Well written - descriptive, thorough, it delves into the actions and the thoughts and feelings of the men involved. Not only does it analyze the Americans, but also covers snippets of Afghanistan's history, what brought it to the state of being a Taliban stronghold, and, more touching to me, also touches on the characters of the Afghans that fought decades against the Taliban. These men became as brothers to the American Special Forces, and together they introduced a new brand of warfare to the country. Not only a strictly modernized war, but a war of tactics previously unused before, where the Special Forces, quite isolated from the might of the rest of the US military, had to rely of their brains and their ability to build relationships, rather than brute strength. The author often emphasized the effects of these global relationships; the Taliban was not created in a vacuum, but sprung up from the residues of international conflicts, and neither would their defeat be best accomplished without effective international collaboration. It was definitely a compelling and enlightening read.
Only complaints are similar ones to other historical, and specifically military, accounts, primarily the fact that there are so many players, and so many locations, that it can be hard to keep track of it. Also, at some points, the chronicle of battles becomes repetitive and monotonous. While many details are no doubt important, they can feel lost when your mind zones out over yet another round of bombs, shots, flanking actions, etc. Interesting, yes, but maybe just give yourself breaks in order to fully absorb the nuances (I read it rather quickly and had to push through a few parts).
Overall, this is an incredible story and worth reading. 9/11 was a devastating blow to America, and its great to see this victory struck in the beginning of the war. But its also great to expand our perspectives, to learn to understand, as the Special Forces soldiers did, that these Afghans had already been fighting that fight for much if not all of their lives. As much as we could bring to the table, there was a lot we were taught in those early battles.