Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Romantic Comedy: Boy Meets Girl Meets Genre

Rate this book
Romantic Comedy offers an introduction to the analysis of a popular but overlooked film genre. The book provides an overview of Hollywood's romantic comedy conventions, examining iconography, narrative patterns, and ideology. Chapters discuss important subgroupings within the screwball sex comedy and the radical romantic comedy of the 1970s. A final chapter traces the lasting influence of these earlier forms within current romantic comedies. Films Pillow Talk (1959), Annie Hall (1977), and You've Got Mail (1998).

144 pages, Paperback

First published April 10, 2007

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Tamar Jeffers Mcdonald

13 books4 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
7 (15%)
4 stars
12 (26%)
3 stars
19 (42%)
2 stars
6 (13%)
1 star
1 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 4 of 4 reviews
Profile Image for E.
281 reviews4 followers
February 22, 2010
Man, I love this book. I knew there was an ideology behind romantic comedies--one that the typical dismissals neglected to address. A reason that I enjoy watching these films (from all decades) and also feel vaguely sickened when the films reach some neat conclusion. Very little has been written about romcoms (especially the past 20 years' worth), so this book is a real boon to anyone studying them.

Boy Meets Girl Meets Genre takes the reader through a whirlwind history of the romantic comedy: from the Screwballs of the '40s (20th Century), which expressed sexual tension through physical aggression of both male and female characters, on through the Sex Comedies of the '50s and early 60s (Pillow Talk), when Kinsey's report made women's sexual lives a topic of public debate, but film and social codes prohibited overt sex to be shown in films (at least and especially between unmarried couples), on through the Radical Romantic Comedy of the (late) '60s and 1970s, which upended the conventions of the romcom and questioned the assumption that a perfect traditional monogamous heterosexual pairing brings happiness, or that immediate sexual ease flows from desire (Annie Hall, Harold and Maude, An Unmarried Woman).

From around 1980-2002, the market was saturated by what McDonald calls the Neo-Traditional Romantic Comedy (such as You've Got Mail), a genre which considers sex immature and unimportant when compared to romantic love. These chaste and often insincere films evoke the trappings of previous decades of romcoms (and also recall romantic dramas) while perpetuating the same ideology of blissful, sexless, "perfect" romantic heterosexual pairings.

The book also touches briefly on what it calls the hommecom (ex: Hitch, The Wedding Crashers, Made of Honor, and Forgetting Sarah Marshall), which focus on male protagonists who desire--or come to desire--romance and love. While these films are more honest about sex and also re-reveal the fact that romcoms are intended as much for male audiences as for female audiences, the new hommecoms still tend to tow the neo-traditional line, suggesting that "perfect" heterosexual pairings are the key to happiness and completion.

The only films that continue to explore themes of the radical romantic comedies are gay and lesbian romcoms (ex: Kissing Jessica Stine), which often suggest that monogamous pairings may have limited longevity; however, Mcdonald quickly points out that this can lead to problematic readings, as the films can be seen to suggest that homosexual pairings cannot be successful or happy.

It's clear that Mcdonald would like to see a return to themes of the Radical Romantic Comedy and the incorporation of relevant material and characters that ground new romcoms in the present decade and include a variety of sexual and romantic modes, homosexual as well as heterosexual pairings, and (this is my own addition), more romance films featuring non-white characters.

The book would have been enriched by the exploration of African American romcoms (which are only mentioned in passing).
222 reviews9 followers
March 11, 2026
2.5

This book has dated fast.

It also started off quite limited with a very restrictive focus. It pays some lip service to recognising that not all Romantic Comedies are white, straight etc. but does nothing to investigate that and the many films created - key queer romantic comedies, the Black rom-coms of the 1990s etc.. A very limited 'canon' which therefore limits the insights given. Analysis is sometimes inconsistent and often biased. The author's disdain for various manifestations of the genre (and the 'romance' more generally) is often made painfully clear. As with all the other books I've read on Rom Coms, I can't help thinking that it would benefit from engagement with Romance scholarship, in which many of the debates and topics here addressed have been argued, theorised, and discussed by a range of critics with the kind of nuance this book doesn't achieve.
9 reviews
April 11, 2023
Read for class. Informative but not quite as fun as its subject. There is one throw away line about bustles (popular in the 1860s-1890s) in the movie Emma (based off of the Austen novel published in 1815) that irks me to no end.
Profile Image for E.H. Nolan.
Author 13 books13 followers
July 22, 2010
When you think of the romantic comedy genre, you don’t normally think of its subgenres, unless you’re a student or reading this book, of course. Tamar Jeffers McDonald gives an interesting analysis of the genre on the whole, as well as devoting sections to subcategories of sex comedies, screwball comedies, and others within the original genre.

I read this during my time as a film student, but it wasn’t required reading. It’s rather short—the meat of the book is around 100 pages—and is more of an introduction to this type of analysis and deconstruction of the romantic comedy genre, rather than the book of authority. If you’re thinking of dabbling in the world of film studies, this is a good book to start out with and see if you like that type of analysis.

http://hottoastyrag.weebly.com/romant...
Displaying 1 - 4 of 4 reviews