I saw some raw footage on YouTube of the Bronx in the early 1980s. It legit looked like a war zone. Huge lots were just filled the rubble of old buildings. The streets were littered household junk: old bed frames; rusted shopping carts; bags of trash; assorted debris. One might guess the sidewalks to be dangerous without the threat of criminals (tetanus seemed a constant threat), and the weeds growing up through the sidewalk suggested disuse. It looked like France after WWII, or modern-day Aleppo.
I knew little about the Bronx of that era and wanted to dig into the research. How the hell had that war zone happened? One of the first books I saw during a quick initial search was Street Warrior. Seemed like the jackpot. Who would know more about that place in that time than a member of the NYPD?
If Ralf knew anything about the socio-economic conditions that transformed a bustling city into a moonscape, he doesn’t share those insights in this book. He barely touches on the physical nature of the landscape; the absolute decay. I was bummed. Ralph stuck to the telling of his own story within a pretty small scope.
Street Warrior is basically a litany of old police reports (at one point Ralph actually confirms this notion). They are action-packed, filled with pathos and humor, but there’s almost no depth to this book. There’s no character arc for Ralph. He joined the NYPD, arrested the shit out of some criminals for a bunch of years, racked up a huge number of commendations and medals, dated a bunch of chicks, and was forced to retire early after a car accident. BTW, this isn’t really a spoiler. There’s no real story to spoil. The end has all the emotional impact of a waving passerby. Bye, we never really knew you!
We never really see the sights, hear the sounds or smell the smells. We learn nothing about the cultures inhabiting the city at time (listing off census numbers doesn’t count).
We learned that Ralph enjoyed busting punks; had some moral flexibilities when it came to observing citizens' civil rights protected by the constitution (a document that unquestionably made his job more difficult) and doesn’t like politicians and police brass.
He undoubtedly made the city safer, during that period. He would argue that this fact makes him a good police officer. I would argue, eehhhhhhhhh… I’m not so sure.
I understand why this book is being rated so highly. It is action-packed, cops-and-robbers mayhem from start to finish. I’m giving it a much lower rating. I didn’t learn much, reading this book, other than Ralph really likes to pat himself on the back. With all those medals you would think he needn’t, but he still does.