I loved it. First, I was so ecstatic to find an urban fantasy novel with a male lead; not that it's a bad thing (far from it), but it's very difficult for me to find a UF book that doesn't center around a kick-ass heroine.
From the opening lines of the book, I started to get a very "Harry Dresden" feel, and I'm a big fan of Butcher's series. I've already recommended BFM to other fans in a Butcher group who are always looking for someone new to read about while the long wait for Peace Talks continues.
Anyway, Janzen is a reluctant hero. After being plucked from a rough childhood by his mentor, Zachariah, Janzen was studying to be an Artificer, someone who works with magic and runes and can create something new by combining this ability with ordinary objects. When his mentor, and the rest of their group, is killed, Janzen loses his way.
When the novel begins, it's five years after this great loss, and Janzen is simply gliding through life, making what he needs to keep himself and his dog fed and housed, but not doing anything to leave a mark on the world. Of course, this is when opportunity comes to almost slice him in the face. When a young woman and her father are attacked by an abominable denizen of the Abyss (a Hell-type level of the universe), Janzen has to become a hero, albeit a reluctant one.
The qualities I love in Janzen mirror what has pulled me in and kept me as a fan of Harry Dresden for the last 15 years. Even though there's some darkness and grit, Janzen has kindness and care for those around him. The man has a rescue dog, for God's sake. My big point is that he's a redeemable man; his biggest struggle is one that every ordinary person can connect to on some level- he's trying to keep his head above water and figure out who he is when he's lost a a big piece of the foundation of his life.
Is he perfect? No. Is he super suave and smooth? GOD, NO. But he's someone who's doing the best he can even though he's bloody, bruised, battered, and way out of his league. I can respect and love a character who shows the moxie and stubborn force of will that he does.
Along with Janzen, we get to meet Grove. Grove is one of the first characters I've "met" in awhile, especially in UF, who has an impairment. I really haven't run into deaf characters very often, and I liked that Davis gave us a hero who could be strong, steadfast, and brave even though he receives the world in a different way than many of us do. Instead of making Grove's deafness into a point of handicap or plot problem, we see Grove and Janzen working together to communicate and finding new ways to work with one another despite the unconventional dynamic.
Overall, the story was easy to follow, and had enough action and intrigue to keep my interest on its own. Davis's world is divided into four parts- the Abyss, the In-Between, the Veil, and the Earth as humans know it. He plays around with the ideas of emissaries and intermediaries whose job it is to observe but not interfere. Neutral entities who make Earth their home, but may not treat it as such. I've always found that an interesting concept, and I'm really curious how that will continue to play out after the events of BFM.
The end is bittersweet, but it opens the door for more Grove and Janzen, who finally seems ready to not only live up to the legacy of his mentor, but to forge his own path. I, for one, am very excited for the prospect of more. My only regret in reading this book now is that I have to wait to see what comes next!