Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Sweet Hills of Florence

Rate this book
1941. Florence, city of strife. It is Hitler’s state visit to Florence and the last of the good times for Mussolini. From now on, he and his lover Clara will cling more closely together, ever more dependent upon each other as their country spirals into civil war and their lives disintegrate.
Annabelle and Enrico, young cousins from an ancient Florentine family, work first with the clandestine resistance, then openly with the partisans. Facing life and death together in the mountains, they forge a passionate life-long bond.
How reliable is memory and can we ever expiate past sins? Are some ghosts better left alone?

420 pages, Paperback

First published January 1, 2018

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Jan Wallace Dickinson

3 books2 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
17 (47%)
4 stars
11 (30%)
3 stars
7 (19%)
2 stars
1 (2%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 15 of 15 reviews
Profile Image for Amanda - Mrs B's Book Reviews.
2,285 reviews355 followers
July 6, 2018
*https://mrsbbookreviews.wordpress.com
The ghosts of the city of Florence and Italy’s past are opened up by the expert eyes of Australian historical fiction novelist Jan Wallace Dickinson. The Sweet Hills of Florence is a powerful testimony to the past and to a time of great civil unrest. Gently wreathed into this compelling tale of Italy at war, is a rich parable of political unrest, Mussolini’s rule and a consuming love story. Jan Wallace Dickinson also reminds us through her novel, how the past vastly impacts on the present, is this richly told tale.

The Sweet Hills of Florence takes the reader right into the heart of the Italian city of Florence. An ethereal city defined by cathedrals and beautiful architecture, it is clear from early on in the novel that the city is under siege. As Hitler makes his all important visit to the city, it becomes apparent that Florence is entering a new stage of change. It is a city under a great deal stress, dealing with a country that is fractured by the presence of civil war. The Sweet Hills of Florence illuminates how lives are suddenly threatened and irrevocably changed. Among the good people of Florence are two young figures, Annabelle and Enrico. The cousins from a prominent Florentine family are compelled by the events around them to join the resistance. It throws these two promising young people in the pathway of the partisans. Fighting for their freedom and for their country, the two form an unbreakable bond. In The Sweet Hills of Florence, Jan Wallace Dickinson shows us how the choices made during unrest and the pressures of uncertainty during war can be continued to be felt in the present day.

The Sweet Hills of Florence a piece of historical fiction that has strong merit and I would urge any reader with even a passing interest in Italian history or World War II to seek out a copy of this novel. The strong lean towards the history books made me realise just how much I didn’t know about Italy’s history and the fate of prominent Italian cities, such as Florence, in the war. Although I have an awareness of the influence and role of Mussolini in Italy’s turbulent past, this book bridged a gap in my knowledge, but it did take some concentration. I came away feeling better informed and educated about Italy’s wartime history. I also felt much more informed about how the past has a part to play in the current political climate felt in Italy.

Jan Wallace Dickinson puts the spotlight on two young figures from a prominent Florentine family in her novel. Annabelle and Enrico are well constructed characters and I appreciated their journey. Both their ensuing adventures in the book are dangerous and action packed. These moments are offset by tender instances of love, loyalty and sacrifice. By the end of the novel I felt like I had been taken on one incredible journey with these characters. I also enjoyed the angle Dickinson took by introducing Annabelle’s grand niece to the mix. This gives the book a firm past to present dimension. The use of Annabelle’s diaries was an effective narrative device that I appreciated very much.

Jan Wallace Dickinson works hard to transport her reader firmly to the time and place of the main events of her novel, which is Florence during the war years. I visited Florence back in 2009 as part of a tour and although my visit was short, I will forever remember the rich history, culture, art and architecture. Through The Sweet Hills of Florence, I felt like the reading experience helped to situate me back in this rich locale, my feet were firmly set on the ground of this beautiful city. Oh how I long to return now I have a new sense of understanding about the torrid back history of this city and nation.

The sheer dedication and commitment the author has demonstrated in ensuring all the historical facts are right in this novel astounds me. This is a book richly seeped in historical understanding. Jan Wallace Dickinson provides a comprehensive picture of the key influential figures of this time (Mussolini, his mistress and Hitler) and she also highlights the all important plight of the ordinary citizens of the country. In addition, we receive a strong insight into the world of the resistance and the activities of the partisans. Likewise, Jan Wallace Dickinson touches on the influence of the Nazi war machine. One of my favourite segments of this novel revolved around the moves to hide Italy’s beautiful artwork from the clutches of the Nazi’s. It was captivating!

All in all this was a grandiose novel, so abundant in history that it reminded me of just how much I still have to learn about European history during World War II. Just be sure sure you have your historical thinking cap on while reading this novel. The Sweet Hills of Florence uses resonating characters to highlight the importance of love, loyalty, family, friendship and includes an Italian/Australian connection that ultimately reads well. I must note that the author of The Sweet Hills of Florence is incredibly giving and knowledgable about her craft. Do not hesitate to connect with Jan should you wish to discover more about this fascinating time in our not too distant past. I would love to hear this historically well versed author discuss her craft in person.

*I wish to thank the author and the publisher, Hybrid Publishers, for providing me with a free copy of this book for review purposes.

The Sweet Hills of Florence is book #73 of the Australian Women Writers Challenge
Profile Image for Patricia Bursill.
1 review1 follower
March 27, 2018
I loved this book! It is beautifully written and paced, with wonderful characters that now feel like family. The story addresses the often complex relationships between family, lovers and friends, things spoken and left unspoken. It is about the weight of the past pressing down on the now.
I loved learning about the history of Italy and Florence during the war and how it still affects the country today. After reading this book, I am looking forward to being in Florence and feeling the weight of this history that is often overlooked in the Renaissance city.
Do yourselves a favour if you are after a stunning tale with strong, inspirational characters, of a time and place you may, or may not know much about.
1 review
March 30, 2018
The Sweet Hills of Florence.

I am not an avid reader but I could not put this book down. Jan Wallace Dickinson, through her very descriptive writing and her vast knowledge of life in Italy, transported me into the hills of Florence. I felt the pain, the love, the danger that the partisans lived through in the early 1940s. I could even smell the mud, the rain, the battles and the killings that took place. All of this culminated in a love story that kept me in suspense right until the very end.
Profile Image for Lisa.
3,947 reviews502 followers
April 25, 2018
Florence is one of the great tourist destinations of the world – a world heritage site of priceless Renaissance art and architecture. (You only need to look at its Wikipedia page if you need any convincing). My memories of the city are full of galleries and cathedrals – and although I thought of Mussolini when we saw his famous balcony at the Palazzo Venezia in Rome, he didn’t cross my mind for a moment in sunny Florence. So the dark history of civil war in Florence during the German Occupation in Jan Wallace Dickenson’s debut novel The Sweet Hills of Tuscany was a revelation to me.

The novel introduces Mussolini in 1941 hosting Hitler’s state visit to Florence, bragging afterwards of his godlike status to his lover Clara. At the same time, the aristocratic Albizzi family reacts with dismay. Annabelle, who’s only a dreamy teenager who would rather read books in her father’s library, doesn’t really understand much of what’s going on, but she’s very interested in her cousin Enrico’s reaction because she loves him better than anyone else in the world.

While the parents watch events with disapproval but fail to act, Italy lurches inevitably towards chaos. There are clandestine efforts to help the Jews caught up in Hitler’s Final Solution, and art works are spirited away into country villas to prevent the Germans looting them, but the city is divided between supporters of the regime and its ineffectual detractors. But as the tide turns against the Axis in the war, Mussolini’s grip on power weakens and eventually he is deposed, only to be rescued by the Nazis and reinstalled as a puppet leader in the north of the country. With the 1943 Allied Landing making its way up the ‘boot’, Enrico joins the partisans. And partly because she loves him, but also because she is fired with passion for the cause, so does Annabelle. At first she is a staffeto, a courier passing messages within the city, but eventually she takes up arms with Enrico in the mountains.

To read the rest of my review please visit https://anzlitlovers.com/2018/04/26/t...
Profile Image for Gilda Carbonaro.
Author 1 book4 followers
October 5, 2020
I envy a writer who balances her deep knowledge of history with her talent to craft a story that keeps you turning the page to the very end. Jan Dickinson doesn't make up the historical facts that are the basis of this story, they are part of the tragic history of Italy under Mussolini particularly during the ferocious fighting after Badoglio signed the Armistice. In a surreal setting of wartime Florence she has woven a tale of courage and passion. It is interesting how humanity forgets; the parallels between the events of those times and our present drift into fascism is disturbing to anyone who is a student of history.
Profile Image for Theresa Smith.
1,087 reviews7 followers
December 31, 2018
I’ve read a few novels about Italy, set during WWII, and it never fails to stun me how devastated that country was. The burden of putting your life back together and living within the stain of so much misery would have been no small feat. As time progressed, history would have mingled with the present, ensuring that the passage of time didn’t necessarily ease the burden of memory. The Sweet Hills Of Florence pays homage to the partisans of Italy, narrowing its focus onto Florence in particular. It’s an ambitious novel, weighted with history, steeped in atmosphere, even including a fictionalised account of the last years of Mussolini, viewed from the perspective of his mistress, Clara Petacci.

‘This was the real Florence, the Florence of sobbing and wailing and tearing of hair, not the painted and decorated Florence put on show by the authorities to distract the populace.’

This novel is heavy reading, not just in its subject matter, but also in its breadth and scope. It was, for me, too long. The history is meticulously documented and woven into the narrative with precision, but the complications of Italy’s political history and the large cast make for a concentrated effort. The author’s passion for Florence, and indeed, for Florentine history, is well realised though, and the resulting sense of atmosphere was richly rendered. There is much food for thought throughout the novel, particularly relating to the protection of art in times of war.

‘Was art worth a human life? Well, she supposed it depended on whose life. But if there was nothing left afterwards, what were they all fighting for?’

There is a romance, or rather, a love story, underpinning the events of the novel, but it failed to draw me in. If I’m honest, it kind of repelled me.

‘It was clear to everyone that Annabelle and Enrico were in love. They would ‘come to heir senses’ was the general view. It was the war. The war turned everything topsy turvy. The war made people do things…’

Annabel and Enrico are first cousins, in what I gathered was an aristocratic family. The family itself seemed lofty and appeared to have placed themselves in a position of isolation on account of being anti-everything. I found this depiction quite interesting actually, and I could see how this had transpired as a result of an ideological clash with the politics of Mussolini, who we can’t forget, was in power for a great many years before WWII. But this lofty view had resulted in a particularly sheltered existence, more so for Annabel than Enrico, and consequently, she became rather fixated on her own cousin. Until Annabel entered the resistance, she was overtly dreamy with little grasp on the wider world around her, embarrassingly obsessed with the ‘love story’ between Mussolini and Clara. While my opinion of her rose immeasurably as she began to find herself through her work in the resistance, and then later as a partisan, I still felt her affair with Enrico was off balance. I simply couldn’t become invested in their love story because I fundamentally didn’t approve of it.

A good portion of this novel was given over to Clara and Mussolini, in a move to humanise them, is my guess, but Clara was such a shallow woman, and Mussolini was so whiny and irrational. I came to dread these sections. What happened to their corpses after their deaths can be evaluated in many ways, but I think allowances need to be made for the pain and loss that people endure, the atrocities and debasement that can be forced upon a person. I refuse to judge another when I truly have no concept on what it’s like to live within their skin. Stories about any war need to be handled with care, particularly those that occurred within the generations of living memory. ‘The wrong sector of the right side’ is a notion that brings me a lot of discomfort. I grew up digesting the history of WWII, my Belgian grandfather never failed to remind us daily how lucky we were. In adulthood, I became privy to the reasons why he had berated us for moaning over wet socks and lumpy porridge. Details about his life as a resistance fighter were imparted to me almost as a revered gift, the knowledge of which sits within me like a solid mass. One thing I appreciate about this novel is that it neither romanticised nor demonised the resistance. It just depicted it as it was. I still feel unsettled though, by this novel, and I can’t seem to put my finger on why.

‘Are we heroes? Are we murderers? When do we become what we are fighting against?’

Overall, The Sweet Hills Of Florence is a novel with great depth and regard for the history that inspired it. Jan Wallace Dickinson is an author who demonstrates a clear passion for her subject. Anyone with an interest in Italian history would do well to add this novel to their shelves.


Thanks is extended to the author for providing me with a copy of The Sweet Hills Of Florence for review.
Profile Image for Leanne.
891 reviews9 followers
December 6, 2018
This is a meticulously researched work of historical fiction that begins in 1941 with Mussolini hosting Hitler’s visit to Florence. What follows is a sweeping saga which outlines Italy’s spiral into decline during WWII and the subsequent civil war. The shocking story is revealed alternately between Annabelle, daughter of a renowned Florentine family, who ultimately joins a band of resistance fighters, and Clara, Mussolini’s besotted mistress. Fast forward 65 years, with the death of one of the main characters and we learn of Italy’s politics in the modern era under Berlusconi’s leadership and wonder what lessons from the past have been learned. Links to Australia are also included as family members flee war-torn Italy to start afresh in a new country, escaping the horrific circumstances in their homeland. A fascinating read. Those with an interest in Italy or its history are sure to enjoy it.
1 review
May 30, 2018
The intertwined threads of Jan Dickinson’s compelling novel show how the human spirit can endure and overcome the absolute mayhem life can periodically produce. We follow the transformation of Annabel and Enrico from privileged young Florentine adults to committed partisans engaged fearlessly in the horrors of both civil and world wars. The maelstrom of their lives unfolds against the fascinating tale of Clara Petacci’s passionate relationship with Italy’s fascist dictator, Mussolini.

Annabelle’s Australian niece, Delia, brings the story to the modern day nurturing Annabelle’s reminiscences and her disquietude that the sins of the fathers could be repeated. The Sweet Hills of Florence is a well-written, carefully researched novel that draws you into the characters’ complex strengths and frailties - I really enjoyed it.
1 review
June 10, 2018
What a glorious, passionate epic of a novel! I could not put it down. I was completely transported. The title is completely misleading (or ironic), as the novel laid bare the brutality of war, human frailty, and political miscreants; woven with the dark and the joyful side of love and relationships. The author has obviously researched meticulously her period, and tells her story with unflinching truth. The tale is as educational as it is entertaining. I have visited Florence and the surrounding region several times, and now want to return with fresh eyes. I cannot recommend this novel enough; treat yourself, and keep your fingers crossed that the author finds further inspiration and is working on a second manuscript! I am!
394 reviews3 followers
August 16, 2021
A really good story, though perhaps it could have been a little shorter as the descriptions of the resistance fighting sometimes felt a bit repetitive. However, overall, I found the story of the resistance and the relationships between the various groups and the members within the groups to be very interesting.
The links back to life of characters living in Australia was well done.
Assuming it's a reasonably historically correct account of the time, it was an absolute eye opener to the heavy losso f life and cruelty of the German forces in italy in WW2.
Profile Image for Sally.
70 reviews
November 12, 2024
This novel is heavy reading in its breadth and scope. It was, for me, too long and required a concentrated effort which for me became somewhat tedious and I wasn't always willing to make the effort.. Italy’s political history during WW2 is meticulously documented and woven into the narrative with precision and the author’s passion for Florence and Florentine history, is impressive. I am now motivated to follow up books written by historian James Holland's expertise on all matters of Italy during WW2.
1 review
June 1, 2018
This is a great read. The historical events of the fascist era in Italy and the eventual civil war come alive with the descriptive and sensual writing of Jan Wallace Dickinson. You feel empathy with the characters, especially the rebel partisan fighters enduring the horrors and privations of conflict, yet also Mussolini and Clara. All emerge as passionate individuals, regardless of their choices.
I loved the contrast of Australian and Italian lifestyles woven through the story and have never found history more compelling
Beverley Yeomans


91 reviews
May 17, 2022
I thoroughly enjoyed this book. Emotional, powerful and great historical information. When I visit Florence again I will see it with a different perspective. Loved it.
1 review
May 27, 2018
Jan has woven history and fiction together to create a compelling read. Her characters are well rounded and believable. I found the history of the Italian partisans and their rivalry with the communists particularly interesting as I did the end of the fascist era as seen through the eyes of Mussolini and his mistress, Clara. A must read!
1 review
June 14, 2018
There is nothing “sweet” about The Sweet Hills of Florence. It is a passionate and raw account of a very real time in Italy’s history; a story well meshed between past and present, between Italy and Australia, between lovers whose past and present create an indelible bond, brought together through the author’s detailed account of and perspective of life and fascism in Florence.

The author’s enormous amount of research together with her profound knowledge of the city she is so attached to would make this book an excellent resource to students and Italian history enthusiasts. The contrast drawn between the Italy of Mussolini then and the Italy of Berlusconi leaves the reader contemplating what the future holds. A must read.
Displaying 1 - 15 of 15 reviews