Amazon math.
Amazon assures me this is the 38th book in a series of 27. I've read and reviewed 31 books (in the series of 27) and have some left. I'm unable to explain this confusion, but Amazon is NEVER wrong, so it must be me.
Superintendent Littlejohn is vacationing on the Isle of Man with his wife Letty and dog Meg. As always, there's a murder while he's there. Either there are a LOT of murders on this sparsely-populated, mostly rural island or having a Scotland Yard Supervisor around brings out the competitive spirit in the local criminal element.
I like Littlejohn, but if I lived on the Isle of Man, I wouldn't leave my house if he was visiting. Nor would I open the door to anyone - friend, foe, or stranger. The honor of being the murder victim in an investigation headed by a famous Metropolitan Police Superintendent isn't worth it to me.
This murder is a puzzler for Littlejohn, local CID Inspector Knell, and the Venerable Archdeacon Caesar KInrade, the Littlejohns' friend and host. The elderly parson is revered for his saintliness, but he loves a good murder investigation. Knowing everyone on the Isle (having baptised, married, and buried several generations of local families) he's a big help to the police.
A man is known by the company he keeps, but not everyone is a good judge of character. A young man from "Over" arrives to spend his vacation with his aunt. On the boat he's picked up by a Teddy Boy (small-time thug) named Alf Cryer. Cryer is older and more sophisticated and his new friend is flattered by his attention. He fails to realize that Cryer is using him to get past the Isle's tight security system designed to keep out criminals like Alf.
Cryer isn't the good buddy he promised to be and he's caught with a stolen wallet Theft is a bad rap, but when the owner has been murdered, it's even worse. Needless to say, Alf puts all the blame on his gullible new acquaintance. Luckily, the boy has an alibi and it's Cryer who's arrested and held.
It would be easy to convict Cryer for the murder, but Littlejohn and Knell think he's too shrewd to murder for petty cash when there's no shortage of drunks with easy-to-lift wallets. They're also puzzled that the victim (a respectable middle-aged bachelor who never drinks alcohol) has been spending so much time at a local pub. The pub owner claims his pretty young daughter is the attraction, but the girl denies it. What's going on?
The murdered man is a member of an old island farming family. Ballacroake is a prosperous farm and they're frugal people. Through the generations, the family has collected priceless antique furniture and ornaments that make the local antique dealer's mouth water. However, they don't need the money and refuse all offers for their family heirlooms.
Before the murder, the family consisted of three ageing bachelor brothers, their spinster sister, and the young son of their late brother. One brother drinks too much, but they get along well with each other and are liked and respected by their neighbors.
The precious family heirlooms are the joy of Miss Bridget, who cares for them like a fond mother. Everyone loves Bridget, but she's had a difficult life. She was prevented from marrying the man she loved because he was an employee of the family and not of their class. She was close to her brother John Croake and his murder devasted her. And she recently saw a doctor and got bad news.
Littlejohn, Knell, and the Archdeacon all believe that Croake's murder wasn't random, but the result of a personal vendetta. They patiently talk to people, pooling their results, and sharing their theories. If they can figure out who had a hold on John Croake, they may learn what was being demanded of him.
Every family has secrets and the Croakes are no exception. One of John Croake's secrets made him vulnerable to particularly vicious criminals. Not only was he blackmailed, he was forced to make payments in the most humiliating way possible. When he tried to break the hold, his tormentors killed him.
I love the Littlejohn mysteries set on the Isle of Man. The English bank manager who wrote under the name "George Bellairs" vacationed there every year and settled there when he retired. He died there at a ripe old age.
Usually I scream if a mystery writer wastes my time on scenic descriptions, but this author's love of the island makes his praise of its beauties charming and touching instead of cloying or irritating. I like Littlejohn better with every book I read about him. Inspector Knell is a fine young policeman. And Archdeacon Kinrade is a wonderful character, combining goodness with a no-nonsense personality and a deep understanding of human nature.
They're a fine investigative team and they share traditional values about violent crime and the appropriate punishments.. OK, punishing the guilty won't bring back the victims. We know that punishment (regardless of how harsh) has little benefit in preventing crime. Human nature being what it is, greed and arrogance are frequently stronger than fear of disgrace and punishment.
I still believe we should punish the guilty. It's the right thing to do and we owe justice to victims and those who loved them. Littlejohn, Knell, and Archdeacon Kinrade are kind-hearted, compassionate men, but they reserve their sympathy for the innocent, not the guilty. Which is as it should be and why I prefer old mysteries to newer ones.