What do you think?
Rate this book
The Sisters of Lancaster County #2
A Simple Singing
Marie Bachmann has always been the good Amish daughter. But when two men, a Mennonite farmhand and a bishops rebellious son, show interest in her, she finds herself at a crossroads. On a journey to Florida and back, she grapples with her heart, finding inspiration and hope for the future in the story of a brave Civil Warera ancestor.
352 pages, Hardcover
Published July 31, 2018
115 people are currently reading
1015 people want to read
About the author
Leslie Gould
78 books600 followersLeslie Gould is the #1 bestselling and Christy Award-winning author of fifty novels. She received her MFA in 2009 and has taught writing on the university level. Leslie enjoys traveling, hiking, and history. She and her husband, Peter, are the parents of four adult children and two grandbabies. Visit her at http://www.lesliegould.com/.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 60 reviews
July 11, 2018
What a great read from beginning to end, the author has us spanning decades, from current to civil war era.
We are shown from one century to the next how things are different and yet the same. People in need, slavery, injury from war, homeless, the list can go on, and what do you do, follow your faith and help or stay in your own little world?
In the past book, we saw what was going on with the farm in Lancaster, and in this book, we learn how the farm stayed in the family. The author also shows us how in this family the way that the Amish and Mennonites are connected.
So many decisions that have to be made that will completely change the way these people live, and you won’t know until the end how everything works out.
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Bethany House, and was not required to give a positive review.
We are shown from one century to the next how things are different and yet the same. People in need, slavery, injury from war, homeless, the list can go on, and what do you do, follow your faith and help or stay in your own little world?
In the past book, we saw what was going on with the farm in Lancaster, and in this book, we learn how the farm stayed in the family. The author also shows us how in this family the way that the Amish and Mennonites are connected.
So many decisions that have to be made that will completely change the way these people live, and you won’t know until the end how everything works out.
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Bethany House, and was not required to give a positive review.
October 26, 2018
A Simple Singing is the second instalment from The Sisters of Lancaster County series by Leslie Gould. Even though it is book two of the series, I have not read the beginning, A Plain Leaving, and felt this one could be read as a stand alone. I love historical fiction, as well as, Amish Fiction. When the two combine, makes it a great read.
I enjoyed A Simple Singing, giving it four stars. I recommend it.
I received this book from the publisher, but was not required to write a review. This review is 100% my own honest opinion.
I enjoyed A Simple Singing, giving it four stars. I recommend it.
I received this book from the publisher, but was not required to write a review. This review is 100% my own honest opinion.
August 11, 2018
Oh, how I enjoyed both of the stories in this book! Leslie Gould is a master at dual timeline stories and each one I read from her is better than the last. This book with its modern day and Civil War-era stories is wonderfully written and if I had to use one word to describe it I would simply say perfect!
I really liked the way this book was set up. First, we get to meet Marie, the main character in the modern day story. She is likable and relatable. She is trying to be the perfect Amish daughter but isn't really happy. Then when we have spent enough time with Marie to feel like we know her then we are introduced to Annie, the main character in the Civil War story. Annie is another strong character and I liked her just as much as I did Marie. There are several supporting characters in the book and there wasn't really one I didn't like. They are all well-developed. It was easy to forget they were fictional characters.
As much as I liked Marie's story I think Annie's was my favorite. I like reading about the Civil War and I think the author did a fantastic job of bringing it to life. Not since reading Margaret Mitchell's Gone with the Wind or John Jakes' North and South series has an author made me feel as if I was experiencing the war right along with the characters. In fact, Gould's descriptions of Annie's arrival in Gettysburg took my breath away. It was so easy to picture everything she described and to feel the emotions Annie did. I feel like through her words I knew what it was like to be there and see the horrors of the war. It was really interesting to read how the Amish played a part in the Civil War.
I highly recommend this book. It's a quick and easy read with two great stories wonderfully tied together. I will advise you to set aside some time to read this one though as once you start reading it's a hard book to put down.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher and was not required to write a review. All opinions are mine.
I really liked the way this book was set up. First, we get to meet Marie, the main character in the modern day story. She is likable and relatable. She is trying to be the perfect Amish daughter but isn't really happy. Then when we have spent enough time with Marie to feel like we know her then we are introduced to Annie, the main character in the Civil War story. Annie is another strong character and I liked her just as much as I did Marie. There are several supporting characters in the book and there wasn't really one I didn't like. They are all well-developed. It was easy to forget they were fictional characters.
As much as I liked Marie's story I think Annie's was my favorite. I like reading about the Civil War and I think the author did a fantastic job of bringing it to life. Not since reading Margaret Mitchell's Gone with the Wind or John Jakes' North and South series has an author made me feel as if I was experiencing the war right along with the characters. In fact, Gould's descriptions of Annie's arrival in Gettysburg took my breath away. It was so easy to picture everything she described and to feel the emotions Annie did. I feel like through her words I knew what it was like to be there and see the horrors of the war. It was really interesting to read how the Amish played a part in the Civil War.
I highly recommend this book. It's a quick and easy read with two great stories wonderfully tied together. I will advise you to set aside some time to read this one though as once you start reading it's a hard book to put down.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher and was not required to write a review. All opinions are mine.
August 12, 2018
I loved how Leslie Gould could weave past to present and then eventually tie it in altogether.
There are many delightful characters in this book.
I do agree with some other reviewers that Marie is kind of hard to warm up to. But, I do like how she is challenged because at first she knew what she wanted out of life. I liked some of the challenges that God sent her way.
Kind of like what I'm going through now. I think God has sent me a wake up call. But, gosh did He have to do it the hard way?
Annie is a character of the past whom I greatly admired! When it is something that she didn't back down.
Before I go on, I wanted to remind y'all that this is a different type of Amish story than we're used to reading.
To me, I think it's very exciting because it's different and it shows us that not all Amish are the same in their beliefs.
It is mentioned through both books about Rebecca's drowning and how it changed Marie and Jessica's mamm.
Tragedy can come unexpectedly and in many different forms. Not just death.
I do admire family (except ours) I know that some ppl believe very strongly about family ties and how they always stand by you. Today, I found out differently. No, they don't.
The other thing I love about Leslie's writing style is that she uses first person. I loooooooove this. It's my favorite genre. To me, I can connect with the people in the story much better than the other way.
The second way she writes I felt like I was in Pinecraft w.ith Aunti Suz and Marie. I felt like I was there with them even tho I just got back from Florida myself. The ocean has a way of soothing you. It has a music all of it own if you listen carefully. It's as if God is really talking to you.
Thank you Leslie Gould for another awesome story!! I wish I could give you ten stars!!
I received this from Netgalley All opinions are my own!
There are many delightful characters in this book.
I do agree with some other reviewers that Marie is kind of hard to warm up to. But, I do like how she is challenged because at first she knew what she wanted out of life. I liked some of the challenges that God sent her way.
Kind of like what I'm going through now. I think God has sent me a wake up call. But, gosh did He have to do it the hard way?
Annie is a character of the past whom I greatly admired! When it is something that she didn't back down.
Before I go on, I wanted to remind y'all that this is a different type of Amish story than we're used to reading.
To me, I think it's very exciting because it's different and it shows us that not all Amish are the same in their beliefs.
It is mentioned through both books about Rebecca's drowning and how it changed Marie and Jessica's mamm.
Tragedy can come unexpectedly and in many different forms. Not just death.
I do admire family (except ours) I know that some ppl believe very strongly about family ties and how they always stand by you. Today, I found out differently. No, they don't.
The other thing I love about Leslie's writing style is that she uses first person. I loooooooove this. It's my favorite genre. To me, I can connect with the people in the story much better than the other way.
The second way she writes I felt like I was in Pinecraft w.ith Aunti Suz and Marie. I felt like I was there with them even tho I just got back from Florida myself. The ocean has a way of soothing you. It has a music all of it own if you listen carefully. It's as if God is really talking to you.
Thank you Leslie Gould for another awesome story!! I wish I could give you ten stars!!
I received this from Netgalley All opinions are my own!
January 30, 2020
I love the growth Marie experiences in this story. I also enjoyed seeing how some people bring out the best in others, and see the best.
Gordon is steady and compassionate, but Marie overlooks him because he doesn't fit her rigid standards (he's Mennonite and doesn't own a farm -- two musts for her).
The man who outwardly fits her ideals (Amish, bishop's son, and will take over the farm) isn't ideal on the inside, at least for Marie. She just keeps believing she can change him and everything will work out the way she thinks it should.
I love the community of family, new friends, and Auntie Suz who all play a part in Marie's growth.
Auntie Suz tells Marie a story, which we read as a companion story. I'm not a fan of companion stories but I enjoy Leslie Gould so I persevered -- and liked the Civil War era story. I was especially touched by the part about helping the wounded after Gettysburg, and the Gettysburg address. The Battle Hymn of the Republic and the thoughts about its meaning touched me. I found myself sharing those parts with my kids. This second story was smaller and placed in a few spots during the book. It tied in well. And I got a kick out of Auntie Suz losing patience with Marie when she wasn't getting the main messages from it.
I wasn't sure if Marie would sort through taking her internal inventory and be willing to change, or if she'd decide to stay the same and end up unhappy (we could see this better than she could). This was another enjoyable and thoughtful book by Ms. Gould!
Gordon is steady and compassionate, but Marie overlooks him because he doesn't fit her rigid standards (he's Mennonite and doesn't own a farm -- two musts for her).
The man who outwardly fits her ideals (Amish, bishop's son, and will take over the farm) isn't ideal on the inside, at least for Marie. She just keeps believing she can change him and everything will work out the way she thinks it should.
I love the community of family, new friends, and Auntie Suz who all play a part in Marie's growth.
Auntie Suz tells Marie a story, which we read as a companion story. I'm not a fan of companion stories but I enjoy Leslie Gould so I persevered -- and liked the Civil War era story. I was especially touched by the part about helping the wounded after Gettysburg, and the Gettysburg address. The Battle Hymn of the Republic and the thoughts about its meaning touched me. I found myself sharing those parts with my kids. This second story was smaller and placed in a few spots during the book. It tied in well. And I got a kick out of Auntie Suz losing patience with Marie when she wasn't getting the main messages from it.
I wasn't sure if Marie would sort through taking her internal inventory and be willing to change, or if she'd decide to stay the same and end up unhappy (we could see this better than she could). This was another enjoyable and thoughtful book by Ms. Gould!
September 26, 2021
This dual era story of today and the Civil War period brought a wonderful story. The Bachmann’s family similarities during both era brought to life the struggles mankind still experiences in modern society.
Marie loved music but it was fond upon with her mother; although, her dad enjoyed singing. She had some struggles to overcome and a trip to Florida did not solve everything. Aunt Suz was a wonderful character in retelling the family history. Fans of Amish and historical fiction will enjoy this book.
A friend loaned me this book without any obligation to write a review. I have expressed my own thoughts.
Marie loved music but it was fond upon with her mother; although, her dad enjoyed singing. She had some struggles to overcome and a trip to Florida did not solve everything. Aunt Suz was a wonderful character in retelling the family history. Fans of Amish and historical fiction will enjoy this book.
A friend loaned me this book without any obligation to write a review. I have expressed my own thoughts.
April 2, 2021
Good story about Marie, an Amish girl who dreams of the perfect relationship with an imperfect Amish bishop’s son who has not yet joined the church. Instead, he is a party guy and makes promises to Marie about their future. Gordon is a farm hand, Mennonite whose lifestyle draws Marie closer to God. Marie must make a decision that will affect her future. Her aunt’s story about her ancestor, Annie, is instrumental in inspiring courage and confidence in making her final decision.
August 3, 2018
Companion stories are beautifully interwoven throughout this very interesting novel. Amish life is portrayed both in Civil War time and modern day, with examples of what is acceptable and not, in both time frames. A bit of Mennonite life is interspersed throughout the stories to give a bit of comparison in traditions in both ways of life.
Well developed characterizations and descriptive depictions of the landscape and pictures of the ravages of war are highlights throughout this book. Relationships and fellowship with those unlike ourselves are highlighted through the use of homelessness, slavery and differences in culture, demonstrating selflessness in a world of selfishness. Spiritual growth and maturation are highlights in both the main characters throughout this novel.
The Civil War was well researched for this book, as tales of the Battles of Gettysburg are well defined and accurate. I loved this book, and look forward to the next in the series. This author has a talent for bringing to life the miseries we share, and the beauty of redemption.
Disclaimer: I received a complimentary copy of this book. All expressed opinions in this review are my own.
Well developed characterizations and descriptive depictions of the landscape and pictures of the ravages of war are highlights throughout this book. Relationships and fellowship with those unlike ourselves are highlighted through the use of homelessness, slavery and differences in culture, demonstrating selflessness in a world of selfishness. Spiritual growth and maturation are highlights in both the main characters throughout this novel.
The Civil War was well researched for this book, as tales of the Battles of Gettysburg are well defined and accurate. I loved this book, and look forward to the next in the series. This author has a talent for bringing to life the miseries we share, and the beauty of redemption.
Disclaimer: I received a complimentary copy of this book. All expressed opinions in this review are my own.
October 15, 2018
Courting or marrying a Mennonite when you are a baptized member of the Amish faith will get you shunned by your Amish family and friends......but Marie is thinking of doing just that. But she has conflicting feelings when a young Amish man. that she is also attracted to. returns from Florida. He is not a baptized member of the Amish church yet and he may be a bit too wild. What will Marie do? Will she follow God's will or decide for herself what God desires for her life.
This book is wonderful! It is the second book in the Sisters of Lancaster County series, but it can be read as a standalone. I didn't want to put this book down for a minute and couldn't wait to see what would take place for the beloved characters.
I am rating this book 5 stars and highly recommend it to readers.
I received a copy of this book from Bethany House Publishers and am happy to write a review of this book. All opinions expressed are my own.
This book is wonderful! It is the second book in the Sisters of Lancaster County series, but it can be read as a standalone. I didn't want to put this book down for a minute and couldn't wait to see what would take place for the beloved characters.
I am rating this book 5 stars and highly recommend it to readers.
I received a copy of this book from Bethany House Publishers and am happy to write a review of this book. All opinions expressed are my own.
August 6, 2018
A Simple Singing by Leslie Gould is the second novel in The Sisters of Lancaster County series. It is December of 2013 and Marie just watched her sister, Jessica marry Silas. Marie Bachman is one for the following the rules and fully expects to be courted by a good Amish man, to settle down on a nearby farm and have a large family. When Bishop Jacobs son, Elijah visits from Florida, it seems like providence. Gordon Martin, their farmhand, likes to sing while he works which reminds Marie of her father who taught her to sing while they worked in the barn. Gordon has a kind nature and a generous heart, but he is a Mennonite. Mrs. Bachman informs Marie that she will be going to Pinecraft, Florida with her Aunt Suz for a vacation. Marie is surprised at how the Englisch, Amish and Mennonite mingle in the community. She enjoys attending services in a church, the opportunity to sing with others, and to spend time with Elijah. Their second week in Pinecraft, Gordon arrives on a mission trip and Marie gets to know him better. While on the trip, Aunt Suz tells Marie the story of their ancestor, Annie Bachmann and the struggles she faced during the Civil War. Back at home, Marie wrestles with her conscience on her life choices. As Aunt Suz finishes telling her the story of Annie, it helps Marie make a decision about her future.
A Simple Singing may be the second book in The Sisters of Lancaster County series, but it can be read alone. I thought the novel was well-written with two interesting, interconnected stories. It did take me a little while to get into the book. Once I did, though, I was engaged. I was happy to see the pacing improve (it starts out a little slow). There are smooth transitions as it switches from Marie to Annie. I actually enjoyed Annie’s story more than Marie’s. I found it more captivating and wish it had been a book on its own. Gordon volunteers at homeless shelters in Lancaster County and in Florida. Ms. Gould handles the subject adroitly as she does the issue of slavery in Annie’s timeline. It was lovely to watch Marie grow as an individual throughout the story. The author is a descriptive writer which helps brings the book to life for me because I can visualize the scenes thanks to her writing. Christian themes present in A Simple Singing are prayer, having faith, and the importance of following the path God has laid out for you (not your own). Ms. Gould did her research for the Civil War scenes especially the Battle of Gettysburg. I like how she included President Lincoln’s Gettysburg Address. I found A Simple Singing to be a heartwarming Amish novel and I am eager to read Liesel’s story in A Faithful Gathering.
A Simple Singing may be the second book in The Sisters of Lancaster County series, but it can be read alone. I thought the novel was well-written with two interesting, interconnected stories. It did take me a little while to get into the book. Once I did, though, I was engaged. I was happy to see the pacing improve (it starts out a little slow). There are smooth transitions as it switches from Marie to Annie. I actually enjoyed Annie’s story more than Marie’s. I found it more captivating and wish it had been a book on its own. Gordon volunteers at homeless shelters in Lancaster County and in Florida. Ms. Gould handles the subject adroitly as she does the issue of slavery in Annie’s timeline. It was lovely to watch Marie grow as an individual throughout the story. The author is a descriptive writer which helps brings the book to life for me because I can visualize the scenes thanks to her writing. Christian themes present in A Simple Singing are prayer, having faith, and the importance of following the path God has laid out for you (not your own). Ms. Gould did her research for the Civil War scenes especially the Battle of Gettysburg. I like how she included President Lincoln’s Gettysburg Address. I found A Simple Singing to be a heartwarming Amish novel and I am eager to read Liesel’s story in A Faithful Gathering.
September 16, 2018
“A SIMPLE SINGING” BY Leslie Gould is the second book in The Sisters of Lancaster County series.
A SIMPLE SINGING” is the story of an Amish woman coming to terms with herself and her faith. It’s a story of choices and listening to your heart.
“A SIMPLE SIGNING” is the story of Marie Bachmann who has always lived by the Amish rule to the letter and being the “good” daughter. She’s always dreamed of marrying an Amish man well respected in the community with a farm close to her family farm and her Mamm and maybe just maybe one that would share her love of singing.
Gordon Martin works on her folk’s farm. He’s dependable, hard-working, has a love of his fellow man. Although a good friend, he’s Mennonite not Amish. On the other hand, her Mamm and Bishop Jacobs would love to see her married to the Bishop’s son, Elijah.
In hopes that Marie’s influence would settle Elijah’s worldly ways and bring him back to join the church, settle down and take over farming his Daed’s farm, Marie is sent off with her Aenti Suz to Pinecraft, Florida where Elijah just happens to be working. Excited to spend time with Elijah, who she feels is her future spouse, and fearful to leave the farm, leave Marie with a mix of emotions. She finds out that Gordon too will be traveling to Pinecraft during her time there for some mission work.
It’s during their journey to Pinecraft that Aenti Suz starts to share the story of one of their Civil War ancestors, Anne Buchmann. It’s through this story that Marie begins to realize that there is more to being faithful than the length of a hemline or following the Amish rule to the letter. She also realizes that servitude and selflessness are also a big part of it. She does a lot of looking at herself and seeing how she has fallen short.
It’s while spending time with both Elijah and Gorton that she see the heart of both men. Has all the time she has been francizing about dream life with Elijah been just that a fantasy? What would become of her dream life if it was with a faithful but Mennonite man?
I highly recommend “A SIMPLE SINGING”. It can definitely be read as a standalone book. However, if like me, once you see who well it’s written and the wonderful story it tells, you will be definitely be looking not only for the other book in this series and anticipating the next book in the series, but also checking out this author’s other books.
A SIMPLE SINGING” is the story of an Amish woman coming to terms with herself and her faith. It’s a story of choices and listening to your heart.
“A SIMPLE SIGNING” is the story of Marie Bachmann who has always lived by the Amish rule to the letter and being the “good” daughter. She’s always dreamed of marrying an Amish man well respected in the community with a farm close to her family farm and her Mamm and maybe just maybe one that would share her love of singing.
Gordon Martin works on her folk’s farm. He’s dependable, hard-working, has a love of his fellow man. Although a good friend, he’s Mennonite not Amish. On the other hand, her Mamm and Bishop Jacobs would love to see her married to the Bishop’s son, Elijah.
In hopes that Marie’s influence would settle Elijah’s worldly ways and bring him back to join the church, settle down and take over farming his Daed’s farm, Marie is sent off with her Aenti Suz to Pinecraft, Florida where Elijah just happens to be working. Excited to spend time with Elijah, who she feels is her future spouse, and fearful to leave the farm, leave Marie with a mix of emotions. She finds out that Gordon too will be traveling to Pinecraft during her time there for some mission work.
It’s during their journey to Pinecraft that Aenti Suz starts to share the story of one of their Civil War ancestors, Anne Buchmann. It’s through this story that Marie begins to realize that there is more to being faithful than the length of a hemline or following the Amish rule to the letter. She also realizes that servitude and selflessness are also a big part of it. She does a lot of looking at herself and seeing how she has fallen short.
It’s while spending time with both Elijah and Gorton that she see the heart of both men. Has all the time she has been francizing about dream life with Elijah been just that a fantasy? What would become of her dream life if it was with a faithful but Mennonite man?
I highly recommend “A SIMPLE SINGING”. It can definitely be read as a standalone book. However, if like me, once you see who well it’s written and the wonderful story it tells, you will be definitely be looking not only for the other book in this series and anticipating the next book in the series, but also checking out this author’s other books.
August 11, 2018
A Simple Singing by Leslie Gould is the second offering in The Sisters of Lancaster series and it just might be even better than the first one that I really liked too. It is another wonderfully inspirational book by one of my favorite authors of Amish stories. This particular series follows three Bachmann sisters and A Simple Singing is about Marie. Marie is the 'good' sister, a rule follower--even to the extent of measuring hems and bonnet lengths, the sister with a tad of a judgmental spirit and yet one who truly desires to follow God and to understand Him, a young woman who has music in her soul and just wants her dream of a perfect future as an Amish farmwife to come true. Following her journey to love is a treat as the author has added plenty of tension to the story with Marie being presented with two young men who are involved in her life. I love the characters in Gould's stories. She portrays them realistically and the reader is easily drawn into their lives. Another treat with this book is a second story embedded into Marie's and it takes the readers back to the Civil War where readers meet Marie's great-great-great aunt. Annie's story is just as compelling as Marie's and the author does a marvelous job of stopping at just the right point in one story to pick up in the other. Gould gives interesting historical background on the Civil War time period, with a glimpse of the horrors of war and slavery and nursing during that time. Being an RN and grandmother to a young Civil War drummer boy reenactor, I really enjoyed reading Annie's story. Strong themes of family and faith are woven throughout the book as the author portrays vibrant and realistic characters who deal with the nonresistant lifestyle of the Amish, learning what it means to care for those who are suffering and understanding the true meaning of grace, God's grace and love exhibited through individuals serving others. The author has expertly written a captivating story that will remind readers that God is in the hard times of our lives, molding us, making us stronger and we can trust Him to give us the desires of our hearts as we learn to delight in Him alone.
I received a complimentary copy of the book from the author. I was not required to write a review and the opinions are my own.
I received a complimentary copy of the book from the author. I was not required to write a review and the opinions are my own.
September 14, 2018
What happens when a young Amish woman is of marrying age and everyone else has her already matched up with someone who apparently does not have any feelings for her nor any true appreciation of who she is as an individual? And what does an Amish person do who has some real talent in areas that are not acceptable to the Amish Ordnung? Marie has a beautiful singing voice but basically has been told by her Mamm to only sing in church and at the youth singings. Otherwise, she may become prideful of her singing ability. This is a question for the reader: does God give a person talents and expect them to hide those talents to avoid the sin of pride? In the story Aenti Suz shares with Marie about their ancestor, Annie, it appears Annie has some God-given abilities when it comes to ministering to the needs of the sick and wounded but her family tried to keep her from doing what God has obviously gifted her to do. In her case, Annie would be treating wounded soldiers fighting in the Civil Wars. As pacifists, many of the Amish did not believe they should help the soldiers in any way, including providing food, medical treatment, or other humane acts because they saw it as showing support for fighting. Did Aenti Suz merely share the story with Marie to fill in the gaps of their past or was there another motive in the telling? No matter whether Annie or Marie married, and no matter what they chose to do with their lives, their stories give us powerful examples of what happens when people choose to put God first. The crucial question is whether we should listen to our elders and the leaders of our church, or should we seek to know the true will of God as it applies in our individual situations? In other words, does a church have the final authority or does God? I received a copy of this book from the author. This is my honest review. All opinions are strictly my own.
August 13, 2018
Amish and Historical fiction with a dual time line! Why yes, I do love all three, especially when they’re as masterfully combined as they are in this novel. With the authors descriptive storytelling and her strong character development I quickly became caught up in the lives of Marie Bachmann in 2013 and Annie Bachmann in 1863.
Marie was difficult for me to like at first because I perceived her to be self-righteous but I soon realized that she wanted what other women her age and in her community wanted which is a husband and family of her own. She had been the perfect Amish daughter, never leaving her family unlike some of her siblings, helping out in her district when needed, but she still hadn’t received the marriage proposal she wanted.
I started to like Marie so much more when she went with her Aenti Suz to Pinecraft and learned more about her ancestor, Annie. I loved Annie from the moment I met her and wished that her story had been a stand alone because I loved the time period, her selflessness and her bravery. The author wrote both time lines so that they connected beautifully and I was more than satisfied with both of the protagonists stories and felt they were complete.
I want to mention the other element of this book that I liked and that is the Mennonite friends and neighbors we meet in Lancaster County and Pinecraft. There are several secondary characters that were interesting and I enjoyed getting to know them, too.
The other thing I can say about this must read book is that it will definitely be on my top ten favorites this year.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher and was under no obligation to write a review. All opinions are my own.
Marie was difficult for me to like at first because I perceived her to be self-righteous but I soon realized that she wanted what other women her age and in her community wanted which is a husband and family of her own. She had been the perfect Amish daughter, never leaving her family unlike some of her siblings, helping out in her district when needed, but she still hadn’t received the marriage proposal she wanted.
I started to like Marie so much more when she went with her Aenti Suz to Pinecraft and learned more about her ancestor, Annie. I loved Annie from the moment I met her and wished that her story had been a stand alone because I loved the time period, her selflessness and her bravery. The author wrote both time lines so that they connected beautifully and I was more than satisfied with both of the protagonists stories and felt they were complete.
I want to mention the other element of this book that I liked and that is the Mennonite friends and neighbors we meet in Lancaster County and Pinecraft. There are several secondary characters that were interesting and I enjoyed getting to know them, too.
The other thing I can say about this must read book is that it will definitely be on my top ten favorites this year.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher and was under no obligation to write a review. All opinions are my own.
August 7, 2018
This was a dual timeline novel with connections on both ends. (Marie 2013 and Annie 1863) They both lived in the same town and the same house but were separated by 150 years. Annie was Marie's great great great aunt and Marie learned a lot not only about Annie but about herself from hearing Annie's story from her Aunt Suz.
I didn't warm up to Marie at the beginning. She was self righteous and always pointing out others sins without examining her own life. She was strict Amish through and through. She had her life planned out which included Elijah, an Amish man that hadn't settled down and joined the church. Her vision was to marry him, be a good wife while he farmed his parent's land. She just hadn't consulted God, one of her downfalls.
Annie was living through the Civil War and although Amish, she was called on to leave her home and family and help nurse wounded soldiers. A big step for her and very hard at the beginning. Interestingly they both had expected matches for marriage, and also close male friends from other religions. I loved reading about their thoughts and observing how slowly God was working on their hearts.
I enjoyed reading the history included. President Abraham Lincoln giving his Gettysburg address, the skirmishes between the North and South, and bits and pieces about the Underground Railroad. The family ties, the romances and the telling of everyday life all added to the beauty of the story. It will remain with me for a long time.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher but was not required to write a review. All opinions are my own.
I didn't warm up to Marie at the beginning. She was self righteous and always pointing out others sins without examining her own life. She was strict Amish through and through. She had her life planned out which included Elijah, an Amish man that hadn't settled down and joined the church. Her vision was to marry him, be a good wife while he farmed his parent's land. She just hadn't consulted God, one of her downfalls.
Annie was living through the Civil War and although Amish, she was called on to leave her home and family and help nurse wounded soldiers. A big step for her and very hard at the beginning. Interestingly they both had expected matches for marriage, and also close male friends from other religions. I loved reading about their thoughts and observing how slowly God was working on their hearts.
I enjoyed reading the history included. President Abraham Lincoln giving his Gettysburg address, the skirmishes between the North and South, and bits and pieces about the Underground Railroad. The family ties, the romances and the telling of everyday life all added to the beauty of the story. It will remain with me for a long time.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher but was not required to write a review. All opinions are my own.
August 7, 2018
This was a dual timeline novel with connections on both ends. (Marie 2013 and Annie 1863) They both lived in the same town and the same house but were separated by 150 years. Annie was Marie's great great great aunt and Marie learned a lot not only about Annie but about herself from hearing Annie's story from her Aunt Suz.
I didn't warm up to Marie at the beginning. She was self righteous and always pointing out others sins without examining her own life. She was strict Amish through and through. She had her life planned out which included Elijah, an Amish man that hadn't settled down and joined the church. Her vision was to marry him, be a good wife while he farmed his parent's land. She just hadn't consulted God, one of her downfalls.
Annie was living through the Civil War and although Amish, she was called on to leave her home and family and help nurse wounded soldiers. A big step for her and very hard at the beginning. Interestingly they both had expected matches for marriage, and also close male friends from other religions. I loved reading about their thoughts and observing how slowly God was working on their hearts.
I enjoyed reading the history included. President Abraham Lincoln giving his Gettysburg address, the skirmishes between the North and South, and bits and pieces about the Underground Railroad. The family ties, the romances and the telling of everyday life all added to the beauty of the story. It will remain with me for a long time.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher but was not required to write a review. All opinions are my own.
I didn't warm up to Marie at the beginning. She was self righteous and always pointing out others sins without examining her own life. She was strict Amish through and through. She had her life planned out which included Elijah, an Amish man that hadn't settled down and joined the church. Her vision was to marry him, be a good wife while he farmed his parent's land. She just hadn't consulted God, one of her downfalls.
Annie was living through the Civil War and although Amish, she was called on to leave her home and family and help nurse wounded soldiers. A big step for her and very hard at the beginning. Interestingly they both had expected matches for marriage, and also close male friends from other religions. I loved reading about their thoughts and observing how slowly God was working on their hearts.
I enjoyed reading the history included. President Abraham Lincoln giving his Gettysburg address, the skirmishes between the North and South, and bits and pieces about the Underground Railroad. The family ties, the romances and the telling of everyday life all added to the beauty of the story. It will remain with me for a long time.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher but was not required to write a review. All opinions are my own.
July 22, 2018
A Simple Singing by Leslie Gould is book two of the Sisters of Lancaster County series. It is a time slip novel where we follow Marie Bachmann’s story in present day Lancaster and her ancestor, Annie which is set in the Civil-War era.
Marie thinks of herself as the “good” daughter and always follows the rules, she even plans on marrying a good Amish farmer. When bad-boy, Eli Jacob returns to town, she sees it as an opportunity to have the life she has dreamed about. Gordon Martin, the Mennonite man that has a big heart, has his eyes set on Marie as well.
When her mother sends her to Pinecraft to accompany her Aunt Suz, she thinks of it as a opportunity to court Eli and get him to come back home until Gordon shows up on a missionary trip.
As Aunt Suz recounts the story of Annie, a heroine of her time, Marie starts to “take a look” at her life.
I really enjoyed hearing Annie’s story and how it helped Marie to realize where God was leading her future. Gould did a great job of brining the two stories together while not allowing one to overshadow the other. The characters were well-developed.
I gave this book 5 stars and can’t wait to read the next chapter in the Bachmann sisters’ lives.
I received a copy of this novel from netgalley.com and Bethany House in return for my honest review.
Marie thinks of herself as the “good” daughter and always follows the rules, she even plans on marrying a good Amish farmer. When bad-boy, Eli Jacob returns to town, she sees it as an opportunity to have the life she has dreamed about. Gordon Martin, the Mennonite man that has a big heart, has his eyes set on Marie as well.
When her mother sends her to Pinecraft to accompany her Aunt Suz, she thinks of it as a opportunity to court Eli and get him to come back home until Gordon shows up on a missionary trip.
As Aunt Suz recounts the story of Annie, a heroine of her time, Marie starts to “take a look” at her life.
I really enjoyed hearing Annie’s story and how it helped Marie to realize where God was leading her future. Gould did a great job of brining the two stories together while not allowing one to overshadow the other. The characters were well-developed.
I gave this book 5 stars and can’t wait to read the next chapter in the Bachmann sisters’ lives.
I received a copy of this novel from netgalley.com and Bethany House in return for my honest review.
August 18, 2018
A Simple Singing is the second book in The Sisters of Lancaster County written by Leslie Gould. I enjoyed this story very much and learned a lot by reading it. The story flashes back and forth between present day to the Civil War era. This story moves along at a good pace to keep the reader wanting more. The descriptions the author has given sets you in both time periods.
The characters are very likeable and realistic. I could identify with several of the characters but really liked Marie and Annie. They were both so much alike they could be twins. Marie to me was like Annie from centuries before her. Both of these young Amish women were at a crossroads in their lives trying to figure out the part that God and faith played in their lives. It will
surprise you the paths they each took to reach their goal. They are both strong, independent, loving young ladies. The characters really told a wonderful story.
I was not given a complimentary copy of this book to read and review. I was not approached by anyone to post a favorable review. I have rated this book with five stars because it has met my expectations of a wonderful story that I can highly recommend to others.
Congratulations to Leslie Gould for writing another fantastic story for her readers to enjoy. I am looking forward to the next book to continue the series.
The characters are very likeable and realistic. I could identify with several of the characters but really liked Marie and Annie. They were both so much alike they could be twins. Marie to me was like Annie from centuries before her. Both of these young Amish women were at a crossroads in their lives trying to figure out the part that God and faith played in their lives. It will
surprise you the paths they each took to reach their goal. They are both strong, independent, loving young ladies. The characters really told a wonderful story.
I was not given a complimentary copy of this book to read and review. I was not approached by anyone to post a favorable review. I have rated this book with five stars because it has met my expectations of a wonderful story that I can highly recommend to others.
Congratulations to Leslie Gould for writing another fantastic story for her readers to enjoy. I am looking forward to the next book to continue the series.
September 25, 2018
This second book in the Sisters of Lancaster series can certainly alone. I read the first so long ago I don’t remember much of the story, but it didn’t matter. Marie Bachmann is a strong character, with whom I could identify. She follows the rules and tries to keep others in line too. Yet she longs to marry Elijah, the bishop’s wayward son. She plans to stay Amish, unlike her sister and some others she knows. Could her family’s Mennonite farmhand, Gordon, change her mind? Marie accompanies her maiden aunt to Pinecraft, Florida, where life is more liberal than their home community in Lancaster. Gordon goes there to help in a homeless shelter, and Elijah works at a bakery there. Will the two men be in competition regarding Marie?
Music also plays a role in the story. Marie enjoys singings and is drawn to music in a way Amish should not take part. Can she reconcile the different pulls on her life and make wise choices? What is God’s will for her future? Interwoven in this contemporary tale is the story of Marie’s ancestors during the Civil War. We even get a glimpse of President Lincoln giving his Gettysburg Address. I enjoyed the thought-provoking novel and its insights into the past along with witnessing well-developed characters work through their struggles. I received a copy from the author. All opinions are my own.
Music also plays a role in the story. Marie enjoys singings and is drawn to music in a way Amish should not take part. Can she reconcile the different pulls on her life and make wise choices? What is God’s will for her future? Interwoven in this contemporary tale is the story of Marie’s ancestors during the Civil War. We even get a glimpse of President Lincoln giving his Gettysburg Address. I enjoyed the thought-provoking novel and its insights into the past along with witnessing well-developed characters work through their struggles. I received a copy from the author. All opinions are my own.
August 15, 2018
I would give this book 4.5 stars if I could. The depth of personal reflection and evaluation on the part of the main character were outstanding. The author writes the characters thoughts and feelings, struggles and victories, and inward transformation in such a way that makes you want to evaluate yourself. It’s genuine and real. The stream of thoughts throughout the book are so cohesive and well written. Loved the redemption, forgiveness, grace and mercy. Loved the transformation from legalism to grace. I could really relate to this being brought up in a legalistic church culture. The author described it so well without sounding preachy. And the transformation in the heart of Marie was great. I questioned the necessity of the time hop story of Annie. It just seemed like it should have been tied in better. I felt like it was a little forced. Both stories were well written I just didn’t particularly like how it was “oh let me tell you this story” all of a sudden. Other than that this was an excellent book. I loved it.
I received a copy of this book from netgalley. This has in no way influenced my review. All thoughts are my own.
I received a copy of this book from netgalley. This has in no way influenced my review. All thoughts are my own.
August 2, 2018
A Simple Singing ( The Sisters 0f Lancaster County-Book 2 )
By: Leslie Gould
A Simple Singing is book two in The Sisters of Lancaster County series by Leslie Gould. This is a great story from beginning to the end. It is almost like reading two stories in one. You cant wait to find out what happened in each one. It is like a time story, both where we follow ancestors and the modern day time. We read about slavery, and the homeless in this story. We have both the Amish and the Mennonites. I enjoyed learning more about the Mennonites. A young woman who has always been good and she has her life already mapped out like she thinks it will go. Does things always go the way we plan? I enjoyed A Simple Singing and cannot wait for book three in this series.
I was given a complimentary copy of this book by Bethany House Publishers , but was not told that I had to give positive review. All opinions are my own.
By: Leslie Gould
A Simple Singing is book two in The Sisters of Lancaster County series by Leslie Gould. This is a great story from beginning to the end. It is almost like reading two stories in one. You cant wait to find out what happened in each one. It is like a time story, both where we follow ancestors and the modern day time. We read about slavery, and the homeless in this story. We have both the Amish and the Mennonites. I enjoyed learning more about the Mennonites. A young woman who has always been good and she has her life already mapped out like she thinks it will go. Does things always go the way we plan? I enjoyed A Simple Singing and cannot wait for book three in this series.
I was given a complimentary copy of this book by Bethany House Publishers , but was not told that I had to give positive review. All opinions are my own.
September 8, 2018
Dual-time stories have become my favorite kind of stories to read! I was first introduced to dual-time stories in Leslie Gould's writing. Her most recent novel, A Simple Singing, is a beautifully written dual-time story.
Marie Bachmann has grown up always following the rules in her Amish Community. One day she will make an Amish man the perfect wife. After her Aunt shares with her a story about one of her ancestors that lived during the Civil War, things change, and Marie's future isn't as clear anymore.
Author Leslie Gould weaves a beautiful masterpiece in this story. There is much research that went into this fascinating novel. The characters experience circumstances that we can all relate to including grief, self-reflection, empathy, faith and love. A definite must-read!
I voluntarily reviewed a copy of this book from the author and publisher and have given my honest opinion.
Marie Bachmann has grown up always following the rules in her Amish Community. One day she will make an Amish man the perfect wife. After her Aunt shares with her a story about one of her ancestors that lived during the Civil War, things change, and Marie's future isn't as clear anymore.
Author Leslie Gould weaves a beautiful masterpiece in this story. There is much research that went into this fascinating novel. The characters experience circumstances that we can all relate to including grief, self-reflection, empathy, faith and love. A definite must-read!
I voluntarily reviewed a copy of this book from the author and publisher and have given my honest opinion.
August 4, 2018
When Leslie Gould writes a story about the Amish, she delivers so much more than a captivating tale. In addition to giving the reader likeable characters caught up in interesting plot lines, she engages our minds. In this book, I learned distinctions between Amish and Mennonite communities and was challenged to consider contemporary issues such as immigration in light of past issues such as the Civil War. Gould's main character was forced to recognize her own prideful religious legalism juxtaposed against her friend's Christlike love as worked out in Christian service...her judgmental attitudes versus his mercy. I liked this book a lot and recommend it wholeheartedly.
I received a complimentary copy of A Simple Singing from Bethany House Publishers with no strings attached.
I received a complimentary copy of A Simple Singing from Bethany House Publishers with no strings attached.
January 24, 2019
A Simple Singing, the second book in Leslie Gould's Sisters of Lancaster County series, is another really good Amish story.
There are some of the typical elements in an Amish romance -- a young Amish girl struggling with her feelings about more than one young man and how to make a decision that might involve her leaving the church. But this story is much more complex than that, including a story from Marie's family's past that may be of great help in her deciding what direction her future should take.
I highly recommend this engaging story to fans of great Amish fiction.
Thanks to the author and her publisher for providing a copy of A Simple Singing. I am happy to share my own thoughts in this review.
There are some of the typical elements in an Amish romance -- a young Amish girl struggling with her feelings about more than one young man and how to make a decision that might involve her leaving the church. But this story is much more complex than that, including a story from Marie's family's past that may be of great help in her deciding what direction her future should take.
I highly recommend this engaging story to fans of great Amish fiction.
Thanks to the author and her publisher for providing a copy of A Simple Singing. I am happy to share my own thoughts in this review.
August 9, 2018
A Simple Singing by Author Leslie Could is an awesome book. I probably could not write one word that someone else hasn't already written, so I will try to explain what this book means to me. This plot is intense with superb writing. I was awed by the characters seeming so real and how the author makes the transition between era's without you feeling anything was lost of any part of the book. To me, this is by far one of this author's greatest books. A Simple Singing is Book Two in The Sisters of Lancaster County series. I encourage you to read this novel.
I received a copy from the publisher, but was not required to review it. This review is one hundred percent my opinion.
I received a copy from the publisher, but was not required to review it. This review is one hundred percent my opinion.
September 16, 2018
I so enjoyed this sweet story of Miriam’s journey to love and faith. Leslie Gould has written a compelling story of how God can use disappointing circumstances to draw us to Himself and reveal things about our own character that we may never have seen before. This is a “split time” story shared with Annie, a young woman who also struggled with difficult circumstances caused by the Civil War. As Miriam learns more of Annie’s story, she begins to look at herself, her Amish life, and her beliefs in a new way. This is another great book by Leslie Gould.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
August 5, 2018
I received a copy of this book from the author, I was not required to give a favorable review. This is the second in this series and such a wonderful read. It gives a bit of history of the family and the tough choices that each woman in their time had to make. I have read many books by Leslie and am never surprised that she draws you into each of the characters and how they deal with the choices they have to make in their lives. It was interesting to see the thoughts of someone raised in such strong Amish belief to have to find her direction after so much time.
August 10, 2018
I really did enjoy reading this second book in the Sister of Lancaster County. This book focused on the middle daughter Marie, and featured two stories. One is current, and the other is during the Civil War. I love history so this was definitely a plus for me. I love the writing style of Ms. Gould as well. I just wish there was just a bit more romance. Overall, this is a wonderful story and I highly recommend to all Amish fiction readers.
*I was given a copy of this book by the publisher, and was under no obligation to leave a review. This is my honest opinion.
*I was given a copy of this book by the publisher, and was under no obligation to leave a review. This is my honest opinion.
May 30, 2019
Two stories intertwined finding love and life in today and in the civil war era.
Marie, the perfect Amish daughter, following everything to the ordinance, unhappy even though she does have a suitor. He follows her to Florida, and now enters another suitor. With her aunt telling of life in the civil war, slavery, Lincoln,and how life was. It spans from, Marie at 2013 to Anne in 1863, being in the same house. A touch of love, history, and decisions, will she have made when she returns. Given ARC by Fiction Guild- Thomas Nelson for my voluntary review and my honest opinion.
Marie, the perfect Amish daughter, following everything to the ordinance, unhappy even though she does have a suitor. He follows her to Florida, and now enters another suitor. With her aunt telling of life in the civil war, slavery, Lincoln,and how life was. It spans from, Marie at 2013 to Anne in 1863, being in the same house. A touch of love, history, and decisions, will she have made when she returns. Given ARC by Fiction Guild- Thomas Nelson for my voluntary review and my honest opinion.
October 30, 2018
Good read....as always
I am not a lover of Amish fiction. That being said, I have to say that Leslie Gould has the knack for writing about the Amish that doesn't feel “time consuming” to me. Most authors who pen Amish stories, in my opinion, totally bore me. I am happy to say that this author has not only caught my reading interest, but helps me to envision the life of these people in a whole new light. And the covers of her books are gorgeous. This story, like others before it, is a tale of faith, love and self-discovery. I highly recommend this book and all others by this author.
I am not a lover of Amish fiction. That being said, I have to say that Leslie Gould has the knack for writing about the Amish that doesn't feel “time consuming” to me. Most authors who pen Amish stories, in my opinion, totally bore me. I am happy to say that this author has not only caught my reading interest, but helps me to envision the life of these people in a whole new light. And the covers of her books are gorgeous. This story, like others before it, is a tale of faith, love and self-discovery. I highly recommend this book and all others by this author.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 60 reviews