Cave emerges from the swamp. The early lyrics are ‘the dolls on the grill are caked in bloody bug guts’ and ‘a fucked little insect’ - actually quite a lot of bugs and insects. Slowly we see the new world gothic of Cave’s first great period. Big Jesus Trash Can gives way to ‘I stuck a six inch gold blade in the head of a girl’ but the lines sit there disconnected without pathos or irony. And then a couplet that wouldn’t be out of place in Cave’s second (and overlapping) great period of lovelorn melodrama - ‘love is for fools and all fools are lovers, it’s raining on my house and none of the others’.
The one act plays, that sit in the middle, are barely curiosities. A priest having already lopped off one of his hands, with the aid of an attachment goes to work on four digits on his remaining hand. His hands are possessed and he is compelled. ‘The unfortunate five’ will become the ‘filthy five’ by the time we get to The Mercy Seat. These are not one act plays though. They last just a matter of seconds before someone blows their head off. Salome is Cave working out what to do with biblical imagery and references.
The second set of lyrics see Cave put it all together. From Her to Eternity has such a strong narrative - incidentally the opening ‘ah wanna tell ya bout a girl’ started as ‘now I wanna tell ya about Maine’ in a one act play. The songs have more magical or mythical imagery that perhaps comes from the biblical where anything is possible. Again from the epic From Her to Eternity - Her tears seep through the floorboards to the protagonist below. Tupulo - released as a single - re-imagines Elvis’ birth and the stillbirth of his twin as biblical prophecy. Pop music was different in 1985.
The collection ends with The Mercy Seat, the point at which Cave achieves perfection. It’s perfection, as with Leonard Cohen, where working within the its form, every word is perfectly chosen and placed. The effect has always been mesmerising, on record, live and on paper. It’s a level of perfection that Cave has gone on to repeat.