I read this because Hugo Pratt and his Corto Maltese were and continue to be hugely famous in Europe, and are almost unknown here, not much has been available. So it's classic comics history. And this is a substantial graphic novel, surprisingly long for the kind of tale it is. Corto Maltese is a privateer/pirate in this 1967 introduction to him, set in 1914 in the Pacific, and involves swashbuckling type adventure characters such as a guy named Rasputin, Monk, shipwrecks, kidnapping… its an adventure story! Fun stuff, and pretty darned chaste for a pirate story, I'd say, as a single young girl (shipwrecked, imprisoned by pirates for ransom from her wealthy parents!) makes it through the whole tale without so much as being kissed, though she is the eye candy in this one, no question, and you need that as part of the genre, of course.
You know, I never read books like this and I found it entertaining. As is often the case with translations, this one is suspect, as the dialogue is sometimes a little stilted, and some of that may have to do with it begin older, but some of it is not great writing. The art is fine, expressive, but as others have observed, it looks like a copy of a copy, which makes sense as from time to time you see mistakes in the dialogue, you see shifts in the placements of the dialogue bubbles… occasionally it looks like it was a rush production job…
But you know, none of this fundamentally undermines the quality of the tale itself, millions of world readers were not wrong. These are pirates, but they all have likable, vulnerable qualities. They all seem tough but they are human beings. Compare this to contemporary noir and it is very tame, no really terrible bloodshed. As with any adventure story, our hero survives several obvious crises.
I thought it was really great. It's not a "ballad" as it says in the subtitle. It's kind of a rambling ride on the high seas, in an "exotic" environment like Bora Bora and New Guinea. The international relations are interesting. There's a war on as the pirates scheme a ransom plot so we see the Brits at odds with the Germans. The racial politics are interesting as the indigenous Pacific Islanders have to deal with all these white people trying to make profits on their land.
Why should an adult read this? Listen: this is my Year of Reading Proust and there is almost NO plot in In Search of Lost Time, so Corto Maltese is the anti-Proust, it's a page turner. They're antidotes for each other!