'Conflicts of Interest' is a collection of 7 essays on the environmental movement in India and the challenges that Ms. Narain faced as someone at the forefront of environmental journalism in India for over 30 years now. My introduction to Ms. Narain's work was through Down To Earth, the fortnightly magazine that CSE(Centre for Science and Environment) publishes on environmental, social, and developmental issues in India.
What's great about these collection of essays is the level of experience and concern that Ms. Narain brings to the table. She was involved herself in every single of these issues - Air quality of Delhi, Endosulfan contamination in Kasargod, Kerala, Pesticide traces in Coca-Cola and Pepsi, Climate Negotiations at the global level, Tiger Endangerment, Water Management, and finally a plan for the coming future. Major running themes across these issues were, well, the conflicts of interest between the government/corporations/local population&NGOs, the idea that policies and laws can substitute implementation, that development and environmentalism are contrasting ideas, and that local population can't be integrated into the solution. Ms. Narain has the right amount of authority to comment and explain the intricacies of all of them.
That's where the book falters for me too, for all of these issues are standalone books and 30 pages per essay do not do their granularity any justice. As much as Ms. Narain tries to get into details, some major aspect, like the solutions end up being generalized and that makes some of the essays dare I say, boring. I understand it must have been an editorial call to limit the length but it came at the cost of detail. I would love to read Ms. Narain's experiences in further detail because the adversarial position that she's put herself in, in order to stand up for the environment, is not an easy thing to do.