Lately, I have been binge watching Donut Showdown online. In an episode that I watched recently, the judges argued over the winner between two contestants. One had made fabulous donuts that had virtually nothing to do with the assigned theme. The other had made decent donuts that absolutely fit the theme. Who should win? The one with the better donuts or the one who completed the assignment?
For me, this book was by the contestant who made fabulous donuts but who completely ignored the theme. And, because of that, I am having difficultly rating and reviewing the book as a result.
The book is a fantastic resource for watercolour painters who would like a full detailing of every aspect of their craft, from where the pigments for each colour of paint come from to types of paper, etc. And really, I am someone who is interested in that type of information but still found it to be a bit too much.
On the other hand, the book, literally in its title, promises guidance on urban *sketching* and storytelling, and on that the author failed to acknowledge the theme. There is virtually nothing 'sketching' in this book. To the contrary, most of the recommendations are for full-on drawing and painting (e.g. making colour schemes first before doing any painting, making multiple thumbnails before making the painting, using salt to create textures, using liquid masking to maintain whites, etc., etc., etc.). The book gives excellent guidance on watercolour painting, but much of that advice is in opposition to what works for the sketching that the book promises.
I admit it, I put three stars to make it middle ground. But, in writing this review, I bumped it back to two. The book is an excellent resource for some purposes. But, it fails greatly on what it promises to be. I am glad that I got my copy from the library. I would be really upset if I spent any of my limited book-purchasing budget on this book because it is not at all what I was looking for, and not at all what I thought it would be based on the promises made in its title and description.