Wow.
This was... such a beautiful read. I adore Milford's other books, and Greenglass House is one of my favorite books of all time. I didn't expect to love this one as much as I did Greenglass House -- since I always have trouble connecting to new main characters and new time periods in the same world -- but this book blew me away. It is not the same as Greenglass House, but in a very, very good way. It takes place in the 1800s (I think? I may have to double check that I've gotten the time period right!) and it follows Lucy Bluecrowne, a girl who has practically spent her whole life on her father's ship, The Left-Handed Fate (which is a brilliant name, by the way) and now must begin a new life ashore with her stepmother and half brother. But two nefarious strangers, Trigemine and Blister, identify her brother as the pyrotechnic genius they need for whatever evil plan Morvengarde has cooked up, and now Lucy must fight to save her brother and keep her family together.
Gosh. The characters. What can I say about them? Lucy is such a relatable character. She has such a fierce, fighting spirit, which I always love in middle-grade characters, and I absolutely love the relationship she has with her half brother and stepmother!! While Lucy and I aren't that much alike, I was still able to slip right into her mind and really understand her. Her brother, Liao, is such a wonderful character as well!! He is relatable, mischievous, kind, and the two of them are a fantastic duo! And his fireworks!!! I loved the addition of pyrotechnics in this story, and I really admire how Milford is able to weave together magic and science and history and the real world! I also loved the relationship Lucy had with Xiaoming (her step mother). I feel like a lot of the times, in stories, the stepmother is always this evil villainess who absolutely hates her stepdaughter... Which did not happen here, actually, and there's just this wonderful family love between the two of them! Though they may still be a tad distant, there's still that love and connection between the two, and which I really liked.
Also, what happened to Xiaoming....
😭😭😭
On one hand, she is such a beautiful character and it was wonderfully written and I just love her so much. On the other, it is so heartbreaking. I really hope we see more of her in a future book!!! 🥺 She's just... so wonderful.
I'm not entirely certain how accurate the Chinese characters (and by that I mean the writing system, not book characters) in this book are. However, my own Mandarin isn't the best, and I don't think those words (especially surrounding pyrotechnics and alchemy and immortal beings) would be used all that often in real life anyway, so... 🤷♀️ And there are a few curse words smattered throughout. Mostly just "damn" from the nefarious characters, though there was one stronger word from Lucy after she burned herself trying to make tea. It did not put me too off, as they were few and far between, but it's something you might want to keep in mind. And some bits of pyrotechnics and alchemy that were discussed, I... kind of just ignored, because I don't understand pyrotechnics or alchemy at all. XD
I did, however, quite like how this book has the POVs of the adult characters!! It is something that you really won't see in so many modern middle-grade novels, which is a pity. I get the reasons for it, but it was so intriguing getting to see parts of the story from the villain's POV. It gave you a lot more information on what was going on, who they really were, and what their plans were!
Overall, this is an absolutely brilliant book that is both beautiful and heartbreaking. I'd highly recommend it to anyone who's a fan of Kate Milford's other books, who might be looking for a middle-grade read with lots of deep and complex plot threads. Five out of five stars from me. (Also, it is very rare that I write a long Goodreads review for any book!! I only ever write such long reviews if I really, really adore the book.)