UPDATE: I like a summer/beach/fun/pool/shady porch read. And the one thing I don't want in my beach read is rather hateful political opinions thrown around, especially at the most likeable person in this book. So, minus another star, for a two star rating.
Original Review:
I wasn't sure about this one when I picked it up off the "new and notable" shelves at the library. I read the reviews/blurbs on the back jacket of this book and the sources were respectable: Richmond Times-Dispatch, The Roanoke Times (which compares this book to 'Wuthering Heights'), The San Diego Tribune, Library Journal and others. (Some book jacket blurbs consist only of quotes from authors of whom I have never heard and that's usually a red flag to me.) So I checked out the book, also appreciating the clear intent of a marketing department: "This is a summer book for a relaxing beach/pool/shade tree read" screams the front cover. And who doesn't need a nice beach read every now and then? I opened the book to page one, and Gable hooked me instantly: there is a social media note entitled "Cliff House a Goner" which tells us about a grand old house about to fall into the sea. Will it be saved? Or should it be saved, given environmental issues? Then I get to page 27 and read what might be, to many readers, (and to me) one of the most surprising lines of any fiction book of 2017: 'Cissy [the book's heroine] drags out the syllables [of the word Cal-i-for-nia], top lip curled as if she were talking about a venereal disease, or a Republican," Gable writes. Instantly we understand Cissy is deeply conflicted: she is a liberal, but at the same time willing to save her old family house and perhaps damage the environment, AND she doesn't like California. (And as the book proceeds, her conflicts deepen.) I'd also like to note that right here, between pages 26 and 27, I found two library check-out receipts dated 5/31/17 and 6/2/17. Either two people recently closed the book upon reading the page 27 quote, or they thought it hilarious (more likely in my county, which is strongly liberal), read the book, and left their receipts here as pointers for future readers. Gable and her publishers certainly take a big risk here: it's true this is a summer fiction read, but the USA is highly polarized right now concerning politics as well as the environment, and climate change is certainly a polarizing factor in this book. Still, no matter your own personal politics, it's a successful character-identification line, and that's the point. Okay, I'm digressing, but I have one more point to make. I did read this book over a two-day period: I very much wanted to know what happened to the house, which along the way I found it's the kind of place I would love to have visited. Who will ultimately win: Cissy or Mother Nature? But Gable throws in a strange plot line which I thought unnecessary: the family has a Deep Dark Secret! There is no reason for me to withhold the secret from future readers, as Gable telegraphs it to us very early, and it has nothing to do with the basic plot or resolution: there is a 'ho-mo-sex-ual' in the family's past! Ahem. What would be more shocking, as we all know here in 2017, is that in a huge, old family, there would be no gay people (extended family members, college friends of the family, the neighbors, the help, etc.) somewhere along the line. In summary: 1) I was hooked from the first page; 2) I appreciated a direct hit from the marketing department/title/cover/author as I knew exactly what I was about to read; 3) I finished the book in two days and 4) I think the author/publishers took a huge risk with that very political line which occurs very early in the book, and the truth is that climate change HAS been politicized (which I don't get at all, I always thought it was fine to talk about the weather, but no, not anymore, that is a political issue). So that's 4 solid points, 4 things I liked much about this book. However, I personally thought the gay plot line out-of-date and really not necessary at all as there was enough romance/sex conflicts here in the first place. This 404-page book is a solid 300-page summer read about an old family house in danger of falling into the sea with numerous, conflicting, heterosexual relationships (rather graphic at times, actually). So, 4-stars, minus 1-star for a page-lengthening, unnecessary (imo) gay plot line, for a 3-star rating. But, wow, congrats to Michelle Gable: that political line to describe a character, early in the book, is indeed gutsy, and on the sensational/memorable side. But that doesn't mean the line is appropriate in a fun/beach read. so minus another star, for a 2-star rating.