The term ‘ultra’ is used for the most hard-core, sometimes violent fans of football clubs. This book deals with the ‘ultras’ who are really perpetrating the damage on football. James Montague excoriates the ‘ultra-rich’ in this fine book. These ‘ultras’ are a small but exclusive club of men who control the modern game arguably for motives other than the game itself.
James Montague’s book I found un-put-downable; I managed it in a few short days and while I still love the game at times it makes itself very unloveable and the roll-call of men manipulating modern football are well-exposed here including Kroenke, Putin’s inner circle like Abramovich and Usmanov , Xi Jinping and Sheikh Mansour bin Zayed al Nahyan plus a cast of supporting ‘ultras.’
The EPL club finances for 2016/17 have just been published and they make staggering reading - the two Manchester clubs alone have a combined player wage bill of £527,000,000 - yep, half a billion! The combined wage bill of the three relegated clubs in summer 2017 was £253,000,000. This may well not be sustainable, already some of the top spenders are wanting even more and there are more stirrings about a super-league in Europe maybe without the ‘moral hazard’ of relegation? Match-day fans suffer as they get priced out of the game, particularly the bedrock of younger fans, men and women now for whom top-flight football is becoming so expensive. I wonder if the EPL ‘bubble’ will burst? James Montague’s book hasn’t convinced me otherwise.
This book has made me think why is it that the ‘ultra-rich’ feel the need to make just another billion or so, or why they believe they can treat the fans in such a cruel way as exemplified in St. Louis by Kroenke. The contemptuous way in which the ‘ultras’ of the former Soviet Union and the U.A.E. treat, in turn, Ukrainians and migrant workers from Bangladesh, is described clearly and it is hard to see how any institution can now govern these modern-day horrors.
I happen to support a lower league club that also has, rather bizarrely, a Jordanian owner who came out of nowhere a couple of seasons back, but no real supporter involvement in the governance of the club or indeed millions injected into the club. Yet? Am I troubled by this - yes, but it is a conflicted yes and James Montague mentions in the book.
Well-researched, well-written and a good summary of where the game currently is and yes you could argue that it is only a matter of scale in that it has always been ‘rich men’ who have owned football clubs but I share a fear for the game that others have expressed too. More than that the horrors of warfare, human exploitation and disregard for fundamental human rights are being masked behind the ‘soft power’ of the top-flight football clubs.