“Open Tab (Whisky Springs #1)” is a more enjoyable book if you listen to the sequel (“Cigar Club”) immediately after “Open Tab”.
As a stand-alone, “Open Tab” is frequently engaging, yet frequently exasperating, if not completely annoying. As a Kindle book, I may have given up on “Open Tab”, and moved on to another in my too quickly growing list of books that interest me. That would have been a shame for me, because after listening to Book #2, I’m really looking forward to Book #3 (“Night Cap”) when it becomes available as an audiobook. What kept me engaged was the very enjoyable narration, and the terrific assortment of secondary characters.
30yo widow MC Riley and her 2yo son Owen are delightful. Riley’s sister (left back in California thank goodness) is controlling and annoying. In Whiskey Springs, Vermont, MCs Fallon and Andi are difficult to like. For 99% of the book, Fallon and Andi have a Friends With Benefits relationship. Andi is married (to a man) and has college-aged sons. Fallon is the town token lesbian, and is well-known for one-nighters with coed tourists, though that’s getting a bit old for her now that she’s in her 30s. Naturally, this being a small town, virtually everybody knows about their relationship, though they think they’re discreet.
Riley is admired and desired by everyone, including Fallon, although everyone assumes she’s straight. I swear to god, It’s a wonder that any of us lesbians ever date IRL; lesbian literature seems determined to train us to be attracted in a serious way only to women we assume are straight, and only to play bouncy-bouncy in bed with other lesbians or the openly bicurious.
Anyway, there are lots of side characters in “Open Tab” - family members, bar patrons, bar employees, etc. etc. Part of the difficulty with “Open Tab” is that the thing that makes the series terrific also makes the first book difficult to embrace: this isn’t a clear cut love story focusing on two people; all of the characters all have their own quirks and personalities, and the interactions between them are historically complex, currently complex, and evolve toward an uncertain…and likely complex future.
Six hours and 26 minutes into the 6:44 book, Fallon made such a WTF decision that I just about lost it. Really? Sigh. People can be such jerks…to themselves as well as to others.
Despite my initial frustrations, “Open Tab” turned out to be a remarkably insightful and thoughtful study into the nature of loneliness, and that of the many types of love. There is a terrific mix of generations, and their interactions, and their observations on the nature of loneliness and love from many viewpoints and hopes and fears. Behaviors IRL certainly are often self-destructive, and “Open Tab” does a great job addressing how we can recognize destructive behaviors, and, perhaps with the help of friends, survive and move on to better situations.
I’m very glad I listened to “Open Tab”, and I recommend it with 4*. Set aside time to listen to Book #2 immediately after, while you have the characters and their situations fresh in your mind!