't sleep after reading them. For me C.J. Carmichael writes a perfect book. I was pulled into the story right from the get go. Her characters were like able for the most part. She included one of two that you just love to hate, adding to the story. The ranching community of Lost Trails, Montana was very interesting. There was so much going on for a small town. The author does not end on a cliffhanger. She leaves just enough suspense that you will want to read the next book to learn more about these interesting people and their budding love affairs. I would recommend this book and can not wait to read more by C.J. Carmichael. I received a complimentary copy of this book from Tule Publishing through NetGalley, Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
February 22, 2018
I really loved Bitter Truth, the second in CJ Carmichael’s Bitter Root Mystery series. The story is set in the small town of Lost Trail and is probably best read as part of the series though there is enough backstory fed into this book to make it work as a stand-alone story too.
Amateur sleuth Zac, despatcher at the sheriff’s office is actually much better at investigating than the sheriff. With a nose for things that just don’t quite add up, Zac embarks on a laborious process of digging up little clues and building a case. I like him. He’s one of a handful of characters central to both the town and the story and I love the way that he gently sucks you into his investigation so that all of a sudden you find yourself utterly engrossed and compelled to see if the hunch you’ve developed yourself is the correct one.
The plot starts off with an almost gentle pace as neighbours gather to mourn the loss of one of their town stalwarts, but the twists and turns in this story don’t take long to start appearing. Along the way there are enough little red herrings thrown in to make the reader wonder if there really was a murder, and if so whether it was this person or that. Even when it became clear to me who was guilty the reason why kept me reading on to the end.
Amateur sleuth Zac, despatcher at the sheriff’s office is actually much better at investigating than the sheriff. With a nose for things that just don’t quite add up, Zac embarks on a laborious process of digging up little clues and building a case. I like him. He’s one of a handful of characters central to both the town and the story and I love the way that he gently sucks you into his investigation so that all of a sudden you find yourself utterly engrossed and compelled to see if the hunch you’ve developed yourself is the correct one.
The plot starts off with an almost gentle pace as neighbours gather to mourn the loss of one of their town stalwarts, but the twists and turns in this story don’t take long to start appearing. Along the way there are enough little red herrings thrown in to make the reader wonder if there really was a murder, and if so whether it was this person or that. Even when it became clear to me who was guilty the reason why kept me reading on to the end.
March 7, 2019
this is Bitter Root #2. it is part of the Bitter Root Series.
Lacy Stillman lives in the ranch community of Lost Trails, Montana. When she dies of a heart attack in her own bed, it seems as if that would be normal for someone at her age.
Zak Waller is the dispatcher with the local Sheriff's Office. He joins in the mourning of the town's rich elderly rancher. When some information is brought to his attention, he starts wondering if Lacey's death is more than it seems.
Tiff Masterson is one of Zak's friends. She is troubled by her mother's escalating breakdown, and her aunt's denial of it being any problem. Family friend and local lawyer Justin Pittman looks to Tiff for help with his serious health issues.
A connection is discovered between the Masterson family and the Pittmans. An old crime with an unexpected twist reaches into both families with effects that will change everything.
I read this book before reading the 1st of the series. I had a bit of trouble in the beginning of this book because of all the characters who were in it. I think if i had read the first one first, i may have had an easier time. Once i could keep up with the people, then it started to flow along nicely. I liked the twists and turns and how it all came together in the end.
Lacy Stillman lives in the ranch community of Lost Trails, Montana. When she dies of a heart attack in her own bed, it seems as if that would be normal for someone at her age.
Zak Waller is the dispatcher with the local Sheriff's Office. He joins in the mourning of the town's rich elderly rancher. When some information is brought to his attention, he starts wondering if Lacey's death is more than it seems.
Tiff Masterson is one of Zak's friends. She is troubled by her mother's escalating breakdown, and her aunt's denial of it being any problem. Family friend and local lawyer Justin Pittman looks to Tiff for help with his serious health issues.
A connection is discovered between the Masterson family and the Pittmans. An old crime with an unexpected twist reaches into both families with effects that will change everything.
I read this book before reading the 1st of the series. I had a bit of trouble in the beginning of this book because of all the characters who were in it. I think if i had read the first one first, i may have had an easier time. Once i could keep up with the people, then it started to flow along nicely. I liked the twists and turns and how it all came together in the end.
February 19, 2018
I have read C.J. Carmichael’s romance stories, enjoying each and every one. However, I had not read any of this series of mysteries. Bitter Truth stood well on its own without me having read the first book, Bitter Roots. Now I want to read it, of course. The Lost Trail community in Montana is like most small-towns there is the good, the bad and the hidden evil. I enjoyed reading the story immensely, trying to find the missing pieces along with Zak Waller.
The plot just flows bringing the reader into the story so that I was trying to figure it all out along with Zak Waller. I especially liked this character, one that is in a position that is often overlooked; usually only a supporting character. Several other important characters in this story that switches between subplots but nicely all tied together in the end. This is a mystery with a hint of romance, but I was surprised, not unhappily but surprised nonetheless as to how it all played out.
An ARC of the book was given to me by the publisher through Net Galley which I voluntarily chose to read and reviewed. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
The plot just flows bringing the reader into the story so that I was trying to figure it all out along with Zak Waller. I especially liked this character, one that is in a position that is often overlooked; usually only a supporting character. Several other important characters in this story that switches between subplots but nicely all tied together in the end. This is a mystery with a hint of romance, but I was surprised, not unhappily but surprised nonetheless as to how it all played out.
An ARC of the book was given to me by the publisher through Net Galley which I voluntarily chose to read and reviewed. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
February 27, 2018
Bitter Truth is the second in the Bitter Root Mysteries. In this novel, Zak Waller is on the case again. Even though he is not a deputy and is the dispatcher, Zak has intuitive detective skills and deep insight into finding the truth to crimes, often brushed off by the lazy Sheriff. Bitter Truth has two mysteries running parallel and crossing each other at several turns. At the core is the death of Lacy Stillman, matriarch to the Stillman family and very much involved at ninety in the family ranch. Her death comes at a time when her sons have asked her to sell off some property and she has given a definite no to the prospect. Threaded through this story is the health problems of Justin Pittman and his need for a bone marrow donor for his Hodgkin’s Lymphoma and the person of Cora Christensen, former teacher/ruler of the
Dewbury Academy and a force to be reckoned with.
The methodical steps Zak takes to solve the mysteries and come to some conclusions about his own life draws you in and keeps you until the end.
Dewbury Academy and a force to be reckoned with.
The methodical steps Zak takes to solve the mysteries and come to some conclusions about his own life draws you in and keeps you until the end.
February 28, 2018
When a typical 91-year-old woman dies in her sleep, most people would think nothing of it. In Lost Trails, ranch owner Lacy Stillman is in the healthier than most younger than her, so when she is found in her bed the day after receivine glowing reports during her check up, Zak Waller is instantly suspicious. There are too many people who have something to gain from her death. When he shares his thoughts with childhood friend, Tiff Masterson, she agree to help investigate. Despite his position as dispatcher in the Sheriff's office, Zak has already proven himself to be an astute investigator. Besides, Tiff needs a distraction from her Mom's deteriorating condition and her Aunt's odd behavior. Tiff had hoped to stay in Lost Trails, but circumstances are making her rethink that decision.
Full of twists, turns, and shocking secrets, this story kept me guessing until the very end. I loved it and can't wait to see what happens next in Zak and Tiff's lives, especially how they deal with the fallout from the ending of this story.
Full of twists, turns, and shocking secrets, this story kept me guessing until the very end. I loved it and can't wait to see what happens next in Zak and Tiff's lives, especially how they deal with the fallout from the ending of this story.
March 14, 2018
It's been many a year since I have read a true mystery and this is a true mystery written by an author that I have read her romance books. WOW she blew my mind away with this book. I did not know what to think when I started reading this and yes this is the second book in a series (you bet your bootie I have already picked up book 1 Bitter Roots...little bit backwards) but once I got into it I simply could not stop reading. I have no idea what Montana does to me but it seems to draw me in and grab me. This town is Lost Trails and it does have some people that have some backwoods thinking. Kind of like some i know from home in Tennessee. This is a well written story that had me in in from the start. I could see with my minds out the lay of the land, the ranch, the sheriff and dispatcher Zak.I am headed to read the first book in this series before the third book comes out. Because it will be time for a complete re-read of the first 2...of course. So if you like a good, well written mystery with a touch of heat this is the book for you.
February 19, 2018
Bitter Truth is an engaging and entertaining read. For me, this book is not about the mystery as much as the interesting characters who solve the mysteries and populate the town. The mystery in this book was good, but the character development is even better.
Zak, our lead detective, is not really a detective. He is a police dispatcher in the Lost Trail police department. Zak is not interested in being in charge or even being a deputy, he is just interested in seeing that justice is served and that his small town stays safe. He doesn't solve crime because he is seeking glory, he solves it because someone needs to, and he is good at it.
The secondary characters are really well written as well and I feel like there is a lot of material there for more books in this great series.
I recommend this series highly to anyone who enjoys well crafted books with mysteries.
I received an ARC for an honest review.
Zak, our lead detective, is not really a detective. He is a police dispatcher in the Lost Trail police department. Zak is not interested in being in charge or even being a deputy, he is just interested in seeing that justice is served and that his small town stays safe. He doesn't solve crime because he is seeking glory, he solves it because someone needs to, and he is good at it.
The secondary characters are really well written as well and I feel like there is a lot of material there for more books in this great series.
I recommend this series highly to anyone who enjoys well crafted books with mysteries.
I received an ARC for an honest review.
November 8, 2018
What a great mystery series! I really enjoyed Bitter Roots (book 1) and Bitter Truth (book 2) did not disappoint. Bitter Truth picks up where the first book left off--in Lost Trails, Montana. We get updates on the lives of Zak Waller and his coworkers at the sheriff's office, Tiff Masterson and her mother and aunt, Kenny at Raven Christmas Tree Farm, and Justin Pittman and his health, his daughter and father. In this installment, 91 year old Lacy Stillman is found dead in her own bed. She was the richest woman around and had two sons and three grandchildren. Since Zak saw Lacy after a great doctor's checkup the day before, he suspects something fishy happened. So he does a little snooping off the record. This book just flows! There are many secrets uncovered and not everyone is what he/she seems to be! I can't wait to read Bitter End!
April 29, 2025
Bitter Truth, the 2nd in Bitter Root Mysteries, C.J. Carmichael's, is an excellent traditional mystery/police procedure. Police dispatcher Zac and his longtime friend Tif again team up when murder hit close to home. Zac is having second thoughts about not apply for a more active role on the small-town police force after their success in the first book of the series as the Sheriff blows off any idea that a senior residents could be more than a heart attack from old age. Something feels off to Zak who can't let it go. Tif is more than willing to let him talk it out, but her focus is on her mother who has never emotionally recovered the from deaths of her son and husband close together. Her aunt, who has been her strength and support all these years is suddenly acting strange and Tiffany is beginning to think she made a big mistake coming home.
February 27, 2018
Bitter Truth has so many story lines weaving together that really draws you in.
When local rancher passes away unexpectedly Zac Waller, Dispatcher for the Sheriffs office, can't believe it was from natural causes. Launching his own unofficial mini investigation Zak starts to look at every possibility. Only to find a complicated web of lies and deceit.
I loved that this second book in the Bitter Root Mysteries picked up with all the characters from book one. Seeing in to so many towns peoples lives was very interesting for me. I found myself trying to figure out what was going to happen from one page to the next. I cant wait to read book three!
When local rancher passes away unexpectedly Zac Waller, Dispatcher for the Sheriffs office, can't believe it was from natural causes. Launching his own unofficial mini investigation Zak starts to look at every possibility. Only to find a complicated web of lies and deceit.
I loved that this second book in the Bitter Root Mysteries picked up with all the characters from book one. Seeing in to so many towns peoples lives was very interesting for me. I found myself trying to figure out what was going to happen from one page to the next. I cant wait to read book three!
November 4, 2019
Zac is a dispatcher at the Lost Trails Sheriff's dept. He takes an emergency call letting him know that Lacy Stillman, a 91 year old rancher died of a heart attack.
Zac finds that hard to believe because he has a beer the night before with her and she had just left the Dr's office with a clean bill of health diagnosis.
So he sets out to do an unofficial investigation into the death of Lacy Stillman. I found with this book and the one before it that once you start reading you are hook you are hooked. I couldn't put it down. I read it in one sitting. It is a book that I lost sleep over but was ok with that. The ending was not what I thought it would be but it was a whole lot better.
Zac finds that hard to believe because he has a beer the night before with her and she had just left the Dr's office with a clean bill of health diagnosis.
So he sets out to do an unofficial investigation into the death of Lacy Stillman. I found with this book and the one before it that once you start reading you are hook you are hooked. I couldn't put it down. I read it in one sitting. It is a book that I lost sleep over but was ok with that. The ending was not what I thought it would be but it was a whole lot better.
May 12, 2020
Another good read from the Bitter Root series. I almost feel like I know the town from the descriptions of the locale. It's interesting how unapologetic the author is about the characters' motivations. She doesn't use any rationalization for their behavior, which is a good thing. As an author it would be easy to do a backstory info dump to explain why someone was the way they were. Carmichael resists doing this. Sometimes, we'll never understand why evil people do what they do.
It was good to catch up on the local people and delve into some of the hidden secrets of small town life, too. Excellent read .
It was good to catch up on the local people and delve into some of the hidden secrets of small town life, too. Excellent read .
April 7, 2018
Small town, big lies
The second book in this series was just as enjoyable, captivating & page-turning as the first. The characters & dialogue are written so well that I was caught up in feeling the pain as secrets were revealed that affected the lives of so many in the community. Evil was so well camouflaged it was hard to see but overwhelming when the truth was revealed. The twists & turns in this book kept me reading until late in the night. I'm looking forward to the next book & continuing the story!
The second book in this series was just as enjoyable, captivating & page-turning as the first. The characters & dialogue are written so well that I was caught up in feeling the pain as secrets were revealed that affected the lives of so many in the community. Evil was so well camouflaged it was hard to see but overwhelming when the truth was revealed. The twists & turns in this book kept me reading until late in the night. I'm looking forward to the next book & continuing the story!
April 12, 2018
Family Secrets
After Lacy Stillman is found dead, All kinds of lies and secrets start coming out. First is why Cora Christensen is getting the Stillman house now? Stillman family fighting over wanting to sell some land. Then the Pittman and Masterson families
have lies and a 33 year old secret. Thanks to Zak he soon starts to get some answers. C.J. Carmichael has written another exciting mystery. Keeps you wondering though the whole book. Can't
wait for her next book in this series.
After Lacy Stillman is found dead, All kinds of lies and secrets start coming out. First is why Cora Christensen is getting the Stillman house now? Stillman family fighting over wanting to sell some land. Then the Pittman and Masterson families
have lies and a 33 year old secret. Thanks to Zak he soon starts to get some answers. C.J. Carmichael has written another exciting mystery. Keeps you wondering though the whole book. Can't
wait for her next book in this series.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 90 reviews