The Captive (Revised Édition) [June 20 2020]
If you take a read of my initial review (of the original edition of this book), you'll find that I rated it the same 3.5 stars as I'm rating the revised edition. Why? Because for all the improvements, some worked well and some didn't. This new edition was meant to lengthen the story so that more is explained, particularly in the mind of our main character, Cassie (whose name I remember now) and clarify points of details that were omitted the last time to maintain the feel of a short, fast-paced story.
And though, this time around there was definitely explanation more in parts that were lacking the first time, there are such fine lines between giving the reader information organically, info-dumping or repetition. I mean, it was great to understand more about Cassie's motivations and her feelings this time around, but it still did not feel like enough at times; why did Khazar (yes, I remember his name too now) just let her go so easily? She was the one that went to him, which yay consent, but at the same time I still couldn't understand that initial motivation behind it apart from maybe curiosity because of how they're connected? Maybe if we'd seen more scenes of them getting to know each other in neutral settings, I might have been more inclined to their relationship.
Of course, by the end, it was a bit easier to understand, given the situation that she was put into; what with all the coups and kidnappings. Cassie just wanted to make sure everyone was okay, at first, but did default back to getting Khazar out and saving everyone (with everyone being a convenient little bonus to their escapes).
The revised edition does go about explaining much more about the history behind the war on Earth and in the galaxy, which is good, and there's more detail into the background of the species that we meet a bit. Though again, there's a fine line between info-dump and organic understanding, most parts did flow naturally with the story and what was happening at the time. And the book has always been fast-paced, that's how the story has been written, and Foster has definitely improved the book enough that I can say it's well fast-paced but still understandable for the most part.
Though there are definite improvements to make the story more enjoyable to read (particularly as a book on its own, rather than a short story), most improvements were overshadowed by points that still feel flat or maybe trying-to-hard and therefore missing the point. Maybe I was just hoping to not being in Cassie's head; maybe seeing some scenes from Khazar's point of view, or other characters, would have shed light on the other side of the story; especially Khazar's time in captivity as well? Perhaps a third-person narrator would have been efficient enough to explain the story from a less emotional stand-point and done better to elaborate on the characters' motivations as they go about the rescue plot. (I'd like to point out here that the revised edition is not a revised plotline, kind of to my chagrin because some of the points from my original review were based on the way the plot unfolded so I might have had my hopes up that some things would be different.)
There is still heaps of potential for this story and the series as a whole, and maybe further revisions to the rest of the series will showcase those better but if the plot remains pretty much the same, I think I'm going to cut my losses. If I recall correctly, each book in this series is about a different character and there are massive time jumps; which aren't necessarily bad if there's context and explanations.
Overall, this revised edition is much better in a lot of places but does fall flat in some areas as well.
3.5/5
•
This book had potential, so much potential to be a great arc of character development and story.
Unfortunately, for me, it fell flat on a whole heap of points (some more than others).
As a short story, the entire story simply just didn't live up to the synopsis. My main peeve would be that our MC went from angry-defiant-not-taking-any-of-your-misogynistic-sh*t about the alien warlord who she was paired with to loving him? I tried really hard to put myself into this story so that I could understand her motives, but the fallback for these stories being so short means that it was a lot more difficult for me to do. (It is usually how I come to terms with any of the out-of-the-box and strange scenarios that I read about in any PNR book). Foster failed to allow me to do that by having a jolting main character who literally changed personality halfway through her arc.
Needless to say, I was left a little disappointed by it; if a heroine is going to be steadfast and determined and this kick-ass female who takes matters into her own hands and doesn't need to do things because of a man, then her development into something else needs to be respected enough that she doesn't seem bipolar. Not to say that our MC isn't efficient in how she gets things done, but yeah, a little let down by her.
That was the main reason number one for which this book lost a whole star. The second whole star deduction came from the really weirdly paced storyline and plot jumps.
I love a good rescue plot, and a survival plot, and I've recently become more appreciative of using political wiles in fantasy and PNR to live day by day (it leaves plot twists on the horizon ahead!) but Foster seems to want to add everything and anything. I'm not sure if it was the storyline, but I found a lot of scenes dragged between action – this left me really uninterested in continuing but I always try to give new PNR series a chance, because I'm a sucker for romance.
This uninterest also left me super apathetic about details – it's been about a week since I read this book and I wouldn't be able to tell you the characters names (if you notice, I've been referring to the main character as the main character because I cannot, for the life of me, remember her name and she's in the sequel as well.)
Okay, but I think I'm getting super personal now – back to the actual analytics, the storyline also had potential but lacked the finesse that gave it an interesting balance. There were cliche and predictable plotlines which I guessed from a mile away. I would have loved to see a more in-depth book, which would have given justice to the characters and their backstory (um, the alien warlord dude (Kalvar??) with the other warriors and their romances? I would have freaking loved to have seen more of them outside of Kalvar (it's what I'm calling him now) and the dude whose name starts with a V. I feel it would have given another level to the story itself.)
Not that there wasn't backstory. There was, but the way it was presented was very dry for me (which ties in with the lengthening and slow paced scenes which left me becoming bored).
This book was not terrible. I do recommend it if you enjoy quick romances in the PNR genre – but do not recommend it if you are like me and enjoy those kind of books which need to be apart of someting much much bigger. (Had these been short story novella companions to a larger PNR series I might have enjoyed them better – cameo opportunities would have kept me going)
So yes, 3.5 stars because it was not terrible but neither was it incredible – I would probably not read it again though.
3.5/5 [August 2018]
•
This copy was provided by the author for free in exchange for an honest review.