What do you think?
Rate this book


Unknown Binding
As always, Malazan is life, even if on this occasion Malazan is only 300 pages. Most the debate will be around whether this and No Life Forsaken should have been one book. In terms of substance and scope, they should; this reads like a companion volume in many ways. Equally, I understand why it's separate, at least in the way it's presented here; it has its own distinct squad of marines and characters to focus on, and one character's identity goes from being merely hinted at to entirely obvious - both things would have got too messy if joined together. Regardless, it's good there wasn't too long a wait between them.
80% of this is the amusing conversation and interaction you come to expect. It's arguably too much, and too light on actual plot as a result, but it's still very enjoyable; one sequence in particular felt completely ridiculous, but then flowed into one of the best sequences in the book. Erikson is rightly having fun at this point, be it the Jaghut, Mandrabaladrogan, or typically over-confident cultists who get undone at every turn. The stakes the book sets up and the finale are far too brief, and quite literally waved away by someone who appears for a page or so in a way that didn't really feel earned, yet I'm also glad it wasn't just a mirror of the previous book. The epilogue was rather clever though and didn't fully see it coming, though there were a couple of clues on reflection (and one detail I admittedly couldn't remember from The God is Not Willing). It will be a very sad day indeed when there is no more of this to look forward to.