What do you think?
Rate this book
Harry Bosch #8
Cmentarzysko
Kiedy pies jednego z mieszkańców okolicy Hollywood Hills znajduje kość, wydaje się, że nie ma w tym nic nadzwyczajnego. Ale właściciel zwierzęcia - emerytowany lekarz - rozpoznaje w zdobyczy pupila ludzkie szczątki. Policja podczas przeszukiwania terenu odkrywa niemal kompletny szkielet chłopca. Badania kryminalistyczne ujawniają, że ofiara została zamordowana kilkanaście lat wcześniej, a za życia była regularnie maltretowana. Detektyw Harry Bosch rozpoczyna śledztwo, by rozwikłać mroczną zagadkę sprzed lat, ale po upływie tak długiego czasu dochodzenie jest niezwykle trudne, a Departament Policji Los Angeles naciska, by jak najszybciej zamknąć sprawę.
Cmentarzysko zostało nagrodzone Anthony Award w kategorii "Najlepsza powieść 2003" i Barry Award również w kategorii "Najlepsza powieść 2003".
Cmentarzysko zostało nagrodzone Anthony Award w kategorii "Najlepsza powieść 2003" i Barry Award również w kategorii "Najlepsza powieść 2003".
326 pages, Unknown Binding
First published April 16, 2002
4682 people are currently reading
12512 people want to read
About the author
Michael Connelly
381 books34.8k followersLibrarian Note: There is more than one author in the Goodreads' database with this name. See this thread for more information.
Michael Connelly decided to become a writer after discovering the books of Raymond Chandler while attending the University of Florida. Once he decided on this direction he chose a major in journalism and a minor in creative writing — a curriculum in which one of his teachers was novelist Harry Crews.
After graduating in 1980, Connelly worked at newspapers in Daytona Beach and Fort Lauderdale, Florida, primarily specializing in the crime beat. In Fort Lauderdale he wrote about police and crime during the height of the murder and violence wave that rolled over South Florida during the so-called cocaine wars. In 1986, he and two other reporters spent several months interviewing survivors of a major airline crash. They wrote a magazine story on the crash and the survivors which was later short-listed for the Pulitzer Prize for feature writing. The magazine story also moved Connelly into the upper levels of journalism, landing him a job as a crime reporter for the Los Angeles Times, one of the largest papers in the country, and bringing him to the city of which his literary hero, Chandler, had written.
After three years on the crime beat in L.A., Connelly began writing his first novel to feature LAPD Detective Hieronymus Bosch. The novel, The Black Echo, based in part on a true crime that had occurred in Los Angeles, was published in 1992 and won the Edgar Award for Best First Novel by the Mystery Writers of America. Connelly has followed that up with over 30 more novels.
Over eighty million copies of Connelly’s books have sold worldwide and he has been translated into forty-five foreign languages. He has won the Edgar Award, Anthony Award, Macavity Award, Los Angeles Times Best Mystery/Thriller Award, Shamus Award, Dilys Award, Nero Award, Barry Award, Audie Award, Ridley Award, Maltese Falcon Award (Japan), .38 Caliber Award (France), Grand Prix Award (France), Premio Bancarella Award (Italy), and the Pepe Carvalho award (Spain) .
Michael was the President of the Mystery Writers of America organization in 2003 and 2004. In addition to his literary work, Michael is one of the producers and writers of the TV show, “Bosch,” which is streaming on Amazon Prime Video.
Michael lives with his family in Los Angeles and Tampa, Florida.
Michael Connelly decided to become a writer after discovering the books of Raymond Chandler while attending the University of Florida. Once he decided on this direction he chose a major in journalism and a minor in creative writing — a curriculum in which one of his teachers was novelist Harry Crews.
After graduating in 1980, Connelly worked at newspapers in Daytona Beach and Fort Lauderdale, Florida, primarily specializing in the crime beat. In Fort Lauderdale he wrote about police and crime during the height of the murder and violence wave that rolled over South Florida during the so-called cocaine wars. In 1986, he and two other reporters spent several months interviewing survivors of a major airline crash. They wrote a magazine story on the crash and the survivors which was later short-listed for the Pulitzer Prize for feature writing. The magazine story also moved Connelly into the upper levels of journalism, landing him a job as a crime reporter for the Los Angeles Times, one of the largest papers in the country, and bringing him to the city of which his literary hero, Chandler, had written.
After three years on the crime beat in L.A., Connelly began writing his first novel to feature LAPD Detective Hieronymus Bosch. The novel, The Black Echo, based in part on a true crime that had occurred in Los Angeles, was published in 1992 and won the Edgar Award for Best First Novel by the Mystery Writers of America. Connelly has followed that up with over 30 more novels.
Over eighty million copies of Connelly’s books have sold worldwide and he has been translated into forty-five foreign languages. He has won the Edgar Award, Anthony Award, Macavity Award, Los Angeles Times Best Mystery/Thriller Award, Shamus Award, Dilys Award, Nero Award, Barry Award, Audie Award, Ridley Award, Maltese Falcon Award (Japan), .38 Caliber Award (France), Grand Prix Award (France), Premio Bancarella Award (Italy), and the Pepe Carvalho award (Spain) .
Michael was the President of the Mystery Writers of America organization in 2003 and 2004. In addition to his literary work, Michael is one of the producers and writers of the TV show, “Bosch,” which is streaming on Amazon Prime Video.
Michael lives with his family in Los Angeles and Tampa, Florida.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 2,646 reviews
November 27, 2024
Harry Bosch #8, Harry Bosch Universe #11 sees the bones of what appears to be a long-time ago murdered young boy found in a rural-ish area; the autopsy reveals that the victim was abused his entire life; Harry can't let this go and picks up the cold case. Meanwhile a new romance might be blossoming in his life, but as this is a Harry Bosch story we all know how that's going to end. Another firm Bosch instalment meriting an 8 out of 12 Four Stars.
2024 read
2024 read
December 7, 2017
The eighth Harry Bosch novel, published in 2002, opens when a dog unearths a human bone in Laurel Canyon in the hills above Hollywood. The dog's owner, a retired doctor, recognizes the discovery immediately and calls the police. Harry Bosch responds, climbs the hill where the dog had been playing, and discovers the bones of a child that had been buried in a shallow grave more than twenty years earlier.
An autopsy reveals that the boy had been murdered, but there are precious few clues apart from the bones themselves. A case this cold will be almost impossible to solve, but for Bosch, this case, like virtually all his others, becomes personal and he simply won't let go of it.
Harry is, ultimately, able to identify the victim, but tracking down the killer will take all of the skills he has honed through the years. Along the way, he will acquire a new love interest, and, as is almost always the case, will find himself in conflict with the department's brass who are, at least in Harry's view, much more interested in protecting the department's image than they are in achieving some sort of justice.
This is another very good entry in the series, featuring the level of detail and insight into police procedure that readers have come to expect from Connelly. One of the particular joys of this book lies in the minor characters, beginning with the doctor whose dog discovers the bones, all of whom are very well-drawn and unusually interesting. The book ends with a particularly shattering climax which will leave readers very anxious to get to the next book in the series.
An autopsy reveals that the boy had been murdered, but there are precious few clues apart from the bones themselves. A case this cold will be almost impossible to solve, but for Bosch, this case, like virtually all his others, becomes personal and he simply won't let go of it.
Harry is, ultimately, able to identify the victim, but tracking down the killer will take all of the skills he has honed through the years. Along the way, he will acquire a new love interest, and, as is almost always the case, will find himself in conflict with the department's brass who are, at least in Harry's view, much more interested in protecting the department's image than they are in achieving some sort of justice.
This is another very good entry in the series, featuring the level of detail and insight into police procedure that readers have come to expect from Connelly. One of the particular joys of this book lies in the minor characters, beginning with the doctor whose dog discovers the bones, all of whom are very well-drawn and unusually interesting. The book ends with a particularly shattering climax which will leave readers very anxious to get to the next book in the series.
December 31, 2017
EXCERPT: The old lady changed her mind about dying but by then it had been too late. She dug her fingers into the paint and plaster of the nearby wall until most of her fingernails had broken off. Then she had gone for the neck, scrabbling to push the bloodied fingertips up and under the cord. She broke four toes kicking at the walls. She had tried so hard, shown such a desperate will to live, that it made Harry Bosch wonder what had happened before. Where was that determination and will and why had it deserted her until after she had put the extension cord noose around her neck and kicked over the chair? Why had it hidden from her?
These were not official questions that would be raised in his death report. But they were the things Bosch couldn't avoid thinking about as he sat in his car outside the Splendid Age Retirement Home on Sunset Boulevard east of the Hollywood Freeway. It was 4:20 p.m. on the first day of the year. Bosch had drawn holiday call out duty.
The day more than half over and that duty consisted of two suicide runs — one a gunshot, the other the hanging. Both victims were women. In both cases there was evidence of depression and desperation. Isolation. New Year's Day was always a big day for suicides. While most people greeted the day with a sense of hope and renewal, there were those who saw it as a good day to die, some — like the old lady — not realizing their mistake until it was too late.
THE BLURB: Detective Harry Bosch tears open a 20-year-old murder case - with an explosive ending that leave all Bosch fans hungrily awaiting the next instalment.
When the bones of a twelve-year-old boy are found scattered in the Hollywood Hills, Harry Bosch is drawn into a case that brings up the darkest memories from his own haunted past. The bones have been buried for years, but the cold case doesn't deter Bosch. Unearthing hidden stories, he finds the child's identity and reconstructs his fractured life, determined that he not be forgotten.
At the same time, a new love affair with a female cop begins to blossom for Bosch - until a stunningly blown mission leaves him in more trouble than ever before in his turbulent career. The investigation races to a shocking conclusion and leaves Bosch on the brink of an unimaginable decision.
MY THOUGHTS: Being a parent is the hardest job in the world, and the relationships between family members the most complex. It is these relationships that form the basis of City of Bones.
Michael Connelly never disappoints. The quality of his writing is consistently high, the pace of the plot fast, but never frantic. Connelly loves, and is master of, the plot twist. I know it is coming, but still he manages to take me by surprise. No matter how hard I try to work out what it is going to be, I have never yet managed to correctly predict it in its entirety.
Bosch continues to grow as a character, both professionally and personally. In City of Bones, Connelly leaves Bosch at a crossroads in his life.
Supporting characters are also well fleshed out. They are not always people we like, but all have relevant parts to play in the plot. Connelly's plots are never simple, but neither are they so complex that they become confusing. He lays red herrings with great skill, and in City of Bones I found myself, as I so often do with his books, picking the completely wrong person as the killer. Perhaps it's just as well I'm not a detective!
I listened to City of Bones by Michael Connelly, narrated by Peter Jay Fernandez, via OverDrive. All opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own personal opinions. Please refer to my Goodreads.com profile page or the 'about' page on sandysbookaday.wordpress.com for an explanation of my rating system. This review and others are also published on my blog sandysbookaday.wordpress.com https://sandysbookaday.wordpress.com/...
These were not official questions that would be raised in his death report. But they were the things Bosch couldn't avoid thinking about as he sat in his car outside the Splendid Age Retirement Home on Sunset Boulevard east of the Hollywood Freeway. It was 4:20 p.m. on the first day of the year. Bosch had drawn holiday call out duty.
The day more than half over and that duty consisted of two suicide runs — one a gunshot, the other the hanging. Both victims were women. In both cases there was evidence of depression and desperation. Isolation. New Year's Day was always a big day for suicides. While most people greeted the day with a sense of hope and renewal, there were those who saw it as a good day to die, some — like the old lady — not realizing their mistake until it was too late.
THE BLURB: Detective Harry Bosch tears open a 20-year-old murder case - with an explosive ending that leave all Bosch fans hungrily awaiting the next instalment.
When the bones of a twelve-year-old boy are found scattered in the Hollywood Hills, Harry Bosch is drawn into a case that brings up the darkest memories from his own haunted past. The bones have been buried for years, but the cold case doesn't deter Bosch. Unearthing hidden stories, he finds the child's identity and reconstructs his fractured life, determined that he not be forgotten.
At the same time, a new love affair with a female cop begins to blossom for Bosch - until a stunningly blown mission leaves him in more trouble than ever before in his turbulent career. The investigation races to a shocking conclusion and leaves Bosch on the brink of an unimaginable decision.
MY THOUGHTS: Being a parent is the hardest job in the world, and the relationships between family members the most complex. It is these relationships that form the basis of City of Bones.
Michael Connelly never disappoints. The quality of his writing is consistently high, the pace of the plot fast, but never frantic. Connelly loves, and is master of, the plot twist. I know it is coming, but still he manages to take me by surprise. No matter how hard I try to work out what it is going to be, I have never yet managed to correctly predict it in its entirety.
Bosch continues to grow as a character, both professionally and personally. In City of Bones, Connelly leaves Bosch at a crossroads in his life.
Supporting characters are also well fleshed out. They are not always people we like, but all have relevant parts to play in the plot. Connelly's plots are never simple, but neither are they so complex that they become confusing. He lays red herrings with great skill, and in City of Bones I found myself, as I so often do with his books, picking the completely wrong person as the killer. Perhaps it's just as well I'm not a detective!
I listened to City of Bones by Michael Connelly, narrated by Peter Jay Fernandez, via OverDrive. All opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own personal opinions. Please refer to my Goodreads.com profile page or the 'about' page on sandysbookaday.wordpress.com for an explanation of my rating system. This review and others are also published on my blog sandysbookaday.wordpress.com https://sandysbookaday.wordpress.com/...
October 11, 2022
4.5/5 Estrellas
Qué decir de esta entrega. Tiene un poco de todo y muy bueno.
Perfecta en su relato de los procedimientos policiales. Estamos a principios de los años 2000. De forma totalmente casual se hallan los restos del esqueleto de un niño, que perece haber sufrido todo tipo de maltratos durante su corta vida. En estos años ya se ha generalizado el uso del móvil, y ya se estaban utilizando métodos genéticos como pruebas forenses para establecer relaciones de parentesco entre individuos o para identificarlos, cómo en el ataque terrorista a las Torres Gemelas. Me extraña que no se haga referencia a ello en el libro, quizá al tratarse de huesos, la extracción de ADN de este tipo de muestras, todavía no era viable. Al no contar con este tipo de análisis, el atar cabos, sobre todo cuando estamos hablando del hallazgo de restos que se remontan a más de 20 años atrás, se convierte en una obra de artesanía que el autor nos plasma con gran maestría.
Perfecta en su análisis de la naturaleza humana, los abusos infantiles, la culpa, la redención, la ambición, la crueldad, la búsqueda de tu lugar en el mundo.....el amor y el odio. Pequeños detalles, que dejan una huella profunda en el lector.
No he acabado de entender lo que sucedió con Julia, pero se intuye. Creo que es un punto clave de la trama y uno de esos pequeños detalles que nos permiten abundar en la psicología de los personajes, que no queda aclarado con limpieza.....entiendo que algo debe poner el lector de su parte.
Ciudad de huesos....¿cuántos huesos se encontrarán debajo del suelo que pisamos esperando que alguien desentrañe su historia? Mejor no pensarlo.
A por la siguiente.
Qué decir de esta entrega. Tiene un poco de todo y muy bueno.
Perfecta en su relato de los procedimientos policiales. Estamos a principios de los años 2000. De forma totalmente casual se hallan los restos del esqueleto de un niño, que perece haber sufrido todo tipo de maltratos durante su corta vida. En estos años ya se ha generalizado el uso del móvil, y ya se estaban utilizando métodos genéticos como pruebas forenses para establecer relaciones de parentesco entre individuos o para identificarlos, cómo en el ataque terrorista a las Torres Gemelas. Me extraña que no se haga referencia a ello en el libro, quizá al tratarse de huesos, la extracción de ADN de este tipo de muestras, todavía no era viable. Al no contar con este tipo de análisis, el atar cabos, sobre todo cuando estamos hablando del hallazgo de restos que se remontan a más de 20 años atrás, se convierte en una obra de artesanía que el autor nos plasma con gran maestría.
Perfecta en su análisis de la naturaleza humana, los abusos infantiles, la culpa, la redención, la ambición, la crueldad, la búsqueda de tu lugar en el mundo.....el amor y el odio. Pequeños detalles, que dejan una huella profunda en el lector.
No he acabado de entender lo que sucedió con Julia, pero se intuye. Creo que es un punto clave de la trama y uno de esos pequeños detalles que nos permiten abundar en la psicología de los personajes, que no queda aclarado con limpieza.....entiendo que algo debe poner el lector de su parte.
Ciudad de huesos....¿cuántos huesos se encontrarán debajo del suelo que pisamos esperando que alguien desentrañe su historia? Mejor no pensarlo.
A por la siguiente.
May 23, 2024
After the delight that “Angels Flight” was, I was eager to delve into Michael Connelly's "City of Bones", the eighth instalment in the Harry Bosch series. Although it did not quite live up to the intensely riveting and thrilling standards set by some of its predecessors, it still proved to be a very enjoyable read.
»The point is, this doctor says it was just a kid, Harry. So could you humor us and go check out this humerus?”«
From the onset, Connelly's writing style was as engaging as ever; as a result, the story was well-paced, providing a steady flow of intrigue and suspense that kept me turning the pages. However, I did find certain sections to be a bit lagging, lacking the heart-pounding intensity that I've come to expect from a Bosch novel.
»Bosch almost laughed.
“The department doesn’t care about it. The department cares about the image, not the truth. And when the truth endangers the image, then fuck the truth.”
“Well, I care, Harry. And so do you.”
Bosch looked down at the card and nodded and put it in his pocket.
“Okay, I’ll call you.”«
Harry remains a compelling character. Connelly continues to explore Bosch's complex personality, delving into his psychological makeup and personal life, which adds depth to the narrative. Bosch's unyielding determination and relentless pursuit of justice are admirable, making him a true master of his craft. However, I found his character development in this book to be somewhat stagnant compared to earlier instalments.
»Don’t go existential on me, Harry. The important thing is that it means something to you. And if it means something to you, then it is important to do what you can.«
The supporting characters were well-developed and added colour to the story. Connelly does a fantastic job of creating multi-dimensional characters that feel real and authentic. However, some of the secondary characters felt underutilised, and I would have liked to see them play a more significant role in the plot, e. g. Julia whose storyline felt unfinished…
»“By the way, I’m Julia Brasher. I’m new in the division.”
- “Harry Bosch.”
“I know. I’ve heard of you.”
- “I deny everything.”«
Ultimately, if you're a fan of the Harry Bosch series, this book is definitely worth a read. If you’re new to Bosch, consider “Angels Flight” instead.
Four stars out of five.
»“Somebody once told me that life was the pursuit of one thing. Redemption. The search for redemption.”
“For what?”
“For everything. Anything. We all want to be forgiven.”
Blog | Facebook | Twitter | Mastodon | Instagram | Pinterest | Medium | Matrix | Tumblr
Ceterum censeo Putin esse delendam
»The point is, this doctor says it was just a kid, Harry. So could you humor us and go check out this humerus?”«
From the onset, Connelly's writing style was as engaging as ever; as a result, the story was well-paced, providing a steady flow of intrigue and suspense that kept me turning the pages. However, I did find certain sections to be a bit lagging, lacking the heart-pounding intensity that I've come to expect from a Bosch novel.
»Bosch almost laughed.
“The department doesn’t care about it. The department cares about the image, not the truth. And when the truth endangers the image, then fuck the truth.”
“Well, I care, Harry. And so do you.”
Bosch looked down at the card and nodded and put it in his pocket.
“Okay, I’ll call you.”«
Harry remains a compelling character. Connelly continues to explore Bosch's complex personality, delving into his psychological makeup and personal life, which adds depth to the narrative. Bosch's unyielding determination and relentless pursuit of justice are admirable, making him a true master of his craft. However, I found his character development in this book to be somewhat stagnant compared to earlier instalments.
»Don’t go existential on me, Harry. The important thing is that it means something to you. And if it means something to you, then it is important to do what you can.«
The supporting characters were well-developed and added colour to the story. Connelly does a fantastic job of creating multi-dimensional characters that feel real and authentic. However, some of the secondary characters felt underutilised, and I would have liked to see them play a more significant role in the plot, e. g. Julia whose storyline felt unfinished…
»“By the way, I’m Julia Brasher. I’m new in the division.”
- “Harry Bosch.”
“I know. I’ve heard of you.”
- “I deny everything.”«
Ultimately, if you're a fan of the Harry Bosch series, this book is definitely worth a read. If you’re new to Bosch, consider “Angels Flight” instead.
Four stars out of five.
»“Somebody once told me that life was the pursuit of one thing. Redemption. The search for redemption.”
“For what?”
“For everything. Anything. We all want to be forgiven.”
Blog | Facebook | Twitter | Mastodon | Instagram | Pinterest | Medium | Matrix | Tumblr
Ceterum censeo Putin esse delendam
January 16, 2016
This is the eighth book in the Harry Bosch series and the one I liked the least so far. I still enjoyed it and found it a quick easy read but it lacked a certain something. I know I was uncomfortable in all the scenes involving Brasher who I found I could not like at all. Eventually I wondered why she had even been included and in fact whether the author felt the same way judging by events! There was a lot of description of police procedure which I enjoy but which can also drag a bit when there is too much. So for me not the most successful book in the series but still eminently readable!
December 1, 2015
Calamity (“he was trouble as a puppy”) was the one who changed the course of Detective Harry Bosch’s future and set a course for the following two weeks of dark memories and turbulent trouble. When Bosch was called to Wonderland in Los Angeles, he suspected the bone which had been unearthed would be the usual; a wild animal of some description. But when the almost complete skeleton of a young boy was brought to the surface; and learning the bones had been in the ground for twenty years, Bosch was determined to discover the identity of the bones, and bring the perpetrator to justice.
Bosch and his partner Detective Jerry Edgar dug deeply – unable to be spared for too long on such a cold case, they worked the clock around. And the secrets they began bringing to the surface chilled them both. Lives changed, circumstances changed – but the end result was always the same – murder. When tragedy struck, they kept going – it was imperative; personal to Bosch. Would he find the killer after so many years?
Wow! What a brilliant instalment in the Harry Bosch series - #8 – and it’s been on my TBR for over 4 years! Gripping, intense, with an extremely fast and chilling pace, City of Bones is (in my opinion) one of Michael Connelly’s best! A writer who is definitely at the top of his game, I can’t recommend this one highly enough.
Bosch and his partner Detective Jerry Edgar dug deeply – unable to be spared for too long on such a cold case, they worked the clock around. And the secrets they began bringing to the surface chilled them both. Lives changed, circumstances changed – but the end result was always the same – murder. When tragedy struck, they kept going – it was imperative; personal to Bosch. Would he find the killer after so many years?
Wow! What a brilliant instalment in the Harry Bosch series - #8 – and it’s been on my TBR for over 4 years! Gripping, intense, with an extremely fast and chilling pace, City of Bones is (in my opinion) one of Michael Connelly’s best! A writer who is definitely at the top of his game, I can’t recommend this one highly enough.
January 24, 2012
A great Bosch book that details many sub-stories within the one novel. Perhaps not stories as much as solutions to the case, in which Connelly has the reader (and Bosch) sure that the killer is Mr. X, only to find out that new evidence points to Ms. Y. It also touches on many powerful (and painful) themes, including missing children, abuse, foster care, and death on the job.
Connelly continues to build a strong emotional foundation for his best character, Harry Bosch, and examines the continually flickering romances that seem to cross his path while he works for the LAPD. A seemingly innocent bone discoverY leads to some fairly scary revelations; news he can share with his new belle, an LAPD rookie. As the case gets more complex, Bosch discovers nothing is as it seems and no answer is truly as simply as it appears on paper.
Much interesting news and happenings occur in the latter 25% of the book, so it is not one to skim, unless your attention to detail is high. I would highly recommend the book, but, of course, read the series in order to get the true feel of character development.
Where will you take us next, Michael Connelly? Tune in to see!
Connelly continues to build a strong emotional foundation for his best character, Harry Bosch, and examines the continually flickering romances that seem to cross his path while he works for the LAPD. A seemingly innocent bone discoverY leads to some fairly scary revelations; news he can share with his new belle, an LAPD rookie. As the case gets more complex, Bosch discovers nothing is as it seems and no answer is truly as simply as it appears on paper.
Much interesting news and happenings occur in the latter 25% of the book, so it is not one to skim, unless your attention to detail is high. I would highly recommend the book, but, of course, read the series in order to get the true feel of character development.
Where will you take us next, Michael Connelly? Tune in to see!
November 13, 2024
5★
“ ‘I’m serious. It’s also against regs. On my part. I’m a D-three. Supervisor level.’
She looked at him a moment. ‘Well, that’s your call, then. I’ll see you tonight. I hope.’”
Harry, Harry, Harry. You just can’t seem to resist tempting fate – or your bosses. She’s supposed to be off-limits, being subordinate to you. And you forgot to be discreet. You are already teetering on the edge with your superiors.
But I think Harry deserves some TLC, and other than being off-limits, new recruit Julia Brasher meets all his criteria. She may be a recruit, but she’s no kid straight out of school. She’s a smart, attractive woman who wants to change her life, so joined the police.
Harry tries to give her the real picture, the terrible crimes he’s seen and the desperate circumstances some people live in. There’s so little police can do.
“That true evil could never be taken out of the world. At best he was wading into the dark waters of the abyss with two leaking buckets in his hands.”
He also can’t resist taking everything personally. It seems that every victim seems to spark a memory. When the weathered bones of a young boy are found by a dog high on a wooded hill, he is immediately struck by the apparent abandonment of someone’s child.
“Child cases haunted you. They hollowed you out and scarred you. There was no bulletproof vest thick enough to stop you from being pierced. Child cases left you knowing the world was full of lost light.”
Harry has spoken before of lost light, what he calls the sensation of being able to see in absolute darkness, as the soldiers felt they did in deep tunnels in Vietnam. They had left real light far behind. He tries to explain to Julia.
“ ‘Lost light. We called it lost light. We never knew where it came from. But it was down there. Like smoke hanging in the dark. Some people said it wasn’t light, that it was the ghosts of everybody who died in those things. From both sides.’ ”
The stark difference in their lives is apparent when Julia talks about her travels around the world.
“ ‘When I was on the road. I spent six weeks in Vietnam. The tunnels, they’re like a tourist thing now.’”
The investigation is interesting, but it’s more than that to Bosch. Edgar notices. When the boy’s bones are identified, Bosch refers to the boy by name.
“ ‘Harry, you usually don’t refer to the vic by name.’
‘Yeah, so?’
‘Just pointing it out.’
‘Thank you. Anything else in the file?’”
It is easy to get caught up in both Bosch’s enthusiasm when he uncovers a lead and his dismay when it fizzles out. He’s trying to stop smoking, slow down drinking, but it’s hard when these cases grip him. (He does need some TLC.)
He’s not a conventional believer, and the ‘bone guy’, the forensic anthropologist, questions how Bosch can do this kind of work without the faith that is so important to this man.
“ ‘What is the question, Doc? Why do you care so much about me and what I believe or don’t believe?’
‘Because it is important to me. I study bones. The framework of life. And I have come to believe that there is something more than blood and tissue and bone. There is something else that holds us together. I have something inside, that you’ll never see on any X-ray, that holds me together and keeps me going. And so, when I meet someone who carries a void in the place where I carry my faith, I get scared for him.’
Bosch looked at him for a long moment.
‘You’re wrong about me. I have faith and I have a mission. Call it blue religion, call it whatever you like. It’s the belief that this won’t just go by. That those bones came out of the ground for a reason. That they came out of the ground for me to find, and for me to do something about. And that’s what holds me together and keeps me going. And it won’t show up on any X-ray either. Okay?’ ”
It's certainly okay with me.
I will add here that I recently saw the first season of the Bosch TV series. It was only when I recognised some of the plot from The Concrete Blonde (#3), that I looked up the details and discovered that it and City of Bones (#8) and Echo Park (#12) were combined.
I was sorry, figuring it would spoil this book for me since I already knew the storyline, but I wasn’t disappointed at all. In fact, there is a major departure from the book in the TV show, which caught me completely by surprise. Connelly’s writing and characters more than made up for the fact that I knew (or thought I knew), everything that was going to happen.
Another great read, and I will still read Echo Park one day.
Below are my reviews of the earlier Harry Bosch books.
(#1) My review of The Black Echo
(#2) My review of The Black Ice
(#3) My review of The Concrete Blonde
(#4) My review of The Last Coyote
(#5) My review of Trunk Music
(#6) My review of Angels Flight
(#7) My review of A Darkness More Than Night
“ ‘I’m serious. It’s also against regs. On my part. I’m a D-three. Supervisor level.’
She looked at him a moment. ‘Well, that’s your call, then. I’ll see you tonight. I hope.’”
Harry, Harry, Harry. You just can’t seem to resist tempting fate – or your bosses. She’s supposed to be off-limits, being subordinate to you. And you forgot to be discreet. You are already teetering on the edge with your superiors.
But I think Harry deserves some TLC, and other than being off-limits, new recruit Julia Brasher meets all his criteria. She may be a recruit, but she’s no kid straight out of school. She’s a smart, attractive woman who wants to change her life, so joined the police.
Harry tries to give her the real picture, the terrible crimes he’s seen and the desperate circumstances some people live in. There’s so little police can do.
“That true evil could never be taken out of the world. At best he was wading into the dark waters of the abyss with two leaking buckets in his hands.”
He also can’t resist taking everything personally. It seems that every victim seems to spark a memory. When the weathered bones of a young boy are found by a dog high on a wooded hill, he is immediately struck by the apparent abandonment of someone’s child.
“Child cases haunted you. They hollowed you out and scarred you. There was no bulletproof vest thick enough to stop you from being pierced. Child cases left you knowing the world was full of lost light.”
Harry has spoken before of lost light, what he calls the sensation of being able to see in absolute darkness, as the soldiers felt they did in deep tunnels in Vietnam. They had left real light far behind. He tries to explain to Julia.
“ ‘Lost light. We called it lost light. We never knew where it came from. But it was down there. Like smoke hanging in the dark. Some people said it wasn’t light, that it was the ghosts of everybody who died in those things. From both sides.’ ”
The stark difference in their lives is apparent when Julia talks about her travels around the world.
“ ‘When I was on the road. I spent six weeks in Vietnam. The tunnels, they’re like a tourist thing now.’”
The investigation is interesting, but it’s more than that to Bosch. Edgar notices. When the boy’s bones are identified, Bosch refers to the boy by name.
“ ‘Harry, you usually don’t refer to the vic by name.’
‘Yeah, so?’
‘Just pointing it out.’
‘Thank you. Anything else in the file?’”
It is easy to get caught up in both Bosch’s enthusiasm when he uncovers a lead and his dismay when it fizzles out. He’s trying to stop smoking, slow down drinking, but it’s hard when these cases grip him. (He does need some TLC.)
He’s not a conventional believer, and the ‘bone guy’, the forensic anthropologist, questions how Bosch can do this kind of work without the faith that is so important to this man.
“ ‘What is the question, Doc? Why do you care so much about me and what I believe or don’t believe?’
‘Because it is important to me. I study bones. The framework of life. And I have come to believe that there is something more than blood and tissue and bone. There is something else that holds us together. I have something inside, that you’ll never see on any X-ray, that holds me together and keeps me going. And so, when I meet someone who carries a void in the place where I carry my faith, I get scared for him.’
Bosch looked at him for a long moment.
‘You’re wrong about me. I have faith and I have a mission. Call it blue religion, call it whatever you like. It’s the belief that this won’t just go by. That those bones came out of the ground for a reason. That they came out of the ground for me to find, and for me to do something about. And that’s what holds me together and keeps me going. And it won’t show up on any X-ray either. Okay?’ ”
It's certainly okay with me.
I will add here that I recently saw the first season of the Bosch TV series. It was only when I recognised some of the plot from The Concrete Blonde (#3), that I looked up the details and discovered that it and City of Bones (#8) and Echo Park (#12) were combined.
I was sorry, figuring it would spoil this book for me since I already knew the storyline, but I wasn’t disappointed at all. In fact, there is a major departure from the book in the TV show, which caught me completely by surprise. Connelly’s writing and characters more than made up for the fact that I knew (or thought I knew), everything that was going to happen.
Another great read, and I will still read Echo Park one day.
Below are my reviews of the earlier Harry Bosch books.
(#1) My review of The Black Echo
(#2) My review of The Black Ice
(#3) My review of The Concrete Blonde
(#4) My review of The Last Coyote
(#5) My review of Trunk Music
(#6) My review of Angels Flight
(#7) My review of A Darkness More Than Night
December 4, 2018
I definitely enjoyed "City of Bones." I really enjoyed this look at what it was that caused Harry Bosch to retire from the LAPD. I'm sad to think about what could have been though when you see a more thoughtful and happy Harry in this one.
Bosch is still teamed up with J. Edgar in this one (book Edgar still sucks) and they get called in when a bone is found up in the hills. When it becomes clear they are looking at human remains, Bosch is thrown into a high profile case that the LAPD just wants closed and doesn't seem to care about the truth. But long time readers know that is all Harry cares about.
Besides the high pressure case, we also have Bosch undertaking another romance in this one that I liked. Connelly always seems reluctant to me in showing Bosch in a relationship. Even when he does show bits of it, he seems to skip over showing any type of romance. Instead it also seems to fade to black. When Bosch gets involved with a rookie cop named Julia Brasher, it felt like the first time in a while we had him connect with someone.
The writing was great and I couldn't put this book down. It was honestly hard to stop. I think that was mostly because I felt invested in finding out who was responsible for the death of the victim in this one, and there was so many other layers to peel back here.
The flow was top notch though the ending felt a but abrupt.
Bosch is still teamed up with J. Edgar in this one (book Edgar still sucks) and they get called in when a bone is found up in the hills. When it becomes clear they are looking at human remains, Bosch is thrown into a high profile case that the LAPD just wants closed and doesn't seem to care about the truth. But long time readers know that is all Harry cares about.
Besides the high pressure case, we also have Bosch undertaking another romance in this one that I liked. Connelly always seems reluctant to me in showing Bosch in a relationship. Even when he does show bits of it, he seems to skip over showing any type of romance. Instead it also seems to fade to black. When Bosch gets involved with a rookie cop named Julia Brasher, it felt like the first time in a while we had him connect with someone.
The writing was great and I couldn't put this book down. It was honestly hard to stop. I think that was mostly because I felt invested in finding out who was responsible for the death of the victim in this one, and there was so many other layers to peel back here.
The flow was top notch though the ending felt a but abrupt.
July 26, 2024
Тази криминална серия продължава да е все така силна, а Конъли е майстор в предаването на историите, които се налага да бъдат разплитани от Хари Бош и колегите му.
Точно след нова година, жълт лабрадор се е върнал при стопанина си - пенсиониран лекар, с част от детска кост между зъбите си.
Убитото хлапе е заровено отдавна в плитък гроб над Лоръл Кениън и очевидно не е липсвало на никой през изминалите години. Но Бош няма как да остави камък необърнат, защото престъпленията срещу деца са му особено противни.
Чете се леко и то въпреки чувствителната тематика. Ще ви допадне много!
Цитат:
"Престъпленията с деца те преследват. Дълбаят отвътре и оставят белези. Оставят те със съзнанието, че светът е пълен с изгубена светлина."
Точно след нова година, жълт лабрадор се е върнал при стопанина си - пенсиониран лекар, с част от детска кост между зъбите си.
Убитото хлапе е заровено отдавна в плитък гроб над Лоръл Кениън и очевидно не е липсвало на никой през изминалите години. Но Бош няма как да остави камък необърнат, защото престъпленията срещу деца са му особено противни.
Чете се леко и то въпреки чувствителната тематика. Ще ви допадне много!
Цитат:
"Престъпленията с деца те преследват. Дълбаят отвътре и оставят белези. Оставят те със съзнанието, че светът е пълен с изгубена светлина."
October 25, 2024
Keep 'em coming! I'm an addicted Harry Bosch fan!
CITY OF BONES, Michael Connelly's eighth entry in the spectacularly successful Harry Bosch series, works on two distinctly different but equally compelling levels.
First of all, CITY OF BONES is a pure police procedural. A dog, out for a walk with its owner, finds a bone in a wooded area off of Hollywood's Wonderland Drive. When the owner who happens to be a doctor recognizes that the bone is unquestionably a human humerus, the hunt is on for the identity of the 20 year old skeleton and the killer who buried it so many years ago.
Connelly covers it all - internal police politics; forensic science; dogged routine investigation; suspect interviews; budgetary constraints; publicity and media; legal subtleties from search warrant execution to the requirement to Mirandize suspects to potential issues relating to libel; the necessity for the police force to maintain an awareness of its own public image; and much, much more.
On a second level, long time fans will savour the continuation of the dark, complex, deeply psychological story of the life of Harry Bosch, the noir bad-boy who refuses to toe the LAPD policy line. Right alongside Harry, readers will allow themselves to ignore departmental fraternization policies and to fall in love with Julia Brasher, the mature rookie cop who, like Harry, totes a jam-packed set of personal psychological baggage. She sees herself as a potential hero who wants to achieve something of lasting importance in the world, no matter the cost.
There is nothing of the high speed suspense thriller in CITY OF BONES. But it is a deeply satisfying novel that ends with a breathtaking twist that, while not particularly surprising given Bosch's personality, will definitely have fans looking for the next novel to see where things are headed.
Highly recommended.
Paul Weiss
CITY OF BONES, Michael Connelly's eighth entry in the spectacularly successful Harry Bosch series, works on two distinctly different but equally compelling levels.
First of all, CITY OF BONES is a pure police procedural. A dog, out for a walk with its owner, finds a bone in a wooded area off of Hollywood's Wonderland Drive. When the owner who happens to be a doctor recognizes that the bone is unquestionably a human humerus, the hunt is on for the identity of the 20 year old skeleton and the killer who buried it so many years ago.
Connelly covers it all - internal police politics; forensic science; dogged routine investigation; suspect interviews; budgetary constraints; publicity and media; legal subtleties from search warrant execution to the requirement to Mirandize suspects to potential issues relating to libel; the necessity for the police force to maintain an awareness of its own public image; and much, much more.
On a second level, long time fans will savour the continuation of the dark, complex, deeply psychological story of the life of Harry Bosch, the noir bad-boy who refuses to toe the LAPD policy line. Right alongside Harry, readers will allow themselves to ignore departmental fraternization policies and to fall in love with Julia Brasher, the mature rookie cop who, like Harry, totes a jam-packed set of personal psychological baggage. She sees herself as a potential hero who wants to achieve something of lasting importance in the world, no matter the cost.
There is nothing of the high speed suspense thriller in CITY OF BONES. But it is a deeply satisfying novel that ends with a breathtaking twist that, while not particularly surprising given Bosch's personality, will definitely have fans looking for the next novel to see where things are headed.
Highly recommended.
Paul Weiss
September 24, 2016
I have such mixed feelings about this story.
Harry Bosch and partner Jerry Edgar respond to a call about a bone found by a doctor's dog. He's certain it's human and he turns out to be right, prompting the start of what ends up being a very cold case.
I loved the forensics aspect of the story, along with the procedurals. Nobody does it better than Harry and I enjoy his investigative style. There are other personal situations that impact the investigation and Harry's career that I found troubling. The ending left me in a weird space but if I'm honest, it was true to the character.
Another new narrator that just didn't come close to capturing Harry. Hopefully, the next one will come closer. I probably just need to let Dick Hill go:) Even with some of my issues, it's still a really good story.
Harry Bosch and partner Jerry Edgar respond to a call about a bone found by a doctor's dog. He's certain it's human and he turns out to be right, prompting the start of what ends up being a very cold case.
I loved the forensics aspect of the story, along with the procedurals. Nobody does it better than Harry and I enjoy his investigative style. There are other personal situations that impact the investigation and Harry's career that I found troubling. The ending left me in a weird space but if I'm honest, it was true to the character.
Another new narrator that just didn't come close to capturing Harry. Hopefully, the next one will come closer. I probably just need to let Dick Hill go:) Even with some of my issues, it's still a really good story.
September 7, 2023
Ciudad de huesos
Novela número ocho en la serie de Harry Bosch donde tendrá que acudir a una colina donde se han encontrado huesos humanos. Todo hace indicar que se trataba de un joven de corta edad al que asesinaron dos décadas atrás.
De nuevo otra historia impecable de Connelly que maneja el ritmo y sus personajes a su antojo para mantener el interés durante toda la novela.
De paso aprendemos como se puede saber lo que pasó hace miles de años al encontrar huesos en pozas de alquitrán con signos de violencia. El mal siempre ha estado entre nosotros.
Novela número ocho en la serie de Harry Bosch donde tendrá que acudir a una colina donde se han encontrado huesos humanos. Todo hace indicar que se trataba de un joven de corta edad al que asesinaron dos décadas atrás.
De nuevo otra historia impecable de Connelly que maneja el ritmo y sus personajes a su antojo para mantener el interés durante toda la novela.
De paso aprendemos como se puede saber lo que pasó hace miles de años al encontrar huesos en pozas de alquitrán con signos de violencia. El mal siempre ha estado entre nosotros.
January 13, 2025
The title of Michael Connelly’s eighth book to feature his hero-detective Harry Bosch, “City of Bones”, refers to a term used by crime scene investigators to describe the sight of an old crime scene, where the body has deteriorated down to the bones. Oftentimes nature will scatter bones throughout a general area, especially if the grave is a shallow one, and the resultant grid that CSI forms is dubbed a “city of bones”.
The title has another, more metaphorical, meaning, as well. It refers to the fact that, like bones in a shallow grave, everyone has a secret story to tell. Everyone has skeletons in the closet.
When a dog brings his owner a human bone back from the Hollywood Hills, Detective Bosch is called to the scene. It’s New Year’s Day. Bosch isn’t expecting much. He doesn’t even think the bone is human, but he is required to check anyway.
Unfortunately, Bosch finds the rest of the body. It is that of a child. It’s been in the ground for roughly 20 years.
The case affects Bosch emotionally, for reasons that he can’t even explain. It brings back memories of his childhood as an orphan, shuffled through foster homes. It forces him to remember how lonely and depressed he was as a child and how those feelings haven’t really gone too far.
The case also quickly becomes a media-driven spectacle.
When news of the case leaks to the press, it results in the suicide of a potential suspect, a man whose horrible secrets---while having nothing to do with the present case---have inadvertently come back to haunt him.
Now Internal Affairs is breathing down Bosch’s neck. They think he either purposely leaked info or accidentally let the info get to the press. In either case, it’s a total fuck-up and a serious impediment to the case.
On top of all this, Bosch has begun dating a rookie cop. Besides being a violation of departmental regulations (Bosch is, after all, a senior officer), it also may be interfering with the case. He also suspects that she is hiding something pretty bad from her own past, something that has repercussions on her present state of mind.
Everyone involved in the case seems to have some secret from the past that haunts him or her. Skeletons are pouring out of closets.
For once, Bosch isn’t the only one dealing with a turbulent past.
As always, Connelly creates a gripping and emotional story. His police procedural is, as always, fascinating and probably more in-depth and realistic than any episode of CSI or Law & Order. It’s the human element, though, that truly breathes life in to this “city of bones”.
The title has another, more metaphorical, meaning, as well. It refers to the fact that, like bones in a shallow grave, everyone has a secret story to tell. Everyone has skeletons in the closet.
When a dog brings his owner a human bone back from the Hollywood Hills, Detective Bosch is called to the scene. It’s New Year’s Day. Bosch isn’t expecting much. He doesn’t even think the bone is human, but he is required to check anyway.
Unfortunately, Bosch finds the rest of the body. It is that of a child. It’s been in the ground for roughly 20 years.
The case affects Bosch emotionally, for reasons that he can’t even explain. It brings back memories of his childhood as an orphan, shuffled through foster homes. It forces him to remember how lonely and depressed he was as a child and how those feelings haven’t really gone too far.
The case also quickly becomes a media-driven spectacle.
When news of the case leaks to the press, it results in the suicide of a potential suspect, a man whose horrible secrets---while having nothing to do with the present case---have inadvertently come back to haunt him.
Now Internal Affairs is breathing down Bosch’s neck. They think he either purposely leaked info or accidentally let the info get to the press. In either case, it’s a total fuck-up and a serious impediment to the case.
On top of all this, Bosch has begun dating a rookie cop. Besides being a violation of departmental regulations (Bosch is, after all, a senior officer), it also may be interfering with the case. He also suspects that she is hiding something pretty bad from her own past, something that has repercussions on her present state of mind.
Everyone involved in the case seems to have some secret from the past that haunts him or her. Skeletons are pouring out of closets.
For once, Bosch isn’t the only one dealing with a turbulent past.
As always, Connelly creates a gripping and emotional story. His police procedural is, as always, fascinating and probably more in-depth and realistic than any episode of CSI or Law & Order. It’s the human element, though, that truly breathes life in to this “city of bones”.
July 1, 2017
Good series! crime thriller and a murder mystery in the plot...nice action and many tense moments but in the end it's still a really good series M.Connelly keep writing (paperback!)
August 12, 2022
An ok read. On the whole I enjoyed it but it didn't blow me away.
Two stars.
Two stars.
November 28, 2023
An excellent police procedural with great writing. Here are my favorite quotes:
"He guessed that her life in Palm Springs was built squarely atop her secrets and that she wouldn't want anyone going down into the basement."
"All I can say is that this better not put hair on the cake, Harry."
"He guessed that her life in Palm Springs was built squarely atop her secrets and that she wouldn't want anyone going down into the basement."
"All I can say is that this better not put hair on the cake, Harry."
December 5, 2018
Hallelujah. After the last volume in this series being such a disappointing cluster, I was a little concerned that it might be impossible to come back from such a mess, but I need not have worried. With Terry McCaleb out of the way, Bosch was more than ready to get back to business as usual.
This storyline is one that was featured in the show (it's all out of order, don't worry about crossover ruination - even having seen it, I wasn't spoiled on the story) and it reads, thankfully, just as easy as watching it, but with the added benefit of being somewhat in Harry's thought process.
Really great being back in the saddle with Harry again. I really love his passion for the work and for wanting to right wrongs and make a difference. I like that he isn't just looking to fit any old piece into the puzzle... it has to be the RIGHT piece.
It was also nice to see Jerry stepping up a bit more in this story. Often, it seems like Harry carries the case and the weight on his own, and just delegates tasks to Jerry. But in this one, Jerry was handling interviews (though not always tactfully or appropriately), putting together evidence, and running down stuff on his own. It was almost like he was a cop too, not an assistant to one. And he wonders why he's always passed over for promotions. *sideeye*
There was a love interest subplot, though thankfully it was short lived. She wouldn't have been good for him, which I think he knows, but whatever.
Finally, there was a crazy spur of the moment decision made at the end of this book, and I'm really not sure where the series will go from here because of it. It seems that Harry always finds a new bridge to burn that freaks me out... but even so, a new barge appears for him to use so he's maybe a bit inconvenienced or slowed down, but not unable to get where he wants to go. Weird analogy.
Anywho! Back on track with this book, and looking forward to the next one! :)
This storyline is one that was featured in the show (it's all out of order, don't worry about crossover ruination - even having seen it, I wasn't spoiled on the story) and it reads, thankfully, just as easy as watching it, but with the added benefit of being somewhat in Harry's thought process.
Really great being back in the saddle with Harry again. I really love his passion for the work and for wanting to right wrongs and make a difference. I like that he isn't just looking to fit any old piece into the puzzle... it has to be the RIGHT piece.
It was also nice to see Jerry stepping up a bit more in this story. Often, it seems like Harry carries the case and the weight on his own, and just delegates tasks to Jerry. But in this one, Jerry was handling interviews (though not always tactfully or appropriately), putting together evidence, and running down stuff on his own. It was almost like he was a cop too, not an assistant to one. And he wonders why he's always passed over for promotions. *sideeye*
There was a love interest subplot, though thankfully it was short lived. She wouldn't have been good for him, which I think he knows, but whatever.
Finally, there was a crazy spur of the moment decision made at the end of this book, and I'm really not sure where the series will go from here because of it. It seems that Harry always finds a new bridge to burn that freaks me out... but even so, a new barge appears for him to use so he's maybe a bit inconvenienced or slowed down, but not unable to get where he wants to go. Weird analogy.
Anywho! Back on track with this book, and looking forward to the next one! :)
January 17, 2018
After a few disappointing reads over the last few days I couldn’t wait to jump back into the Harry Bosch series. Having only recently read Michael Connelly for the first time, he has quickly became one of my favourite authors and I can’t think of an author in this genre who writes better crime fiction than this. The realism just oozes off the page and I can’t get enough of these books.
Once again Connelly has written a truly gripping and engrossing tale with so many strands running off it across the whole of Los Angeles. Bosch is the kind of police officer you hope exists in the real world. Somewhere amongst all the political bullshit that goes on, there’s got to be officers like him out there. The politics in policing in crime fiction has always made me feel quite sick and it definitely did here when Bosch’s superiors once again make some shocking decisions.
In terms of Bosch’s personal life there’s some huge developments here and I was gobsmacked at some of the things that happened to him whilst reading this book (although not the cliffhanger as I stupidly knew that was coming). Connelly’s writing has real emotion within it and you really get inside Bosch’s head in this story, learning his thought processes and what makes him tick. He’s just an endlessly fascinating character and I can’t wait to continue his story.
There can’t be many people left who haven’t discovered the sheer brilliance of Connelly and Bosch for themselves but if there is, then I cannot recommend these books more highly.
Once again Connelly has written a truly gripping and engrossing tale with so many strands running off it across the whole of Los Angeles. Bosch is the kind of police officer you hope exists in the real world. Somewhere amongst all the political bullshit that goes on, there’s got to be officers like him out there. The politics in policing in crime fiction has always made me feel quite sick and it definitely did here when Bosch’s superiors once again make some shocking decisions.
In terms of Bosch’s personal life there’s some huge developments here and I was gobsmacked at some of the things that happened to him whilst reading this book (although not the cliffhanger as I stupidly knew that was coming). Connelly’s writing has real emotion within it and you really get inside Bosch’s head in this story, learning his thought processes and what makes him tick. He’s just an endlessly fascinating character and I can’t wait to continue his story.
There can’t be many people left who haven’t discovered the sheer brilliance of Connelly and Bosch for themselves but if there is, then I cannot recommend these books more highly.
April 15, 2008
A South African mystery writer recently said this was the best crime book ever written. I have no way of verifying that, but it was very, very good. This novel seems to come in the middle of Michael Connelly's series featuring Los Angeles detective Harry Bosch. The title derives from the discovery at the outset of a set of boy's bones on a wooded hillside above a residential street, and the case resonates strongly with Bosch because of his own troubled childhood.
Through the twists and turns that follow, three more people will die and what looked like an unsolvable mystery, then like an open-and-shut case, finally goes through an end-of-the-book reversal that pulls it all together, without straining a reader's credulity. There are a few standard mystery tropisms, but also some very nice touches, particularly the obligation that Harry lays upon the dead boy's mother at the end of the novel.
I've promised myself no spoilers, so you'll have to see for yourself. As with all good crime-solving heroes, Harry Bosch has a stubborness about him that makes him a top detective, but also makes it difficult for others to work with him, even when he's trying to treat them well. And without overdoing the scenic descriptions in the least, Connelly manages to convey a good sense of the sprawl, diversity, meanness, traffic and rootlessness of Los Angeles, and particularly of Hollywood.
Through the twists and turns that follow, three more people will die and what looked like an unsolvable mystery, then like an open-and-shut case, finally goes through an end-of-the-book reversal that pulls it all together, without straining a reader's credulity. There are a few standard mystery tropisms, but also some very nice touches, particularly the obligation that Harry lays upon the dead boy's mother at the end of the novel.
I've promised myself no spoilers, so you'll have to see for yourself. As with all good crime-solving heroes, Harry Bosch has a stubborness about him that makes him a top detective, but also makes it difficult for others to work with him, even when he's trying to treat them well. And without overdoing the scenic descriptions in the least, Connelly manages to convey a good sense of the sprawl, diversity, meanness, traffic and rootlessness of Los Angeles, and particularly of Hollywood.
October 10, 2018
A solid mystery featuring my favorite lone wolf, Harry Bosch. Unfortunately it dragged for me, but not because of anything Connelly did or didn’t do, but because most of this book was well-covered in the third season of the Amazon series.
Because TV manages to change up even the best of storylines, there were a few surprises. Most notable the ending.
I didn’t see that coming but no doubt Bosch will find new ways to annoy the LAPD leadership.
Because TV manages to change up even the best of storylines, there were a few surprises. Most notable the ending.
I didn’t see that coming but no doubt Bosch will find new ways to annoy the LAPD leadership.
July 9, 2023
4 Stars for City of Bones: Harry Bosch, Book 8 (audiobook) by Michael Connelly read by Len Cariou.
This is the first book in this series for me. I enjoyed it enough that I’m going to start at the beginning and see how Harry got his start.
Harry Bosch is an interesting detective. He definitely had to use his hard upbringing to give him some insight into the foster care system. After several tries he got to the bottom of what happened in this cold case.
This is the first book in this series for me. I enjoyed it enough that I’m going to start at the beginning and see how Harry got his start.
Harry Bosch is an interesting detective. He definitely had to use his hard upbringing to give him some insight into the foster care system. After several tries he got to the bottom of what happened in this cold case.
January 8, 2023
A dog finds a bone that turns out to be from the shallow grave of a twelve-year-old boy, buried twenty years ago. The drunk Dad lives in a trailer park, after Mom left when he and his sister were two and four. More evidence reveals physical abuse. The kid had been in the same youth home as Bosch had lived, firing his desire to take the case. And he has a new love, a rookie cop.
They have a solid suspect, and approach him; then things go very very wrong. This is a solid and much awarded entry to the series, a basic police procedural with mopey Hieronymous (rhymes with anonymous, we are reminded regularly) Bosch, who gets in trouble for being a rogue outsider, breaking the rules, mostly standard-issue stuff. I'd rate it, for this series, 3.5, a kind of average entry for Connelly, but then he is also basically the bar-setter for this kind of story, so the bar's pretty high, better than most books of this kind for sure. We're wrong more than once about whodunnit, and then we have that terrific last chapter, so ethically and emotionally complicated. Some writers just don't know how to finish stories; Connelly really does.
I like how in the nasty underworld of LA crime, Connelly creates a good balance of admitting there are those in the LAPD who are corrupt and self-serving (how to we play the media, sweep it under the carpet so the public sees the cops as admirable) and those like Harry who really do care about justice, who are hindered by the system because of the bad guys in the system (OJ and Rodney King are regularly referenced).
Connelly says the story was inspired by the discovery of the bones of woman buried in the La Brea Tar Pits more than ten thousand years ago. City of bones! Including the bones of those who Harry has loved. Harry keeps a collection of empty shells from all the dead cops he's known killed in the act of duty. It's got a lot of shells in it.
They have a solid suspect, and approach him; then things go very very wrong. This is a solid and much awarded entry to the series, a basic police procedural with mopey Hieronymous (rhymes with anonymous, we are reminded regularly) Bosch, who gets in trouble for being a rogue outsider, breaking the rules, mostly standard-issue stuff. I'd rate it, for this series, 3.5, a kind of average entry for Connelly, but then he is also basically the bar-setter for this kind of story, so the bar's pretty high, better than most books of this kind for sure. We're wrong more than once about whodunnit, and then we have that terrific last chapter, so ethically and emotionally complicated. Some writers just don't know how to finish stories; Connelly really does.
I like how in the nasty underworld of LA crime, Connelly creates a good balance of admitting there are those in the LAPD who are corrupt and self-serving (how to we play the media, sweep it under the carpet so the public sees the cops as admirable) and those like Harry who really do care about justice, who are hindered by the system because of the bad guys in the system (OJ and Rodney King are regularly referenced).
Connelly says the story was inspired by the discovery of the bones of woman buried in the La Brea Tar Pits more than ten thousand years ago. City of bones! Including the bones of those who Harry has loved. Harry keeps a collection of empty shells from all the dead cops he's known killed in the act of duty. It's got a lot of shells in it.
December 14, 2015
Harry Bosch has one of his most puzzling cases yet. The skeleton of a 12 year old boy has been found in a shallow grave on a hillside. Not only must Harry find the identity of this boy murdered 20-30 years ago but he must also find the killer. Harry follows a few false leads as he tries to match the evidence from what he knows of the boys life and his friends and family and it comes to look as if it may remain a cold case. Harry also has some serious thinking to do about his future and where he might be heading.
This is one of the best Harry Bosch cases I have read to date. Highly recommended!
This is one of the best Harry Bosch cases I have read to date. Highly recommended!
December 30, 2018
The eighth book in the Harry Bosch series opens on New Year's Day with a dog returning to his owner with a bone. The owner, a retired doctor, realizes the bone is human and calls the police. Harry is working the holiday and gets the call. When Harry arrives on the scene he climbs the hill where the dog had been playing and discovers the bones of a child that had been buried in a shallow grave twenty years ago. Forensics show that the child had been abused repeatedly. It is a cold case. It is the start of a new year and this case will cost a lot. It will be difficult, if even possible, to learn the truth. The brass in the LAPD would like to close it ... soon. Just close it. For Harry it becomes personal, stirring up memories of his own childhood. He cannot let it go. One is worried about image and budget. One is looking for the truth and justice for a child.
Harry also meets, and develops a relationship with, a rookie cop. A violation of LAPD policy. It doesn't take long for rumors to start. Some just wink and smile and make a comment. Some urge Harry to be careful. For others, especially Deputy Chief Irvin Irving, it is just another reason to want Harry gone. With Harry there is always conflict with the brass who seem more interested in protecting the department's image.
The abuse and the death may have occurred twenty years ago but now that the bones have been unearthed there will be other victims. This is about a child who was abused and killed. What had been secrets, like the bones, will brought out into the light of day. Sometimes there are innocent victims.
Of course I like Harry Bosch but part of what makes this series great is the supporting characters you meet along the way. Some you like, like the retired doctor whose dog found the bone, and others you dislike, like Irvin Irving. This particular entry in the series ended with a terrific cliff hanger that leaves the reader wondering what is next for Harry?
Harry also meets, and develops a relationship with, a rookie cop. A violation of LAPD policy. It doesn't take long for rumors to start. Some just wink and smile and make a comment. Some urge Harry to be careful. For others, especially Deputy Chief Irvin Irving, it is just another reason to want Harry gone. With Harry there is always conflict with the brass who seem more interested in protecting the department's image.
The abuse and the death may have occurred twenty years ago but now that the bones have been unearthed there will be other victims. This is about a child who was abused and killed. What had been secrets, like the bones, will brought out into the light of day. Sometimes there are innocent victims.
Of course I like Harry Bosch but part of what makes this series great is the supporting characters you meet along the way. Some you like, like the retired doctor whose dog found the bone, and others you dislike, like Irvin Irving. This particular entry in the series ended with a terrific cliff hanger that leaves the reader wondering what is next for Harry?
January 7, 2021
Cuatro estrellas.
Octava entrega de la saga sobre Harry Bosch. Un libro entretenido y ligero. Se lee muy rápido, pues la investigación y la acción no decaen en ningún momento. Como todas las entregas anteriores, y como viene siendo la tónica en los libros de Michael Connelly, la intriga se mantiene hasta las últimas páginas del libro.
La jerga policial así como la de la judicial es algo que Michael Connelly maneja a la perfección. Su personaje, Harry Bosch, incluso después de tantos libros, mantiene su humanidad y sigue siendo muy creíble.
En este caso concreto, Harry Bosch investigará unos huesos antiguos desenterrados por un perro en una colina junto a una urbanización tranquila donde nunca había pasado nada. Poco más se puede decir para no destripar el libro.
Muy recomendable para los que les gusta las novelas policíacas.
Octava entrega de la saga sobre Harry Bosch. Un libro entretenido y ligero. Se lee muy rápido, pues la investigación y la acción no decaen en ningún momento. Como todas las entregas anteriores, y como viene siendo la tónica en los libros de Michael Connelly, la intriga se mantiene hasta las últimas páginas del libro.
La jerga policial así como la de la judicial es algo que Michael Connelly maneja a la perfección. Su personaje, Harry Bosch, incluso después de tantos libros, mantiene su humanidad y sigue siendo muy creíble.
En este caso concreto, Harry Bosch investigará unos huesos antiguos desenterrados por un perro en una colina junto a una urbanización tranquila donde nunca había pasado nada. Poco más se puede decir para no destripar el libro.
Muy recomendable para los que les gusta las novelas policíacas.
January 24, 2023
3.5 stars
February 1, 2023
“The solution is not to bend things to fit our needs. This is a homicide case.”
“I know that, Harry.”
First published in 2002, City of Bones is the eighth in the long-running series featuring LA detective Harry Bosch. Harry is attached to Hollywood Division with partner of 10 years, Jerry Edgar, under Lt Grace Billet. Kiz Rider was promoted to Robbery-Homicide Division less than a year earlier, and Asst. Chief Irvin Irving, a political animal, is more committed to the preserving the image of the police and his own reputation, and he and Bosch have had a long-standing run-in.
The title stems from a play on words: those used by the ME’s office to describe the grid system used by crime scene investigators to locate, unearth, and photograph artefacts/ remains in situ prior to transporting them to a lab for forensics, and also a term for LA itself, built on ancient La Brea tar pits, where bones, both human and animal have remained buried for thousands of years, occasionally rising to the surface.
The case opens with a bone retrieved by a dog, Calamity, at Laurel Canyon, taking it to his owner, a retired doctor who recognises it as a human humerus, possibly that of a child. Called to the scene, Bosch meets the attending uniforms, and is mutually attracted to rookie Julia Brasher. Within days the ME’s office retrieves almost half a skeleton from a shallow grave, some bones uprooted and dispersed by animals, high on a trail above nearby houses, with the media swarming for details.
Forensics points to the bones being buried almost twenty years earlier, some showing fractures, as if a victim of sustained abuse, and the investigation turns to who the body is, and who lived in the nearby street at that time.
With the victim so young, the Police try to keep a lid on it, but news of a potential suspect is leaked to the media, compromising the investigation, with tragic results. Amid the blame game, Harry’s budding relationship with Julia Brasher has tongues wagging, and identifying the body takes second stage to office politics. Thus the book drifts for a while, with Bosch still methodically checking out possible witnesses and family members.
To this reader it seems a peculiarly (though not exclusively) American thing of partnering of uniforms and detectives. Add to that Navy Seal “buddies” and Mormons travelling the world in pairs - perhaps a throwback to the days of the stagecoach with a driver and someone riding shotgun. And while a partner adds strength, it can also lead to challenges if the partners don’t always see eye-to-eye. Another avoidable death, the police covering for their own, and Harry Bosch considers his future.
This was one of the better earlier ones in the series, but I probably would have appreciated it more had I read it a decade ago, and more emphasis on forensics and less on personalities.
“I know that, Harry.”
First published in 2002, City of Bones is the eighth in the long-running series featuring LA detective Harry Bosch. Harry is attached to Hollywood Division with partner of 10 years, Jerry Edgar, under Lt Grace Billet. Kiz Rider was promoted to Robbery-Homicide Division less than a year earlier, and Asst. Chief Irvin Irving, a political animal, is more committed to the preserving the image of the police and his own reputation, and he and Bosch have had a long-standing run-in.
The title stems from a play on words: those used by the ME’s office to describe the grid system used by crime scene investigators to locate, unearth, and photograph artefacts/ remains in situ prior to transporting them to a lab for forensics, and also a term for LA itself, built on ancient La Brea tar pits, where bones, both human and animal have remained buried for thousands of years, occasionally rising to the surface.
The case opens with a bone retrieved by a dog, Calamity, at Laurel Canyon, taking it to his owner, a retired doctor who recognises it as a human humerus, possibly that of a child. Called to the scene, Bosch meets the attending uniforms, and is mutually attracted to rookie Julia Brasher. Within days the ME’s office retrieves almost half a skeleton from a shallow grave, some bones uprooted and dispersed by animals, high on a trail above nearby houses, with the media swarming for details.
Forensics points to the bones being buried almost twenty years earlier, some showing fractures, as if a victim of sustained abuse, and the investigation turns to who the body is, and who lived in the nearby street at that time.
With the victim so young, the Police try to keep a lid on it, but news of a potential suspect is leaked to the media, compromising the investigation, with tragic results. Amid the blame game, Harry’s budding relationship with Julia Brasher has tongues wagging, and identifying the body takes second stage to office politics. Thus the book drifts for a while, with Bosch still methodically checking out possible witnesses and family members.
To this reader it seems a peculiarly (though not exclusively) American thing of partnering of uniforms and detectives. Add to that Navy Seal “buddies” and Mormons travelling the world in pairs - perhaps a throwback to the days of the stagecoach with a driver and someone riding shotgun. And while a partner adds strength, it can also lead to challenges if the partners don’t always see eye-to-eye. Another avoidable death, the police covering for their own, and Harry Bosch considers his future.
This was one of the better earlier ones in the series, but I probably would have appreciated it more had I read it a decade ago, and more emphasis on forensics and less on personalities.
September 8, 2022
Detective Harry Bosch Returns with a difficult “track” of bones to find & uncover a murder trail.
Dr. Paul Guyot MD, called to report his dog found “an arm bone of a kid” on a steep hill behind his home. His dog helps Bosch find more bones scattered under dirt, including a child’s hand. This is near a Hollywood street named Wonderland.
After seeing a TV news report, Shelia Delacroix called to say 20+ years ago, she lived near Wonderland & her brother, Arthur(12) had disappeared after being hospitalized with “head injuries” from skateboarding with his best friend, Johnny Stokes(13).
This helped them get the case started finding a 1980 police report with a boy’s hospital medical record for “head injuries” to confirm it was Arthur.
1. Don Blaylock - Set Director runs a foster home & has the skateboard with Arthur’s initials?
2. Nicholas Trent - neighbor, punished molesting a 9 year old boy in 1966?
3. Johnny Stokes - his best friend growing up mostly in & out of foster homes?
4. Samuel Delacroix (dad) - confesses but why prove him innocent?
I found the death/killer of Alex Delacroix is a.....nice surprise on what happened, what was he doing & it was well written.
Dr. Paul Guyot MD, called to report his dog found “an arm bone of a kid” on a steep hill behind his home. His dog helps Bosch find more bones scattered under dirt, including a child’s hand. This is near a Hollywood street named Wonderland.
After seeing a TV news report, Shelia Delacroix called to say 20+ years ago, she lived near Wonderland & her brother, Arthur(12) had disappeared after being hospitalized with “head injuries” from skateboarding with his best friend, Johnny Stokes(13).
This helped them get the case started finding a 1980 police report with a boy’s hospital medical record for “head injuries” to confirm it was Arthur.
Bosch searches for suspects...
Titus Welliver as Harry Bosch
1. Don Blaylock - Set Director runs a foster home & has the skateboard with Arthur’s initials?
2. Nicholas Trent - neighbor, punished molesting a 9 year old boy in 1966?
3. Johnny Stokes - his best friend growing up mostly in & out of foster homes?
4. Samuel Delacroix (dad) - confesses but why prove him innocent?
I found the death/killer of Alex Delacroix is a.....nice surprise on what happened, what was he doing & it was well written.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 2,646 reviews