Dr. Neal Barnard comes with an impressive résumé: He’s a professor at the George Washington University School of Medicine in Washington, D.C.; he’s the president of the Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine, a group promoting veganism; he’s authored quite a few studies on health and veganism. Which is why I am not going to give this cookbook a rating — because a rating would depend on whom you are.
Dr. Barnard insists that diabetes is not caused by a surfeit of sugar and carbohydrate-laden foods, such as potatoes or bread — the latter is the conventional medical position — but by too much fat, especially animal fat. Consequently, none of the recipes in this cookbook have any meat or even animal products: no eggs, milk, butter, cheese, Worcestershire sauce, soy sauce, etc. Dr. Barnard’s cookbook is strictly vegan.
As a vegan cookbook, this is a five-star tome, including vegan variations on quesadillas, creamy smoothies, chili, burgers, ice cream and more. If you’re vegan, you’ve hit the jackpot.
But what if you’re diabetic? Or you’re looking for low-carb recipes? While I respect Dr. Barnard, I do not believe in his notion that fat, not carbs, are making Americans fat nor bringing on our current epidemic of Type 2 diabetes. If low-fat diets were the answer, then the low-fat craze of the 1960s through the 2000s would have turned the United States into a svelte, healthy nation with barely a diabetic to be found. And it didn’t. In addition, the vast majority of physicians and medical researchers do not agree that veganism without regard to sugars and carbohydrates will improve — much less, reverse — high blood sugar. (Dr. Barnard adds maple syrup to all kinds of recipes, including those which don’t need sweetening. Very few of these recipes are low-carbohydrate, needless to say.)
I commend Dr. Barnard’s commitment to cruelty-free eating, but I don’t believe that eschewing meat and animal products will reverse anything about your health, much less diabetes. If you decide to become a vegan, do so for ethical reasons, not to cure your diabetes.
In the interest of full disclosure, low-fat diets never helped me, and I have lost 25 pounds in the last six months by counting carbs and eating more vegetables. If you’re like me, you’ll find some interesting recipes in Dr. Barnard’s cookbook, but you’re rating will be closer to three stars rather than five.
The cookbook is available free for those with a Kindle Unlimited subscription.