I can give this book a three and a half star review out of five.
The information in it is really good and can help couples who, individually, are committed to improve themselves and own their part in a problem while respecting their partner as a separate individual. The topic of boundaries is very well explained. Valuable things like how to set boundaries, how to have non-defensive responses, giving consequences, etc. are given in great detail.
However, it is a book that I would not recommend to someone who's in an abusive relationship or with a partner who has a personality disorder. This book will keep people who are in a FOG of confusion, due to manipulation, get deeper into the FOG. It will make them work harder for the relationship, and take a lot of blame upon themselves making it very unbalanced and extremely unhealthy.
I was in an abusive marriage for 8 years. It’s been 9 years since I left that marriage. I’ve learned to set boundaries and have a high sense of self-respect. I’m not in an abusive relationship now so I can see from a healthier perspective and have a sense of discernment to point out what could be very dangerous from this book and what could be helpful. If I would have read this book while I was married to my ex-husband it would have probably kept me stuck deeper into the abuse. Even if the book has great tools, it’s not helpful for someone who’s dealing with a partner who has a personality disorder because of the reasons below:
I absolutely hate it when the subject of religious’ views is brought up into a relationship book. This has kept many people trapped in abusive marriages. For example the typical overused saying, "You should forgive as God forgives you" can lead someone who's being abused to forgive and overlook offenses that should actually receive serious consequences. Yes, the subjects of consequences, holding people accountable, setting boundaries and all that are mentioned in this book, but they are in the context of assumption that both people are somewhat “normal” people. But when God and biblical quotes are mixed in the subject it can really keep someone very trapped in more abuse.
Religious teachings can actually limit our understanding of behavioral problems, mental health issues, personality disorders, and it can interfere with developing a strong sense of self-respect. I don't care if the bible says a wife is to submit to her husband. If I was to submit to my ex-husband I would have been dead by now. He was a sociopath and such counsel, which was given to me before by religious leaders, led to more abuse. It's important that religious beliefs are left aside when giving advice in a book about boundaries. Don’t get me wrong, I believe in a higher power, in God, but I do believe that we have a higher self (which is probably part of God himself) and that’s the best guidance we can receive. We need to learn to honor that higher self instead of some traditional religious teaching which are more limited than our higher self. When relationships and religious teachings are mixed, we act out of fear and guilt instead of self-respect and self-acceptance.
Furthermore, stating that divorce is not Godly and should be the very last option is misleading. I get it that you don’t want to threaten divorce as a form of “boundary” or to use it to control your spouse. That is indeed not healthy, but the idea of divorce as a bad thing has to stop being influenced by religious teachings as if it’s not approved by God. This is something that, again, if someone in an abusive relationship reads, it will probably push them to being in very dangerous situation. I speak from a place of experience. Religious believes tend to oversimplify things, they tend to force people to look at everyone else as loving and caring children of God and because of this we lower our self-protection and end up caring more about the other than ourselves.
This book could have been excellent if it gave more warning regarding boundaries while dealing with people with personality disorders. It talks about this only in a small portion of one chapter towards the end of the book. There are more people with personality disorders than we are aware of and we need to be very careful about that.
I could only recommend this book to a couple who makes their religion the center of their lives, a couple who is composed of two healthy people, who neither partner has a personality disorder. Maybe a couple in which both partners are individually self-aware and want to grow and improve themselves. This book can be very dangerous to many so I can't recommend it to everyone. If this book is read by someone who's married to a narcissist it will create more problems than solutions. I would recommend instead Emotional Blackmail by Susan Forward.
Now, if I’m to remove the religious perspective in this book and the lack of warning on personality disorders, I did get a lot of good out of this book. The book has a lot of great tools and wonderful information on respecting your boundaries. I like that they clarify the difference between completing and complementing each other in a relationship. My favorite parts from the book are the following:
“The crucial element of ‘two becoming one’ is that the two people must be complete in and of themselves--they must be adults--before they marry. This does not mean that the husband and wife possess all of the same talents and abilities, or even the same style. It does mean, however, that they possess all of adult functioning in key areas of personhood.”
"If your spouse is hurting or failing, you are not morally superior, but you are in the stronger position at that moment to be able to help.”
“Validate each other's feelings with empathy, understanding, care and non-defensiveness, because what your spouse is feeling is real and true for him or her.”
“Boundaries are not to be used to control your spouse. Boundaries are to protect, love, and respect yourself and your spouse.”
Lastly, I liked that they talked about good suffering and bad suffering. They use the terminology godly suffering and ungodly suffering, which I hate that terminology but the concept is good. Meaning that if you set boundaries with your spouse in a healthy way and they respond in a defensive way, you’ll suffer from their response because they might withdrawal or create fear in you. It’s better to suffer their response and hold on to your boundaries, than to suffer the consequences of not setting a boundary at all which can have greater ramifications.