I'm not really sure what to rate this book. I have it as two stars though it might be 2.5. This being the 4th book I've read by this author you'd think I'd be used to the uncomfortable, hard limit subject matter, but I was proven wrong, lol. Whether things were done for shock value, I can't really say. There are two things I could have done without. Yet another pseduo-incestuous relationship, this time with Scarlet and David who could have been her father, and the rape scene. I felt the latter was put in to kind of "put Scarlet in her place" since her revenge against Reid was going so well. I don't know why Scarlet thought he wouldn't turn violent against her. He raped you chick! You really thought this time around he'd just sob and cry because he was paranoid? Her revenge plot left a lot to be desired. Who has the kind of patience to drive someone out of their mind when there were a million opportunities beforehand to get someone thrown in prison?? When Reid himself had so many run-ins with the law? That just made no sense to me.
Reid was already a few cards short of a full deck. Driving him to a psychotic break, the way it was described kind of made me feel like I was reading a cartoon, to be honest. I didn't feel Reid's fear, I didn't feel him losing it. He just more or less came off as perpetually drunk. So that plot could have been fleshed out more. And as someone else pointed out, Scarlet getting contacts, coloring her hair, adopting a Scottish accent, and wearing dowdy clothes wouldn't have been enough to convince Reid who was obsessed with her that she was a totally different person. Then again in the fictional world people can't see that Clark Kent is Superman simply because Clark wears glasses, guess I can suspend my disbelief.
Moving on, I read Jaimie's after word, or message to the fans, and her novella idea involving a what-if if Richard hadn't died. I'm glad he's dead and that's where he needs to stay. In the figurative grave. I don't need a what-if on what would happen between a child rapist and his victim. In this climate, #metoo movement, we don't need more stories like that. Women shouldn't have to be victimized in order to find their empowerment. That's just my opinion. Other than that, I think Scarlet's story has been wrapped up in the best way it could.