What do you think?
Rate this book
Villa of Secrets
If you love Karen Swan and
Santa Montefiore
, you will love this perfect summer read from the author of
Island of Secrets
.
Rebecca Neumanner's marriage is on the brink of collapse, as her desire to be a mother becomes an obsession. Then she receives news from her estranged family in Rhodes.
Called back to the beautiful Greek island of her birth, she realises how little she knows of the grandmother she has eluded for over a decade. Bubba has never spoken of the Nazi occupation during her youth, but there have always been whispers. What desperate measures did she take that terrible day in 1944 when her family was ripped apart? Can the rumour she had blood on her own hands really be true? But Bubba intends to take her secrets to the grave.
However, as Rebecca arrives on Rhodes, bringing the promise of new life, this broken family must come together. The time has come to tell the truth about the darkest of days . . .
Rebecca Neumanner's marriage is on the brink of collapse, as her desire to be a mother becomes an obsession. Then she receives news from her estranged family in Rhodes.
Called back to the beautiful Greek island of her birth, she realises how little she knows of the grandmother she has eluded for over a decade. Bubba has never spoken of the Nazi occupation during her youth, but there have always been whispers. What desperate measures did she take that terrible day in 1944 when her family was ripped apart? Can the rumour she had blood on her own hands really be true? But Bubba intends to take her secrets to the grave.
However, as Rebecca arrives on Rhodes, bringing the promise of new life, this broken family must come together. The time has come to tell the truth about the darkest of days . . .
459 pages, Kindle Edition
First published February 22, 2018
194 people are currently reading
634 people want to read
About the author
Patricia M Wilson
8 books70 followersThere is at least one more author with this name in this data base. This one is Patricia M Wilson.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 131 reviews
April 3, 2018
Thank you to Netgalley and the publishers for an advanced copy of this fantastic book.
After saying that Island of Secrets was my favourite book of 2017 I was excited and a little apprehensive about reading Villa of Secrets, just in case it didn’t live up to the previous book. There was absolutely no reason to worry as I was gripped from the first chapter.
It’s a powerful captivating love story about a young Jewish girl’s bravery during WW2. A story of unbelievable atrocities, courage and the struggle to survive and of friendship and devotion, love, loss, and tragedy. Literally breath-taking in parts, it's a book you'll get lost in and certainly one you won't forget.
I think I am going to struggle to find another book that beats this to being my favourite book of 2018.
After saying that Island of Secrets was my favourite book of 2017 I was excited and a little apprehensive about reading Villa of Secrets, just in case it didn’t live up to the previous book. There was absolutely no reason to worry as I was gripped from the first chapter.
It’s a powerful captivating love story about a young Jewish girl’s bravery during WW2. A story of unbelievable atrocities, courage and the struggle to survive and of friendship and devotion, love, loss, and tragedy. Literally breath-taking in parts, it's a book you'll get lost in and certainly one you won't forget.
I think I am going to struggle to find another book that beats this to being my favourite book of 2018.
June 4, 2022
http://www.hyperebaaktiivne.ee/2022/0...
Aitäh, Pegasus, raamatu eest!
Patricia Wilson "Saladuste villa" on üks neist raamatutest, millest ma enne lugemist midagi oodata ei osanud, kuna polnud ei teosest ega autorist varem midagi kuulnud. Ajaviitekirjandus ei ole žanr, milles ma end koduselt tunnen, eriti kui kirjanik on võõras. Sisukirjeldus ahvatles aga minevikusaladustega ning kaanepilt oli kutsuvalt suvine ja soe, mistõttu otsustasin proovida.
Rhodos. Naomi ja Rebecca on õed ning Bubba on nende vanaema, kes kasvatas tüdrukud üles, kuna nende vanemad hukkusid merel. Rebecca kolis kümmekond aastat tagasi pärast suurt tüli Inglismaale ning pole sellest ajast saati õe ega vanaemaga suhelnud. Hiljuti oli Bubbal insult ning ta taastub Naomi hoole all. Parematel päevadel on vana naine elujõuline, kuid halvematel kerkivad üles sünged minevikumälestused. Ta ei ole kunagi lapselastele rääkinud oma elust Rhodose natsiokupatsiooni ajal ning võtaks parema meelega saladused hauda kaasa. On aga tekkinud võimalus, et kohtu kaudu antakse tagasi juutidelt võõrandatud vara ja selleks peab perekond kokku tulema. Rebecca tuleb viimaks nende ellu tagasi ja mõlemad õed saavad 16-aastase Pandora päevikute kaudu teada vanaema süngetest saladustest ja suurtest vägitegudest.
"Saladuste villa" üllatas väga positiivselt. See ei olnud lihtsalt minevikusaladustega lugu, vaid jutustas detailselt Rhodose ajaloost. Ma ei olnud kunagi mõelnud, et ka Kreeka paradiisisaared kannatasid natsiokupatsiooni käes. Ebaõiglus ja julmus olid südantlõhestavad, aga vastupanuliikumise vahvus andis lootust. Üks eriti põnev detail oli suletud uks politseijaoskonnas, mis mind nii paelus, et kohe google otsingu tegin, et teada saada, kas see oli päris. Oligi!
Mulle läksid korda ka Naomi ja Rebecca olevikumured, aga need muidugi kahvatusid selle kõrval, mida Bubba/Pandora teismelisena koges. Ainuke asi, mis mulle kuidagi pähe ei mahtunud, oli see, kuidas õdedel vanaema päevikute lugemiseks nii palju aega kulus. Põnevaid raamatuid on niigi raske käest panna, aga ma ei kujuta ette, et see oleks üldse võimalik lugedes pereliikme memuaare, aga nemad jätsid tihtipeale kõige närvekõditavama koha peal pooleli. Igasugused kokkusattumused ei häirinud mind absoluutselt, aga see oli nii loogikavastane.
Ühe kivi tahaksin veel kirjaniku kapsaaeda visata. Pealkirjad on Patricia Wilsoni romaanidel küll mitte midagi ütlevad. Jah, selles raamatus on üks salajane villa, aga see ei olnud nii määrava tähtsusega, et pealkirjas figureerida. Tema teistel raamatutel on ka väga sarnased pealkirjad - kõik on mingit sorti saladustest ja Kreeka saartest - saladuste saar, Santorini saladused jne. Eesti keeles on ilmunud veel tema "Põgenemine Kreetale".
"Saladuste villa" on ajaviiteromaan kahest õest, kes loevad vanaema päevikust, kuidas too osales Rhodose natsiokupatsiooni vastases liikumises. Mulle meeldis teose rikas ajalooline taust ja peategelasteks olevad kolm naist, igaüks oma muredega. Soovitan kergeks suvelugemiseks!
Aitäh, Pegasus, raamatu eest!
Patricia Wilson "Saladuste villa" on üks neist raamatutest, millest ma enne lugemist midagi oodata ei osanud, kuna polnud ei teosest ega autorist varem midagi kuulnud. Ajaviitekirjandus ei ole žanr, milles ma end koduselt tunnen, eriti kui kirjanik on võõras. Sisukirjeldus ahvatles aga minevikusaladustega ning kaanepilt oli kutsuvalt suvine ja soe, mistõttu otsustasin proovida.
Rhodos. Naomi ja Rebecca on õed ning Bubba on nende vanaema, kes kasvatas tüdrukud üles, kuna nende vanemad hukkusid merel. Rebecca kolis kümmekond aastat tagasi pärast suurt tüli Inglismaale ning pole sellest ajast saati õe ega vanaemaga suhelnud. Hiljuti oli Bubbal insult ning ta taastub Naomi hoole all. Parematel päevadel on vana naine elujõuline, kuid halvematel kerkivad üles sünged minevikumälestused. Ta ei ole kunagi lapselastele rääkinud oma elust Rhodose natsiokupatsiooni ajal ning võtaks parema meelega saladused hauda kaasa. On aga tekkinud võimalus, et kohtu kaudu antakse tagasi juutidelt võõrandatud vara ja selleks peab perekond kokku tulema. Rebecca tuleb viimaks nende ellu tagasi ja mõlemad õed saavad 16-aastase Pandora päevikute kaudu teada vanaema süngetest saladustest ja suurtest vägitegudest.
"Saladuste villa" üllatas väga positiivselt. See ei olnud lihtsalt minevikusaladustega lugu, vaid jutustas detailselt Rhodose ajaloost. Ma ei olnud kunagi mõelnud, et ka Kreeka paradiisisaared kannatasid natsiokupatsiooni käes. Ebaõiglus ja julmus olid südantlõhestavad, aga vastupanuliikumise vahvus andis lootust. Üks eriti põnev detail oli suletud uks politseijaoskonnas, mis mind nii paelus, et kohe google otsingu tegin, et teada saada, kas see oli päris. Oligi!
Mulle läksid korda ka Naomi ja Rebecca olevikumured, aga need muidugi kahvatusid selle kõrval, mida Bubba/Pandora teismelisena koges. Ainuke asi, mis mulle kuidagi pähe ei mahtunud, oli see, kuidas õdedel vanaema päevikute lugemiseks nii palju aega kulus. Põnevaid raamatuid on niigi raske käest panna, aga ma ei kujuta ette, et see oleks üldse võimalik lugedes pereliikme memuaare, aga nemad jätsid tihtipeale kõige närvekõditavama koha peal pooleli. Igasugused kokkusattumused ei häirinud mind absoluutselt, aga see oli nii loogikavastane.
Ühe kivi tahaksin veel kirjaniku kapsaaeda visata. Pealkirjad on Patricia Wilsoni romaanidel küll mitte midagi ütlevad. Jah, selles raamatus on üks salajane villa, aga see ei olnud nii määrava tähtsusega, et pealkirjas figureerida. Tema teistel raamatutel on ka väga sarnased pealkirjad - kõik on mingit sorti saladustest ja Kreeka saartest - saladuste saar, Santorini saladused jne. Eesti keeles on ilmunud veel tema "Põgenemine Kreetale".
"Saladuste villa" on ajaviiteromaan kahest õest, kes loevad vanaema päevikust, kuidas too osales Rhodose natsiokupatsiooni vastases liikumises. Mulle meeldis teose rikas ajalooline taust ja peategelasteks olevad kolm naist, igaüks oma muredega. Soovitan kergeks suvelugemiseks!
February 17, 2018
'Villa of Secrets' is a nicely paced historical fiction story that delves back into the terrible events on Rhodes Island in Greece during WW11.
Rebecca and Naomi's grandmother has been hiding a secret from them for many years. After suffering a stroke, she decides it is time to reveal all through a series of diaries she started during her teenage years. Rebecca and Naomi are shocked to discover that 'Bubba' had a dark but heroic past as a freedom fighter. As they progress through her writings, they learn more about the tragedies that occurred during wartime and the fate of Bubba's friends and relatives.
While the chapters concerning Bubba and the plight of the Jewish during the war were moving, I found the focus of some of the present day chapters a little distracting. I couldn't quite workout why Rebecca's lack of children and IVF treatment became such a large focus; it didn't seem to add anything to the overall story and went into quite a bit of unnecessary detail at times.
There was a sad but clever twist in the historical story, and I could see that lots of research had gone into these areas to bring Bubba's story as a young girl to life. The major reveal at the finish whilst sweet, was a little implausible; although it did bring all the loose ends together. The historical chapters are definitely this books strong point and I would have given a higher rating had the modern chapters been as developed and had a little less distracting drama in them.
*I received a copy of the book from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Rebecca and Naomi's grandmother has been hiding a secret from them for many years. After suffering a stroke, she decides it is time to reveal all through a series of diaries she started during her teenage years. Rebecca and Naomi are shocked to discover that 'Bubba' had a dark but heroic past as a freedom fighter. As they progress through her writings, they learn more about the tragedies that occurred during wartime and the fate of Bubba's friends and relatives.
While the chapters concerning Bubba and the plight of the Jewish during the war were moving, I found the focus of some of the present day chapters a little distracting. I couldn't quite workout why Rebecca's lack of children and IVF treatment became such a large focus; it didn't seem to add anything to the overall story and went into quite a bit of unnecessary detail at times.
There was a sad but clever twist in the historical story, and I could see that lots of research had gone into these areas to bring Bubba's story as a young girl to life. The major reveal at the finish whilst sweet, was a little implausible; although it did bring all the loose ends together. The historical chapters are definitely this books strong point and I would have given a higher rating had the modern chapters been as developed and had a little less distracting drama in them.
*I received a copy of the book from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
January 11, 2022
Another os Audible's free listens. This one was quite good, although a bit too dramatic to my taste. And too neatly wrapped up in the end, you would have to suspend all disbelief to enjoy this.
The narrator did a good job, but maybe a bit too keen on the dramatization, it as if I can still hear all the wailing that was going on. Not that the plot doesn't warrant it, it is just a little too much, sometimes it felt as if it was going on for hours.
The narrator did a good job, but maybe a bit too keen on the dramatization, it as if I can still hear all the wailing that was going on. Not that the plot doesn't warrant it, it is just a little too much, sometimes it felt as if it was going on for hours.
December 29, 2018
A charming story interspersed with humour and joy to soften the extreme sadness and fear suffered during WW11 in Greece.
Much of the book is in flashbacks via Bubba's diary (aka Pandora Cohen) and is very well written.
This is the second book I've read by this author and as with the first one, I looked forward eagerly to each chapter and highly recommend it.
Much of the book is in flashbacks via Bubba's diary (aka Pandora Cohen) and is very well written.
This is the second book I've read by this author and as with the first one, I looked forward eagerly to each chapter and highly recommend it.
April 10, 2018
Given that Island of Secrets, the incredible début novel from Patricia Wilson, was one of my favourite books of 2017, to say I was eager for the publication of Villa of Secrets would be a massive understatement. Writing in the historical fiction genre, Patricia, seamlessly blends the past with the present helping her characters to bring long held secrets to the fore and in doing so creates a story that is increasingly difficult to put down. Admittedly I did read this book in two halves, I was enjoying the story but then life and other commitments got in the way and I am afraid this book was left to one side for several weeks. Up until the point at which I stopped I did think this was a good story but I was still waiting for that moment that I experienced while reading book one, that pivotal point that sets this book apart from anything I have recently read, that makes me want to shout about it from the rooftops.
I was slightly worried that I hadn't got that vibe yet so I did return to finish Villa of Secrets with some slight trepidation. I needn't have had any as once again the author really ramped up the pace in what I am calling part two even though the book was not divided into sections. Once I picked the book up for the second time it wasn't left out off my hands until I had finished it. I think the time I took away from the book only enhanced my enjoyment once I got stuck back into Dora and her granddaughter's lives. There were plenty of twists and turns, surprises and heartache and one major twist I didn't see coming. In fact said twist left me frustrated as it left me with one big question on my lips which I would love to know the author's viewpoint on and why she left things the way she did?
The setting this time for Villa of Secrets is the island of Rhodes, in the present day, and during World War Two under Italian and then German occupation. Throughout the story there is fantastic, glorious imagery of the island and also much detail regarding the history and how actions of people in the past play an important role on those living in the present. It felt like I was almost there on the island especially during the wars years as Dora takes on a vital, dangerous and courageous role. The island became her workplace of sorts and hiding in an old shepherds hut on the mountain was the centre from which so much happened in her life. In the present day Naomi is caring for her grandmother Bubba, it soon becomes apparent as Naomi reads through her grandmother's diaries that Bubba was Dora.
Bubba although recovering slowly from a stroke is still as sharp as ever. Yet the memories and pain of the past still deeply affect her today. Her experiences during the war and what she witnessed and endured have always had a forbearing on the way she reacts to people, particularly to Fritz, the husband of her granddaughter Rebecca now living in London. Rebecca has not seen or spoken to her family in many years. Harsh words were said which were aimed to hurt and are very difficult to retract. But times are changing and as a court case is about to be heard in relation to property stolen from people during the war, maybe now is the time for the family to reunite. A time to put the past to rest and to bed for once and for all but to do this we must go back and read Bubba's story through her diaries, to allow both Rebecca and Naomi to make sense of everything.
As we are taken back to July 1944, we are told Bubba's story in her own words. At all times she had a diary and would write in it, to keep memories fresh be they good or bad. Dora is like any other girl living in Paradissi village, well she should be except for the war that has changed all of her family and friends lives forever. When she couldn't think that things would get any worse her family are brutally torn apart, all because of their religion and heritage. Suffice to say Dora and her sister Evangelisa are the only ones left on the island. One through fate and Dora through sheer courage and bravery putting herself in the utmost of danger.
From this point on the innocence of youth is forever gone for Dora and she grew up very very quickly. I couldn't imagine the youth of today taking on such a challenge. For a quest is what it was, a challenge to be reunited with her family and relatives, Dora would not rest until they were together again. She wanted to play her part in winning the war, no matter how big or small that role was to be. In doing so she encounters many things which were shocking but definitely needed to be included in the story to show just how courageous this girl was in the face of so much danger and adversity.
Dora was taken on a journey, one which she would not have planned for herself but, in trying to stop the Germans exerting further control and in a bid to save the people she loves so dearly, Dora will make many sacrifices. To say much more regarding Dora's experiences during the war would take away from the story. Patricia Wilson did such an amazing job of bringing that time to life and I felt every bit of the fear, pain, anger, nervousness and at times passion that Dora goes through. She is helped by people who can see the strong traits she possesses. Of course there has to be an element of romance and to say the least it was very bittersweet and heartbreaking, it felt so real, so passionate and the ultimate surprise that tied everything together made me go ah that was lovely but god I wanted things to work out differently.
In the present day Bubba is very much moulded by the secrets of the past she holds within herself but still that feisty, strong nature is still evident. She has been through an awful lot in her life, yes during the war but also in the years that followed it. At all times she was selfless and put others needs very much before her own. Taking in and raising her granddaughters after tragedy struck was just one example of such an act. I think the strand of the story set during the war years slightly edged out the present day timeline for me but I did enjoy how one was necessary to bring the other full circle in an attempt to bring about resolution and a deeper understanding on all sides.
Naomi was so tender and caring towards Bubba whilst at the same time balancing many things in her life. I felt she struggled with her husband working away and at times felt under pressure. Her sister Rebecca is conspicuous in her absence but has Bubba something up her sleeve that will make Rebecca return to the island? I understood Naomi was there as a support and anchor for Bubba but I did think she didn't have as vital a role to play as other characters. I did like her but she wasn't always at the forefront of my thinking when it came to slotting pieces of the puzzle together or understanding subtle hints dropped throughout the story. Many of which I missed considering I never saw the biggest surprise of all coming from a mile away.
Rebecca in London is tormented by the fact her struggles to have a child are only ever increasing. She loves Fritz and that love is reciprocated but it is under immense strain and pressure. When strange parcels start arriving in the post, is this just another thing to put more worry on Rebecca or will she give in to the calling card in the packages? Rebecca needed time away from her situation and to reconnect with her family, to push the water under the bridge and accept forgiveness. To understand how the actions of one warrior in the past led the family to the point they are at today. Can resolution be found for all involved? Will everyone change their opinions once the truth finally emerges? Will the property lost to the family be returned to them?
So many questions, so many twists and turns and things you would never have thought possible. All these combine to make for another excellent read from Patricia Wilson, she has proven what writing talent she has. She is no one hit wonder as the 'difficult' second book didn't come across as being challenging more so as if it was an exciting, thrilling writing journey, yes tinged with bitterness and sadness for what happened to the people of Rhodes and the neighbouring islands during the war but still the author has turned the spotlight on a time in history that many need to read and understand about. Villa of Secrets had the perfect blend of fiction with historical fact and the story was told with tact and sensitivity. Definitely a highly recommended read, now when is Patricia's next book out?
I was slightly worried that I hadn't got that vibe yet so I did return to finish Villa of Secrets with some slight trepidation. I needn't have had any as once again the author really ramped up the pace in what I am calling part two even though the book was not divided into sections. Once I picked the book up for the second time it wasn't left out off my hands until I had finished it. I think the time I took away from the book only enhanced my enjoyment once I got stuck back into Dora and her granddaughter's lives. There were plenty of twists and turns, surprises and heartache and one major twist I didn't see coming. In fact said twist left me frustrated as it left me with one big question on my lips which I would love to know the author's viewpoint on and why she left things the way she did?
The setting this time for Villa of Secrets is the island of Rhodes, in the present day, and during World War Two under Italian and then German occupation. Throughout the story there is fantastic, glorious imagery of the island and also much detail regarding the history and how actions of people in the past play an important role on those living in the present. It felt like I was almost there on the island especially during the wars years as Dora takes on a vital, dangerous and courageous role. The island became her workplace of sorts and hiding in an old shepherds hut on the mountain was the centre from which so much happened in her life. In the present day Naomi is caring for her grandmother Bubba, it soon becomes apparent as Naomi reads through her grandmother's diaries that Bubba was Dora.
Bubba although recovering slowly from a stroke is still as sharp as ever. Yet the memories and pain of the past still deeply affect her today. Her experiences during the war and what she witnessed and endured have always had a forbearing on the way she reacts to people, particularly to Fritz, the husband of her granddaughter Rebecca now living in London. Rebecca has not seen or spoken to her family in many years. Harsh words were said which were aimed to hurt and are very difficult to retract. But times are changing and as a court case is about to be heard in relation to property stolen from people during the war, maybe now is the time for the family to reunite. A time to put the past to rest and to bed for once and for all but to do this we must go back and read Bubba's story through her diaries, to allow both Rebecca and Naomi to make sense of everything.
As we are taken back to July 1944, we are told Bubba's story in her own words. At all times she had a diary and would write in it, to keep memories fresh be they good or bad. Dora is like any other girl living in Paradissi village, well she should be except for the war that has changed all of her family and friends lives forever. When she couldn't think that things would get any worse her family are brutally torn apart, all because of their religion and heritage. Suffice to say Dora and her sister Evangelisa are the only ones left on the island. One through fate and Dora through sheer courage and bravery putting herself in the utmost of danger.
From this point on the innocence of youth is forever gone for Dora and she grew up very very quickly. I couldn't imagine the youth of today taking on such a challenge. For a quest is what it was, a challenge to be reunited with her family and relatives, Dora would not rest until they were together again. She wanted to play her part in winning the war, no matter how big or small that role was to be. In doing so she encounters many things which were shocking but definitely needed to be included in the story to show just how courageous this girl was in the face of so much danger and adversity.
Dora was taken on a journey, one which she would not have planned for herself but, in trying to stop the Germans exerting further control and in a bid to save the people she loves so dearly, Dora will make many sacrifices. To say much more regarding Dora's experiences during the war would take away from the story. Patricia Wilson did such an amazing job of bringing that time to life and I felt every bit of the fear, pain, anger, nervousness and at times passion that Dora goes through. She is helped by people who can see the strong traits she possesses. Of course there has to be an element of romance and to say the least it was very bittersweet and heartbreaking, it felt so real, so passionate and the ultimate surprise that tied everything together made me go ah that was lovely but god I wanted things to work out differently.
In the present day Bubba is very much moulded by the secrets of the past she holds within herself but still that feisty, strong nature is still evident. She has been through an awful lot in her life, yes during the war but also in the years that followed it. At all times she was selfless and put others needs very much before her own. Taking in and raising her granddaughters after tragedy struck was just one example of such an act. I think the strand of the story set during the war years slightly edged out the present day timeline for me but I did enjoy how one was necessary to bring the other full circle in an attempt to bring about resolution and a deeper understanding on all sides.
Naomi was so tender and caring towards Bubba whilst at the same time balancing many things in her life. I felt she struggled with her husband working away and at times felt under pressure. Her sister Rebecca is conspicuous in her absence but has Bubba something up her sleeve that will make Rebecca return to the island? I understood Naomi was there as a support and anchor for Bubba but I did think she didn't have as vital a role to play as other characters. I did like her but she wasn't always at the forefront of my thinking when it came to slotting pieces of the puzzle together or understanding subtle hints dropped throughout the story. Many of which I missed considering I never saw the biggest surprise of all coming from a mile away.
Rebecca in London is tormented by the fact her struggles to have a child are only ever increasing. She loves Fritz and that love is reciprocated but it is under immense strain and pressure. When strange parcels start arriving in the post, is this just another thing to put more worry on Rebecca or will she give in to the calling card in the packages? Rebecca needed time away from her situation and to reconnect with her family, to push the water under the bridge and accept forgiveness. To understand how the actions of one warrior in the past led the family to the point they are at today. Can resolution be found for all involved? Will everyone change their opinions once the truth finally emerges? Will the property lost to the family be returned to them?
So many questions, so many twists and turns and things you would never have thought possible. All these combine to make for another excellent read from Patricia Wilson, she has proven what writing talent she has. She is no one hit wonder as the 'difficult' second book didn't come across as being challenging more so as if it was an exciting, thrilling writing journey, yes tinged with bitterness and sadness for what happened to the people of Rhodes and the neighbouring islands during the war but still the author has turned the spotlight on a time in history that many need to read and understand about. Villa of Secrets had the perfect blend of fiction with historical fact and the story was told with tact and sensitivity. Definitely a highly recommended read, now when is Patricia's next book out?
May 20, 2019
I absolutely loved this book. I really liked the strong female characters, especially Bubba. It was an emotional read at points and it explores the complexity of different types of relationships in a wonderfully tender manner. I think that this book is one of my all time favourites and I can't wait to see what Patricia Wilson releases next.
March 27, 2018
Really good read.
I could not read this book fast enough, I so wanted to know the end, it was a very moving story and as it was based on a real life experience it made it very special to read. Most enthralling.
I could not read this book fast enough, I so wanted to know the end, it was a very moving story and as it was based on a real life experience it made it very special to read. Most enthralling.
November 19, 2018
This is an exquisitely crafted story that I would not have discovered if a friend had not sent it to me. Enjoyed it so much that I've placed it among my all-time favorites. It's the kind of book that doesn't get old and you'll read again and again. Wonderful!
April 26, 2018
Excellent
Excellent book. Couldn't put it down. The characters feel real. A lot of tragedy, but hope as well! Definitely recommend
Excellent book. Couldn't put it down. The characters feel real. A lot of tragedy, but hope as well! Definitely recommend
May 12, 2018
I was hooked at Greece, double hooked at the Andartes Resistance (based on a true story). The diary of Pandora enhances the present day story. Would have given 6* if I could. Plus a twist in the tale!
September 21, 2018
Not dissapointed...read this one on holiday in Paxos....set in Rhodes during 2nd world war...again informative...sad...beautiful...like this author very much
January 10, 2022
Pleasant book. But a little slow for me. Just a pleasant easy read. Nothing special.
September 11, 2025
Im so disappointed that the writing of this book was so awful because the historical events being shared were important and impactful. This book had so much potential but fell flat.
October 5, 2022
Lugemise aeg läks suht sujuvalt, kuid lõpp jättis segased tunded. Üldiselt julgen täitsa soovitada.
Pikemalt kirjutan blogis: http://midaheliluges.blogspot.com/202...
Pikemalt kirjutan blogis: http://midaheliluges.blogspot.com/202...
June 7, 2018
Loved this book even more than the first one. When I started I wasn’t sure I would enjoy it as thought it was too similar to first one but once I got into it I realised it was even better. I would have given 10 ⭐️ if I could!
May 1, 2018
A very Moving story.
Once I started reading I went from tears for the terrible things that actually happened on the island to enjoyment of the beautiful story telling of Patricia Wilson,Very talented author..
Once I started reading I went from tears for the terrible things that actually happened on the island to enjoyment of the beautiful story telling of Patricia Wilson,Very talented author..
February 28, 2018
Villa of Secrets is the second novel by Patricia Wilson and was a book which had a lot to live up to as her first novel Island of Secrets was one of my favourite novels of last year. Not to worry though I think Villa of Secrets is even better.
Sisters Naomi and Rebecca have been estranged for ten years after Rebecca chose her husband over her family. Both sisters are feeling lonely in their own ways, Rebecca is starting her forth round of IVF and is feeling further and further away from husband Fritz as the longing for a baby overtakes her. Naomi is suffering empty nest syndrome with both her grown boys away at university and husband Costa working on a cruise ship, the strain od Bubba’s stroke is also taking its toll on her. Now the sisters must come together once more as their grandmother has decided its time to share her. Can this family put the horrors of the past behind them and finally come together for the future?
The narrative of this story is split between the present day reuniting of Naomi and Rebecca and through Bubba’s diaries of the past. For me its though these diaries that the story really comes alive and where Patricia Wilson’s writing is at its best. The diaries are from when Bubba or Pandora as she was named, and her family were made to leave the island of Rhodes during WWII being that they were a Jewish family. The tell of how Pandora being small managed to escape being taken away by the Nazi’s on the evacuation ship to the concentration camps. They gradually unravel how Pandora showed great courage at just sixteen and joined the resistance and helped to try and sabotage the war for the Germans.
I found these diaries incredibly powerful in their storytelling, every emotion and every detail has been written about so precisely it’s as if you are there reliving the whole events. It’s through these diaries that we learn just how courageous Pandora was, risking her life to try and bring freedom to the island and they kind of left me in awe of how inspiring and determined she was. I’m ashamed to say that when I’ve thought about WWII, the Greek isles and Rhodes particularly have never really crossed my mind. Rhodes has always just been that happy relaxed holiday destination that we all think of. Villa of Secrets has altered that view dramatically and shown that the effects of the War affected all of Europe and not just the bigger countries like Poland, Germany and France.
The present-day side of the story shows us both Rebecca and Naomi have also inherited the Cohen determination and ability to fight for what they believe in. This comes across more with Rebecca as she left her family to be with the man she loves and has been determined to be a mother despite having many setbacks getting pregnant. I also think Naomi shows courage and determination, in a smaller dose granted but she’s single-handedly nursed Bubba back to health after her stroke and has had to help to raise Rebecca also after losing her parents at ten years old.
I think Villa of Secrets is a great novel which has been thoroughly researched and very well written. Patricia Wilson has written about this sensitive time in history with great empathy and has developed a strong and courageous heroine in Pandora Cohen. This novel is about family loyalty, love, religion and fighting for what you a believe in. It’s a novel full of emotions which will make your heartache in places but its also a novel which shows there’s nothing stronger than love.
Thank you so much Bonnier Zaffre for sending me a copy to review which I have done honestly and for inviting me to be part of the blog tour.
Sisters Naomi and Rebecca have been estranged for ten years after Rebecca chose her husband over her family. Both sisters are feeling lonely in their own ways, Rebecca is starting her forth round of IVF and is feeling further and further away from husband Fritz as the longing for a baby overtakes her. Naomi is suffering empty nest syndrome with both her grown boys away at university and husband Costa working on a cruise ship, the strain od Bubba’s stroke is also taking its toll on her. Now the sisters must come together once more as their grandmother has decided its time to share her. Can this family put the horrors of the past behind them and finally come together for the future?
The narrative of this story is split between the present day reuniting of Naomi and Rebecca and through Bubba’s diaries of the past. For me its though these diaries that the story really comes alive and where Patricia Wilson’s writing is at its best. The diaries are from when Bubba or Pandora as she was named, and her family were made to leave the island of Rhodes during WWII being that they were a Jewish family. The tell of how Pandora being small managed to escape being taken away by the Nazi’s on the evacuation ship to the concentration camps. They gradually unravel how Pandora showed great courage at just sixteen and joined the resistance and helped to try and sabotage the war for the Germans.
I found these diaries incredibly powerful in their storytelling, every emotion and every detail has been written about so precisely it’s as if you are there reliving the whole events. It’s through these diaries that we learn just how courageous Pandora was, risking her life to try and bring freedom to the island and they kind of left me in awe of how inspiring and determined she was. I’m ashamed to say that when I’ve thought about WWII, the Greek isles and Rhodes particularly have never really crossed my mind. Rhodes has always just been that happy relaxed holiday destination that we all think of. Villa of Secrets has altered that view dramatically and shown that the effects of the War affected all of Europe and not just the bigger countries like Poland, Germany and France.
The present-day side of the story shows us both Rebecca and Naomi have also inherited the Cohen determination and ability to fight for what they believe in. This comes across more with Rebecca as she left her family to be with the man she loves and has been determined to be a mother despite having many setbacks getting pregnant. I also think Naomi shows courage and determination, in a smaller dose granted but she’s single-handedly nursed Bubba back to health after her stroke and has had to help to raise Rebecca also after losing her parents at ten years old.
I think Villa of Secrets is a great novel which has been thoroughly researched and very well written. Patricia Wilson has written about this sensitive time in history with great empathy and has developed a strong and courageous heroine in Pandora Cohen. This novel is about family loyalty, love, religion and fighting for what you a believe in. It’s a novel full of emotions which will make your heartache in places but its also a novel which shows there’s nothing stronger than love.
Thank you so much Bonnier Zaffre for sending me a copy to review which I have done honestly and for inviting me to be part of the blog tour.
March 22, 2018
BRILLIANT
As a lover of Victoria Hislop who writes similar style books based in Crete. I bought this. It is equally as good, if not better. How these true story lines are researched, I have no idea. But thank you and well done Patricia.
As a lover of Victoria Hislop who writes similar style books based in Crete. I bought this. It is equally as good, if not better. How these true story lines are researched, I have no idea. But thank you and well done Patricia.
March 4, 2018
Excellent
Found the book very interesting, having visited Rhodes many times, I knew a lot of the place mentioned in the book.
Found the book very interesting, having visited Rhodes many times, I knew a lot of the place mentioned in the book.
February 20, 2018
I never take the Publisher's blurb too seriously and just use it to get an idea of the subject matter of the book. In this case I clearly mis-read it because this book is nothing like I thought it would be. The opening chapters tell of two orphaned sisters - Rebecca and Naomi - who have been raised by their Bubba and are now grown women forging their own way in the world. Estranged from each other by Rebecca's choice of husband we learn of their parallel lives. This is what I thought the book would be about - how they came to be estranged and how they came back together.
Instead this is a powerful book about a tough woman, Pandora Cohen, feisty and fearless she avoided the Nazi cleansing of her people from the Island of Rhodes and strove to protect the island from the invaders; despite it's populace not wanting "her kind", the Jewish "kind". It did open up an area of history that I had never thought of before - I always associated the Nazi atrocities with Holland, France, Germany, Poland, Czechoslovakia but never even stopped to think about other European countries. I didn't even know that Rhodes used to be Italian territory, thinking of it always as the Greek holiday destination of now.
Told through the pages of Bubba's diaries we learn of the Andartes and their push to free the Dodecanese from German occupation. The telling is full of life and is so fresh and human it feels, ultimately, real. There is everything between those flimsy exercise book pages about Bubba's resistance life, her loves, her fears and her desire to "be brave". You immediately connect with this fictional person and suffer and laugh and love with her, wishing for just an ounce of her spirit.
The juxtaposition with the modern tales of Naomi and Rebecca works well. Particularly Rebecca's trials in her quest for children which is told with compassion and a straightforwardness that leaves you breathless. The only character I could not really connect with is Naomi. Maybe because she is the peacekeeper, the one with the family, the one who just does what is expected without complaint. She is not a Cohen woman.
Set time aside to read this book because you will become sucked into this dangerous world and before you know it bedtime has come and gone, the lights are burning the small hours of the morning away and you just have to read one more diary entry.
I RECEIVED A FREE COPY OF THIS BOOK FROM READERS FIRST IN EXCHANGE FOR AN HONEST REVIEW.
Instead this is a powerful book about a tough woman, Pandora Cohen, feisty and fearless she avoided the Nazi cleansing of her people from the Island of Rhodes and strove to protect the island from the invaders; despite it's populace not wanting "her kind", the Jewish "kind". It did open up an area of history that I had never thought of before - I always associated the Nazi atrocities with Holland, France, Germany, Poland, Czechoslovakia but never even stopped to think about other European countries. I didn't even know that Rhodes used to be Italian territory, thinking of it always as the Greek holiday destination of now.
Told through the pages of Bubba's diaries we learn of the Andartes and their push to free the Dodecanese from German occupation. The telling is full of life and is so fresh and human it feels, ultimately, real. There is everything between those flimsy exercise book pages about Bubba's resistance life, her loves, her fears and her desire to "be brave". You immediately connect with this fictional person and suffer and laugh and love with her, wishing for just an ounce of her spirit.
The juxtaposition with the modern tales of Naomi and Rebecca works well. Particularly Rebecca's trials in her quest for children which is told with compassion and a straightforwardness that leaves you breathless. The only character I could not really connect with is Naomi. Maybe because she is the peacekeeper, the one with the family, the one who just does what is expected without complaint. She is not a Cohen woman.
Set time aside to read this book because you will become sucked into this dangerous world and before you know it bedtime has come and gone, the lights are burning the small hours of the morning away and you just have to read one more diary entry.
I RECEIVED A FREE COPY OF THIS BOOK FROM READERS FIRST IN EXCHANGE FOR AN HONEST REVIEW.
January 1, 2019
I absolutely found myself immersed in Patricia Wilson’s writing in her novel Island of Secrets and I was eager for a new release so I could get lost in her wonderful descriptive writing again. When I read the synopsis for her new release Villa of Secrets it sounded so promising and I couldn’t wait to begin.
Sisters Naomi and Rebecca have been estranged for years after a family dispute lead to Rebecca leaving Rhodes to live in Bromley in England. The women now live very different lives but both face their own struggles but this must be put aside when their Grandma Bubba has a stroke and important information has come to light that requires the family to come together and it is time to truly get to know their dear Bubba through her diaries.
This storyline was told from the past and the present and I have to say although I loved both telling's. the present was told from Dora’s personal diaries and it was these memoires that I enjoyed the most. The author has such a skilled way of weaving the past and present together to create such a compelling storyline that flows perfectly. I am not a great fan of storylines told from dual time zones but this book is definitely an exception.
I loved the comforting and communal feel I got from the setting in Rhodes where Naomi and Bubba live, with friends passing by whereas when we meet Rebecca in Bromley which in itself was a shock to see somewhere so close to where I live appear in a novel it felt so cold and lonely a complete contrast to what I loved from Rhodes.
Through Dora’s diary we get to see great insight into what devastation she faced during her fight for survival and desperation to do her part to end the war so she could be reunited with her family. Dora was a remarkable young woman who had to grown up hard and fast. She was a selfless and courageous young woman who suffered through so much loss and her honesty and at times confusing emotions that she shares within her pages really touched my heart. How someone can face so much heartache through their lives and manage to conceal this from those around them is such a selfless act.
The ending of this book was such a poignant part and really brought a lump to my throat. I love this authors descriptive writing style and her storylines are so captivating I can not wait to see what her third novel will bring.
Sisters Naomi and Rebecca have been estranged for years after a family dispute lead to Rebecca leaving Rhodes to live in Bromley in England. The women now live very different lives but both face their own struggles but this must be put aside when their Grandma Bubba has a stroke and important information has come to light that requires the family to come together and it is time to truly get to know their dear Bubba through her diaries.
This storyline was told from the past and the present and I have to say although I loved both telling's. the present was told from Dora’s personal diaries and it was these memoires that I enjoyed the most. The author has such a skilled way of weaving the past and present together to create such a compelling storyline that flows perfectly. I am not a great fan of storylines told from dual time zones but this book is definitely an exception.
I loved the comforting and communal feel I got from the setting in Rhodes where Naomi and Bubba live, with friends passing by whereas when we meet Rebecca in Bromley which in itself was a shock to see somewhere so close to where I live appear in a novel it felt so cold and lonely a complete contrast to what I loved from Rhodes.
Through Dora’s diary we get to see great insight into what devastation she faced during her fight for survival and desperation to do her part to end the war so she could be reunited with her family. Dora was a remarkable young woman who had to grown up hard and fast. She was a selfless and courageous young woman who suffered through so much loss and her honesty and at times confusing emotions that she shares within her pages really touched my heart. How someone can face so much heartache through their lives and manage to conceal this from those around them is such a selfless act.
The ending of this book was such a poignant part and really brought a lump to my throat. I love this authors descriptive writing style and her storylines are so captivating I can not wait to see what her third novel will bring.
February 25, 2022
Would have absolutely loved this book if the author hadn't tried to cover too much story.
Pandora's story of the occupation of Rhodes was fascinating and I found myself skipping ahead a bit to the diary entries. This was the book I wanted to read. Just that.
Naomi and Rebecca should have been an epilogue not part of the main story. It just detracted from it and I struggled with the start of the book because there was so many people and so much information. Sometimes less is more.
Maybe Rebecca and Naomis story could have been a sequel...rather than packed into this book and being the dullest part of the book. Then we could have expanded that story further and made it interesting rather than being a distracting side note in this one.
The other thing I would say was there were too many coincidences that made it unbelievable.
I read alot of historical novels and this one had me scoffing at some of the things. The whole story was Evangelisa made me want to stop reading it was so daft.
Then who Fritz turned out to be had me rolling my eyes...completely ruined the credibility of the novel which would have been so much more powerful without these silly ploys.
They weren't engaging they just detracted from the actual fascinating story of Rhodes in war time.. the whole thing with the resistance...enthralling and so brave.
What happened Evangelisa was so frustrating and annoying...it undermined everything and made it a beach read rather than an engaging historical novel which teaches you...the same could be sad for them kissing..ridiculous.
Other things that seemed to be plot points rather than to progress story;
Why didn't Giovanni wait when he came to visit ? Completely ridiculous
Then the whole thing with who he turned out to be made me chuckle.
Throw in a pistol, dead parents, 2 boating accidents and a court case...oh and a killers ancestors...and a woman pining for a man for 50 years...oh and infertility....just goes on and on!
Nope just too much. Every single idea ever was rammed into this one book.
Could have been such a clever and intelligent look at Rhodes during war time and I could see flashes of brilliance. I am unsure why we needed to cram so many sub plots in but it was definitely a mistake and diluted the message substantially.
Pandora's story of the occupation of Rhodes was fascinating and I found myself skipping ahead a bit to the diary entries. This was the book I wanted to read. Just that.
Naomi and Rebecca should have been an epilogue not part of the main story. It just detracted from it and I struggled with the start of the book because there was so many people and so much information. Sometimes less is more.
Maybe Rebecca and Naomis story could have been a sequel...rather than packed into this book and being the dullest part of the book. Then we could have expanded that story further and made it interesting rather than being a distracting side note in this one.
The other thing I would say was there were too many coincidences that made it unbelievable.
I read alot of historical novels and this one had me scoffing at some of the things. The whole story was Evangelisa made me want to stop reading it was so daft.
Then who Fritz turned out to be had me rolling my eyes...completely ruined the credibility of the novel which would have been so much more powerful without these silly ploys.
They weren't engaging they just detracted from the actual fascinating story of Rhodes in war time.. the whole thing with the resistance...enthralling and so brave.
What happened Evangelisa was so frustrating and annoying...it undermined everything and made it a beach read rather than an engaging historical novel which teaches you...the same could be sad for them kissing..ridiculous.
Other things that seemed to be plot points rather than to progress story;
Why didn't Giovanni wait when he came to visit ? Completely ridiculous
Then the whole thing with who he turned out to be made me chuckle.
Throw in a pistol, dead parents, 2 boating accidents and a court case...oh and a killers ancestors...and a woman pining for a man for 50 years...oh and infertility....just goes on and on!
Nope just too much. Every single idea ever was rammed into this one book.
Could have been such a clever and intelligent look at Rhodes during war time and I could see flashes of brilliance. I am unsure why we needed to cram so many sub plots in but it was definitely a mistake and diluted the message substantially.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
June 26, 2023
Dual timeline novel set mainly on RHODES
There is a lot going on in this fairly lengthy novel. Dora’s story is told from the present looking back over the years of WW2, when Rhodes was under Italian rule, with German invaders. Her family is Jewish and many members were shipped off to concentration camps, leaving her to bravely fend for herself and a very young woman.
Her story comes to life through the medium of diaries, which her granddaughter Naomi has read and now feels the need to pass on to her sister, Rebecca, who is with Fritz, living in Bromley, London. There has been no contact between the sisters for more than a decade, ever since Rebecca announced her marriage to Fritz, who is of Teutonic descent. Dora took against him because he reminded her of the war years and the suffering she had to endure in her homeland.
In London, Rebecca is going through rounds of IVF which is inevitably putting a strain on her couple relationship. One day she receives a package, which, although addressed to her, she assumes it is for her husband. But when she does in fact open it, she is horrified to discover the contents (I thought it unlikely that the contents could have been sent through the post?). Anyway, shocking as they are, she understands that she must pick up contact with her family on Rhodes and start to read Dora’s diaries, and in this way she will discover the exact nature of her grandmother’s life during the terrible years. Dora was a brave soul, who stoically fought for her country and bore a child. She suffered a high level of loss, during and beyond the war years.
In present day Rhodes the family is fighting for the right to reclaim a property that was illegally taken from them during the war, and if they win their case, it would set a precedent for all those who lost their rights to their own properties during the war years.
I found it a compelling and at times heart wrenching audiobook (beautifully narrated by Lucy Paterson), which offered a lot of insight into the history of Rhodes and of the people and traditions. However, the novel felt overly long and the dramas that plague the characters – right up to the end when a ship capsizes – seemed rather excessive, and the drawn-out ending caused a bit of an eye roll.
There is a lot going on in this fairly lengthy novel. Dora’s story is told from the present looking back over the years of WW2, when Rhodes was under Italian rule, with German invaders. Her family is Jewish and many members were shipped off to concentration camps, leaving her to bravely fend for herself and a very young woman.
Her story comes to life through the medium of diaries, which her granddaughter Naomi has read and now feels the need to pass on to her sister, Rebecca, who is with Fritz, living in Bromley, London. There has been no contact between the sisters for more than a decade, ever since Rebecca announced her marriage to Fritz, who is of Teutonic descent. Dora took against him because he reminded her of the war years and the suffering she had to endure in her homeland.
In London, Rebecca is going through rounds of IVF which is inevitably putting a strain on her couple relationship. One day she receives a package, which, although addressed to her, she assumes it is for her husband. But when she does in fact open it, she is horrified to discover the contents (I thought it unlikely that the contents could have been sent through the post?). Anyway, shocking as they are, she understands that she must pick up contact with her family on Rhodes and start to read Dora’s diaries, and in this way she will discover the exact nature of her grandmother’s life during the terrible years. Dora was a brave soul, who stoically fought for her country and bore a child. She suffered a high level of loss, during and beyond the war years.
In present day Rhodes the family is fighting for the right to reclaim a property that was illegally taken from them during the war, and if they win their case, it would set a precedent for all those who lost their rights to their own properties during the war years.
I found it a compelling and at times heart wrenching audiobook (beautifully narrated by Lucy Paterson), which offered a lot of insight into the history of Rhodes and of the people and traditions. However, the novel felt overly long and the dramas that plague the characters – right up to the end when a ship capsizes – seemed rather excessive, and the drawn-out ending caused a bit of an eye roll.
May 5, 2023
I'm not sure what I expected from this book (I don't often read blurbs as don't want spoilers) but what an absolutely heart-wrenching and stunning read.
We spend the book alternating between present day - Pandora Cohen, grandmother, Bubba, recovering from a recent stroke with the help of her granddaughter, Naomi. Both hoping that estranged granddaughter/sister, Rebecca, will travel back to Rhodes to help out and reacquaint with them. And re-living the past through diaries - 1944 - young Dora Cohen, 16 year old Jew who was caught in the futility and chaos of the war years and coping with coming to terms with loss, grief, love, fighting for freedom all whilst coming of age.
I loved the way this was presented to us and the format of the girls reading Dora's thoughts, feelings and memories through her old diaries. Learning about life as it is now with Pandora struggling with her health but wanting to share the burden of her horrific memories and make sure that all is in order in case her time is near.
Naomi's complete and utter selflessness looking after her Bubba whilst trying to set up her own business, reunite with her sister and keep everyone happy.
Rebecca's desperation to start a family with her husband while tensions run high and the marriage struggles.
All our characters were utterly adorable!
The way they were introduced completely cemented them in my heart before we even delved into their lives and their complications. As we progress through the book, they blossom and develop so much. All so relatable for different reasons and all tugging at the heart strings.
The writing was so beautiful and I was completely living in both the present day world and the past with Dora.
Such an emotive subject and so sensitively delivered.
I absolutely felt every joy and every heartbreak along with them all!
The last few chapters we're just everything.
The conclusion of the diaries and the coming together of all the different parts of the stories - oh my, make sure to have the tissues to hand!
An absolutely brilliant book and I can't wait to read more from this author.
We spend the book alternating between present day - Pandora Cohen, grandmother, Bubba, recovering from a recent stroke with the help of her granddaughter, Naomi. Both hoping that estranged granddaughter/sister, Rebecca, will travel back to Rhodes to help out and reacquaint with them. And re-living the past through diaries - 1944 - young Dora Cohen, 16 year old Jew who was caught in the futility and chaos of the war years and coping with coming to terms with loss, grief, love, fighting for freedom all whilst coming of age.
I loved the way this was presented to us and the format of the girls reading Dora's thoughts, feelings and memories through her old diaries. Learning about life as it is now with Pandora struggling with her health but wanting to share the burden of her horrific memories and make sure that all is in order in case her time is near.
Naomi's complete and utter selflessness looking after her Bubba whilst trying to set up her own business, reunite with her sister and keep everyone happy.
Rebecca's desperation to start a family with her husband while tensions run high and the marriage struggles.
All our characters were utterly adorable!
The way they were introduced completely cemented them in my heart before we even delved into their lives and their complications. As we progress through the book, they blossom and develop so much. All so relatable for different reasons and all tugging at the heart strings.
The writing was so beautiful and I was completely living in both the present day world and the past with Dora.
Such an emotive subject and so sensitively delivered.
I absolutely felt every joy and every heartbreak along with them all!
The last few chapters we're just everything.
The conclusion of the diaries and the coming together of all the different parts of the stories - oh my, make sure to have the tissues to hand!
An absolutely brilliant book and I can't wait to read more from this author.
May 20, 2021
I listened to Villa of Secrets, by Patricia Wilson, as an Audiobook from Borrowbox. Read by Lucy Paterson, I was so taken with the story that it only took me a couple of days to reach the end, listening as I went out for a long walk with my dog and then planting tomatoes in my greenhouse! Books and gardening - I couldn't have been happier.
Sisters, Naomi and Rebecca, were raised by their grandmother, Pandora Cohen and the story is told through Pandora's diaries which Naomi and Rebecca are given to read. Unbeknown to the girls, their grandmother was a Freedom Fighter for the Andartes during World War II and risked her life to help free the Greek island of Rhodes from German occupation. Rebecca and her family had a falling out, ten years previously, and we also learn how this affected Naomi and Dora and how Rebecca eventually comes back into their lives.
Although a work of fiction, Villa of Secrets is based on some fact, I wasn't aware of how affected Greece and her islands were by the second world war. Patricia Wilson's attention to detail, and descriptive ability, bring to life the often harrowing and heartwrenching times of this war on the Greek communities.
There were humorous moments coupled with often very sad moments in Villa of Secrets, I didn't want some of the characters' stories to end the way they did, but I guess life doesn't always pan out the way you want it to, and because some of this novel was based on fact, it does bring home the reality that sad things sometimes happen to good people.
I would recommend Villa of Secrets to anyone who enjoys reading about World War II, particularly the lesser-known aspects of the German invasion. However, this is by no means a historical war novel, yes there is an element of this, but it also brings together the importance of family and friends and love and romance.
Sisters, Naomi and Rebecca, were raised by their grandmother, Pandora Cohen and the story is told through Pandora's diaries which Naomi and Rebecca are given to read. Unbeknown to the girls, their grandmother was a Freedom Fighter for the Andartes during World War II and risked her life to help free the Greek island of Rhodes from German occupation. Rebecca and her family had a falling out, ten years previously, and we also learn how this affected Naomi and Dora and how Rebecca eventually comes back into their lives.
Although a work of fiction, Villa of Secrets is based on some fact, I wasn't aware of how affected Greece and her islands were by the second world war. Patricia Wilson's attention to detail, and descriptive ability, bring to life the often harrowing and heartwrenching times of this war on the Greek communities.
There were humorous moments coupled with often very sad moments in Villa of Secrets, I didn't want some of the characters' stories to end the way they did, but I guess life doesn't always pan out the way you want it to, and because some of this novel was based on fact, it does bring home the reality that sad things sometimes happen to good people.
I would recommend Villa of Secrets to anyone who enjoys reading about World War II, particularly the lesser-known aspects of the German invasion. However, this is by no means a historical war novel, yes there is an element of this, but it also brings together the importance of family and friends and love and romance.
April 12, 2021
3.5 stars
I probably would have rated Villa of Secrets higher had I not read The Things We Cannot Say recently which had a very similar storyline. However, I enjoyed following the lives of three strong women - Naomi, her sister, Rebecca, and their grandmother, Pandora (Bubba). The book alternated between the present as the two sisters reunite and 1944, through the pages of Bubba's diaries.
At the age of sixteen, Dora's life was forever changed when she managed to escape when her family was rounded up and taken away on a ship to the concentration camps. Although only a teen, Pandora Cohen showed amazing courage as she joined the resistance fighters. Her journal entries were powerful and heartbreaking, and I found them extremely emotional as I read about her losses, devotion and determination to stop the Germans.
I have to admit that I have given very little thought about the Greek Isles during WWII and knew nothing about Rhodes and the atrocities the Jewish community faced, so Villa of Secrets was a real eye-opener. Also, the author did a great job weaving the two timelines and three storylines together, and the ending was poignant.
An enjoyable read that was well researched and based on fact.
I probably would have rated Villa of Secrets higher had I not read The Things We Cannot Say recently which had a very similar storyline. However, I enjoyed following the lives of three strong women - Naomi, her sister, Rebecca, and their grandmother, Pandora (Bubba). The book alternated between the present as the two sisters reunite and 1944, through the pages of Bubba's diaries.
At the age of sixteen, Dora's life was forever changed when she managed to escape when her family was rounded up and taken away on a ship to the concentration camps. Although only a teen, Pandora Cohen showed amazing courage as she joined the resistance fighters. Her journal entries were powerful and heartbreaking, and I found them extremely emotional as I read about her losses, devotion and determination to stop the Germans.
I have to admit that I have given very little thought about the Greek Isles during WWII and knew nothing about Rhodes and the atrocities the Jewish community faced, so Villa of Secrets was a real eye-opener. Also, the author did a great job weaving the two timelines and three storylines together, and the ending was poignant.
An enjoyable read that was well researched and based on fact.
July 13, 2018
Villa of secrets is a lovely summer read from Patricia Wilson.
Naomi and Rebecca have lost their parents to a tragic boat accident at sea. They are raised by their grandmother, Bubba(Dora) in Rhodes.
When Rebecca brings her fiancé home to meet her family, Bubba is horrified. Fritz is the image of the man who ordered the killing of hundreds of Jewish people during the German occupation. Rebecca and Bubba have words and Rebecca leaves for England.
Over the years, Bubba writes letters to Rebecca but she does not respond.
Bubba has a stroke and Naomi cares for her with her own family too. Bubba has never spoken of the past but now thinks it’s time to tell the girls. Her diaries tell her story and the girls are fascinated. Dora was a freedom fighter in the war and fought to save her family.
Bubba tries one last time and sends parcels to Rebecca. She is curious and finally comes back to Rhodes. Rebecca and Naomi find out the truth about their family history.
A wonderful story which you won’t put down full of courage, love, hope and secrets.
Naomi and Rebecca have lost their parents to a tragic boat accident at sea. They are raised by their grandmother, Bubba(Dora) in Rhodes.
When Rebecca brings her fiancé home to meet her family, Bubba is horrified. Fritz is the image of the man who ordered the killing of hundreds of Jewish people during the German occupation. Rebecca and Bubba have words and Rebecca leaves for England.
Over the years, Bubba writes letters to Rebecca but she does not respond.
Bubba has a stroke and Naomi cares for her with her own family too. Bubba has never spoken of the past but now thinks it’s time to tell the girls. Her diaries tell her story and the girls are fascinated. Dora was a freedom fighter in the war and fought to save her family.
Bubba tries one last time and sends parcels to Rebecca. She is curious and finally comes back to Rhodes. Rebecca and Naomi find out the truth about their family history.
A wonderful story which you won’t put down full of courage, love, hope and secrets.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 31, 2022
This was ok but I did feel that the story was overly complicated and distracting. It felt like there were 2 maybe even 3 protagonists. Rebecca’s character and storyline with her pregnancy and Fritz her husband was not really a necessary or even interesting part of the storyline. Both Rebecca and her sister Naomi were reading Bubba/Dora’s diary to get the historical story which I felt unnecessary. The story would have been much better with just Naomi as the single protagonist reading her grandmother’s diary. Bubba featured heavily in both historical and modern story so was a further protagonist.
The story was however interesting about the German occupation of Rhodes and I found it really interesting to hear about the confiscation of Rhodens property by the Nazi’s and how documents about this were only relatively recently uncovered. This is my first book by this author and I will try others as this to me had all the making of a great book, it’s just it’s distracting ramblings let it down.
The story was however interesting about the German occupation of Rhodes and I found it really interesting to hear about the confiscation of Rhodens property by the Nazi’s and how documents about this were only relatively recently uncovered. This is my first book by this author and I will try others as this to me had all the making of a great book, it’s just it’s distracting ramblings let it down.
June 15, 2023
This book is a pure example of Patricia's talent as a writer. An outstanding balance of compassion and mystery with twists, turns and even outright shocking bomb shells dropped in the storyline that will keep you page turning until way past bedtime and have you aghast with horror at the same time.
On a very serious note this well written story, although fictional is based on true events and is an important education to those who know nothing of the way in which WW2 tore through Rhodes. The devastation to the community is perfectly portrayed even down to the impact it had on the generations that followed in the decades after WW2 had ended.
It is clear that the writer really has researched this history to its very core and gone to such effort to ensure that the casualties of WW2 and indeed the turmoil it caused are spoken about with dignity and respect.
The modern day element of the story was carefully linked together with the historical side and the switch between the 1940s and the present day kept it fresh and interesting.
On a very serious note this well written story, although fictional is based on true events and is an important education to those who know nothing of the way in which WW2 tore through Rhodes. The devastation to the community is perfectly portrayed even down to the impact it had on the generations that followed in the decades after WW2 had ended.
It is clear that the writer really has researched this history to its very core and gone to such effort to ensure that the casualties of WW2 and indeed the turmoil it caused are spoken about with dignity and respect.
The modern day element of the story was carefully linked together with the historical side and the switch between the 1940s and the present day kept it fresh and interesting.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 131 reviews