Nadia Knox knows all about secrets, but nothing has prepared her for what the Eye of Zinnia will reveal! (Ages 8-12) For as long as she can remember, Nadia and her younger brother, Chris, have been tagging along with their parents as they travel the world searching for the untold stories of ancient societies. This summer is different, though. This summer, her parents and their research partners, Mr. and Mrs. Haynes, are angling to win the world-famous F.I.S.H. Prize for Finding Inaccuracies in Science and History. With competition fierce and only a few months left until the finalists are chosen, it’ll take the whole team to uncover something truly the Kamju, a civilization hidden deep in the wilds of Uganda. Some people believe the Kamju, known for their powerful magic, are not real. Nadia’s parents think they can find them. Nadia knows how important this discovery could be to her parents, but she can’t shake the feeling that something is wrong. After all, wouldn’t there be more than legends and whispers if the Kamju actually wanted to be found? And why are her parents being so secretive about their plans—if they find the Kamju, what happens next? Things go from weird to worse when they meet their mysterious new tour guide, Bantu. Nadia just knows that he’s hiding secrets of his own, and she’s determined to find out what they are. Young readers and parents alike will love the Eye of Zinnia’s combination of magic, action, and exploration. Get a copy today.
I really can't recommend this book. I feel I could go on at length about all they ways it disappointed me, but, really, I don't want to dump on a book that has its heart in the right place. Sadly, so much is wrong with it, and it's really not very entertaining.
It focuses on Nadia Knox, even though the main story revolves around her African tour guide. Subsequently, we have chapter after chapter of talking about his background, and Nadia doing almost nothing. The editing is cringingly bad. Seriously, so many errors, even in the second edition! Motivations are shaky. The big action scenes are almost identical (a kid falls into a river full of dangerous animals, Nadia saves the day, TWICE). Nadia uses her magic amulet in the first of these scenes, ignores it the second - why? The climax is half-hearted. People argue by repeating themselves instead of trying to make new points or convince anyone.
It's just a let down. If this was a set-up to future books I feel no interest, maybe even cheated a little. The concept was good, the actual book was not fun, sadly.
I'm at a loss on how to rate this book. We read this book as a read-aloud for our 1st Grade homeschool curriculum, and it was one I was really looking forward to.
The premise is great. It promises adventure, a little magic, thought-provoking topics, and fun characters - who are all PoC! In an African setting! There is so much potential for awesomeness here!
The book starts with an enormous exposition dump, which really sets the tone for everything that follows. There is A LOT of talking. Nadia gets a few opportunities to actively do something, but most of the story is her receiving backstory explanations from another character. There is very little conflict. The two action scenes are nearly identical to each other and don't do much to move the plot forward. There is very little plot to begin with, which is the bigger issue. The ending is a flop - there is no tension, nothing interesting happening at all. It all just sort of peters out.
On the plus side, the book does seem to have gone through at least one revision, because there were only a couple of grammar mistakes that we found, compared to the issues we heard others had. It's a mostly clean manuscript, it was just not a gripping story.
I liked the concept of the book, but it was honestly a letdown. I felt like the author was trying too hard to create twists and turns, so it all felt a bit disconnected. Example: the tribe changes names three times I believe, so even I was getting a little lost.
The editing was awful. There were so many spelling and grammar mistakes. I kept having to reread sentences because I was confused about the fact that they weren't even full sentences.
I also didn't feel a connection to Nadia. One scene describes how she suddenly feels special, but it has no emotional pull to it because nothing prior to the scene paints her as an underdog or lacking in any way.
I really wanted to like this book. The premise was solid and I love the concept of an anthropological expedition. The issue was... it wasn't even remotely realistic. I realize this is a children's book, but no parents would take their kids on a journey with so much unknown and certainly not two families. Also, the parents who were apparently well respected anthropologists didn't seem to know very much about their subject matter and their daughter, Nadia, seemed to have more respect for the culture of the tribes than all the adults combined. It irritated me. The author shows on more than one occasion that the adults are flawed this way, but it still left a bad taste in my mouth. Also, some really close calls happen, but the parents don't seem phased by any of it. They also don't seem terribly interested in Nadia's new gift either, which is one of the cooler things that happen. Finally, the dialogue between the children is weak at best.
On a more positive note, the information given about the tribes and the relationships between the African families is quite interesting. I also liked Nadia's character as a whole. I wish her parents weren't involved and she was the one sent on a study abroad or something similar. She has real potential! I also like that the author wrote something to encourage kids to get involved in science and she presented the argument very clearly that modern humans tend to ruin ancient cultures when we think we're educating everyone. I thought she did a fine job exposing that narrative.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
When Nadia, a clumsy, thirteen-year old girl, is dragged off to Uganda to find the Kamju, a civilization believed to be extinct, by her parents and their documentary team, she is in for some really weird experiences. Though a little slow to start, by the second chapter the story grabs your attention and is hard to put down. In addition to realistic family interactions and conflict, both American and Ugandan, there is an element of an ancient magic that tantalizes the reader. The book is full of action, emotion, and riveting descriptions, such as the Guardian Souls (nightmare creatures, twice as tall as a human that "looked like a warthog: big, widely spaced eyes on either side of a scruffy pig snout") and their human-headed companion birds. It explores both the fantastical and real beauty and danger of Uganda. The story raises questions whether a civilization's desire for autonomy and non-interference from the "outside" trumps science's desire to know, catalogue, and explain everything in the world. Overall, it is an enjoyable, absorbing adventure, focused on the clash of cultures and beliefs, that will leave the reader eagerly awaiting Jessica's next book. (Though, admittedly, it could use more editing.)
We liked that it was a mystery and that Nadia could talk to her parents to get them to try to change their minds. —H & N (who wanted to give it 5 stars) I liked the generally idea for the story and the setting, but there were plot holes.—W Way too many characters, hard to follow, needs another round of editing for typos. Great premise, source of good discussion with the kids. —K
I was gifted the book Nadia Knox and the Eye of Zinnia by Jessica McDougle & Plum Street Press through the wonderful Multicultural Children’s Book Day reviewer initiative.
The middle-grade novel introduces readers to 13 year old Nadia Knox, who, with little brother Chris, accompanies her anthropologist parents around the world searching for the ‘untold secrets of cultures and civilizations’. In this adventure, the Knox family is off to Uganda as Nadia’s parents try to locate a legendary lost people in order to win an important scientific prize.
Accompanying the Knoxs are their anthropologist friends, the Haynes, and their 2 children (who happen to be about the same age as Nadia and her brother). Together, the group embark on a journey of (literal and metaphorical) discovery through Uganda with their guide Bantu, a friendly but enigmatic young man.
Nadia Knox and The Eye of Zinnia is a great adventure story with elements of magic and fantasy set in the rich landscapes of Uganda. Nadia is a wonderful character with great courage and determination, who is not afraid to act in dangerous situations, but who is also able to think for herself and confront difficult questions.
At points, the story does take a bit of a dark turn, as the characters learn about the history of the people they are searching for. Nadia’s parents’ obsession with winning the competition at times seems comical, but at other points gains a more sinister note as characters argue over the ethics of what they are doing. These points are certainly important though, and help lend an air of realism and maturity to counterpoint the fast and fun adventure.
While there is no interior artwork, the book features a stylish & contemporary cover illustration by Ravshan Karimov that gives a face to Nadia and the other kids in the story.
***
About Multicultural Children’s Book Day Multicultural Children’s Book Day 2019 (1/25/19) is in its 6th year and was founded by Valarie Budayr from Jump Into A Book and Mia Wenjen from PragmaticMom. Our mission is to raise awareness of the ongoing need to include kids’ books that celebrate diversity in home and school bookshelves while also working diligently to get more of these types of books into the hands of young readers, parents and educators.
We’d like to also give a shout-out to MCBD’s impressive CoHost Team who not only hosts the book review link-up on celebration day, but who also works tirelessly to spread the word of this event. View our CoHosts: http://multiculturalchildrensbookday....
TWITTER PARTY Sponsored by Make A Way Media: MCBD’s super-popular (and crazy-fun) annual Twitter Party will be held 1/27/19 at 9:00pm. E.S.T.
Join the conversation and win one of 12 five book bundles and one Grand Prize Book Bundle (12 books) that will be given away at the party!
Nadia and her family are on their way, with another team of anthropologists, to Uganda in search of an ancient tribe called the Kamju. The goal of this adventure is to prove that they Kamju really exist. If they can prove it then her parents and the team can win the very prestigious FISH award. The only problem is that Nadia is suspicious of their guide, Bantu. She thinks he is hiding something. And Nadia was right. Bantu is part of the Kamju tribe but according to him they no longer exist because of a revolt that happened. It’s also the same time that Bantu’s brother went missing. One night, Bantu told Nadia the entire story of his family and the Kamju. Bantu also gave Nadia a gift. It was a stone called the Eye of Zinnia. The stone would grant her a power because she was pure of heart. Nadia also learned that Bantu was given a power from his father, a high priest, it was the power of “where.” This meant Bantu could find any place. Is Bantu the key to the FISH award? What will Nadia’s power be? Will the group find anyone else from the mysterious Kamju tribe?
Author Jessica McDougle has created a fun chapter book for young readers. There is plenty of mystery, humor and adventure. The characters are interesting and relatable. Parents and teachers can use this to discuss history, foreign places, cultures and even do some research of their own. This book would also make an excellent read-a-loud.
In this adventure story, Nadia Knox travels with her anthropologist parents to find an ancient African tribe that is thought to be extinct. With the help of their guide Bantu and a mysterious necklace, Nadia discovers that she has the magical power to communicate in any language. Her powers help her family in their quest to safely traverse the Ugandan wilds and find people and a habitat who remain isolated and protected from the modern world by choice. Bantu’s family connection to the tribe adds another layer of emotion to the story, as we wonder if his family will be happily reunited or remain fractured.
This story serves as an introduction to magical realism. I recommend it for older fans of the Magic Treehouse or even the I Survived series. Some suspenseful scenes and imagery may render this story a little scary for younger middle grade readers, but the right audience will delight in these thrilling, plot-driving details. I would have rated this book higher if the themes and characters were developed a bit more. I know this is an adventure story, but as a parent it is hard to believe that two sets of anthropologist parents would continually put their children in danger and endanger the cultural preservation of an isolated tribe just to win a professional award.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
We read this book for one of my son's curricula and the discussion it prompted, in part thanks to the lit primer provided by the curriculum, was excellent. This book brings up a lot of good questions that made reading it worthwhile. But, this book is in desperate need of a good editor. First of all, there are many, many typos. I have typos all the time, but I'm not publishing a book. It really feels like no one read this book before it went to print. And secondly, there are many holes in the story and ideas that need to be fleshed out or explained. It is hard to discuss this point without giving spoilers, so I will just say that lots of times I would find myself asking questions aloud that the book never answered. My son, who is eight, wasn't bothered by either of these. I read it aloud to him so he didn't notice any of the typos and while he noticed a couple of the holes, on the whole they didn't bother him and he loved the story enough (he gave it five stars) that he was willing to overlook them. I think this could have been a really enjoyable read, it just needed a decent edit.
This book was a read aloud for my homeschooled second grader. I really wanted to like this book because it featured a female of color (and homeschooler!) as the main character but the many typographical errors throughout the book were distracting and disappointing.
This book was a bit crazy to me because there’s a lot going on. Nadia is very kind and if she wasn’t, Bantu wouldn’t have given her the necklace. Charlotte is a bit sassy. Teddy and Chris are not people I would want to travel with. The parents were so interested in winning their award that they didn’t seem to care that they were affecting so many other people. They should have just let the Maji be! What happens to the Eye of Zinnia when Nadia goes home? Will it continue to glow at times? Will Nadia speak in different languages all the time? I would recommend this book to others but you may have to read it a couple times to understand it. — O, age 7
We wanted to love this book, and it deals with interesting themes and has a ton of potential.
Ultimately, it reads like a first draft of something on its way to becoming a great book—four or five drafts from now.
The pacing is stilted and uneven. There’s way too much exposition, and the characters lack development in many ways. For an adventurous tale, it’s really not very engaging.
The lower order concern issues with grammar, punctuation, and general proofreading are very, very distracting. I was reading it aloud to my kids, so I could gloss over the errors, but if they were reading it independently, it would really bother me as an educator that they were seeing such clearly unedited prose in a finished, polished project.
While this might not be a deal breaker for some kids, I wasn't prepared for how brutal some parts of this book was considering it was part of our Level 1 curriculum. The pieces about people being torn limb from limb was quite scary for my not-typically-sensitive kiddo.
Great connections for geography and history - just a bit much for young learners.
Great overall premise and could see these being a great series but needs some more fleshing out of characters, there seemed to be a lot of repetition with no meat. My 7 year old gave it 4/5 stars and really enjoyed it but I think it needs some more depth. There are lots of educational items that you use as conversation but still needs more in the way of plot and character depth.
DNF. There were a few bright moments that were memorable for my daughter but it was an utter chore to read aloud. Dialogue was clunky and drawn out. The story wasn’t terrible, when I skim-read and leapt over whole paragraphs it was more enjoyable — but ultimately not worth the time
A wonderful journey full of magic and imagination. Use this book to spark a discussion of the importance of keeping a promise and trust. I thoroughly enjoyed it and I know my students will as well.
Good story with nuggets of good writing. A little clunky. Characters don't seem very realistic, though. I wish the main character were the tour guide, though. He seems to have a cool backstory.
I read this book aloud to my 6&4 year olds. It was a little hard to read aloud, but my 6 year old assured me he liked it. It has a good moral topic to discuss, and has some spooky adventure scenes.
We struggled with this book as a read aloud. However, when we switched to the audio version it was so much better. It prompted lots of discussions with my Lv 1 kiddo.
I read other reviews and agree with a lot of the points, but my kids loved this book and always begged me to keep reading. My kids are 10 and 6. They are excited for any future books with Nadia.
Read with kiddo for third grade Language Arts. Kiddo thought it was okay and liked the adventure parts. I thought it had a lot of typos and at times was borderline problematic.
Read with my nine year old, and we were so looking forward to this adventure in Africa. It has a wonderful message, but it really missed the mark on having any excitement.
Glad we didn't skip this one! I prepped with these details: the story starts on an airplane with the big brother puking. They are flying to Africa to look for a mysterious hidden tribe. Nadia is proud of her ability to keep secrets safe like Fort Knox keeps gold safe. She is worried her parents will put the tribe in danger if they find them. The parents need a secret to tell so they can win a prize. What do you think should happen?
For read aloud, voices make this a lot of fun, but you often have to scan whole paragraphs to find out who is talking and what voice to use. Just takes a bit of patience.
Cast of Characters for read aloud: Two thoughtful tween girls, a little kid voice for the younger brother, a teenage brother who likes to tease, the Ugandan guide with a polished English accent, all the other Africans with Ugandan accents. A fancy photographer mom, a passionate scientist mom, and two dads who don't say much, one is big and buff.