The Darkling Threads by Derek Corsaro is a complex, engaging piece of classic epic fantasy. Some of the characters and plot points are stereotypical and/or traditional for this genre but, overall, I found Corsaro’s work to be incredibly inventive and original, something which any fantasy fan will appreciate.
The geldens are a private race of beings. They don’t venture into the outside world often and keep their city hidden. They have yet to reach the end of Quiem Forest, and they don’t even know if the black flames at the end of the world are truly the end of the world. Yet when the Time of Measurement comes, they find out that there is a lot more outside of their walls than they’ve ever imagined, good and bad. Will they make this realization—and recognize the consequences—before it’s too late? Or will another malicious race take advantage of this relatively-docile kingdom before they have a chance to defend themselves?
Corsaro populates his fantasy world with a surprisingly wide variety of characters, but one thread connects many of them: the feeling of being a misfit. Meen is a human/gelden hybrid who many geldens see as a burden; Coda is so connected to magic that the other mumblers think he’s lost his mind; Risa cannot master spells nearly as quickly as her colleagues; and the other fledgling demons and fledging dragons think Elemelemelem is too weak to become a true demon. This isn’t one of those stories where all of the misfits come together, even the one on the “wrong” side, to defeat the ultimate evil, but it is certainly a story about how different kinds of people deal with being ostracized.
Unfortunately, I think this cast of characters may have been too large at times. On the one hand, such a large cast is needed to thoroughly explore the plot and this world. The larger cast also provides a more realistic interaction with the political manipulation, battles, and threats faced in Quiem Forest. On the other hand, I had a hard time keeping track of the different characters and perspectives earlier in the novel.
Overall, I think that The Darkling Threads is a very exciting and engaging novel. I really appreciate all the imaginative energy Corsaro put into it, as well as the fact that while humans are involved on a minor scale, they do not dominate the narrative. Some elements are a little darker than some people may like, but it should be perfect for the typical fan of epic fantasy. I can’t wait to see what Corsaro comes up with next!