I'm currently almost done with this book, and while it is okay, it loses points due to a plot hole I noticed and 2 other issues. I just wanted to put down how this book went with me before I forgot.
The Good:
1) The story. Seriously, aside from the issues below, this really was a good story. I'm putting the good at the top because it was primarily a good book, even if it loses points (and stars) due to the problems I have with it.
2) Not bringing back the "see ya" part. I can not tell you how cringy I found that overly silly part. I can enjoy silly, but that was over the top
Plot Hole:
When Dirk (or w/e his name is) attacks the MC and severs his hand, he is then killed in a SINGLE BLOW, even though he had the pin which was supposed to prevent death a single time. Technically that 1 hit that smooshed his skull should have taken him down to 1%.
Issues:
1) When Druegar are introduced, it isn't really explained how anyone knows what they are. Let me tell you, I've been reading fantasy for well over a decade, and the first time I ever heard of them was about a year ago when I was playing the D&D 5e campaign "Lost in the Underdark". The knowledge of these guys is REALLY obscure or niche, and while it was good that what they were was explained to the audience, it doesn't explain how any of the characters knew what such an obscure race was. Could have been solved in like 1-2 sentences.
2) The virtue signalling. I swear, there are times when I feel like yelling "I GET it, the MC and party are the GOOD GUYS!". Seriously, there are plenty of times when something is listed as SO CLEARLY EVIL and the MC & friends have a "round table" moment where they all decide to do something about it, or make a stand, or whatever. Seriously, TONE IT DOWN. I'm not saying he needs to be a bad guy, or CLEARLY selfish, or whatever, but if you feel the need to have this happen in the book, but you don't want it to be so eye-rollingly-cringy, a suggestion would be to have it happen off screen and then have the MC find out about it afterwords, where his friends (or someone else) did the good and proper (and holy, why not?) thing.