3.5 stars
Contrary to what I expected going into this one, I actually quite liked Oblivion. Sure, it meanders a lot in terms of the plotting, it's over a 100 pages longer than it needs to be and it does get repetitive at some points, but I found the whole thing riveting for some reason.
I think that what hooked me about the novel is how different it is. Oblivion is edgy and bold and it went in directions that I did not expect it to and that I am sure not many authors would dare to go to. From the story to the characters, the author didn't shy away from rawness, brutality, ugliness and flaws, and that had an impact on me that I did not expect. Callie, our main character, is a perfect example of that. She is clearly disturbed, definitely not perfect, prone to making mistakes and sometimes unapologetic about it, but still not wholly unsympathetic and definitely not uninteresting. She was a strange brand of YA heroine, a flawed, broken one that definitely had me intrigued from beginning to end.
I found the way the author handled the romantic plot in the novel fascinating. I am used to authors glorifying first loves, sanctifying guys and bleaching away all the possible ugliness out of young love. It is all perfect and glorious and squeaky clean. That is not the case in Oblivion with Callie and the other two wheels in her love triangle, Elijah and John. In fact, this whole love triangle is a messy tangle of mistakes and terribly wrong reasons, a wreck for all intent and purposes, and yet still fascinating. I liked it because it was honest, brutally so, but honest nonetheless. It never tried to paint love as this saving grace, as this true, beautiful, pure thing that never gets confused or tarnished. Quite frankly, all the relationships in this novel were flawed, even ugly, and yet I never once doubted their existence. I honestly believed Callie and Elijah loved each other, sick as it was, and I actually believed Lindsey and Callie did love each other as sister, horrible as that relationship turned, all of which I find absolutely fascinating and which I consider a fairly great show of skill on the author's part. That doesn't mean I agree with some of the things that went down in this book, especially how quickly things got serious between John and Callie and definitely how the relationship between Lindsey and Callie developed, - especially the amount of slut shaming and mean girl drama -, but I can't say it didn't keep me interested or that it hurt in any way my feelings for the book.
The writing in this novel does need some getting used to. It's jerky, repetitive, disjointed at times and vague at others. There were times where I honestly got lost and had to go back and reread because I hadn't been able to understand what had happened at one point and had become relevant at another. But in the end, I think this added a believable quality to Callie's damaged psyche. I particularly liked how the graphomania was used, how it contributed to the mystery and helped develop the story. The story could've definitely unfurled faster than it did. The book takes quite a while to get anywhere and there was a point where it started to get very repetitive. I was also slightly disappointed by the fact that, in spite of the characters' efforts, the mystery kind of gets solved by itself,and there were admittedly some holes in the story or things that are left slightly and unconvincingly unexplained.
In the end, in spite of all its obvious flaws, I found myself oddly pleased with this one. I didn't expect to, not even when I was reading it; it wasn't until the end that it even hit me that I'd actually enjoyed the novel, but the truth is that the novel managed to mesmerize me somehow from beginning to end, and these days, that's not something I can easily ignore in spite of the novel's flaws. Eerie, disturbing and even somewhat brutal, Oblivion was a riveting book and a nice surprise for me. I can see where other readers would hate it, but I appreciate the author's boldness, the originality of the book and the rawness of it, regardless of its many flaws.