Inheritance
This book was very divisive for me at first. Steven Savile clearly has exceptional talent to create a dark, heavy atmosphere perfectly fitting for the slowly sinking to decay villages and towns as the influence of Warhammer's infamous sylvanian vampires spread through the lands. He also created many excellently portrayed characters only to kick up the estabilished rules of the Warhammer Fantasy universe and pretty much delete the personality of ALL characters he build up so well, the moment some of them became vampires. After reading through Mike Lee's peak chapters in the Rise of Nagash that told the sad and slow descend of Neferata to darkness after becoming the undead monster that we know as a vampire in Warhammer, it was simply canon-breaking from Steven Savile to instantly turn people who dedicated their lives to exact vengeance upon the vampires for murdering their families, become bloodhungry crazed murderers of innocents from one page to another. I felt all the characters built up so far were thrown out to the trashcan in an instant, which is a shame since Vlad and Isabella von Carstein barely ever show up after the epilogue so losing the (historically speaking significantly less important random) characters the book focuses on made me think reading it was pointless. This book was my first and biggest disappointment so far after reading many Warhammer Chronicles books. However, it finds redemption.
Dominion
Because in the second book, it feels as if the author realized his mistake and does a succesful job of turning it into something else - bad pacing. The book spends significant amount of time with characters from the first book "waking up" to the fact of what they have become, and this finally restores what the vampires in Warhammer always had: free will. Just because one became a vampire, that doesn't mean they have to be evil. At this point we get significant character development for all the people, their real self I thought we lost in the first book, because they decide for themselves how to live with what they became - revel in undeath and blood of innocents as the monsters they fought against their whole life, or reject it and "live" as an outcast, enemy of both the living and the dead, trying to save the former while hunted by both, and trying to preserve of what's left of one's former life. Additionally we get a new main character, Konrad von Carstein who the book portrays as a political genius, rooting out all who'd betray him until a major twist in the book made me rethink everything I've read about him so far. The slowly turning to repetitive boredom infighting of the von Carsteins go out with a bang, and overall the whole second book is just miles ahead of the first one, fixing it's missteps and giving new value to Inheritance as an entirely setup book for Dominion, which speeds up the events significantly as the reader goes through it.
Retribution
And thankfully, through the last book this rise in quality never stops. Retribution combines the excellent character and atmosphere portrayal talent of Steven Savile, while successfully introduces new characters and fantastic war stories of footsoldiers, connecting the events of Inheritance and Dominion into a great final book. It finds perfect balance between showing us one of the biggest threat the Empire has ever seen, Mannfred von Carstein and how a few people around the world who stand up to make a difference were all required to put a stop to Mannfred's advance. However, while his presence is the obvious threat to the Empire - and undeniably the whole world next - after finishing the book I think it was still a secondary thing. Steven Savile thankfully did not abandon all those sidecharacters he used as eyes to tell the story of the vampire counts through them. I'm not going to list names here for spoiler reasons (you don't want it revealed here who makes it through the first two books, right?) but every sidecharacter who the author actually used as main characters get their story finally finished, and each in a very personal and satisfying way. To some, that's redemption, to others, punishment, to another, peace. And all three of these to one of my new favourite Warhammer Fantasy characters ever, the closing pages of Retribution says goodbye to. And I have Steven Savile to thank for creating him, the author who's knowledge and respect towards Warhammer Fantasy lore I seriously questioned in the first book. What a comeback these two others were!
I would recommend the book to everyone who likes grim, almost depressed characters and world building, and has the patience to eat yourself through it when it becomes too much, just to start to see the light at the end and go on an amazing journey out of the darkness along with the characters themselves. Characters who unlike us, can't put the book down to escape that world, and if you like characters who move in the moral grey zone, have tragic stories of suffering from or doing evil, and you want to root for them to find redemption or feel sad if they choose the wrong path - and to see these paths colliding - the von Carstein trilogy is definitely a great choice for you. However if you are looking for big, historical events of the Warhammer Fantasy world, you might want to skip this. Those who pick up this book already know Vlad, Konrad and Mannfred are destined to fail, and you won't get much more than that about them from this book, as they are treated as the sidecharacters in a story told through Empire witchhunters, soldiers, a young dawi adventurer, and half dozen lesser vampire characters where the author could enjoy the freedom to create his own characters and storylines. At first, that was hugely disappointing, but through the second book Steven Savile justifies this choice with excellent writing and doesn't stop until the last words of the third.