I wish I could give a better rating to this book, but I just can't. It could have been so much better.
I love history, geography, and stamp collecting, so I thought I would love this book. I didn't. This book suffers from several problems.
One problem is probably due to the sheer scope: I believe I counted seventy-six chapters (some dealing with multiple stamp-issuing entities) crammed into roughly 250 pages. Nearly all of the chapters are only two or three pages long. With so much territory to cover, and so few pages to do it in, very little of interest can imparted to the reader. Unfortunately, most of what is told is simply a brief, dry listing of what wars the country has been involved in from the middle ages on. Royalty, the nobility, and generals occasionally show up - but the actual inhabitants of the country never do. Neither does their culture or anything not of a militaristic nature. A number of colonies are listed in this book, but most of the time we are never told what is being extracted and exported, simply who invaded. Almost all of the military history could have been summed up as "Then (*) happened. So, anyway...". (*Insert any war from the middle ages to the present).
Another problem is how little anything remotely philatelic is discussed. The chapter on Thurn und Taxis does mention the postal service, but that's because the Thurn und Taxis family was the postal service. We aren't told how many people are using or interacting with a particular service nor are we shown many stamps. Out of more than 70 countries, only 28 are depicted in color photos. The rest are given a one or two sentence description in the text.
Still another problem was the uneven writing. Part of this may have been due to the fact that there are two authors. Some chapters were very casual, even flippant in tone while others were written in a more normal manner. I don't mind casual, humorous writing, but I do mind paying nearly twenty dollars for a book that contains entries that wouldn't make it into a Cracked "listicle". (I love Cracked sometimes, but still). I do appreciate British humor, but none of the references were funny. Some chapters read like a kid trying to pad out the word count in a school paper.
I did enjoy some of the chapters, although one of the chapters I enjoyed most, Sedang, is only about three-and-a half pages long. Half the chapter isn't even about Sedang, instead it discusses "Cinderella" stamps which aren't actually postage stamps.
All of the countries are listed alphabetically (to imitate a stamp album?) but really ought to have been grouped by geographical area. This would have prevented multiple chapters rehashing the same war or political situation again and again, or chapters referencing something that happened literally dozens of chapters ago.
I really can't figure out who this book is for. Neither serious or casual collectors or history buffs will find much of interest here. Its not written for children either. This book might have been better in the pre-internet age.
The dust-jacket for this book is great. The cover and its tagline (Exotic Tales From An Old Stamp Album) is what convinced me to buy this book. I wish it had lived up to its cover. It contains only one "Exotic Tale" and I already knew about it: that time Alexander of Greece was bitten by a monkey and died. While that is both a great and terrible fact, I really expected more of interest in the book. How can such material (countries & colonies, wars & revolutions, knights & pirates) be so, so dry?