What do you think?
Rate this book
همهی شما زامبیها
ع مخاطب «همهی شما زامبیها» توصیف فشردهی راوی داستان را در مورد زمان روایت که در یک منطقهی «مکان – زمانی» گمانهزنی شده (منطقه زمانی شماره 5 – زمان مناطق شرقی) میگذرد،
22 pages, ebook
First published March 1, 1959
211 people are currently reading
5495 people want to read
About the author
Robert A. Heinlein
1,053 books10.5k followersRobert Anson Heinlein was an American science fiction author, aeronautical engineer, and naval officer. Sometimes called the "dean of science fiction writers", he was among the first to emphasize scientific accuracy in his fiction, and was thus a pioneer of the subgenre of hard science fiction. His published works, both fiction and non-fiction, express admiration for competence and emphasize the value of critical thinking. His plots often posed provocative situations which challenged conventional social mores. His work continues to have an influence on the science-fiction genre, and on modern culture more generally.
Heinlein became one of the first American science-fiction writers to break into mainstream magazines such as The Saturday Evening Post in the late 1940s. He was one of the best-selling science-fiction novelists for many decades, and he, Isaac Asimov, and Arthur C. Clarke are often considered the "Big Three" of English-language science fiction authors. Notable Heinlein works include Stranger in a Strange Land, Starship Troopers (which helped mold the space marine and mecha archetypes) and The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress. His work sometimes had controversial aspects, such as plural marriage in The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress, militarism in Starship Troopers and technologically competent women characters who were formidable, yet often stereotypically feminine—such as Friday.
Heinlein used his science fiction as a way to explore provocative social and political ideas and to speculate how progress in science and engineering might shape the future of politics, race, religion, and sex. Within the framework of his science-fiction stories, Heinlein repeatedly addressed certain social themes: the importance of individual liberty and self-reliance, the nature of sexual relationships, the obligation individuals owe to their societies, the influence of organized religion on culture and government, and the tendency of society to repress nonconformist thought. He also speculated on the influence of space travel on human cultural practices.
Heinlein was named the first Science Fiction Writers Grand Master in 1974. Four of his novels won Hugo Awards. In addition, fifty years after publication, seven of his works were awarded "Retro Hugos"—awards given retrospectively for works that were published before the Hugo Awards came into existence. In his fiction, Heinlein coined terms that have become part of the English language, including grok, waldo and speculative fiction, as well as popularizing existing terms like "TANSTAAFL", "pay it forward", and "space marine". He also anticipated mechanical computer-aided design with "Drafting Dan" and described a modern version of a waterbed in his novel Beyond This Horizon.
Also wrote under Pen names: Anson McDonald, Lyle Monroe, Caleb Saunders, John Riverside and Simon York.
Heinlein became one of the first American science-fiction writers to break into mainstream magazines such as The Saturday Evening Post in the late 1940s. He was one of the best-selling science-fiction novelists for many decades, and he, Isaac Asimov, and Arthur C. Clarke are often considered the "Big Three" of English-language science fiction authors. Notable Heinlein works include Stranger in a Strange Land, Starship Troopers (which helped mold the space marine and mecha archetypes) and The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress. His work sometimes had controversial aspects, such as plural marriage in The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress, militarism in Starship Troopers and technologically competent women characters who were formidable, yet often stereotypically feminine—such as Friday.
Heinlein used his science fiction as a way to explore provocative social and political ideas and to speculate how progress in science and engineering might shape the future of politics, race, religion, and sex. Within the framework of his science-fiction stories, Heinlein repeatedly addressed certain social themes: the importance of individual liberty and self-reliance, the nature of sexual relationships, the obligation individuals owe to their societies, the influence of organized religion on culture and government, and the tendency of society to repress nonconformist thought. He also speculated on the influence of space travel on human cultural practices.
Heinlein was named the first Science Fiction Writers Grand Master in 1974. Four of his novels won Hugo Awards. In addition, fifty years after publication, seven of his works were awarded "Retro Hugos"—awards given retrospectively for works that were published before the Hugo Awards came into existence. In his fiction, Heinlein coined terms that have become part of the English language, including grok, waldo and speculative fiction, as well as popularizing existing terms like "TANSTAAFL", "pay it forward", and "space marine". He also anticipated mechanical computer-aided design with "Drafting Dan" and described a modern version of a waterbed in his novel Beyond This Horizon.
Also wrote under Pen names: Anson McDonald, Lyle Monroe, Caleb Saunders, John Riverside and Simon York.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 831 reviews
February 1, 2018
Just as the limerick, “There once was a man from Nantucket –“ is the foulest yet most recognized of all, and just as the classic “Why did the chicken cross the road?” is the best joke, so is Robert A. Heinlein’s “All You Zombies-“ it is hands down the best time travel short story.
Published in 1960, a reader and fan can see the early ideas for Time Enough for Love and I Will Fear No Evil. Was Heinlein a dirty old man? Yes, and in 1960, at the still young age of 53, he was just learning to fill out his garter and stockings.
I love the time travel section of the science fiction / fantasy genre. I love the weird ones, the quizzical ones and the ones you just can’t figure out. I love the good (H.G. Wells classic The Time Machine), the bad (Piers Anthony’s Bearing An Hourglass) and the ugly (Heinlein’s own Time Enough for Love). Poul Anderson’s many adventures in time needs special mention.
But for a short story to pack a lot into a small package, “All You Zombies-“ wins the prize.
Published in 1960, a reader and fan can see the early ideas for Time Enough for Love and I Will Fear No Evil. Was Heinlein a dirty old man? Yes, and in 1960, at the still young age of 53, he was just learning to fill out his garter and stockings.
I love the time travel section of the science fiction / fantasy genre. I love the weird ones, the quizzical ones and the ones you just can’t figure out. I love the good (H.G. Wells classic The Time Machine), the bad (Piers Anthony’s Bearing An Hourglass) and the ugly (Heinlein’s own Time Enough for Love). Poul Anderson’s many adventures in time needs special mention.
But for a short story to pack a lot into a small package, “All You Zombies-“ wins the prize.
July 5, 2015
Why does the English language still not contain a word meaning "to have sex with an earlier or later version of yourself, using a time machine"? I'm baffled.
_________________________________
Inspired by Ivonne's new word, I present a couple of extracts from All You Heinleiners, which I am reliably informed will be the big indie hit of 2021:
- Why, you heinleining little bitch! I should put you over my knee and spank you!
- You do that, big boy. And remember, you're going to enjoy it twice.
- Twice?
- Three times if the guy watching us is who I think he is.
******************************
- Son, we need to have a serious talk. There's things I gotta tell you.
- Yes Dad.
- Look son, you think you're a big hit with the ladies. But they're all like that. They've been heinleinin' you, each and every one of them.
- Well Dad, I was starting to wonder about it too. And I thought... okay, so what if they are?
- Son, you're saying it doesn't matter if they're all you?
- Yeah, why should it?
- You know, they're all Mom as well. That doesn't bother you?
- Nope.
- And they're all Grandma.
- So?
- Jeez, it's like I'm talking to myself here.
- You are talking to yourself.
- Don't get smart with me, kid.
_________________________________
Inspired by Ivonne's new word, I present a couple of extracts from All You Heinleiners, which I am reliably informed will be the big indie hit of 2021:
- Why, you heinleining little bitch! I should put you over my knee and spank you!
- You do that, big boy. And remember, you're going to enjoy it twice.
- Twice?
- Three times if the guy watching us is who I think he is.
******************************
- Son, we need to have a serious talk. There's things I gotta tell you.
- Yes Dad.
- Look son, you think you're a big hit with the ladies. But they're all like that. They've been heinleinin' you, each and every one of them.
- Well Dad, I was starting to wonder about it too. And I thought... okay, so what if they are?
- Son, you're saying it doesn't matter if they're all you?
- Yeah, why should it?
- You know, they're all Mom as well. That doesn't bother you?
- Nope.
- And they're all Grandma.
- So?
- Jeez, it's like I'm talking to myself here.
- You are talking to yourself.
- Don't get smart with me, kid.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
October 21, 2019
Never an Episode of Star Trek...
... And why not? Consciousness creates itself according to Heinlein. Forget about the mythical divine genesis stuff or that Darwinian evolution bunk. This is the real thing, the theory with oomph: time travel comes with the Homo sapiens territory, at least for the ones who can hack it (it’s the rest who are zombies). The perks are pretty spectacular - picking when and where you’re born for a start. And none of the neurotic consequences of family life. Literally no one to blame but yourself. Puts an entirely new perspective on the idea of solitary sex. Must have knocked their socks off in 1959. It’s still a bit of a whiz-bang. That’s probably why not.
... And why not? Consciousness creates itself according to Heinlein. Forget about the mythical divine genesis stuff or that Darwinian evolution bunk. This is the real thing, the theory with oomph: time travel comes with the Homo sapiens territory, at least for the ones who can hack it (it’s the rest who are zombies). The perks are pretty spectacular - picking when and where you’re born for a start. And none of the neurotic consequences of family life. Literally no one to blame but yourself. Puts an entirely new perspective on the idea of solitary sex. Must have knocked their socks off in 1959. It’s still a bit of a whiz-bang. That’s probably why not.
March 7, 2012
I'm speechless!
March 11, 2023
5/5⭐
¡Madre del amor hermoso! ¡Y me lo quería yo perder! Siempre digo que los relatos cortos no son para mí, pero este es sencillamente perfecto. Imposible hacerlo mejor. Qué 50 páginas más bien logradas. No lo concibo como una historia más larga. Es verdad que, dentro de la CF, los viajes en el tiempo son mi debilidad, pero este es de lectura obligada. Me ha dejado con más ganas de Heinlein.
Recomendable 100%.
¡Madre del amor hermoso! ¡Y me lo quería yo perder! Siempre digo que los relatos cortos no son para mí, pero este es sencillamente perfecto. Imposible hacerlo mejor. Qué 50 páginas más bien logradas. No lo concibo como una historia más larga. Es verdad que, dentro de la CF, los viajes en el tiempo son mi debilidad, pero este es de lectura obligada. Me ha dejado con más ganas de Heinlein.
Recomendable 100%.
January 5, 2022
Pequeña joya sobre los viajes en el tiempo y sus paradojas, genial!!
Te armas un cacao de muy señor mío jajaja
#18. El libro más corto de tu lista de pendientes de goodreads. Reto literario lecturas pendientes 2022
Te armas un cacao de muy señor mío jajaja
#18. El libro más corto de tu lista de pendientes de goodreads. Reto literario lecturas pendientes 2022
January 23, 2021
Me acaba de explotar la cabeza 🤯. ¡Qué locura tan maravillosa!
El tema de los viajes en el tiempo siempre será algo que me fascine, y en este relato es simplemente... INCREIBLE. El autor juega con las paradojas de forma brillante.
Hasta el final no se sabe exactamente que narices pasa, pero todo tiene sentido al final... O no. La verdad es que hay que pensar un poco (bastante) en lo que se revela al final.
Una genialidad.
El tema de los viajes en el tiempo siempre será algo que me fascine, y en este relato es simplemente... INCREIBLE. El autor juega con las paradojas de forma brillante.
Hasta el final no se sabe exactamente que narices pasa, pero todo tiene sentido al final... O no. La verdad es que hay que pensar un poco (bastante) en lo que se revela al final.
Una genialidad.
February 1, 2024
Lo he tenido que leer dos veces y estudiarme los diagramas, pero ya me hago una idea... Mientras lo digiero y puedo preparar una reseña, diré que me ha parecido una novela muy entretenida, ingeniosa y curiosa, aunque me temo que choca bastante con mi idea de los desplazamientos temporales.
July 5, 2015
A man walks into a bar. (Hah.) He gets into a conversation with the bartender, who wears a ring shaped like the worm Ouroboros. The barkeep is actually a "temporal agent." (What that means is revealed over the course of the story.)
The two men talk of many things: writing "true confession" stories, love lives, cads who love em' and leave em'... It turns out the guy at the bar is intersex (born with both sex organs, raised as a woman but now a man). Introduce time travel and a paradox or three and you've got a short story guaranteed to make your brain whirl.
Heinlein was imaginative and brilliant but some of his viewpoints about free love, incest, etc., were pretty screwy. 1960, when this short story was written, is about the time Heinlein started really exploring these ideas in his fiction. Combine that with his outdated views about sexual stereotypes--in particular, in this story, astronauts are men, and any women who are interested in space can aspire to join the "Space Angels" group and become glorified hookers--and you've got a really weird backdrop to an otherwise intriguing exploration of time travel paradoxes.
You can read a copy of this story online here.
The two men talk of many things: writing "true confession" stories, love lives, cads who love em' and leave em'... It turns out the guy at the bar is intersex (born with both sex organs, raised as a woman but now a man). Introduce time travel and a paradox or three and you've got a short story guaranteed to make your brain whirl.
Heinlein was imaginative and brilliant but some of his viewpoints about free love, incest, etc., were pretty screwy. 1960, when this short story was written, is about the time Heinlein started really exploring these ideas in his fiction. Combine that with his outdated views about sexual stereotypes--in particular, in this story, astronauts are men, and any women who are interested in space can aspire to join the "Space Angels" group and become glorified hookers--and you've got a really weird backdrop to an otherwise intriguing exploration of time travel paradoxes.
You can read a copy of this story online here.
January 17, 2022
Todos ustedes, zombies (1958) es un relato bastante recomendado del prolífico autor de Ciencia Ficción, Robert A. Heinlein (1907-1988). Una historia original y compleja a pesar de su brevedad. Aborda el tema de los viajes en el tiempo y las paradojas que pueden provocar.
Aparte de la propia paradoja, el resto de los elementos son ya por sí mismos surrealistas. También me ha parecido atrevido el tema de género que plantea (aunque sea necesario para la historia) teniendo en cuenta el año en que fue escrito: 1958.
No es una relato fácil de entender. Al principio parece una historia normal, que da la sensación que introduce una trama demasiado compleja para la extensión que tiene el cuento, pero al final, Heinlein la resuelve de un modo totalmente inesperado.
Realmente el final consigue desconcertarte y no tuve más remedio que volver a leerlo (lo digo sin vergüenza, no me enteré de nada). Aunque no es grave, solo son 22 páginas. No debo ser un caso raro, porque al final del texto aparecen dos diagramas explicativos.
Todos ustedes, zombies (el título no ayuda mucho) me ha resultado audaz y sorprendente, pero lo recomiendo solamente para aquellos a quienes no les importe “comerse el coco” durante un buen rato. Además, creo que hay una película basada en él.
Aparte de la propia paradoja, el resto de los elementos son ya por sí mismos surrealistas. También me ha parecido atrevido el tema de género que plantea (aunque sea necesario para la historia) teniendo en cuenta el año en que fue escrito: 1958.
No es una relato fácil de entender. Al principio parece una historia normal, que da la sensación que introduce una trama demasiado compleja para la extensión que tiene el cuento, pero al final, Heinlein la resuelve de un modo totalmente inesperado.
Realmente el final consigue desconcertarte y no tuve más remedio que volver a leerlo (lo digo sin vergüenza, no me enteré de nada). Aunque no es grave, solo son 22 páginas. No debo ser un caso raro, porque al final del texto aparecen dos diagramas explicativos.
Todos ustedes, zombies (el título no ayuda mucho) me ha resultado audaz y sorprendente, pero lo recomiendo solamente para aquellos a quienes no les importe “comerse el coco” durante un buen rato. Además, creo que hay una película basada en él.
Read
March 7, 2023Sin valorar por incapacidad.
Mi no entender casi nada
Cómo buen microbiólogo, el proceso paradójico de creación de la vida no me ha llegado. ¿Cómo empieza el bucle? ¿Quién va antes el huevo o la gallina?
Renuncio a las paradojas, he dicho.
Mi no entender casi nada
Cómo buen microbiólogo, el proceso paradójico de creación de la vida no me ha llegado. ¿Cómo empieza el bucle? ¿Quién va antes el huevo o la gallina?
Renuncio a las paradojas, he dicho.
January 22, 2019
I’m not really into too many short stories or Zombie sci fi ones at that!
However I did see a comedy British film with Zombies in it, does that count?
Anyways, this is a bartender travelling thingy as well.
It only took me half an hour to read.
Why did I read it?
Because my two grown adult children said the film came out in 2014 and I should watch it. They think I’ll enjoy it.
Not sure!
But I’ll give it a go
However I did see a comedy British film with Zombies in it, does that count?
Anyways, this is a bartender travelling thingy as well.
It only took me half an hour to read.
Why did I read it?
Because my two grown adult children said the film came out in 2014 and I should watch it. They think I’ll enjoy it.
Not sure!
But I’ll give it a go
June 2, 2018
Re-read 6/2/18:
Nostalgia hits again. :) Thinking about doing a lot more Heinlein reads fairly soon. :)
Original Review:
I had to reread this after just watching Predestination on which it was based. I was impressed with the movie but even more so with the story. I guess I picked up more nuances this time. It was all the more impressive because of how the character study really played out and what wasn't said but could be deduced. I think I can thank the movie more for that aspect, although one storyline hadn't existed in the short story.
Even so, very impressive ideas and a minimalist style that was so understated that I'm not too surprised I missed it the first time. Preferred some of his other short stories more, but maybe I need to revisit them all and see how my grown-up-self takes them.
What can I say? It was tight and impactive and so very easy to see how it informed the later third of his novels in both strangeness and, dare I say it, incestuousness? Absolutely, but I'm of a mind that Heinlein is still the Grandmaster and should retain the title forever, regardless of the kinds of stunts he has been known to play. After all, he's not merely informative and didactic. He's one hell of a storyteller.
Nostalgia hits again. :) Thinking about doing a lot more Heinlein reads fairly soon. :)
Original Review:
I had to reread this after just watching Predestination on which it was based. I was impressed with the movie but even more so with the story. I guess I picked up more nuances this time. It was all the more impressive because of how the character study really played out and what wasn't said but could be deduced. I think I can thank the movie more for that aspect, although one storyline hadn't existed in the short story.
Even so, very impressive ideas and a minimalist style that was so understated that I'm not too surprised I missed it the first time. Preferred some of his other short stories more, but maybe I need to revisit them all and see how my grown-up-self takes them.
What can I say? It was tight and impactive and so very easy to see how it informed the later third of his novels in both strangeness and, dare I say it, incestuousness? Absolutely, but I'm of a mind that Heinlein is still the Grandmaster and should retain the title forever, regardless of the kinds of stunts he has been known to play. After all, he's not merely informative and didactic. He's one hell of a storyteller.
May 27, 2022
Ow! My brain hurts! This is a short story of 13 pages, featuring a time traveller, which I read because it was recommended in another book I just finished, Time: 10 Things You Should Know. Once you've read it, you'll spend longer trying to work out the lead character's timeline than you did actually reading the story. It's an illustration of why it's a good thing that we can't really travel in time. If we could then the psychological ramifications would leave us all as a bunch of gibbering idiots.
One thing is that the story is pretty dated in the way it envisages gender roles. Then again it was written in 1958, or maybe it was written in 2058.
One thing is that the story is pretty dated in the way it envisages gender roles. Then again it was written in 1958, or maybe it was written in 2058.
January 18, 2019
Next up on my Book then Movie list was this 1950’s short story that was later adapted into Predestination in 2014.
This Sci-Fi time travelling paradox was so bizarre that even at its modest page count really makes an impact.
It’s the type of story that I really enjoy!
The story starts with a young man walking into a bar and strikes up a conversation with the time-traveling bartender.
The reader soon learns how the two are connected and the significance of snake-swallowing-his-tail ring on the barkeep's finger.
I’m sure this story is going to leave a lasting impression on me, I find the best movie adaptations are based on short stories as there’s room to expand the narrative.
It’s a really quick half hour read, excited to watch the movie now!
This Sci-Fi time travelling paradox was so bizarre that even at its modest page count really makes an impact.
It’s the type of story that I really enjoy!
The story starts with a young man walking into a bar and strikes up a conversation with the time-traveling bartender.
The reader soon learns how the two are connected and the significance of snake-swallowing-his-tail ring on the barkeep's finger.
I’m sure this story is going to leave a lasting impression on me, I find the best movie adaptations are based on short stories as there’s room to expand the narrative.
It’s a really quick half hour read, excited to watch the movie now!
December 1, 2014
simply mind blowing, one of the most unusual and thought-provoking stories I've read this year!
May 11, 2018
An uber meta time travel short in which I, the reader, get mind-fucked.
January 10, 2022
Cualquier historia que comienza en un bar ya empieza con buen pie. Heinlein nos presenta en pocas páginas un puzzle extraordinario, un relato muy bien hilado. Es difícil hablar sobre él sin destriparlo, así que se queda tal cual.
July 31, 2014
This is a time paradox story. It's not specifically *about* gender, but Heinlein's deeply sexist assumptions about how gender affects personality and his assumptions about how even a future society's sexism will not change in any way, are fully on display here. (In the future, women don't become 'spacemen,' they are sent to be 'comfort women' for lonely spacemen who can't control their 'urges.' The possibility of a woman being a competent astronaut isn't even considered.) Ugh.
I didn't find the ramifications of the time-travel dilemma, as presented here, as interesting or 'mind-blowing' as other readers have.
PS, there are no zombies in this story. (not that the fact makes it a better or worse story, but if you're a zombie fiction completist, it's just something to be aware of...)
[Just a note: I read this story directly after reading an editor's note complaining that Heinlein's writing is often dismissed due to its supposed misogyny (a charge, he implied, which is untrue and unfair) - so that probably caused me to be more alert to the topic that I might've been otherwise.]
I didn't find the ramifications of the time-travel dilemma, as presented here, as interesting or 'mind-blowing' as other readers have.
PS, there are no zombies in this story. (not that the fact makes it a better or worse story, but if you're a zombie fiction completist, it's just something to be aware of...)
[Just a note: I read this story directly after reading an editor's note complaining that Heinlein's writing is often dismissed due to its supposed misogyny (a charge, he implied, which is untrue and unfair) - so that probably caused me to be more alert to the topic that I might've been otherwise.]
February 11, 2023
Relato corto pero muy bien escrito. Es una maravilla como en tan pocas páginas consigue hacer algo tan completo y tan enrevesado.
Para coger todos los detalles es recomendable leerlo un par de veces al menos, puesto que aunque en una primera lectura se entienda bien con la segunda pillarás todos los detalles que se entienden así mejor.
La trama en spoiler, que es gordo además
Muy recomendable ver también la peli que lo adapta, aunque hay un añadido de trama es realmente buena también.
Para coger todos los detalles es recomendable leerlo un par de veces al menos, puesto que aunque en una primera lectura se entienda bien con la segunda pillarás todos los detalles que se entienden así mejor.
La trama en spoiler, que es gordo además
Muy recomendable ver también la peli que lo adapta, aunque hay un añadido de trama es realmente buena también.
January 3, 2016
I stumbled upon this short story by legendary Sci-Fi writer Robert A. Heinlein thanks to its movie adaptation (that came out recently and which I happened to watch just last week): Predestination, starring Ethan Hawke as the time-travelling Temporal Agent.
I have always been fascinated by the Time-travel genre, but this was simply mind-fuck of the highest order! O.O
I have always been fascinated by the Time-travel genre, but this was simply mind-fuck of the highest order! O.O
December 19, 2022
“‘Oh, that.’ I showed it to him.’ It just looks like a wedding ring; I wear it to keep women off.’ It is an antique I bought in 1985 from a fellow operative — he had fetched it from pre–Christian Crete. ‘The Worm Ouroboros... the World Snake that eats its own tail, forever without end. A symbol of the Great Paradox.’”
All You Zombies is a very interesting short story involving time travel. It starts with a bartender working in a bar and a man, let’s call him The Unmarried Mother, walking inside. A drink is poured for The Unmarried Mother and all we know is that for some unknown reason the bartender wants to recruit him for some other unknown business.
This is both a clever and weird story, with its implications of causality and the order of events involved during time travel. There isn’t much more that can be said without spoiling the story itself.
All You Zombies is a very interesting short story involving time travel. It starts with a bartender working in a bar and a man, let’s call him The Unmarried Mother, walking inside. A drink is poured for The Unmarried Mother and all we know is that for some unknown reason the bartender wants to recruit him for some other unknown business.
This is both a clever and weird story, with its implications of causality and the order of events involved during time travel. There isn’t much more that can be said without spoiling the story itself.
July 19, 2018
Me lo leí ayer noche dos veces y es que no sé qué decir, es alucinante!!!! Realmente me ha volado la cabeza.
Si tenéis la oportunidad leedlo por favor.
Si tenéis la oportunidad leedlo por favor.
January 14, 2017
OMG! This is just wrong on so many levels. A science fiction, time travel, short story that will have you scratching your head.
May 19, 2023
2023 update:
Masterpiece of time travel stories.
-------
Estuve a punto de ver Predestination en Netflix hasta que me enteré que está basada en una historia corta de Heinlein (buscando algunas críticas en Internet). Apreté el botón de pausa.
¡Ah! Es ese tipo de historias en las que te preguntas si lo que estás pensando que ha pasado es lo que realmente pasó. Tuve que regresar algunas páginas en algunos momentos solo para estar seguro. Me gustan las historias de viajes en el tiempo y esta está particularmente condimentada con paradojas temporales. ¡Excelente!
Ya puedo continuar con la película.
Masterpiece of time travel stories.
-------
Estuve a punto de ver Predestination en Netflix hasta que me enteré que está basada en una historia corta de Heinlein (buscando algunas críticas en Internet). Apreté el botón de pausa.
¡Ah! Es ese tipo de historias en las que te preguntas si lo que estás pensando que ha pasado es lo que realmente pasó. Tuve que regresar algunas páginas en algunos momentos solo para estar seguro. Me gustan las historias de viajes en el tiempo y esta está particularmente condimentada con paradojas temporales. ¡Excelente!
Ya puedo continuar con la película.
January 30, 2021
No sé muy bien qué reseña hacer de este relato...
Porque me encantan los viajes en el tiempo y, al mismo tiempo, me dejan la cabeza rota; pensando hacia atrás y hacia delante, queriendo encontrar la "conexión lineal" que me empeño en que haya... precisamente cuando el tiempo ha perdido su carácter lineal.
🤯
Merece mucho la pena, pero me quedo con la necesidad de seguir escrutando el esquema temporal dibujado al final del relato...
Porque me encantan los viajes en el tiempo y, al mismo tiempo, me dejan la cabeza rota; pensando hacia atrás y hacia delante, queriendo encontrar la "conexión lineal" que me empeño en que haya... precisamente cuando el tiempo ha perdido su carácter lineal.
🤯
Merece mucho la pena, pero me quedo con la necesidad de seguir escrutando el esquema temporal dibujado al final del relato...
June 2, 2018
Wow. Just ... wow.
A man walks into a bar ... in this case that is NOT a joke. *lol*
The man is a writer and was born female. He has frequented the bar for the past few years but only now is talking to the bartender, telling his/her story of getting pregnant and ending up then and there.
The rest is a very surprising, mind-boggling time travel story full of paradoxes that makes perfect sense.
According to my research, Heinlein wrote this story in one afternoon. It's amazing if one considers all the subjects he's touching upon and how intricate the plot is.
I must say that due to his view on women, I'm not much of a fan. This view is portrayed in this story as well by the "Space Angels" (basically hookers for astronauts). And no, the time he lived in cannot always simply explain or excuse it away.
However, he seems to have been a gifted author with intelligent stories to tell (sometimes at least) and this one was truly brilliantly executed. Though I did know where he would take the story thanks to the bartender mentioning his ring, it was awesome to be taken on that journey.
But only read this if your mind is primed for timey-wimey stuff. ;)
A man walks into a bar ... in this case that is NOT a joke. *lol*
The man is a writer and was born female. He has frequented the bar for the past few years but only now is talking to the bartender, telling his/her story of getting pregnant and ending up then and there.
The rest is a very surprising, mind-boggling time travel story full of paradoxes that makes perfect sense.
According to my research, Heinlein wrote this story in one afternoon. It's amazing if one considers all the subjects he's touching upon and how intricate the plot is.
I must say that due to his view on women, I'm not much of a fan. This view is portrayed in this story as well by the "Space Angels" (basically hookers for astronauts). And no, the time he lived in cannot always simply explain or excuse it away.
However, he seems to have been a gifted author with intelligent stories to tell (sometimes at least) and this one was truly brilliantly executed. Though I did know where he would take the story thanks to the bartender mentioning his ring, it was awesome to be taken on that journey.
But only read this if your mind is primed for timey-wimey stuff. ;)
February 13, 2023
Una pequeña y divertida historia de viajes en el tiempo de Heinlein, "All you Zombies..." presenta los temas de la dualidad de género y la identidad personal que prevalecen en muchas de sus obras.
Un joven que parece sentir mucha lástima por sí mismo le cuenta la historia de su vida a un barman. Comenzó su vida como una niña (sí, dije niña), creció en un orfanato y juró nunca tener hijos fuera del matrimonio y abandonarlos como aparentemente había sido. A pesar de sus buenas intenciones, cuando crece, sucumbe a la seducción de un joven que agita billetes de 100 dólares y que rápidamente la deja atrás. Desafortunadamente, ha quedado embarazada y, a su debido tiempo, da a luz a una niña. El bebé es secuestrado y desaparece para siempre o eso cree ella. Esa es la sencilla y aparentemente normal premisa de partida. A partir de ahi tenemos todo un juego de paradojas y linajes.
Como en varias obras de Heinlein, juega con la idea del solipsismo y termina la historia con los pensamientos del barman en lo que creo que es uno de los pasajes más conmovedores que jamás haya escrito.
Esta historia junto con "Puerta al verano" son ejemplos de lo que se denomina historias "deterministas" o "línea de tiempo inmutable". En otras palabras, todos los eventos tienen lugar en bucles de tiempo, pero no hay cambios en lo que sucede cada vez que pasa por el bucle. Los eventos son "fijos". Un problema filosófico asociado con este tipo de historia es obvio. ¿Qué sucede con el “libre albedrío”? Heinlein no intenta responder a esa pregunta en esta historia. Espero que lo evite porque es incontestable, y en esta historia tampoco trata de dar ninguna base "científica" para su viaje en el tiempo. Una verdadera maravilla del gran maestro.
Un joven que parece sentir mucha lástima por sí mismo le cuenta la historia de su vida a un barman. Comenzó su vida como una niña (sí, dije niña), creció en un orfanato y juró nunca tener hijos fuera del matrimonio y abandonarlos como aparentemente había sido. A pesar de sus buenas intenciones, cuando crece, sucumbe a la seducción de un joven que agita billetes de 100 dólares y que rápidamente la deja atrás. Desafortunadamente, ha quedado embarazada y, a su debido tiempo, da a luz a una niña. El bebé es secuestrado y desaparece para siempre o eso cree ella. Esa es la sencilla y aparentemente normal premisa de partida. A partir de ahi tenemos todo un juego de paradojas y linajes.
Como en varias obras de Heinlein, juega con la idea del solipsismo y termina la historia con los pensamientos del barman en lo que creo que es uno de los pasajes más conmovedores que jamás haya escrito.
Esta historia junto con "Puerta al verano" son ejemplos de lo que se denomina historias "deterministas" o "línea de tiempo inmutable". En otras palabras, todos los eventos tienen lugar en bucles de tiempo, pero no hay cambios en lo que sucede cada vez que pasa por el bucle. Los eventos son "fijos". Un problema filosófico asociado con este tipo de historia es obvio. ¿Qué sucede con el “libre albedrío”? Heinlein no intenta responder a esa pregunta en esta historia. Espero que lo evite porque es incontestable, y en esta historia tampoco trata de dar ninguna base "científica" para su viaje en el tiempo. Una verdadera maravilla del gran maestro.
Read
June 27, 2015Amazing, Mind-blowing, Thrilling, Fascinating..
December 30, 2022
Vaya locurón de viaje en el tiempo! No lo he acabado de entender, pero para eso hay dos diagramas al final. Original es poco. Un clásico que hay que conocer y que no deja indiferente (aaunque sí con el coco torcido). 'Predestinación' es una peli basada en esta historia del maestro Heinlein.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 831 reviews