This provocative book begins with a question about the Vietnam War. How is it, asks Robert D. Dean, that American policymakers--men who prided themselves on "hardheaded pragmatism" and shunned "fuzzy idealism"--could have committed the nation to such a ruinous, costly, and protracted war? The answer, he argues, lies not simply in the imperatives of anticommunist ideology or in any reasonable calculation of national interest. At least as decisive in determining the form and content of American Cold War foreign policy was the common background and shared values of its makers, especially their deeply ingrained sense of upper-class masculinity. Dean begins by examining the institutions that shaped the members of the U.S. foreign policy establishment--all-male prep schools, Ivy League universities, collegiate secret societies, and exclusive men's clubs--that instilled stoic ideals of competition, duty, and loyalty. Service in elite military units during World War II further reinforced this pattern of socialization, eventually creating an "imperial brotherhood" imbued with a common global vision. More than that, according to Dean, the commitment to tough-minded masculinity shared by these men encouraged the pursuit of policies that were aggressively interventionist abroad and intolerant of dissent at home. Applying his gendered analysis to the McCarthy era, Dean reveals how the purge of suspected homosexuals in the State Department not only paralleled the repression of the political left, but also reflected a bitter contest for power between the foreign policy elite and provincial Congressional conservatives. He then shows how issues of manliness similarly influenced the politics and policies of the Kennedy and Johnson administrations. Just as programs like the Peace Corps were grounded in ideals of masculine heroism, decisions about intervention in Vietnam were inextricably bound up with ideas about male strength and power. In the end, Dean makes a persuasive case that these elite constructions of male identity fundamentally shaped the course of American foreign policy during the early decades of the Cold War.
I enjoyed this book immensely, even though I have mixed feelings about some of the analysis. Dean sensibly argues that we cannot fully understand the foreign policy decisions of the Kennedy and LBJ administrations, especially with respect to Vietnam, without understanding the socialization and shared experiences of the generation of men in positions of power during the period.
Dean explores the education provided by American elite boarding schools, especially East coast schools, and the social environment of the Ivies with their exclusive clubs. He identifies a specific class within a specific generation as an object of study- men who matriculated through a small subset of elite boarding schools and Ivies, who served as junior officers in WWII, who held positions of some influence in the Truman administration, who lived through the Red and Lavender purges of the federal government, and who rose again to prominence in the Kennedy and Johnson administrations. Dean follows the individual careers of several policymakers of this generation and argues they shared a class identity and a belief in a particular model of leadership, the heroic, stoic, patrician man. Thus the Red and Lavender purges (which in Dean's narrative are inextricably entwined) were partisan but they were also class-based, a power play by largely Midwestern conservatives without elite educations who sought to unlock the patricians' hold on foreign policy in the Truman administration.
Through researching the specific case of Foreign Service Officer Charles Thayer, Dean teases out the class resentments on both sides of the purge, the so-called patricians and primitives. Some sort of normative heterosexuality (depending on who was judging, either monogamous marriage or marriage plus socially-sanctioned affairs) became linked with more abstract qualities of loyalty and patriotism and was weaponized to break the hold of the patricians over foreign policy. Real and valid concerns about Soviet intelligence operations were subverted by communist-hunters' fantastical assumptions about the prevalence of and security risk posed by homosexuals, on the one hand, and the real risks posed by other vulnerabilities that were not similarly investigated on the other. The case of Thayer, fired for fathering a child with a woman not his wife, is case in point- the FBI, State, and other components of the Red hunters resisted acknowledging the heterosexual nature of Thayer's offence because 1) heterosexual transgressions were by policy not treated as a security risk and 2) if Thayer wasn't believed to be a homosexual then his firing would look like what it was, namely an effort by conservative Congressional Republicans to embarrass political opponents in the State Department and the administration with the active collusion of Hoover's FBI, busy as always empire building at the expense of the proper and constitutional functioning of the U.S. government. Ethnic, class, and cultural resentments fueled the righteousness of of the Red hunters on the one side, and the utter contempt for them held by the targets of the investigations on the other.
Dean's book is best when he's recounting the specific details of Thayer's case, or the checkered wartime service of Kennedy, McCarthy, Johnson, and others who traded upon their WWII experiences (real, imagined, and staged) for later political capital. It's weaker when Dean moonlights in theory, and the narrative overall is blemished by his habit of putting nearly everything in ironic "scare quotes" to make it clear that he is not taken in by the apparently-sincerely held beliefs of the players he is chronicling. His choice to label his object of inquiry, his generation under study, the "imperial brotherhood" gives you a flavor of his own prejudices. Gregg Herken's The Georgetown Set: The Establishment Elite Who Waged--and Won--the Cold War does a better job of chronicling this generation from a more human perspective, capturing their blind sides and prejudices while still leaving to his subjects the dignity of being sincere and messy human beings, not socially constructed imperial automatons.
Still, despite its flaws, Dean does an important service in documenting the subtleties of the Red and Lavender scares and their impact on the State Department, especially the Foreign Service. Dean goes to the heart of the matter on page 131:
"[The White House and the Justice Department] understood that the battle with the congressional Right was as much about the production and control of secrets, including sexual secrets, as it was about the particular 'security risk' posed by the real or imagined 'deviance' of Charles Bohlen. In the context of the purge, control of the secrets meant leverage over the careers of powerful men, and, by extension, leverage over the policy decisions they made."
That the purges were about power, and control of power, and not about loyalty or counterintelligence is the key insight of this book. The consequences were manifold. Researchers have noted that the expulsion of the China hands left State devoid of area expertise much needed in the run-up to Vietnam. Dean expands upon this, pointing to the loss of many Soviet experts as well as the creation of a general climate of suspicion, demoralization, and quietism within the State Department. Alger Hiss was almost certainly a communist spy and the establishment's impulse to rally around its own was fateful. In the scheme of U.S. policymaking, however, Hiss was practically a nobody and the hundreds of subsequently purged or tainted State employees were almost certainly innocent, ranging from the Department's power players to people as insignificant in the scheme of things as Paul Child, Julia Child's husband. The human cost was extraordinary- Dean blithely mentions an unspecified number of State employees committed suicide upon being cashiered as homosexuals. Loyal Americans and public servants- I wish they had been named.
For one the book was just so dry when the content had the potential to be fascinating and captivating. And second the book is titled and suggests that it’s about the imperial brotherhood and gender in the 20th century but instead the author spends like half the book talking about all of the different ways and different people that were persecuted for being “homosexual”. There was superficial engagement with the relationship between sexuality, gender and masculinity. The book overall would have been more compelling if it focused on lavender persecution and what that meant for foreign policy or on the projection of masculinity under Kennedy and Johnson. As it stands it reads like a gossip rag throughout the middle.
An excellent commentary on the effects social gender norms can have on domestic and foreign policy. Less of an analysis, and more of a commentary on the masculine overtones exhibited during the era of Kennedy, Johnson, McCarthy and the purges, and the Vietnam war. Overall, a competent book. A bit meaty to read, but worth the read for anyone who is interested in the topic.