What do you think?
Rate this book


619 pages, Kindle Edition
Published January 17, 2018
I spent the first 9 chapters of this book struggling to get through, it was a lot of information and not enough action. I realize that this is a fantasy novel and world building is to be expected. The books I'm used to typically give you the information when you need it rather than all at once to avoid overwhelming the reader. Once chapter 10 hit and the tyros started their journey around the nation the book picked up quickly, and stayed interesting. You learn about the Tyros individual homes and their customs. The shadow nation was thoroughly intriguing and probably by far my favorite of all the nations. Throughout the first -probably- half of the book my rating was a steady 3/3.5 stars. It was good, but not great. I hadn't found that one thing that pushed it over the edge to great.... until the last few chapters. I was on the edge of my seat in fear and sadness. The author managed to take my heart and rip it into shreds, effectively pushing the rating to 4 stars. Courtney Praski has very much earned a purchase from me, and I will most definitely buy the second book. I really hope that enough people show interest in this series and she manages to snap a publisher. She thoroughly deserves it, and everyone should give this book a chance if fantasy and great world building is their thing, Now, onto the spoilery review bits.
Attention: I received this ebook in exchange for an honest review.
It took two months to slog through this book. Yes, slogged as if I was crossing the Northern Ice Fields with ice hounds nipping at my icy heels sinking straight into the icy ice. Hmm… this should give you an idea where this review is headed.
First, this isn’t a bad read by any means. It’s a decent fantasy that desperately needs an editor (or twelve). Second, this might end up being a bit nitpicky by the end but I have some serious beef with certain parts of The Seven--especially the length. At 400 pages (with some format errors) this thing is a brick. A very, very, very, very incredibly slow brick. Buckle up because I’m about to walk you through it.
Kane Emard is on the run from the queen in the north, Kaidina. Unfortunately he spends a good portion of his journey dropping a load of information about the layout of land, the apocalyptic world called Oloris. Even though we had a long introduction to Oloris in the prologue, Kane helpfully reminds us. When he finally ends his journey at Nascent, he meets Nero, Doyen of the Seven, and claims the king and queen of the Fallen were murdered and he has their only child.
Any of this make sense yet?
As Kane meets with the Seven, we get an info dump on each nation’s representative and a little information about the nation itself. The Fallen, Honorbound, Pure, Defiance, Hunter, Shadow, and Nameless--memorize them now as names will disappear, replaced by each character’s nation, and it gets very confusing. Introductions are stopped to assure the readers that the Black Glades are deadly, the Undying Valley is truly terrible, and yes Onyx and Griffin are definitely a couple.
Hmm, yes, this makes sense.
Kane mentions a lot more names and titles that mean nothing to us as he explains he’s collecting on a life debt. He wants shelter for the last living Isolde, Edlyn, who has been tucked in his coat the entire time. Luna, the Fallen member of the Seven, loses control of her powers when she hears her king and queen have been murdered and there’s a lot of heavy-handed description quickly followed by more information. Nero spells out Aether and annex and what it means to be “enhanced” and each Seven’s elemental ability to Kane, because this is very important information that the reader must be told right away (instead of, say, waiting until later chapters to show us as the kids train with their mentors).
Anyway, the life debt is accepted and Edlyn stays with the Seven in Nascent and fifteen years pass and suddenly it’s the Day of Nations.
Are you still following all of this?
On the Day of Nations, each nation presents their enhanced candidate and the Seven choose who they will mentor to take their place for the next thirty years. Insert more thick paragraphs of information that we don’t need, with a few bits that we do, and the new Seven are chosen. Edlyn, Theo, Luca, Kora, Sorin, Reina, and Tomin.
Edlyn, who the Seven were carefully raising to take her place as queen in the north. Theo, who becomes the group dad when it’s convenient for the plot. Luca, the rich bastard child with a heart of gold. Kora, a skilled assassin no longer in slavery. Sorin, the one kid who gets dropped for the entirety of the book. Reina, who quickly steals Edlyn’s thunder and becomes the main character. Tomin, the blind runt of the group but everyone roots for him anyway.
On page 123, we get introductions. And more info dumps. One hundred pages in and surely the story will kick off, right? Wrong. We get a condensed version of training--instead of taking this time to talk about Aether and annex, and demonstrating each character’s ability in offensive and defensive settings--and an extremely detailed description of Nascent, despite the fact the characters leave Nascent three chapters later.
Finally, with the ironically titled chapter “The Journey Begins” (on page 187), several months have passed and the characters set off to travel Oloris and meet the leaders of each nation. Traveling over an apocalyptic wasteland should be exciting--mutated creatures to fight, radiation to avoid, merchants and pilgrims to meet, ghost towns to explore. Oh wait, no, it’s just more description about a typical fantasy world.
The first stop is the Black Glades, home of the Shadow women. The majority of the book is spent here. 59 pages and nothing is accomplished. Eventually we visit the Barren Highlands, home of the Nameless. Only one thing is accomplished here; the Seven convince the Nameless to accept any and all war refugees. Then it’s off to the Undying Valley, home of the Defiance, for about 17 pages of, oh look, more nothing. Time for Kraint’s Deep, home of the Pure, where we are quickly drowned in so much information that we absolutely do not need.
The Seven decide to slip into a Senate meeting. Awesome. Politics--the best way to tease a plot! Oh, never mind. It’s just an assault of name after name after name after name. As if we’re supposed to care who these people are. But one thing is accomplished; the kids find their way into the restricted Citadel to find evidence that a Pure family had their souls stolen.
Wait, what?
No time to dwell on that--time to head to the Dummons Valley, home of the Hunters. Oh, nothing is accomplished here, either. Just a lot more info dumping about the nation. Just like the previous chapters. Just like the entire book. But it’s here, on page 326, that the romance starts to rear its ugly head. Because, of course, these characters are so close to each other.
We’ve seen them overcome so many trials, so many battles! They’re enhanced; they control the elements! The book has been filled with action and… oh, no it hasn’t. We haven’t seen anything like that. But sure, somewhere in all that description and zero character development, I’m positive they found something to love about one another.
Anyway, time for the Glowing Forest, home of the Honorbound. And as expected, nothing happens here.
It’s finally time, with 50 pages left in the book, to head to the Northern Icefields (which, we can guess are different from the Northern Ice Fields in the beginning of the book since they’re spelled differently) and confront the evil Kaidina who killed Edlyn’s parents fifteen years ago. Alright, plot time, let’s go--wait, Kaidina, where are you going? The evil queen says maybe ten lines and then disappears, and after an attempt to poison one of the kids, the Seven decide to cut the trip short and head back to Nascent.
No confrontation between Edlyn and Kaidina. No angry “Why did you do it--why did you kill my parents?” in a secluded tower. No subtle threats over an awkward dinner. The Seven just pack up and leave, and as soon as they’re back at Nascent, they peace out and leave the kids in charge. That’s it. Training’s over.
Now. What did everybody learn?
Nothing happens in this entire book. Nothing at all. The characters that set out at the beginning of the story are the exact same that return. Despite all of the information the reader is given about each nation, it doesn’t seem to change or influence any of the characters whatsoever. There are no trials to bring them together. We never see any form of team building. And despite being called “enhanced” there’s barely any use of elemental power! What’s the point of having super magical powers if you don’t even use them?
There is one small skirmish at the end of the book but by this point, both the author and any form of editor have fallen asleep (or suffered alcohol poisoning) that it doesn’t make an impact. It’s the equivalent of “She swung her sword and the bad guy fell over.”
400 pages and nothing happens.
And it’s upsetting because, somewhere under all of the weight of information, a solid story could be pulled out. If it was tightened up, if there was any conflict, if the cast was cut in half--I would be interested in that book. This is a good foundation but it’s not enough. With a few more rounds of edits (by an editor or four that doesn’t fall asleep by page 312, but kudos for trying) it could be something that engages readers instead of, say, putting them off for two months.
So now that we’ve covered the play-by-play, let’s get into the nitty-gritty. I have some issues with this book outside of, you know, the whole no conflict thing.
Now the blurb for the book claims it’s apocalyptic. It might even be considered a dystopian novel with all the different factions in play. No, my friends, we have just a regular medieval fantasy setting. Nothing in all the giant paragraphs of description screams “apocalyptic” except for the early mention of Wuthering Heights. That counts, right?
Besides Nascent, there’s no crumbling towns or highways, no overgrown parks, no razed cities. We get icy wasteland, desert wasteland, glowing forests, swamp, grassy plains, medieval tiered city, and mountains. Everything is stone or wood, all organic. No proof, despite being set after the year 2100, that there was technology in the world.
The cast was too large for the author to handle. Not only do we have the Seven, but we have the seven kids--and the nation’s leaders--and the story suffers because of the size. Who are Griffin and Onyx? They’re supposed to be a lovey-dovey couple but we never see them. They’re supposed to be powerful, built like oxen, but we never see them in action. Nina says maybe a handful of words in all 400 pages. When Sorin reappeared in the later half of the book, I had no idea who he was; I had to go back to the Day of Nations and figure out if he was part of the Seven or part of the kids. Theo had a slightly bigger role, I recognized his name, but he basically didn’t exist either.
The typos and abuse of words ran rampant, especially after page 312. “Immediately” was used five times within the space of three paragraphs; it’s used 13 times within 8 pages. “Precise precision” was certainly a thing. “The two continued striking and defending each OTHER's attacks, their skill with the sword matching the OTHER as they danced around each OTHER, neither able to gain the upper hand. Finally, their swords met, and an array of sparks danced in the air between them as the two gritted their teeth at the OTHER" was absolutely a paragraph that happened.
Names changed. Eastmund became Eastman and back again. At one point, a Gale says a line and is then never mentioned ever again in the entirety of 400 pages, but the scene continued as if he was still there.
9 out of 10 names, especially feminine, ended in A. Disclaimer: This is a nitpick. But I am so guilty of doing this that I automatically recognize it in other’s writing. 48 names throughout the entire book, and I might have missed a few. When your cast is already so big, and personalities/voices so similar, this is a real problem. I could barely keep anyone straight. I think all but two women in the Black Glades had a name that ended in A. I actually kept reading this book just to keep my tally going. Every time a name appeared I got a little excited, and then a lot confused as I tried to keep them all straight.
All in the all, The Seven is not a bad book. It’s a heavy book. It reads more like the author’s world building journal instead of a fleshed out story. If it had a bit more work put into it, and the author decided if they want apocalyptic or medieval fantasy, I think it would be a fairly decent read.
“The feeling of something falling against his legs caused his eyes to shoot open, as the sight of the dead ice hound with Onyx’s dagger buried in the side of its head immediately greeted his eyes.” – PDF pp. 355
Tomin’s brow furrowed for a moment. A second later it was followed up by a shrug of acceptance before turning to Edlyn. “Are you attracted to Luca because you think he would make a good father to your hypothetical children?” – PDF pp. 254 - 255
Luca nudged her shoulder, forcing the Defiance enhanced to meet his gaze. “Because before there can be life, there must first be love,” he answered quietly, smiling timidly at her. – PDF pp. 332
“Our first voyage out of Nascent, and I am already a liability,” he whispered dejectedly.
Edlyn opened her mouth to respond, to assure the young man that he was not a liability, but a flash across her peripheral stopped her. Kora was at their side now, but the Defiance enhanced paid Raina and Edlyn no mind, as she moved forward and smacked Tomin upside the head.
Tomin cried out in surprise as he moved his hand up to rub the back of his head.
“Do not be an idiot, Tomin,” hissed Kora. “It does not suit you.” – PDF pp. 195
“I can’t believe you blew up Nascent,” Luca teased Sorin, his voice cutting through the uncomfortable silence that overtook the small passageway they moved through.
Sorin choked on the air next to him. “My Doyen told me to,” he slurred out deliriously. “Technically, she blew up Nascent.” – PDF pp. 395 - 396
“Well, they are human,” Kora reminded them drolly, shaking her head at the men. “It is only natural for them to seek comfort from someone.”
Theo and Sorin turned to Kora at the same time, devious smiles on both their faces.
“You are human, Kora,” Theo started.
“Who would you like to be”—Sorin cleared his throat—“comfortable with?” – pp. 256
“Edlyn,” Fay soothed softly, as she reached out to grasp Edlyn’s shoulders in a tight squeeze. “No one wants to leave you, but you know that we cannot stay.”
Edlyn’s chest tightened painfully at her words, as she lowered her gaze to childishly kick a rock with the toe of her boot. “Yes, but that doesn’t make it any easier to say goodbye.” – pp. 383
I got this book as a free copy, so I could review it.
First of all, I really like the story and the characters; they have this realness to them that made them feel very real. Of course I have my favourites, but I’ll keep them for the spoilery part of this review.
Even though the story is great, at first I had some struggle getting really into it. It is built very slowly in the first part and I started really appreciating it only later on in the storytelling.
Some parts of the story felt reptitive and sometimes I could find some grammar and structure mistakes that, with english not being my first language, sometimes had me struggle (this is probably due to its being a self-published book, so the author has all my respect, because I’d make a lot more and far worse mistakes).
Now let’s get into the spoilery and fangirling part, where I’ll talk about how much I loved this story.
POILER AHEAD
I warned you
-
-
-
-
I’ll follow a little order here so if you haven’t read the book and you want some spoiler it makes sense.
Edlyn is one of my favourites, she’s awesome. She is kind and gentle, but she also is a fierce warrior. Ever since her head popped out of Kane’s coat, she’s had a special place in my heart.
Kane also could have been a favourite had I seen more of him in the story, which I hoped there’d be, but sadly there wasn’t.
The Seven are awesome, especially Nero and Conrad, though I also love Griffin and Onyx just as much, so I’ll talk about them: first of all let’s talk about this quote
“And if anyone dares, always remember she is a child of the Seven- and may God have mercy on whoever hurts our daughter, because they’ll find none from us.”
This is where Nero became my favourite of all the Seven, because despite his being the Doyen and rarely showing his emotions, he deeply cares for all the Seven and the tyros.**First of all, I was provided this book for free by the author in exchange for an honest review**
This is the first time for me I review a book I got for free to share my opinion on it. Somehow, I really want to only say kind things because the author is kind too. But it’ll be hard and I apologize in advance if someone is unhappy with my opinion but I’ll express it as it is and everyone is free to think differently and judge the book by themselves. Anyways, here we go.
When I read the blurb, I found the story promising and I am sure the author has put A LOT thoughts in creating the plot, the world, the characters and everything that needs to be planned beforehand. I also can see, the author tried her very best to make this book, its plot and characters great. I literally can sense the high expectations she has on herself in every sentence. She wanted a lot. To make this an unforgettable and remarkable start of a series. And I do agree, the story itself isn’t bad at all. Edlyn’s past and how she ended up with the Seven, the training of the tyros and the surprising end (though I had predicted something will happen, the signs were everywhere), it was really good! Actually, a great plot.
But then, there was a big problem to my mind. The style of narration couldn’t entertain me at all. To be honest, partly, I found it quite poor. Those always long sentences were tiring and things were repeated over and over, or described to its tiniest detail, though not necessary. I never felt tension rising, not even in action loaded situations. The narrative style, tiring and slow as it was, took the speed from the action that happened and sometimes you could skip entire paragraphs without missing a bit. Everything was told like from far away and I couldn’t really get into it because of that distance.
The characters were lovely. I especially grew fond of Tomin. Such a cutie, I thought. Actually, as time passed by and I struggled more and more to continue reading, he was my reason to go on. I cared for him and, sadly, only for him. The style of narration never let me grow close to one of the other characters. Also I found them too smoothly fitting in and adjusting. The entire training of the tyros by the Seven kind of happened as a sideline. They never struggled, though it was obvious how some of them would need more training than others. Instead, the training just happened as if it wasn’t more but a part of the story the author had to write while actually wanted to be done with it to get to the more exciting part of the story. This didn’t make anything feel realistic or authentic. Even when the tyros grew closer to each other, it felt like this had to happen, so let it happen, smoothly of course. I just couldn’t like it.
If I was asked to give the author advice how to make this book an entertaining and thrilling read, I would at first recommend to change the style of narration. Then also, things can’t go so smoothly, not always and everything. Make it more realistic by not making the characters so perfect in their behavior. Lastly, the summary of this book is awfully long and doesn’t give much information about the book’s content but the world and the characters. And the title and cover are other issues. I think I would have preferred a phoenix, inspired by Nascent.
This is the first book of a series and though the end is promising, I won’t read it. Finally, would I recommend to read this book? I’m not sure. Actually not as it is. Maybe after it was rewritten in a better style of narration.