Book Review | Mine: Essays by Sarah Viren.
University of New Mexico Press, 2018.
Paperback, 167 pages.
Reviewed by Christine Newton Bush.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
In Daemon Voices (Knopf, 2018), a collection of essays about stories and storytelling, Philip Pullman addresses a writer’s responsibility to be emotionally honest. “We should never try to draw on emotional credit to which our story is not entitled. . . .Stories should earn their own tears and not pilfer them from elsewhere.” Sarah Viren’s Mine is a collection of fourteen essays that draws from the author’s own ledger of experience and yields its riches in intimate, often poignant, prose that evoke heartache and wonder. Viren fearlessly interrogates her life with honesty and verve in an exploration of the joys and risks of believing that we can or should claim something as our own and the corresponding sense of loss when we are mistaken.
Mine discloses selfhood by examining different aspects of its construction. In “My Murderer’s Futon” Viren begins with a meditation on how our own material possessions may themselves have haunting histories imbued with personal struggles that resonate with our own. In subsequent essays she unpacks the intersection of identity with relationships, vocation, sexuality, embodiment, names, culture, family, and nationality. Each of these essays is written with a directness that penetrates beyond the analytical. In “My Catch” the Floridian obsession with tarpon fishing becomes an allegory for falling in love. “My Ballad For You” is in turn a love song for the author’s infant daughter in the dark tradition of the lullaby that explores the story behind a beloved tune about Tom Dula. In “My Hands” Viren peels back the layers of body focused repetitive behavior to reveal insights into lesbian intimacy, palm reading, teleological proofs for the existence of God, the theory of evolution, and stillness.
In an assembly of interviews grouped as “The Genre of Resistance” in Poets & Writers (Sept.-Oct. 2018) Viren discusses how she has come to embrace essay more as a verb than a noun. For Viren, to essay is an individual act of defiance. This is perhaps one of the superpowers of her collection. “My Wife” is a quiet, devastating accounting of the inherent discrimination and moral outrage experienced by same sex couples. “It doesn’t make any sense that so many of us were routinely unmarried when we crossed state lines,” Viren writes. “But it is a fact that six months after we were married, Marta and I got unmarried just by getting in a Penske truck and starting to drive.”
The essays in Mine, winner of the River Teeth Literary Nonfiction Prize, are smart, evocative, and difficult to shake. These inquiries of self-exploration transmute into possessions, and ultimately one isn’t quite sure whether they have become yours or you have become theirs. “Putting yourself in charge of uncovering the truth can also feel like an unraveling,” Viren writes of her time as a journalist. As an essayist, she has unearthed a gold mine of truth and staked a claim.