Before a friend sent me this book, I had briefly come across the bullet journal concept before and been intrigued. As I love diaries, lists, tidiness, and notebooks, the appeal was obvious. This book certainly makes a strong case for bullet journals as an organisational tool. The argument for them as an artistic outlet is less effective, although the examples shown are certainly pretty. I was most interested in the mentions of bullet journals as a return to the diary norms of hundreds of years ago. Before the self-reflective, individualistic turn of modern times, a diary was apparently more likely to consist of short lists of events for family reference. I liked this deliberate effort to connect a new and trendy phenomenon to the past. Although the writing style was very bloggy, which I don't mean to sound as patronising as it probably does, the book discusses a lot of helpful material. How to set up a bullet journal, why this approach can be useful, and a range of ways to customise it to specific needs are covered well. The copious illustrations support the text nicely, and make for a quick and pleasant read. Only in the section about pens does it morph entirely into a stationary catalogue.
While 'How to Bullet Plan' certainly sold me on bullet journals in principle, in practise I'm less convinced. Reading it made me realise that at the moment I make daily use of no less than four diaries: a work diary in outlook, a handbag diary that I use to plan my non-work life, a small notebook tracking health, and a chunky journal of daily reflections on whatever I'm doing and thinking about. The idea of consolidating all of them into a single notebook of bullet points is intimidating, to say the least. While four diaries does seem excessive and was definitely not planned, it also reflects a compartmentalisation of different elements of my life. When writing in my reflective diary before going to sleep, I don't want to think about all the bullshit tasks I have to do the next day. Conversely, I wouldn't want to drag a compendium of personal thoughts around in my bag all the time. The bullet journal approach has potential to replace my work, life planning, and health diaries, but not the reflective one. When re-reading my old diaries (which I've been keeping on and off in various forms since the age of 13), I find the longform reflective stuff most interesting and thought-provoking, not the lists of mundane tasks I had to do. I recently rediscovered some diaries from 2011 and found reading them quite an intense experience, intermittently hilarious or upsetting. Thus I agree with Wilkerson Miller about storing old journals for future reference, but do not think a bullet journal could ever totally replace my diaries. While I love making to do lists, I also love rambling about last night's dreams at length. I'm not sure whether the two could or should co-exist in the same notebook. The tracking boxes are really neat, though.