Windhover

by Alan Brown, Christian Birmingham (Illustrator)

Windhover is the story of a Kestral chick and a young boy. A compassionate and moving story, beautifully illustrated, creating a real sense of how the world is seen through the eyes of a young bird.

Genres: Picture Books

32 pages, Hardcover

First published September 15, 1997

Reviews

[Mathew · Rating 2 out of 5]

When a family of kestrels give birth to three chicks in the roof of a building close to a school, a young boy sees his opportunity and steals one of them. He deeply wants to raise the bird but does not have either the knowledge or understanding to look after it. Soon it grows weak and ill - can it be returned to its nest before it's too late?
There were too many elements that just grated me with this story. I do like Birmingham's illustrations (I think) but the story itself was weak and jumpy. Written from the perspective of the chick (which was a nice touch) much was missed in understanding why Dan chose to take the chick and his relationship with the girl who challenges him. It was like reading a book with several chapters missing.
Then there was the factual inconsistencies too. When the kestrel is returned to its family, several days later or more, it's welcomed and prioritised again: nope.

[Alice · Rating 3 out of 5]

3.5 Stars At first I wasn't sure about this book. It is from the perspective of the bird. The story is interesting and a perfect lesson for children to leave the birds alone.

I don't love the pictures! There could be so much more detail. I liked this story did not love it! Still worth reading!