Maria Vale is such an incredible writer. Just wanted to say that first off.
Second, don’t read this if you haven’t read the first in the series (The Last Wolf), because you’ll be missing out on a ton of lore and character knowledge. I saw some reviews where the person hadn’t read the first one and therefore rated it low, which made me 🙄
Like The Last Wolf, A Wolf Apart is first-person, single POV. This time, we’re in the head of Elijah Sorensson, who garnered some brief mentions in TLW. He’s the Pack’s lawyer and lives primarily Offland, in New York City. We learn that he loathes it—loathes dealing with humans, loathes their smell, loathes having to confirm to an archetype: a rich playboy asshole, kind of like if Don Draper was a lawyer and more disingenuous.
He feels his wild—the wolf inside—growing weaker and wants to go home, but the Pack’s new Alpha, Evie, says she needs him there, defending the Pack’s interests.
So Elijah is an increasingly desperate wolf until he meets Thea… a human woman. And there’s the central conflict: a wolf who must present as human and hates it, yet wants desperately to be with Thea.
I ate this book up. It’s beautifully written; Vale does an excellent job with Elijah’s voice, which is utterly distinct from Quicksilver’s in TLW. Even though he comes across as a misogynistic dick (more on this later), that’s not all there is to him. He’s desperate, hating himself and hating everyone around him because he has had to hide his true self for years and years. And I love the world Vale has built, where these don’t-call-them-werewolves are wolves first, not humans who occasionally turn into wolves. It’s gory and well researched and immersive.
So, my one criticism is this: There is a strong seam of misogyny running through this book, and it’s hard to tell if it’s coming from Elijah or the author. Apart from the female wolves and Thea, all woman are presented as fake, cookie-cutter, mercenary sluts. You could argue that Thea, who seems cool but remains enigmatic, is being positioned as a Not Like Other Girls character. Or you could argue that, if this is all from Elijah’s POV, it is simply part of his loathing of all things human and, in turn, what he has become. He is drawn to Thea because she is the most wolf-like human he’s ever met, so for him she stands apart from the human world he so abhors. I tend to believe the latter is true, because Maria Vale seems like a cool person—so my criticism is that this nuance is not resolved clearly enough.
All that said, I loved this and am so tempted to launch straight into the third book.