Yes, it was repetitive but it really helped to get the main points ingrained into my head. And hey smoking is repetitive too, so I'm not gonna complain about that! While I have not read any of the previous editions, the "for women" part seems a bit gimmicky. Aside from the chapter dedicated to smoking dyrng pregnancy and the letter excerpts from women, I'm not really sure how it targets women. Nonetheless, after a couple of weeks of struggling with willpower methods I picked this book up and read it as fast as I could. Even before finishing I noticed that my desire to smoke was decreasing, the taste was horrible, and I knew this was the tool I needed. Although I didn't feel like smoking that final cigarette, I did, and it was disgusting.