Looking for a home to purchase in London is anything but easy, so when Jack and Syd find a house that could just about be perfect, they decide to put in an offer. Granted, it may be packed with junk and have a funny smell, but given the fact that they’ve just scored the deal of the century, both sign on the dotted line.
Once they’ve moved in, Jack and Syd set out to clear the place up. Room by room they sort through the former owner’s belongings intrigued by the story they tell. That is, however, until Jack makes a startling discovery in the attic and Syd befriends a lonely little girl from the neighborhood.
Neither occurrence in and of itself is particularly sinister, but when neither tells the other about what they’ve learned, the die has been cast. Because, suddenly, a dead body has been found in the alley behind their house and the police strongly suspect the couple for the crime. Could they have prevented all of it from happening just by sharing their secrets with one another? They’ll likely never know.
Now Jack and Syd are left with only one option: convince the police that they’re innocent. But are they really not to blame or merely concealing the perfect crime? After all, neither Jack nor Syd seems particularly sold on the other’s side of story. So who is to be believed? Him? Or her?
A chilling tale that merged suspense with a thoroughly disturbing domestic thriller, The New Neighbors will definitely haunt my nightmares. Dark and decidedly creepy, I initially wondered whether I’d accidentally picked up a paranormal thriller (have no fear, it’s not). Yet the further into the novel I got, the more obvious it became that the plot had plenty of oh so genuine bogeymen. Sadly, though, the story lacked a true-to-life feel which left me somewhat disappointed.
Told in alternating dual POVs in the form of journal entries, it took me a bit to adapt to the format. A large part of this was because I felt like I had to constantly fill in the blanks between their two accounts. Granted, by the end of the book, it was quite clear why Lelic wrote it the way he did as too many details would have definitely given away the twists in the plot. But still, it was like trying to fight my way out of a wet paper bag for the first two-thirds of the book, just trying to follow the storyline. Which was, of course, frustrating to say the least.
One piece of this novel that was a total home run for me, though, were Jack and Syd who I thought were first-class characters. Filled to the brim with authentic flaws and difficult pasts, I was drawn into their individual stories right from the get-go. I do have to say, I connected a bit more with Jack, but Syd was just hard enough to love that her backstory made sense. You could see the damage her history had given her, which made her feel all the more real.
Ultimately, though, this one was very much a mixed bag for me. While I was intrigued by the premise and felt riveted to the pages, there was plenty that felt almost too thickly veiled. I know that to successfully deliver this storyline, tidbits had to be left out, but I found it a struggle to put the pieces together at times, which may have ruined the excitement to a certain extent. On top of that, much of the book was a long, slow burn that left me wanting more. And when the big, earth-shattering twist finally did arrive, part of me thought “Is that it?” Don’t get me wrong, I didn’t once consider DNFing this one, so there was obviously plenty keeping me spellbound, but, by the end, I was undeniably underwhelmed. Rating of 3 stars.
Trigger warning: drug use, assault, child abuse, suicide, death of a sibling, rape
*If you have first-hand experience with child abuse, I strongly recommend giving this book a miss.