I don't know if I've been more disappointed in an MM paranormal mystery than I have been for this book.
I don't often do updates on my progress while reading a book, it is usually too distracting and often not needed, but every single page I found something to take issue with. If it wasn't the plot, it was the characterization, or it was the grammar, or it was the insta-love, or it was the terrible mystery, or it was the lack of realism, or it was the 50+ references to real life. Check my statuses in my review because I laid into this book.
Full disclosure, I am a huge atheist. I think religion is dumb and I think that anyone who follows a religion when they have been given reasons to question it, like gay people, are even dumber. Both Ronan and Tennyson and literally every other character in the book kept referencing Christianity and Catholicism and the context often didn't fit. All the prayers that were made or the religious figures referenced were out of place.
Arguably, psychics don't only come from Christian backgrounds, especially when Tennyson works in a shop showcasing non-Christian spiritual effects. Yet it felt like everything Tennyson and the other psychics did fell under a Christian umbrella. Carson prayed and Tennyson prayed and Ronan prayed. They said their sermons and chants. Typical Christian set-up where nothing is explained or given proper context. So that was frustrating.
Nothing about how this police department worked made any sense. From the very beginning it is super unbelievable that there is any problem with Ronan shooting and killing a suspect that literally already shot him. I care deeply about police abuse and excessive police shootings, but we cannot pretend that there is any doubt that Ronan did the right thing. He was shot and the person who shot him was running straight towards him. Why would the family, the family who the suspect had been held at gunpoint by, ever think a lawsuit against Ronan made sense?
Why was there a need for IA (internal affairs) to investigate Ronan? His drinking (which never makes any appearances in the actual story) had nothing to do with the shooting. Why were two homicide detectives allowed to marry, work together, divorce, and still work together? Why was one of them not transferred? How did this department afford to send Ronan away to rehab? Why did they send him to cold cases? Why did they make this one case so important to solve or he would lose his badge? Cold cases usually don't get solved. Why did this police department not have fucking cameras in the station?
Tennyson's psychic abilities are the fakest abilities I have ever read about. Other than the fact we as the reader know his powers are real, they are super fake. The more you read about them, the more you compare them to "real" fake psychics and compare the fakeness. His abilities are poorly showcased and it is way too easy to convince others that he is real. It's usually as simple as "your mother told me this, your father told me that..." and it's something no one else would know. Why would the author use all the tropes of a fake psychic for their real psychic? It reads badly.
The mystery is no mystery. I'll spoil it now. The first person the reader comes across that is a living and negatively portrayed character, it is them. The first one. Yeah, it'll be weird and out of place, and that is how this character is. It seems like poor writing, and honestly it is.
The insta-love is so ridiculous that I skipped most of it. They kissed 10% of the way into the book. There is barely any positive chemistry between the characters and they just start making out. Then they are dating and having kinky sex.
Why was this thing even a reality TV show? All the legalities of following an ongoing investigation. Everything about this concept, minus one star.
Lastly, all the fucking times real actors or characters or TV shows were referenced. I got Kit Harrington from Game of Thrones, Jon Snow, Benington Cucumber from Sherlock Holmes, Long Island Medium, the other fake medium who does Hollywood stars, Avengers, Law and Order & SVU, Matt Damon, some other Hollywood actor, Will & Grace. I hated it. Every time. It shows the shallowness of the writing. The writer cannot write solidly enough on their own without having to use other media to connect with the reader. Except, when the reader doesn't know those references, or isn't that familiar with them (say a non-Christian and all those Christian references), then the read is bluntly awkward.
I'm sorry to author for this scathing review. It's really biased, but I was so excited to see a new psychic detective type series. I love the genre and I always want to read more of it, but this is one of the worst executions of it I've seen yet.