Tony Stafford, a slippery eco-protester, is hired by a scheming Russian salmon farmer to batter his competitors. The Russian wants to keep his friends close but his anemones closer while Tony, rising to the bait, ditches his current girlfriend, Kim, for an old High School sole mate starring in panto. Cullen catches Kim while her wounds are raw. And when he finds a new salmon facility is secretly being built nearby, he casts around for the help of Big Paul. With the police trawling for suspects, Cullen hopes to smoke Tony out while Big Paul grills one of the Russian’s henchmen. Meanwhile a shoal of outrageous characters glimmer in the shallows and loom from the depths in this hilarious crime farce. Will Tony wriggle away or end up being hooked? And will his Russian paymaster get caught in the net? With Cullen and Big Paul any fin is possible. (Well, salmon had to say it!) This is the first book in the Cullen and Big Paul series, a criminally funny collection of novels and novellas. Each of the books is a standalone story and they can be read in any order.
In the interests of bias, I used to work with the author.
Cullen Me Softly. When someone chooses to self publish a novel there can be several reasons. A vanity project, a strong belief in the ethos of DIY which a great way to learn more by getting down to the guts of how publishing works and not wanting the hassle of sending it publishers and risking rejection. The main problem with with self publishing is that there isn't a professional editor involved to cut out the chaff and help the story flow.
The story is based in the world of salmon farming, murder, intrigue and suspense. It looked promising, but sadly it didn't live up to expectation. I can recognise that some of the characters are mash-ups and exaggerated elements of people the author has worked with. Tony on the other hand is inspired by the real life anti-salmon farming campaigner and some might say unhinged, Don Staniford. Go on, Google him, you know you want to. Cullen takes much influence from the thoughts and dry humour of the author himself. These factors helped keep my interest throughout the book, but was it enough?
The story feels lacking in places and bloated in others. Examples are, a liberal sprinkling of sex, which would be fine if it added something to the plot, or painted a clearer picture. I suspect it was done to show how awful a character Tony is, but humour doesn't always comes across well in writing. The author seems drawn into his fish related past, a lot descriptive emphasis on salmon farms, boats and related equipment, not all of which is necessary and could do with being pared back. This is where an editor is much needed, they'd also have caught several of the typos dotted throughout the book.
As for the plot, it's not that believable, not that it has to be, it has to hold our attention, which for me it didn't. Like panto, it's fairly weak, it's not clear why various things happen, or why the oligarch is intent on the fading Hollywood starlet, it's too focused on fish. More background into the characters, to show us why they behave the way they do would help. On the bright side there's a few good puns thrown in.
It is clear the author has put a lot of work into this, and it's a good effort. Nobody gets it right first time, though there are a few digs at the author's fishy past which impart the feeling that this is more of a therapeutic exercise that had culminated in a story.
I'd have given it an extra star for better editing, still there's hope for the next one. OH NO THERE ISN'T! OH YES THERE IS!
How do I class a "good read"? Keeps me entertained without me having to force myself to read it or feel tempted to bin it. (A "great read" is when I can't wait to get back to it). Where Seagulls Dare was a "good read". The ending came a bit suddenly and was a bit contrived, but OK.
I also thought that with the title being a play on "Where Eagles Dare", it would be a lot funnier, more of a spoof comedy read, which it wasn't.
Really enjoyed this novel and would recommend it to anyone who enjoys books that are engaging, make you smile and, sometimes, laugh out loud. As it is self-published, there are more typos than you would normally encounter in a commercial book but they are not distracting once you get into the story. Similar to a lot of Tom Sharpe's hilarious books, the humorous plot is complex and highly improbable. The main characters are good fun and there's plenty of action (of all categories). Good job Mr Farrer - looking forward to reading the follow up "A Fistful of Collars" and will also download for free your "Dirty Barry" novella - keep them coming!
Updated 2/2/2018 - Just discovered that the version I read was the first edition and that the typos have been corrected in the current version.
I wasn't quite sure about this book when I started to read it, but the story picked up and the characters became more engaging. Cartoon bad guys, eco-warrior gone wrong. eco-warrior doing right and a bit of romance thrown in. It was an OK read but I'm not sure I'll read the follow on.
I was gifted a copy of this book by the author, in return of a voluntary and honest review.
This book is a debut by this author, so there wasn't any history to rely on. What I will say is that the author should continue in his work, because he tells a really good tale.
The story is compact without unnecessary page-filler paragraphs that so many other writers seem to employ. There's a good 'Reader's Digest' version of the salmon farming industry, so the reader can understand the intricacies of the industry - which is the centrepiece of the story.
The story moves along nicely, and the intermingling of the various characters is very smooth. The characters themselves are terrific; criminals, greed, revenge, good guys, subtle romance and subtle humour. Caledonian surrounds, expressions and slang. (NB. Some reviewers have made comment regarding swearing etc. Ignore those reviewers. The swearing is there, but only occurs at appropriate times of the 400+ page book, depending on the character/s or circumstances.) An excellent Postscript that gives a wrap-up of all the characters after the main curtain falls - other authors should take note of using this tactic.
I chose to read this book as my local library had three titles, one I fancied, but reading in order. It was good, entertaining, but there were some bits let it down. There was a lot of description at the start of the book, lists of synonyms which felt like fillers. Sex scenes which didn’t really add to the story but give it some excitement. The number. Of. Times. The. Characters. Spoke. A. Word. At. A. Time. Still it was rounded up from a 2.5 so not all bad.
I’m now more versed on the salmon farming industry, every day schoolday. Although this is a Cullen & Big Paul series, these characters seemed to be minimal. Will I continue with the series, absolutely but at the moment only those on offer at the library.
I enjoyed this book. It reminded me of a Scottish version of Carl Hiaasen’s series set in the Florida keys which features a character called Skink (The character Cullen has the same eco- maverick credentials- capable of violence but good hearted at one with nature and a compelling hero). The Russians are comedy villains and violent bits cartoonish . Funny, with an eco message, scenic description, a love story on the side as well, with likeable characters. Looking forward to more by this author .
Slow starter - but in the end I couldn’t put the last half down.
Took me a while to get through the first half of the book - and to start to care about the characters in whatever funny way.
But then I got half way through and couldn’t wait to see the twists and turns. I’ve already bought the next in the series (although i wish there was more about the detective) and I look forward to seeing how Mark develops two of his characters!
The comparison to Carl Hiaasen is apt: odd characters, environmental hijinks, poetic justice. I would read more from Farrer.
This book is self-published, which is great in and of itself. But it could have used an editor. In addition to the typos and misprints in the text, there are overly detailed sections about the fish industry that could have been pared down. Still, I rated it on the story itself. Solid 3.5, rounded up.
Too much graphic violence and animal cruelty. Plus the one villain who most needs to be brought down is left for the next book in the series.
But I learned a lot about the salmon industry, and I really enjoyed Kim's clever repartee. Cullen is a mysterious protagonist as he doesn't appear very frequently, which is odd to me.
Glad that I did as it was very enjoyable. Starts a bit slowly but soon becomes quite gripping. Not as laugh out loud as Brookmyre but still very good. Will try more of the authors work.
Turned out better than the middle section of the story which just seemed to drag, not engaging me at all. The different characters are came crashing together, albeit in various parts of Scotland. Worth reading without being excellent.
I get it pulp fiction vibes; but it just wasn’t for me. It was cool having all of these obscure categories intersect but it just wasn’t for me. The writing style was very entertaining and the crack shot cast was fun. I won’t be reading any more books like this in the future.
This novel was my entry into the world of Mark Farrer's writing. Where Seagulls Dare mixes a tale about underhanded business dealings by a Russian oligarch wanting to corner the Scottish salmon market, with a story of a jilted lover, as well as introducing the central characters for Farrer's series of novels and novellas - Cullen and Big Paul. By the end of Where Seagulls Dare I was delighted to find more tales of Cullen and Big Paul are readily available.
Mildly amusing read. The author is clearly highly influenced by Carl Hiaasen but without quite the same level of skill in plotting and absurdity. I did read it to the end, although it was clear the direction the plot was heading. Not in a rush to read any more by this author.