Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Twins Make Four

Rate this book
I have one of those faces.
The type of face where someone thinks you're someone you're not.
Scarlet thinks that. She thinks I'm her first love.
I'm not, but I'll be her last.


When I meet Scarlet, she's unlike any girl I've ever met.
Feisty, determined, she'll do anything to get her way.
Sauntering over to me in the bar with those hips. That silky hair. Those kissable lips.
Two can play at this game.
After this weekend we'll never see each other again.
Just 48 hours between the sheets.
Then I go back to Chicago and she stays in this sleepy little town.
Except four months later she shows up at my office with a secret so big it could tear our whole worlds apart.
One word changes everything.
Daddy.

Twins Make Four is a super steamy secret baby romance. It has a HEA and NO Cliffhanger. There are a few bonus books for your reading pleasure. Enjoy!

1101 pages, Kindle Edition

Published January 1, 2018

798 people are currently reading
221 people want to read

About the author

Nicole Elliot

56 books297 followers
PRESS the FOLLOW button for updates on my books!
USA Today Bestselling Author, Nicole Elliot, is a superhero who writes steamy romance on the side.
Okay so maybe not totally true. But she does write romance, lots of it. And she loves every second of it.
She finally created a fan group on Facebook, she does post a lot of pictures of cats, you've been warned. https://www.facebook.com/groups/ybbki...
You can also join her Newsletter!
When you join you get to read a FREE full length novel from her as a thank you for signing up!
BookHip.com/HMZGQM

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
258 (33%)
4 stars
196 (25%)
3 stars
219 (28%)
2 stars
82 (10%)
1 star
23 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 61 reviews
338 reviews6 followers
March 29, 2025
Just when I thought the plot was starting to move SMUT whoa smutty smut. Not bad smut, maybe a little too juicy smut. Tobias and Scarlet hook up quite a bit. He is a ceo of a legal firm, she works for a non profit. they went to the same private HS and she actually believes him to be an ex from HS all the way till the next morning. wow, I thought Scarlet was a total ditz after that. Tobias treats her to a nice dinner out and some emotional discussion then back to wham bam put the audiobook on mute in case anyone hears. There were other characters and layers to the story that were teased. But they never got past the hotel and office sessions drowning in bodily fluids.
Profile Image for Heather Miller.
1,483 reviews51 followers
January 11, 2018
I did receive a free ARC copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

This is a short story / quick read.

In this book we have Scarlet. Scarlet is ready for some fun so she goes out to a bar with her girl friends. However her night isn't looking exciting since her friends seem more interested in gossiping than dancing. She wanted to stay at home and watch her Netflix instead. Scarlet gets excited when she sees a man who she thinks she is her first love and boyfriend from high school, Preston. She goes up and starts a conversation with "Preston" who says his name is Tobias. Scarlet thinks "Preston" is just playing with her and goes along for old times sake. The sparks fly between the two and they take it back to his hotel room.

Tobias is a Prep School wealthy rich man. He is worried that woman only want his wealth, that they couldn't be actually interested in him but only care about his money.

There is no epilogue.

No character development.

Some inconsistencies
Profile Image for Dorel.
4,338 reviews38 followers
January 17, 2018
These are the 1st books I read by Nicole Elliot. TWINS 👶👶 MAKE FOUR: This book's story line was okay. I liked the hot & steamy scenes. I liked Scarlet's character. I liked Tobias's character. I liked the ending. DOCTOR'S FAKE PROPOSAL: I'm sorry I stopped reading this story at chapter 3 because it didn't hold my interest.
Profile Image for zen_s.
2,015 reviews17 followers
February 12, 2020
[1 star] book was sadly mediocre, not much development and substance. scarlet just comes off as a huge bimbo, i mean she thought the hero is her ex-bf and when the hero said he is not, she thought he was role-playing, like come on, seriously??
Profile Image for Kelly Fountain.
908 reviews2 followers
January 7, 2018
Possibly some spoilers.


This was an ok read. I'm left with a bit of confusion. Like is Scarlett actually a bad girl or just has a wild side. Why was the headmasters words made out to be such a big deal? The mistaken identity seemed to carry or more than necessary. The sex scenes were hot and written well. I'm disconnected because the relationship was rushed. After so much time apart and not really knowing one another, the "I love you's " came to quick for me. I needed more dialogue and connection between the two. I think it has a lot of potential and if more were added to make those connections, it could go from ok to a really great book.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Rebecca Grove.
3,492 reviews26 followers
January 8, 2018
Scarlet is ready for some fun so she goes out to a bar with her girl friends. However her night isn't looking exciting since her friends seem more interested in gossiping than dancing. The selection of available men is horrible until she spots a newcomer. Scarlet gets excited when she sees him because she thinks she is her first love and boyfriend from high school Preston. She goes up and starts a conversation with "Preston" who says his name is Tobias. Scarlet thinks "Preston" is just playing with her and goes along for old times sake. The sparks fly between the two and they take it back to his hotel room. There they have a very passionate night but the next morning she discovers that he really was Tobias. Once the two get over the mistaken identity issue, they have another passionate night and go their separate ways.
A few months later Scarlet hunts down Tobias to let him know that their passionate encounters have left her with a couple of consequences. Tobias is afraid that Scarlet might have ulterior motives since he is very wealthy. His former headmaster had also warned him against spending time with Scarlet. Now Scarlet just has to convince Tobias that she wants nothing from him that he isn't willing to give. Will Tobias listen to his heart or his doubts. I voluntarily received a copy of this story and this is my honest review.
Profile Image for SC.
810 reviews26 followers
January 10, 2018
Ah, what to say about this book .... It's short, and that's a good thing. I can't say I care for this author's writing style because there were just too many inconsistencies and very little character development.

I mean, the male MC actually says something like "I can't endure" while they're having sex, but she turns around and has the female MC saying things like "he grabbed my butt" which seems childish, especially if you're trying to set a specific tone by using words like "endure". And while speaking of the sex scenes, they just seemed sloppy and there was definitely no romance or love coming from them.

We do not get any information at all on the characters other than their present and maybe a touch of a past. This woman is pregnant with twins, and the ONLY person she talks about it with is one friend? No parents, no other family, nothing.

There is a whole chapter on how the male MC thinks having twins will affect his workload and business, do we even know how he worked that out? Of course not. She moves in, he proposes, the end. It felt incomplete.

If this author had beta readers and an editor for this book - she needs new ones. There are quite a few mistakes/errors and the book is much too short to have that many. I gave it two stars because I actually finished it and didn't delete it off my kindle after 3 chapters.
Profile Image for Michelle.
1,070 reviews22 followers
January 8, 2018
More like 3.5 stars....

A cute read overall but there are a few things that bugged me.

Spoilers possible....

They meet and she thinks he's someone else. He tells her who he really is but she doesn't believe him. Even slips up and calls him the other guys name while they talk. They have a 2 night stand and he leaves town. They keep thinking about each other but he deliberately deletes her number so he won't be tempted to call her (what a jerk). She calls him to tell him she's pregnant but (understandably) doesn't leave a message. Finally she shows up in his office to tell him. He's thrilled to see her and they pick up where they left off. There's a misunderstanding when he reads a text message from her best friend and he leaves. They make up and it's instant "I love you's". That was sudden. That's the last of the "bugged me" bits.
The rest actually goes really well and quite believabley. The happy ending is sweet and made me smile.

***I decided to review an ARC of this book.***
Profile Image for Jinx.
878 reviews
January 22, 2018
A case of mistaken identity that leads to a passionate two night affair.... or so they both thought.

Scarlet Kale was out with her friends for the night when we first meet her, she mistakenly sees a man she thinks is her ex boyfriend across the room, and boldly approaches Tobias Gentry, and when he invites her back to his hotel room she accepts, and they have a wonderful two nights together...

Fast foward 4 months and Scarlet is in Chicago at Tobias' office.... She's got news that will change both their lives forever, will he accept the news? Will they find their HEA?

I liked this book but it lacked depth for my liking. The characters while nice, just didn't have much going on for them to make the endearing. If they went to the same high school... here's a thought.. Look up the year book! Irritating when books don't quite deliver as promised.
1 review
February 28, 2024
This book… ugh, it was just sooo disappointing! It felt rushed and the characters were underdeveloped. There are a lot of questions left unanswered… for instance the headmaster what was his deal with her. I know she sorta answers by saying she skipped some classes and parties but why did the headmaster overreact. I also wanted to see/hear more about her ex and interacting with his look alike. At first I was thinking this book was going to take a twins separated at birth then adopted turn, where the headmaster knew about it thus trying to discourage MC from getting with FC but sadly that did not happen, might of made it more interesting though. Welp… this book has so much potential but really fell short imo.
Profile Image for BP34.
6,271 reviews46 followers
March 23, 2018
Talk about confusion and mistaken identities. Scarlet meets Tobias at a bar thinking he is her old high school boyfriend, Tobias and he doesn't tell her any different. The chemistry's there so they eventually make it to his hotel room for some steamy action. Parts of this are crazy, he deletes her phone number so he won't be tempted to call her and she calls to tell him she's pregnant but doesn't leave a message or return number. Then she shows up at his office to tell him she's pregnant with Twins. No spoiler here, but there's an HEA and an interesting journey on how they get there. I read an advance copy and voluntarily chose to write a review.
1,180 reviews3 followers
March 28, 2018
Fairly average

All these romances come with a sweet, lovable h, and a strong alpha male H.
Each has a nice hea. They were all very...nice. Nothing great. Not terrible. Just average.
But on a side note, they did make me wish this, and many other writers would download a thesaurus, and find some other word to replace about a blue million 'smirks'. Everybody in all these stories, smirk. All the time. They say it with a smirk. They look at each other, with a smirk. They smirk when they're happy, sad, mad, or glad. Surely there must be an interchangeable word. It's becoming a real sore spot for me.
93 reviews
March 23, 2018
Scarlet and Tobias have a fling while he is in town for business. Scarlet originally thought that he was someone else and Tobias is told that Scarlet is bad news, can they make it past these given impressions? Months later when Scarlet shows up pregnant with twins, will Tobias have an instant family or will Scarlet be turned away? An interesting, quick read. I liked the characters and the story line, but I didn't like where it ended, it seemed abrupt. Overall it was an enjoyable read and I liked it.
Profile Image for Karry.
1,419 reviews21 followers
May 18, 2018
A bit disappointed.

I was really looking forward to Twins Make Four. After how great book one in the series was, I had high hopes. Unfortunately, it fell short. There wasn’t enough. I didn’t read the other story in this book. To be honest Twins Make Four should have had its own book so that those reading that series get a full read, not just a novella sized story and a separate book unrelated to the series.
Profile Image for Carol.
3,560 reviews3 followers
January 7, 2018
Twins Make Four

Scarlet is a single female, not really wanting to have a serious relationship right now. Tobias is back home for a presentation at his home school, unexpectedly meets Scarlet, she mistakes him for someone else. What will happen when a mistaken identity takes on a new twist, cute, fun, great story about trust, learning to open your heart. ❤️
Profile Image for Sherry Westendorf.
4,593 reviews22 followers
January 8, 2018
I enjoyed this. She goes into a bar and sees him. She thinks he is her old high school boyfriend. They have a good time for a couple of days and then he goes home. She shows up 4 months later pregnant with twins. It is sweet, loving, mysterious, exciting, emotional and so much more. I recommend it. I was given a review copy and voluntarily review it.
Profile Image for Meredith Wu.
5 reviews
March 29, 2018
When I am looking for something to read on the steamier side, Nicole Elliot is one of the authors I always turn to.

I really loved the whole mistaken identity aspect of the story. The scenes with Tobias and Scarlett are super hot and I loved every minute of it.

If you are looking for a steamy read, with a great HEA, I would highly recommend it!
Profile Image for Dawn Pressel.
1,675 reviews
October 10, 2018
I'm having a problem with this insta-love-pregnancy story. Mistaken identity was believable. Greedy ex was expected but the whole "I love you" thing was to fast. Not to mention that his sister hasn't met Scarlet in that entire 4 months time? That is a bit too far of a stretch for me considering Tobias already discussed Scarlet with her.

Did I miss the gender of these babies?
Profile Image for Gladys.
13.9k reviews163 followers
January 5, 2018
Twins Make Four is a fun and steamy read. A highly entertaining and enjoyable read that tells a cute story of mistaken identity, a secret baby and hot passion. I'm posting a voluntary review after reading an ARC copy of this book.
Profile Image for Shannon.
4,096 reviews31 followers
January 5, 2018
I voluntarily reviewed an ARC of this book.

This is a really fast paced story, quick easy read. Scarlett and Tobias are really interesting sweet characters with sizzling hot chemistry between them.

A hot weekend of slight mistaken identity, four months later leads to twins.
4,261 reviews20 followers
January 8, 2018
Quick and fun read, an entertaining storyline and likable and relatable characters. This romp has plenty of misunderstandings to untangle before the H/h can find their HEA. I voluntarily read an ARC and this is my honest review.
Profile Image for Rhonda.
1,276 reviews4 followers
January 10, 2018
This is a good quick read. I didn’t realize it was interconnected with another story till I was about halfway through and was like umm... these people sound familiar lol! Aside from that it was quick and hot. I just wish there was a bit more of a relationship overall...
Profile Image for Rachel Wheeler.
1,614 reviews10 followers
January 10, 2018
2-3ish Stars


I wasn’t a huge fan... it was entertaining at times but I struggled through a majority of it.
~Instant love after making an ass of himself
~No epilogue
~No real character development....
Profile Image for Heather Matlock.
329 reviews2 followers
January 12, 2018
Thoroughly enjoyable quick read!

I really enjoyed the whole mistaken identity concept that brought the two characters together. Of course along with being endearing and sweet.. there was plenty of hot and dirty involved.
Loved Tobias!
Profile Image for Puna.
1,310 reviews14 followers
January 24, 2018
I had high hopes for this one but the female MC, Scarlet, was just TSTL. She confuses the MC with a guy from high school and even after he tells her who he is she STILL thinks he is the other guy ‘playing a game’ with her’
Profile Image for Kara.
7 reviews14 followers
January 30, 2018
I thought this book would be able to hold my interest but sadly it did not. It had potential but was short and kinda goofy in parts. I felt like there could have been so much more to the story, the characters and everything in between. I stopped reading....
Profile Image for Cathy Arbo.
26 reviews1 follower
February 4, 2018
Great story

I loved the story line. It was an easy read. The fact that the "father" had to pick up the child from daycare before knowing about the child was priceless.
However there are several grammatical errors.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 61 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.