As anyone who has spent even a little time on my page knows, I studied for a time as a field archeologist, and currently work as an archivist and research. So I love a good dense bit of research writing. Unfortunately, I'm usually not looking for it when I pick up historical fiction.
While I appreciated that this story was attempting to impart a good deal of history and mathematics to the reader, the information felt very dumped, halting the story in its tracks for pages at a time. I also found the evidence the characters presented to be circumstantial at best.
It reminded me very much of an archeology course I took while studying in Belfast, NI. My professor told a story about a very specific type of settlement hut found only along the East coast of the Irish isle. She then asked the class what kind of reasons we could think of that these settlements were only along the coast. Fishing villages? Communities that kept to the coast for migratory purposes? Trading towns? She then showed us a modern map and said, Does anyone see this line right here? This is a highway. All of these towns were only discovered because of the pre-building rescue archeology.
Sometimes, it really is just our minds making up the connection.
I was also deeply disappointed to find that a shocking amount of the citations in this book were Wikipedia articles. Only. And not only that, many of them cited sections that were tagged with Citation Needed. That's not terribly impressive or thorough research.
I also felt a bit blindsided by the excessive discussions of religion in the book. While I appreciate the characters' position, I have always found attempts at finding a single confluence of religions through spirituality inevitably feels like mere erasure of minority religions. While core ethics may be the same, I don't want to be included in any overlap with Jesus or Christianity.
Overall, I wish there had been more focus on Ötzi as a man and less on everything that happened after his death.
If anyone has any more good archaeological remains-inspired historical fiction, send it my way.