Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Tales of Witness #3

Legacies of Betrayal

Rate this book
Endless training, gruelling marches, and the frenzy of battle against more enemies than can be counted-such is the life of a marine in the Malazan Empire.

Year by year, month by month, week by week, day by day, moment by moment. Skills are honed to deadly precision, the secret language of the soldier in a world drowning in perpetual discontent, the eternal conflict against the fates. And we should forget the seemingly inevitable interference of mischievous gods and more often than not, the resurrected remains of ancient and once believed long-dead entities.

As a new holy war starts sparked in the fire-blackened cauldron of Seven Cities, the Fifth and Sixth squads are about to embark a mission they don't want for a cause they don't care about. Not that anybody asked their opinion. They can only hope that their objective isn't as hopeless as it seems, and that they aren't simply being used as pawns—a strategic sacrifice, if you will, in the machinations of their betters.

So what's life like as a marine in the Malazan Army?

Well, let's see, shall we...

Unknown Binding

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Steven Erikson

148 books15.9k followers
Steven Erikson is the pseudonym of Steve Rune Lundin, a Canadian novelist, who was educated and trained as both an archaeologist and anthropologist. His best-known work is the series, the Malazan Book of the Fallen.

http://us.macmillan.com/author/steven...

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
233 (43%)
4 stars
210 (39%)
3 stars
78 (14%)
2 stars
9 (1%)
1 star
2 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 64 reviews
Profile Image for Jack.
55 reviews
October 12, 2026

As always, Malazan is life, even if on this occasion Malazan is only 300 pages. Most the debate will be around whether this and No Life Forsaken should have been one book. In terms of substance and scope, they should; this reads like a companion volume in many ways. Equally, I understand why it's separate, at least in the way it's presented here; it has its own distinct squad of marines and characters to focus on, and one character's identity goes from being merely hinted at to entirely obvious - both things would have got too messy if joined together. Regardless, it's good there wasn't too long a wait between them.

80% of this is the amusing conversation and interaction you come to expect. It's arguably too much, and too light on actual plot as a result, but it's still very enjoyable; one sequence in particular felt completely ridiculous, but then flowed into one of the best sequences in the book. Erikson is rightly having fun at this point, be it the Jaghut, Mandrabaladrogan, or typically over-confident cultists who get undone at every turn. The stakes the book sets up and the finale are far too brief, and quite literally waved away by someone who appears for a page or so in a way that didn't really feel earned, yet I'm also glad it wasn't just a mirror of the previous book. The epilogue was rather clever though and didn't fully see it coming, though there were a couple of clues on reflection (and one detail I admittedly couldn't remember from The God is Not Willing). It will be a very sad day indeed when there is no more of this to look forward to.

Profile Image for Amie.
711 reviews9 followers
October 28, 2026
The third book in the Tales of Witness series follows the Malazan marines as a new holy war erupts in Seven Cities, with the Fifth and Sixth squads sent on a mission that may be little more than a strategic sacrifice by those pulling the strings.

I thought this was such a good ending to the trilogy. The story started and finished strongly, although I found the middle a little slow at times. Overall, I loved it and thought it was a very satisfying conclusion.
Profile Image for Kyle Foley.
368 reviews8 followers
October 8, 2026
This is peak Erikson humor from start to finish, and so many moments felt like him staring at the camera and telling us he knows what we're memeing on him for (I'm looking at you, ochre references/conversations). The book is good, but it's one I think I'll only be able to fully appreciate once I see how all of the pieces converge. The banter from the Marines is great, I went from hating the Mandies to willing to die for them, and any book with Iskaral Pust and Mael is great, even better when they're together. The big character reveal was obvious but I'm glad we finally got it. Also, the tie back to compassion at the end was nice. It's the core of the entire Malazan world so I'm glad we got to see the Marines doing more than just killing. Though the killing in this book is wild.
Profile Image for Wild Bill.
10 reviews3 followers
October 14, 2026
Erikson you dog, Convergence again!

Now bring me Karsa in book 4!
Profile Image for Brayden Lane.
49 reviews
October 2, 2026
'Who?' He wondered. 'Who are these soldiers? I don't – I can't –' Then he shook his head. 'I know. They're Malazan marines.'

Not my all time favorite, but limpers weathered balls do I enjoy reading about the Malazan antics.
Profile Image for Jason Waltz.
Author 37 books81 followers
November 3, 2026
I really enjoyed some terrific scenes and the camaraderie banter, as well as getting to know / better know some characters.

I'm really torn on the feeling so much more could have been accomplished or shared.

As the shortest book of Malazan, it took me far too long to complete. Some of that is on me, as I was writing the completion of a novel and did not read much. BUT normally I read a Steven Erikson MBOTF title ASAP.

I liked the previous book, which this was supposed to be part of, much more. I feel, while I prefer readers read the books in order, many MBOTF books can be handed to new readers...but this is not one of them. This is most likely my least favorite book of all of them, quite frankly. Characters and those scenes salvage the stars.

There are some very touching moments and thoughts expressed, and again, that special touch of Erikson's examination of humanity. There is violence and love, hate and optimism. There is also a very interesting writerly choice of this story structure entwining the 3 books to date in Karsa's quartet that I do look forward to discovering how it all comes together and when the big guy makes his appearance.
Profile Image for Ty MaC.
275 reviews3 followers
November 13, 2026
5/5

A week five star but a five-star for sure this book really felt like it was a part two of No Life Forsaken less than its own book. I love all of the references to the main series as well as ICEs work.

This Series has kind of lost its way in my opinion and is now more just a loose sequel to the main series that is for super fans. I'm still hopeful it can get back to its Witness roots but that would take the final book either being 1500 as Pages or the series being expanded to 6 Plus books.

I still loved it and it is a high high recommendation for Malazan fans
Profile Image for Spencer Foster.
61 reviews4 followers
October 22, 2026
“The most confident faith, after all, had no need to defend itself. But a faith in crisis delivered slaughter again and again, trapped in a world of enemies.”
Profile Image for Josh.
1,041 reviews44 followers
October 20, 2026
Well, here we are. Another volume in the Malazan world from signature author Steven Erikson. Another collection of philosophical ramblings and very little actual momentum getting made. I learned that this was supposed to be the second half of the last book, which explains its short length, but I could have forgiven that if anything of any import had happened. As usual, Erikson introduces new characters for us to follow instead of picking one of his hundreds of previous characters in this world that he'd already established. Then he has a bunch of random things happen, releases a bunch of new gods and threats into the world without explanation or resolution, and then has his new characters discover some new magic system that didn't exist before but that amazingly saves the day. This is getting tiring. We wanted more Karsa Orlong! We wanted resolution to some of the loose threads from the main series! I can only hope that the final volume in this series will actually see the plot move somewhere.
As usual, a strong language and adult content warning with this one. The new narrator does a good job, but has changed most of the pronunciations that we had from all the previous books, which was constantly annoying. I can't say I recommend this book, but if you've read everything else in this series you're probably going to anyway.
67 reviews1 follower
November 16, 2026
While I always love malazan it felt like this book had some issues in my mind. I wish it could have have been somehow mashed in with no life forsaken to keep this series a trilogy instead of 4 book. Overall, felt like Erickson heart wasn’t in this one, and he didn’t have much of a story to tell. Still scratched the itch of the best setting in fantasy
250 reviews2 followers
October 29, 2026
Gave up about half way though.

I was so excited for this book. The Seven Cities subcontinent is my favorite setting in Malazan, and apparently this book was so important that Stephen Erickson needed to turn his Witness Trilogy into a four part series to make room for it.

...maybe this should have remained a trilogy. I was so mind numbingly bored through most of what I read here. The plot was non existant. The characters boring. And what is especially disappointing is that the first two books of the Witness series are fantastic. Two of my favorite Erickson novels. And I expect the next one to be fantastic as well. I'll probably give this one a second chance then, but for now this one was a real stinker.
Profile Image for daniel alberto.
36 reviews
October 27, 2026
was this...a bad one? from Erikson???

Maybe I just didn't get it, but there were so many plot threads that were utterly uninteresting and went nowhere. The typical malazan formula of converging plot threads just doesn't work in this short of a book. The climax feels like it comes out of nowhere and feels inconsequential. There was also a bit too much comedy for my liking; at some points, it really felt like a bad imitation of Pratchett. 2 stars only because of that certain marine (you know the one) returning to classic form by coming (slightly) back down to earth.
Profile Image for Amine.
241 reviews45 followers
October 26, 2026
Very funny and entertaining read.
The ending and the overall story left much to be desired though, it was too thin.
Profile Image for Jeroen.
197 reviews16 followers
November 12, 2026
A little outpost in the middle of the desert, and a dozen Malazan marines to hold the fort. A place that Dunsparrow had expressly asked for, because what is the worst that could happen in such a forgotten place? Erikson shows us just how much craziness can pop up if you put a bunch of idiotic sappers together, have insane people show up, and before you know it the future of a continent hangs in the balance. Beneath all the comedy and wackiness, deeper philosophical questions peek out. This novel is not as superficial as it may seem at first.

Legacies of Betrayal may not be comparable in length, content and thematic weight to a full Malazan Book of the Fallen novel, but it is still in top form for what it wants to deliver. Erikson made the choice to split the second novel in this series, having us end up with a situation similar to Martin’s A Feast for Crows and A Dance With Dragons, in which the second book No Life Forsaken (2025) received most of the heavy moral themes and philosophising, and Legacies of Betrayal (2026) most of the comedy, with silly Malazan marines and random wacky magic. In hindsight, merging these two novels might have given us a more balanced and meatier novel in which the tragedy and comedy had played off of each other. Be that as it may, I loved every page of Legacies of Betrayal. I found it hilarious and full of brilliant imagination, and its focus on a small number of locations made it a wonderfully contained story. It would be best though not to expect these Malazan follow-up novels to be like the main Malazan series novels.

So, while these soldiers are stuck in some godforsaken, dusty outpost in the middle of endless flat desert, three Jaghut ladies show up, and they pretty much act like agents of chaos. The Jaghut have a disturbing sense of humour, and they don’t believe in civilisation. One of the Jaghut ladies says that she formed a Civilisation of One. And now the three of them are trying to form a Civilisation of Three. But it is not really working. The soldiers have treaties with them, but they need to have separate treaties with each individual Jaghut. So that is the dichotomy that is set up in these scenes: civilisation versus anarchy. On the one hand we have the trappings of empire and the military, represented by the soldiers, with its structures and rules and hierarchy, and on the other hand the chaos of the Jaghut who each consider themselves to be a sovereign nation.

Meanwhile, the continent of Seven Cities seems to exist in a state of absolute confusion as a dozen new faiths and cults are pitted against each other, in a survival of the fittest. We follow the High Priest Harapa, an absolute bellend of a zealous man, foaming at the mouth with righteous indignation. His storyline is ultimately also about the consequences of the invasion of the Malazan Empire. The Malazans tried to impose rule and order, but from the high drama and bloodshed that came from it has arisen a religious counter-reaction in the local population by forming new faiths around key figures and great losses, which again assails the more logical and technocratic impulses of the Malazans’ empire-building.

The common thread seems to be that Erikson questions of whether civilisation, or militaristic Empire at least, is something that solves problems, or merely creates different sets of problems that subsequently require solving. These themes aren’t new for Erikson by any stretch of the imagination; every Seven Cities book dealt with them. But they were never executed in such a funny way.

A young and disillusioned scrivener sums it up later in the book: they’re all shits. The soldiers are shits and the bandits they fight are shits. What even is civilisation but a bunch of traps and illusions? And in a rather grim way, Erikson asks the same questions of religion. All the new cults are kept alive by shits, fired up by their base emotions. It is a rather nihilistic vision of humanity. The main Va’Shaik cult worships the apocalypse, the final end of all this madness, but can civilisation not form an alternative answer in some way or is there another solution?

All in all, this follow-up series to the main Malazan novels seems an opportunity for Erikson to play around with prose and ideas. Revisiting some old ideas, also tackling some new ones and trying out some creative writing. A fun entry, if a bit short.
88 reviews1 follower
October 30, 2026
Basically book 2.5 in the Witness trilogy as it takes place concurrently as No Life Forsaken (one character in this book flits in and out of the action here as he is involved in what's going on in G'danisban). Apparently Erikson couldn't fit it all in one book so split off all this into a separate novel. I think it works as a stand-alone, and is a nice chance of pace, being Erikson's most compact book.

However, it has much of the same problems as No Life Forsaken compared to the main ten books. Characters have become cartoonish, instead of having one or two quirky soldiers to liven up the mood in a squad now they are all over the top, rather than a rare and solitary eloquent jaghut there's three of them prattling on and on and on. It's much more black and white in morality as well, whereas the main ten books had varying degrees of grey (with exceptions of course, Bidithal, etc, but in general it was grey at least) and most characters motivations could be understood, we now have obvious "good guys" and irredeemable "bad guys". And as in the previous two books, the power level of the Malazan marines is so absurd there's basically no tension at all, and this book continues on with the whitewashing of imperialism, since no matter how much slaughter the marines dish out they are still the heroes at the end of the day.

Having said that I actually enjoyed this more than No Life Forsaken since we have a bunch of fun returning characters, the action is a bit more snappy as it is shorter, and the flaws are not as pronounced as in the previous book. Let's hope the final book will redeem this trilogy.
Profile Image for Alexandru.
476 reviews36 followers
October 29, 2026
I'm feeling very conflicted about Legacies of Betrayal. I know that this book and the previous book were meant to be one single book and they ended up being split. But the previous book was really good, it had a bit of everything that made Malazan good. Whereas Legacies of Betrayal feels a incomplete. It's too short but at the same time some sections felt too drawn out.

The marine sections were one big long gag which usually works well if offset by scenes that are deeper or more philosophical in nature. But since there was nothing to offset them they kind of fell flat. None of the marines stood out too much.

The best part were the non-marine sections like the inquisitors of Va'Shaik or the various cults. It was great being back in Y'Ghatan and seeing what became of the city following the events of the Bonehunters. Also was great seeing some returning characters.

I think this book beats Dust of Dreams as my least favourite Malazan book. It's still a good fantasy book on its own but just misses the mark a bit. I'm very interested to see where the last book goes and hope it will be a longer book.
Profile Image for Chris.
723 reviews16 followers
October 13, 2026
I could read marine banter all day. This and NLF should’ve been one book though
Profile Image for DHMC45 .
101 reviews1 follower
October 17, 2026
A fine enough continuation in this 'sequel' series, though after the devastating climax of the previous one, this installment spent a bit too much time with newer characters just having conversations with Erikson's witty dialogue actually becoming repetitive (esp when put in the mouths of every character) with an exciting enough climax that took a bit too long to arrive at.
Profile Image for Will Yams.
59 reviews6 followers
October 10, 2026
Legacies of betrayal, went by way too fast for me.
It’s a hilarious read that continues on in the malazan style and if you’ve read all the rest, you’re probably reading this one now or just finished.
Oh no, I feel like I need to do a Malazan reread again… sorry TBR.
33 reviews2 followers
October 15, 2026
"You ain't living in a cave any more soldier. Old rules don't apply. It's Malazan rules now."

"What's rules. No rules. Malazans are insane. We have seen this."

"Sure but that don't matter. What matters is whose madness happens to be running things. And out here in the Malazan empire, it's our madness running things, not yours."

I've never laughed so hard. This book is so self aware it just drops gems like rain. Erickson is clearly only getting better with age which is testament to his dedication to his love for the world and those that enjoy it. His analysis of empire, power and religion is so satirical I found myself laughing every chapter. It's insane to think the series has lasted this long yet feels so fresh.

This book is interesting for its focus on the low level aspects of empire building through the marines. Not my favourite set of people in the world, as someone who instinctively hates empires. It's always interesting how Erickson manages to write them in a way that makes following imperialists not only entertaining but insightful, in way rarely seen anywhere else, and not just fantasy. The honesty and earnestness of philosophy spreads not just from the marines but to the Inquisitor and high priests.

The plot involving the seven cities is an easy sell, and the premise of a new holy war brewing just added to my excitement. As expected some parts hit while others I missed. Unlike the other books were the first half always feels like trying to shove an entire food platter into your mouth at once, this book is more streamlined or maybe I've just become Malazan-brained and feel too comfortable in this world. That changed how I experienced the book overall. I expected complications and confusion to set in midway, but as the book went on, it never came. I was on top of things and for that reason I had high hopes for the conclusion because I've never read one ending that didn't blow my mind. This one sadly felt predictable. Nothing came as a surprise, which wasn't bad, but a little disappointing. It was a good thing the book was so enjoyable from the start.

Listening to the audiobook, I found it impressive how the narrator was able to differentiate the so many characters from each other given the madness of Erickson pov shifting epics. I'm already re-listening to it because Erickson managed to write this so sharply every chapter feels like a small meal. I don't know were this ranks among the series favourites, but the ending glimpse into what follows has made me all hyped for the next book.

Thanks to Netgalley and Brilliance Audio for an ALC.
Profile Image for Phil.
345 reviews14 followers
October 26, 2026
[Disclaimer: While I have read all the main books, all the novels by Esslemont (including the Path to Ascendancy), and the Kharkanas novels, I will be the first to admit that I can barely remember a damn thing other than highlights. I'm in my mid-40s and between work, family, and life, I no longer can keep the threads of hundreds of thousands of years together in my mind. So this will be a review from someone who has familiarity but has probably missed about 75% of the connections and hints that are throughout this book.]

If you are a die-hard Malazan fan, I suspect that you are likely somewhat tepid on the Witness novels. They are quite different than anything that Erikson has penned in this universe (note: I haven't read the Bauchelain and Korbal Broach series so perhaps they are similar). And given some of the things that I have read in this universe, I do not mind that at all. This book was, for lack of a better word, funny! I do not recall ever laughing out loud reading any of Erikson's prior novels. This one just cracked me up.

I noted in my review of No Life Forsaken that there was a different underlying tone in the book, such that the book ended on a somewhat upbeat vibe. Again, this is weird for what is unquestionably a grim-dark universe of books. Legacies of Betrayal continued that trend to the point that (all else equal in this universe) I was shocked that despite the fact that there are the usual machinations from various factions representing gods (including one who wants to destroy everything), I found myself laughing or smiling more than cringing in abject horror.

The book ends where the first (The God is Not Willing) ended as well, providing some needed context for where we are in the timeline. And the final note was an homage to what is, unquestionably, the biggest strength in the entire world of Malazan: the Marines.

If you are like me, and enjoyed all of these books - some more than others and some where you wish you could forget ever reading certain scenes - but have not gone further because of misgivings or no longer having a desire to read true grim-dark, then boy are you in for a treat. Erikson is in rare form in this one as he crafts the loveable characters that are the series' best assets. It has been a while since I have enjoyed the minutia so much and this is a welcome change for me. If this continues in its current form, it may replace the Path to Ascendancy series as my all-time favorite in this universe of stories.
625 reviews4 followers
October 10, 2026
This book is almost impossible to review independently of NLF, that being said I understand why the two were separated. One joined up novel would have worked as a lot of the threads are indistinguishable from one another, but damn would it have been confusing and I think some of the characters would have been buried in the amount of disparate threads that were happening.

So as it is it tells the other half of what is happening in the seven cities, what Arenfall had organised with Quick, Dunsparrow and Lathora (fun character, despite very limited page time) have set in motion. I found the start introducing the Mandies and Jag overlong, but, if the books were conjoined this wouldn't have been so much an issue.

When it got going? It was excellent. How things escalated was great and how they were resolved at Y'Ghatan worked well. I do wish we'd seem Leoman at least in some fashion, but it felt a little as if the native Seven Cities fanaticism was being buried. Honestly, it felt a little on the nose at times, the author saying this is all bad, love is better, as is civilisation. I'm not necessarily saying I disagree at all, but the ending of the Semk bodyguard just felt a little too blunt on this topic.

Throughout the Marines are excellent. I don't think any of them particularly excelled, but they all lived and showed how good Erikson can be with these characters and, as an added bonus, he scaled back on the worst of the philosophising with the Marines.

The ending sets up perfectly, this all happened pre-tGinW, and we've now got the confluence of all these events. It's going to involve Shadowthrone, Mael, Jag, Karsa, and then there's the empire at the crux of all these factions. It's going to be explosive to say the least!

Ps. Mael wanting revenge. I'm not sure if the timelines match up but was the failure of the ice above the Teblor lands his first move in this? Maybe I'm over thinking things but I guess we'll get answers in book 4.
7 reviews
November 15, 2026
This is a bit of an oddly placed book within its series, this book and No Life Forsaken originally planned as one book, then later split up. Having now read both, I think this decision was very much to the benefit of No Life Forsaken. The tone of the two books end up being quite different, and separating them makes them more tonally coherent, but it does leave this book feeling a little like the fat which was trimmed off the more important half of the story. It is, one must admit, a very funny book to have as the third instalment in a trilogy about Karsa Orlong. It was already funny how Karsa barely appeared in the previous two books and is mostly just talked about. The most we get of Karsa from Legacies of Betrayal is talking about some guy Karsa hung out with one time.

This isn't to say I had a bad time with this book, it's nice to get some more Malazan marine antics and offbeat world-building and it's fun to see Erikson play around in a tone which I would describe as Pratchett-esque. It's a nice change of pace for the main antagonists to be the ones who are hopelessly out of their depth this time 'round, but this does feel oddly low stakes for a Malazan book. You don't get the world changing status quo shift you expect from a mainline Malazan book. All said though, I'm glad there's a place here to get an update on what became of Captain Kindly's combs.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 64 reviews